Is it discourteous to butt in between two people talking?
By Morning Girl
@salonga (27775)
Philippines
October 2, 2008 2:43am CST
In real life conversation, it is okay with me if someone else butts in but he should be polite enough to ask permission first before talking. Have you encountered people who have the habit of meddling in conversation even when they are not invited? I find it so rude. Here at myLot I've seen people butting in in others' comments. Some are polite, some are not! some could give funny side comments that add glitter and fun to the discussion. However, I've personally encountered some rude ones and I'm finding it hard to understand what is their business for doing so. How about you?
2 people like this
15 responses
@arthi_88 (1516)
• India
2 Oct 08
As far as my friends are concerned I don't mind but if a stranger suddenly butts in between a private discussion that gets me real angry...Sometimes they even refuse to notice the subtle hints of "please leave" and keep on speaking until either one of us move away...
And here in mylot some people are really rude but guess they can't help it or they enjoy doing so....
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
Yes, if they are my closed friends here, it's okay with me. In fact, I love it when a friend is joining the conversation. It's turning out healthier but those rude and impolite ones, I really can't tolerate. So you also encountered those rude ones! Oh I understand your feelings over them!
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
Your second day only and you were already harassed by some jerks! Tsk!Tsk! What a rude way to treat a beginner!
@shana123 (2095)
• India
3 Oct 08
Yea even i have encountered such situations here at mylot , i was just telling the experience i had in my life , two women were like they say i gave a dangerous suggestion , i told her to mind her own and ask not to interfere my response , as the owner understood that im just sharing what i experienced but these woman's i dont know what bothered them , i don't like to keep my mouth shut in such situation who are they to comment me ? as i dint do anything that is against the mylot rules are mid guiding anyone.I hate these things
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
Oh that is irritating! Why are they so mindful of other's response when it does not in a way addressed to them. I find them rude as well. Maybe it is really their business to meddle in other's affairs. How rude!
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
2 Oct 08
[i]hi salonga,
Absolutely it is..I haven't experienced that yet here but in real life yes and sometimes, I will just say , it's still my turn..hahahha!
ANyway, this site is very open and one disadvantage is that people abuse it intentionally on unintentionally@[/i]
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
Oh yes, the cyberspace is very open, we can't control anyone from misbehaving. There are indeed abusers around here but that is always their loss because they will get the discredit for showing what kind of person they are. Thanks dear for your response!
@neildc (17239)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
3 Oct 08
I am not so aware or maybe I just ignore people butting in in some of mylot discussions. But in real life, there is one person who I hate so much when people are talking and she will butt in, without asking for permission to talk. That is my step daughter, and my wife hates her too with her attitude.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
Oh I wish that girl will change her attitude. If you can't take her bad attitude, how much more other people? I also know one person in our office who is like that and he is the most disliked person in the office.
@anneshirley (1516)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
Yes, it is for me. I am annoyed when someone butts in my conversation with other people and share their unwanted opinion but I cannot help it because we are sharing a common room in our work and there are many people there but I do make it a point not to do it with other people. Whenever the person I need to talk to is conversing with other people, I would wait for the discussion to be over first before I approach the person I needed to talk with. If I can't wait, I would say a simple "excuse me" and talk to the person as fast as I could. I was raised by my parents knowing too well how to respect other people and I still carry it with me wherever I go.
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
That's it! A person's behavior is a reflection of how his parents have raised him. The impolite ones are not fortunate enough to have good parents who could have taught him the way to behave well. Thanks dear for your thoughts!
@mercuryman3a (2477)
• India
3 Oct 08
When you feel very strongly about the subject bein discussed and feel that the discussion is going in the wrong direction, youfeel like butting inand correcting the people invilved in the discussion. Some people feel offended, but some feel glad you corrected them. It depends on teh relationship with the individuals.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
It depends if the person who interrupted is my friend and we are that close and it depends also if he is doing it politely instead of sounding like more brainy and knowledgeable. Thanks my dear for sharing!
@rsa101 (38126)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
In real life I really find it rude bu in here at Mylot I think it is really just a normal thing and I do not find it rude at all. I also do that sometimes. When I find a a response to a post that I like and most of the things written there is the same as my thoughts then instead of writing a response I just add to it instead.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
Yes anything can happen here. We can't really control anybody here and for as long as the person is polite and talking with sense it is welome to me. But those impolite ones will get what they want from me. Surely! Regarding adding your thoughts to a response instead of writing, Are you not losing some points by doing so? I can see some people adding comments on mine and their comments are reaching my end instead of going to the poster and then when the poster answered it is going to me and not to the one who added the comment.
@nengs10 (3180)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
It's a case to case basis. For me, you have to approach them in a nice way and if you're acquainted with what they're talking, then you can butt in and tell them your ideas as well. You have to be humble and stay nice all throughout.
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
If we only behave in the same manner as we behave in real life situation then I see no problem at all. You are right, it is a case to case basis. For as long as you do it nicely then no problem. Thanks Neng!
@djoyce71 (2511)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
For me, sometimes it's really discourteous if someone just butts in in a conversation specially not invited, but sometimes there are emergencies and someone needs to really butt in and cut the conversation (ex. something bad happened at home and somebody just got to tell the person).
Yes, I agree maam. I have seen a lot here in mylot. I just hope they just respond and not comment on others' response. I don't know if I'm right: I guess it should be starter-respondent interaction and not respondent-respondent interaction.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
Yes in real life conversation, if emergencies happen, then it is understandble and excusable. Here at myLot, I you want to contradict the opinion of anyone, I believe it is better to just respond on your own, give all your views, as much as you can if you really want to share your ideas. Commenting on other's response to contradict his ideas is plain and simple rudeness not only to the respondent but also to the one who started the discussion. Everyone is entitled to his own opinion and we cannot insist on influencing and changing the stand of anyone here. Thanks Djoyce!
@yenwie84 (1344)
• Malaysia
2 Oct 08
I have the same point of view as you. As long as the person asks permission for interrupting the conversation,it's fine for me to stop talking for a while. But I find it very annoying for someone just directly butts in the dialog without saying "excuse me". Lol. Unless there is an urgency to do so,if not I don't see the courtesy for doing so. If I were the person,I will always wait for the one who is talking to stop talking first then I ask for permission to interrupt in for a while.
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
That's it. Politeness is the key! There is always a way to be polite, it is just that there are persons who were not raised well. Poor parents they have... I should say!
@sumiirajj (1983)
• India
2 Oct 08
Hi salonga,I have faced the situation many times , I get irritated when someone behaves so.But at the same time I feel that some people are like that and they dont even know that their behaviour irritates others.When someone behaves so I cant be rude to them as am not used to be rude.Then the whole surrounding and our mood would get spoilt .So its better to ignore such characters.thanks for sharing.happy mylotting.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
Right it is better to ignore my dear. But there are some instances when we really have to give the impolite intruder some good lessons without necessarily going down to their levels and that I did for two times already. It's good the rude intruders did not answer back anymore.
@eiram25 (1076)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
hello there! it's impolite to butt in in a conversation.i agree with you that that person has to ask permission first before stating his opinions.but if that person is included in the conversation,then i don't think there's no need for him to ask.i've encountered people like these who just interrupts out of nowhere and blend in with the conversation as if they're invited.i personally think that it's an unhealthy behavior and decorum.happy mylotting!
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
In a personal conversation between two people... that is really annoying. Here at myLot we have no control over the situation but this does not mean we can be impolite at anytime we want. Yes you are right it is an unhealthy behavior. Thanks for being the first to response, I appreciate it.
@momforwork (161)
• Philippines
2 Oct 08
Hi there friend...
I really haven't been around long enough to find such "rudeness" in mylot but I guess it is not really that far fetched to have some unsolicited comments that are rude. Mylot does cater to all kinds. Comments may come from all points of view and are expressed in all ways. But where a member is persistently commenting rudely and it really gets offensive, is there no way for a member to report such member at mylot? I believe there should...
Otherwise, take it with a grain of salt...
Happy mylotting...
1 person likes this
@Flying1024102 (47)
• Australia
2 Oct 08
Maybe it's Ok if you are trying to help?
I still find it rude though.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
If the intention is to help then it is much welcome. But it depends on how the respondent will take... suppose the respondent said she is not even asking your unsolicited advice? So to avoid such... it is better to just respond on your own instead of commenting on others response. Thanks Flying!
@Opal26 (17679)
• United States
2 Oct 08
Hi salonga! Yes, you are right. It can sometimes be very
rude when someone comes in out of nowhere to butt into
the conversation who nobody asked to be there and starts
answering the discussion question instead of the person
that started it. In fact I saw that happen just yesterday
and the starter of the discussion was having trouble getting
back in her own discussion. It was really funny, but not.
I saw it happen in another discussion and that was plain
stupid. This person came out of nowhere and was trying to
take over the discussion. It was absolutely ridiculous!
It isn't polite in real life conversations, so why would
it be here. It is fun when it's side comments meant to add
to the humour sometimes, but when it's done in the middle
of a serious discussion it is just plain rude!
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
3 Oct 08
Exactly my friend, that is the same as my observation and although we really have no control, I really take it as plain and simple rudeness. If it is rude in real life conversation then it is just as rude here in cyberspace. You hit my points my friend and for that, I will give you the best response!