Do you think the new 'Smart Choices' label will help people eat more healthily?

Smart Choices label - Just the basic info
@owlwings (43914)
Cambridge, England
October 25, 2008 5:37am CST
Several of the nation's biggest food makers have created a common nutrition label that will be featured on the packaging of their products. The label, dubbed "Smart Choices", which was developed with the input of academic nutritionists, is aimed at helping consumers make sense of the competing claims made by individual companies. It will be featured on products made by General Mills, Unilever, Coca-Cola, Pepsico, Kellogg, Con-Agra, and Kraft. It really gives only the most basic information: the number of calories per portion and the number of portions in the pack. It is supposed to be only applied to foods which supply other 'good' nutrition - vitamins, minerals and calcium, for example. Do you think that this is the kind of information that will really help people or is it making nutrition too simplistic?
11 responses
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
25 Oct 08
I think it would be helpful for people who are health conscious. But I guess it won't make a difference for people who don't care less. I think it is a good tool that can help the customers to select their products wisely. © ronaldinu 2008
1 person likes this
@owlwings (43914)
• Cambridge, England
25 Oct 08
Do you really think that knowing how many calories in a portion is helpful, Ronaldinu? I find that a 'portion' is usually too small for me, anyway. I'm not a big eater, by any means, but I usually find that those 'two portion' ready meals are just about enough for one! As far as I can see, the 'Smart Choice' label is just another way of hiding the really useful and important information from people and, basically, a sneaky way of actually promoting some products which may not actually be any better for you. Since the labels will, presumably, only be used on highly processed food, where does that leave all the green vegetables, meat, organic foods and all the other low-process things that are actually better for you?
@Shar19 (8231)
• United States
25 Oct 08
I think it will help people in making their purchases. It seems these days people are more likely to buy things with those types of labels on them, "smart choices".
@owlwings (43914)
• Cambridge, England
25 Oct 08
... and, of course, those people are like sheep led to the slaughter. All the labels are there for are to (1) pre-empt possible government restrictions which will be designed to protect our health and (2) to persuade people to buy highly processed food from large corporations whose main profit comes from processing the food. The branding may indicate that the food meets certain standards better than food which doesn't carry it (though I am unconvinced). It certainly DOES NOT mean that food with a green tick is better for you than fresh fruit, vegetables, meat or fish (which almost certainly won't carry the label).
• United States
25 Oct 08
I do not think it will make any difference to me. I already get the information you quote on my food products. I check every label and expiration date on everything I buy.
@owlwings (43914)
• Cambridge, England
25 Oct 08
I have to confess that I don't check every label (there are some things that I know already - like that cheese is high in sodium and usually very high in the wrong kind of fat, even if it says 'low fat'). I check expiration dates with glee, usually. The po-faced powers that be generally have a very generous margin and when something like tinned goods or fruit or fresh vegetables (and even meat) is knocked down to half price because of the date, I inspect it carefully and fill up my basket. I know that the fresh goods, at least, must be dealt with straight away but this adds excitement to the menu and, of course, once cooked, they can always be frozen. The sad thing about it is that the 'sell by' date principle has inevitably increased the overall price of food because the losses incurred by occasional overstocking and either throwing stuff out unnecessarily or selling it off cheap have to be recouped elsewhere.
@ersmommy1 (12588)
• United States
31 Oct 08
While people should be interested in the label, I don't think it will make a big difference. No one pays much attention to the labels that are currently on our foods.
@Adoniah (7513)
• United States
25 Oct 08
They can put all the stickers on food that they want to,but they still lie about what is in the food. Did you know that they use prok rinds in gummy bears and marshmallows? What about all of you anti pig people or veggans who have let your kids occasionally treat themselves to a gummy bear? No I do not trust lables. I still write to companies or eat food marked Kosher and read those lables. Shalom~Adoniah
@owlwings (43914)
• Cambridge, England
25 Oct 08
Yes, I agree that gelatin is derived from animal skin and that they don't have to specify which animal. In fact it may be a mix of beef and pork gelatin which, of course, immediately disqualifies it for Jews and Muslims! Marshmallows should, by rights, have no animal product in them whatsoever. The name comes from a plant (a member of the Malvacea family) and originally meant that the candy/sweetmeat was made from the boiled roots of the Marsh Mallow, sugar and some flavoring (probably rose water). Gummy bears are, of course, a later invention. Eeek! Who wants to eat BEARS? (I do remember how we used to bite the heads off Jelly Babies - which are the same thing, really) with great relish! I am not bound by religious strictures about what meat I should or should not eat but I still wonder if all that goes into gelatin is really good to eat. The same stuff, after all, is used to make traditional wood glue!
@nini89 (670)
• India
4 Nov 08
Hi owlwings! The label pf smart choice does not make any difference some people buy and some not. In my case I read most of the labels and the expiration date printed and the rate of the stuff which I go to buy. Regarding this some people are calorie consicous and must be buying it. Happy posting and have nice day.
@nannacroc (4049)
25 Oct 08
No I don't think it will make any difference. Someone on the radio pointed out that she could get 12 doughnuts for a pound and had to pay £1.50 for a spear of broccoli, making the foods that are good for you cheaper than the junk food may make a difference. I still abide by the old fashioned 'everything in moderation'. I think maybe looking back to old ideas may help but many people won't even try anything that has any taste as they are so used to tasteless fast food.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
25 Oct 08
I think ppl see labels and automatically think they are better, newer, new and improved and really it's the same old thing. Maybe these are better for you but ppl should still read the labels carefully and not just trust the label. [b]~~IN SEARCH OF PEACE WITHIN~~ **AGAINST THE STORMS, I WILL STAND STRONG** [/b]
25 Oct 08
I think it is common sense knowing what is healthy and what isn't. I doubt labelling will make much difference. I also don't believe one food is bad for you unless you eat out of balance. Everything in moderation with enough fruit and veg and you will be fine!
@Barbietre (1438)
• United States
26 Oct 08
The problem I have with this, is WHOSE idea of smart choices is it? I do not now or never will eat low fat. Studies after studies show ot does not help you in any way. In fact lower triglycerides only happens when you avoid excess suagras and starches, and this is now beginning to be accpted by the AMA. Now not eating Hi Carb items and unprocessed foods are healthy choices to me. I want carb counts also. Now providing lables with all the aspects are good, but just blankly labelling it as a SMART CHOICE will do nothing for me.
@gaisri (154)
• India
26 Oct 08
Before going to all this data and statistics regarding calories consumption, people should basically have a health awareness among themselves..There is a saying that what ever is good for health does not taste good always and what tastes good always need not be good to health..Whether it is good or bad, it is better to avoid foods such as dairies,fries,burgers etc as the basic content of this foods are fats.Statistics and nutrient facts comes next..