Is it okay for a wife to hit her husband?

@808nala (640)
United States
December 20, 2008 7:39am CST
When a husband hits his wife, people will often advise her to leave him. It is believed that if you let them get away with it once, they will continue to be abusive. So what if it were the other way around? Would it be okay for a wife to hit her husband? If that were your friend, what would you advise him to do? Leave her or give her a 2nd chance?
17 people like this
74 responses
@liisafiat (659)
• Latvia
20 Dec 08
It is not OK to beat other live being at all! If man beats a woman: obviously he did not accept his nature of being `a man` and that it means not to use his power on weaker creatures. If the woman beats her husband: wow, probably it is the same way around. Or she feels more like a man inside herself, otherwise she would have noticed that she does not have so strong muscles to stand against and fight with A MAN!!! It is more like a mental problem, I think. I would advice that man to watch woman more carefully and maybe if he does not find anything frong in her: then to speak out about what has happened. About that beating. Maybe she was defending herself from him or thought she was?
3 people like this
@808nala (640)
• United States
21 Dec 08
Thank you for your response. She admitted to me that it was not self defense. She hit him one time out of anger. He walked out right after that. One hit is bad enough, but I'm thankful that it wasn't a beating. I hope he makes the right decision.
@Annmac (949)
21 Dec 08
I think I'd recommend they go for counselling. It doesn't matter which one is the abusive partner and it's just as wrong for a wife as well as a husband. I think without help abusive people will continue to be that way and so just giving them a second chance doesn't work!
2 people like this
@808nala (640)
• United States
22 Dec 08
Thank you. If he does decide to give her a 2nd chance, he says that they will get counseling. I also suggested anger management to the wife. I hope they follow through.
@lisa0502 (1724)
• Canada
20 Dec 08
I do not think that it matters what gender you are. I do not think that it is okay for anyone to hit another person. I have known men that have been abused by women and it is no more right than a man hitting a woman. I would for sure advised the man to leave the woman.
2 people like this
@808nala (640)
• United States
21 Dec 08
Thanks. I totally agree with you, but I think he's leaning toward working it out with counseling.
@DEVONECO (144)
• United States
21 Dec 08
It is not ok for ANYONE to hit ANOTHER - even an animal. Hitting is associated with violence - and fighting is one aspect of it. Even fighting in sport, in my opinion, is competitive violence. I used to box and also used to watch boxing as a sport during my younger years - but now I believe its nothing more than hurting another person for your own personal glory and financial gains. And the worst people associated with these acts of violence are the spectators themselves. I cannot believe how so many people - especially women - watch the fights conducted by UFC's Ultimate Fighting Championships - cheering on their favorite to hurt or even kill the opponent. I would rather propose learning Martial Arts as form of self-defence and not as a weapon - where you are first taught patience and tolerance. When you are strong knowing a form of martial arts, you have the inner strength, self esteem and confidence to ignore any challenges - and rather avoid a conflict at all costs. It also helps to be patient with everyone - including your family members - and to be tolerant with them and avoid fighting. I may have strayed a little from your specific question, but it all eventually boils down to violence. I also believe that all these wars, gangs, murders, rape, invasions, etc. that are happening in this world today are all forms of conflict which are a direct consequnce of violence that is bred in societies that seem to feel fighting is an acceptable thing. To answer your question, there's no difference whether its the husband hitting the wife or vice versa - hitting in any form is wrong.
2 people like this
@808nala (640)
• United States
22 Dec 08
You made your point clear. Thanks for responding and I hope he makes the right decision for himself. I'll have to wait and see.
• Philippines
20 Dec 08
either way its a No! No!. bitting or hurting anyone is unbearable in marriage. whoever hurts whoever. i guess the couple should talk together with a marriage counselor in order to fix the issue.getting out of the relationship is not the solution everytime there are petty issues about their marriage. couple should love each other and not hurt each other.
2 people like this
@808nala (640)
• United States
20 Dec 08
Thanks for your response. They are planning on going through counseling. Although they are taking some time apart from each other, divorce is not being discussed as an option.
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Dec 08
Why anybody sticks around after their spouse hits them is beyond me. Battered wives/husbands getting beat on for years. I just don't understand. Even if that person doesn't know how to throw a proper punch. The intent to hurt is still there. Then one day you wake up like John Wayne Bobbitt. (Not that he didn't have it coming.) Leave, and leave quickly. Call the police to get it on record. Do something, anything, but do not stay. If you stick around, the best you can hope for is to keep getting hit.
2 people like this
@808nala (640)
• United States
21 Dec 08
Good point. I don't think it was reported to the police, but it should've been. Thanks.
@rusty2rusty (6763)
• Defiance, Ohio
21 Dec 08
It doesn't matter what gender a person is. Nobody should use voilence against their spouse to get them to do what they want. If they really loved that spouse. They would not use voilence against the like that. I see no reason for that type of voilence. No woman or man for that matter should have to put up with it. They should leave. I have seen men go to abuse shelters just as well as woman. Men are more embarassed about it. But it does happen. IF it was happening to my friend, I would advise him to leave her. I would also advise him to have it happen in a public place where others seen it and have the police called.
1 person likes this
• Defiance, Ohio
22 Dec 08
You know I don't see where counseling can't hurt either of them. I didn't suggest counseling because most people would not in this instance. I will say if it works, great. Anger management might be a good counseling session for the wife. My ex husband was absive, thats why I say to leave. I can't tolerate any form of abuse. But if two people are both willing to get counseling and work on their married. I don't see why everyone should not give them a chance to do so. But the husband should be made aware that it may not work. I am keeping my figers crossed that it does.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
22 Dec 08
Thank you. Telling him to leave her was actually my first reaction on this issue. After speaking to both of them, it looks like they are leaning toward getting counseling. Neither is speaking of divorce.... just some time apart and professional help.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
23 Dec 08
I'm a little torn. On one hand, I want them to try counseling and try to work it out. On the other hand, I don't think she will change and I want him to move on and find someone that will treat him right. I just feel so evil to think this, but I can't help it.
• United States
27 Dec 08
He should leave her.i think it is worse for a man. Why? because he can't hit her back or he will be in trouble and she knows it.He should leave faster than a battered woman would.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Dec 08
Oh. I didn't know there was a real person linked to this post. Please send him my support. Tell him I hope he leaves her. He doesn't deserve this. There is a woman out there that will treat him with the respect he deserves.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
28 Dec 08
Unfortunately this did happen to my friend in real life. I will let him know that many wonderful mylotters are supporting him. I hope he makes the right decision!
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
27 Dec 08
I thought the same thing when he first told me. I knew that he couldn't and wouldn't hit her back.... ever! He had to walk away and punch concrete walls to release some of his frustrations. Thank you for your wonderful point of view.
1 person likes this
@tessah (6617)
• United States
21 Dec 08
regardless of who is doing the abuse.. theyre wrong. and the one being abused ought screw up their spine and leave. i dont agree that any hitting whatsoever is considered "abuse" however. my husand and i have gotten into some major knock down dragout shove push slam fests in the ten years we`ve been together.. and neither of us are "abusers" we just get rather overly passionate with our tempers at times.
1 person likes this
@tessah (6617)
• United States
22 Dec 08
its escalated to the point where hes shoved me and ive hauled off and clocked him in the face for it. weve managed at this point now in our relationship, that before the fists start flying.. one or both of us will state "im walking away so i dont kill you!" and the other has to respect the need to cool off and not follow.. leave each other be at a respectable distance.. and then we come back, sit down like rational adults and talk to each other. we both love hard, feel much, and are very passionate people. this is going to steam over into our fights as well when we do fight. which thankfully, now, is usually only once or twice a year
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
23 Dec 08
Good to hear that your disagreements are few and far between. Stay passionate and keep loving as hard as you can. Happy Holidays!
@808nala (640)
• United States
22 Dec 08
You guys must have a mutual understanding in your relationship and I respect that. I can't say that I would be able to deal with shoving and knock downs in my relationship. I don't consider that abuse, but I would be afraid that it may lead to a punch in the face or worse. Thanks.
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
21 Dec 08
Honestly I'd tell ANYONE be it man or woman on the receiving end of an abusive relationship to leave. It wouldnt matter to me if they were male or female no one deserves to be abused.
1 person likes this
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
22 Dec 08
I will say that if a guy ever hit me i'd be one that would probablyhit back and then leave him. Even if i didnt hit back I wouldnt stay with someone who hit me.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
22 Dec 08
Many people feel the way you do. Some other people feel like she deserves another chance, but should seek counseling. I know if I were in that situation, I'd leave. I don't know what he'll decide to do. Thanks.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
23 Dec 08
Same here. Good to see that someone else would do what I would do.
@jdyrj777 (6530)
• United States
3 Jan 09
I believe it is not okay for anyone to hit anyone else. Period. Husband, wife, parents, children. Violence is never the answer. If couples are fighting like that they need counceling. They need to respect each other. Nothing ever gets resolved by violence.
@jdyrj777 (6530)
• United States
4 Jan 09
I sure hope everything gets resolved for everyone. Just respect each other. Blessing to you all.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
6 Jan 09
Yes, I hope they can find a resolution. Thanks for your blessings!
@808nala (640)
• United States
3 Jan 09
Agreed. I don't think anything got resolved as of yet. It seems that they are going to seek counseling and for their sake, I hope it helps. I also suggested to the wife that she get anger management, but I don't know if she will take my advice. I'll have to wait and see.
@neuronic (242)
• Japan
21 Dec 08
No offense to what I'm going to write. You have been warned. The thing is, so many years women have been struggling to be equal to men and now that they have finally achieved their goal, of course, they started talking it's unfair 'n stuff. Well, really? Usually, it is considered very nice if you let woman out of the room, and you hold door for her, but I disagree. If you've won your liberty to be equal, thus making some sort of equilibrium then face it - we are all equal. And when I say this, I really mean that. Like if girl in a train touches my shoulder why am I not allowed to say 'pervert' or 'she tried to rape me?'. If I make a parallel to what you are saying - yes, if woman hits a man, it's absolutely the same as other way around. It might sound I'm bad guy, but in fact I'm just trying to stress out that equality thing.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Dec 08
I am a woman, and I like it when men hold the door for me. But I will also, in turn, hold the door for someone, male or female, old or young. Its common courtesy. I know this is totally off the original posters topic, and I'm not trying to be argumentative, but if you aren't holding the door for a woman simply because women have fought for equal rights that is really just rude. Many women just want to be treated fairly and aren't the feminazi types that argue they are being treated badly because they aren't being treated as equals. But I do agree with you that a woman that hits a man should be treated just the same as a man that hits a woman.
1 person likes this
@neuronic (242)
• Japan
21 Dec 08
Don't get me wrong on this, I was just trying to prove me point, and since I'm not native my text might not have been so well placed. But I think you understood what I was trying to say. Personally, I will always hold the doors for anyone, either woman, man, kid... But just for the sake of point I had to mention it.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
22 Dec 08
Thanks. I get your point about equality.
@missybear (11391)
• United States
20 Dec 08
If someone hits you, hit him back. Man or woman it shouldn't matter. It's not right for either one but if you hit me, expect to get hit back.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
20 Dec 08
I know exactly what you're saying. You know it's wrong, but it would be the normal reaction. Thanks.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
20 Dec 08
but hitting back will not solve the problem. if the husband hits the wife, the wife should go out of the house and get back when the husband is calm, the same thing if the wife hits her husband. hitting or hurting each other happens only when both are angry but i am pretty sure when they cool down they will realize what they have done. better not to trigger the fire when arguement is on going. better talk to the issue peacefully.
1 person likes this
@missybear (11391)
• United States
20 Dec 08
I hit him back and then get out fast.
1 person likes this
@kg4bah (78)
• United States
24 Dec 08
When a husband hits his wife or when a wife hits her husband it is wrong, either way you stack it. I can't see why it would be okay for a wife to hit her husband, I wouldn't do that it a million years. Give your friend some advice, tell them that there is obviously something wrong and maybe there is a way to fix things. I believe marriage counceling may be the best thing for them. There is obviously some issues that they have to deal with and they need to be talked out, without hitting one another. Some anger control is also needed. You should never just leave a marriage without trying to save it. After you have tried, went through marriage counceling, anger management and all that, if there is still abuse going on, then it is time to walk away - point blank. If someone loves you, then no matter what, they will not hit you. Thanks, Melanie
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
25 Dec 08
Thanks for the response. i believe they are going to seek counseling before trying to move any further in their marriage. I've suggested anger management to the wife, but I'm not sure if she'll take my advice or not. I'm sure they will try a few things before they call it quits. I just hope she never hits him again. They probably do enough mental abuse to each other. Hopefully they can fix that as well.
@kg4bah (78)
• United States
26 Dec 08
Yeah, they are probably putting each other through a lot. The councelor will probably suggest that she go through anger management, in fact, that would be the best bet. I wish them the best of the luck and if they speak to each other and try to understand one another, then there shouldn't be a problem....when my husband and I disagree on something, he gets on one computer, I get on the other and we talk it out. lol. Might sound funny, but it works for us. Instead of sitting there trying to talk out my feelings, I just write a letter...it works. By the time I am done writing a letter, I see how the argument isn't worth it. :-P ~Melanie
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
26 Dec 08
I know what you mean. I used to write letters to my boyfriends when we would fight and it helped me because I was able to say everything I wanted to say without interruption. I could think long and hard about it and write what I was feeling. After I calmed down a little, I would read it again and edit it. I would find myself writing things I know I would regret, but those were my emotions talking at the time. I found this much better than arguing because we would both say really hurtful things that we couldn't take back. I will definitely suggest your idea to the couple I started the thread about and to other friends and family members that have quarrels. Thank you!
@tentwo67 (3382)
• United States
3 Jan 09
No it is not okay, and it would not occur to me to do that. You reap what you sow, right? Early in our relationship the subject of women hitting men came up and my husband said to me that he would never hit me first, but that if I ever hit him he would be very tempted to hit me back. We have both respected each other by not doing that.
@808nala (640)
• United States
3 Jan 09
It's good that you and your husband respect each other. My husband and I have the same respect. I don't think he would hit me back if I hit him first, but I'd surely hit him back if he hit me first! I believe we would never let it get to that point, but unfortunately my friends did.
@lovesummer (1162)
• Malaysia
28 Dec 08
I think it is really not ok for a guy to hit a girl. Also it is not ok for a girl to hit a guy but somehow it will not cause any damage as I believe a girls energy don't damage much unless she is a boxer or trained for some proffession hehe.. yes Guess I would like her to get rid of him if any guys hit my girl friends. No second chance!
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
28 Dec 08
OH, I see, maybe she need some yoga or meditation could help. :)
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
28 Dec 08
I don't think she hurt him physically by hitting him. He's more mentally and emotionally hurt. I think if she doesn't get anger management, she will keep on hitting him.
@oldboy46 (2129)
• Australia
21 Dec 08
Violence or any sort of abuse (mental or physical) is not acceptable under any circumstances. That is regardless of whether the victim is a male or female and in fact it is probably worse when it involved a couple who are married. If a man was to physically abuse or use violence towards his wife, he would no doupbt be charged with a criminal offence. Similarly, if a woman was to do the same towards anyone other than her husband, she too would be charged with a criminal offence. Why should marriage change that situation .. violence is an offence regardless of who inflicts it and who the victim is. The victim becoming the aggressor is not the answer, as all that does is introduce more violence into what would appear to be an already troubled relationship. If the victim wants to save the marriage and the wife is willing to give it a go to see if they can work things out, then they should seek counselling as a first step to help them resolve the issue. Also whichever one of the couple is subject to violent outbursts needs to undertake some anger management lessons. Without counselling and those anger management lessons, the physical abuse will not just disappear. What a horrible environment to bring children up in, that is presuming there are already children or might be in the future.
1 person likes this
@oldboy46 (2129)
• Australia
21 Dec 08
It is a good thing that this couple do not have chidren I agree. If they do decide to attend cousneling with a view to getting back together, we can only hope that they work through all the issues before they even consider having children. My partner was a victim of physical abuse in her first marriage and it was only after counselling that she sorted out her life. Also as we had both been through rather traumatic separations from our marriages, we did attend couple counselling before we started to live together. Also we asked all of our respective children to attend some of the counselling sessions as well, so there could not be any problems that we did not know how to handle. At the time my children were still teenagers and hers were around the same age and I can honestly say that it did help us a lot. We were able to leave the baggage of the past behind us and I am sure that is what has made the relationship we have much stronger.
1 person likes this
@808nala (640)
• United States
21 Dec 08
Thankfully they do not have any children. Your response is pretty much exactly how I feel about the situation. Much appreciation!
@808nala (640)
• United States
21 Dec 08
Wow. Great story. Thank you for being so open and honest about your own experiences. I'm glad to hear that you and your partner have a strong relationship with each other as well as your children. I hope my friend makes the right decision for their future. Have a nice day!
• United States
21 Dec 08
Hey you....... We all know it's not cool to hit someone. Most of the time the men are alot stronger than the woman. It's not fair for the woman to hit the man either. I use to get beat up by my EX-husband, and it is the worst feeling in the world, I couldn't imagine beating up my husband. I just don't understand why anyone would ever want to do that anyway. I think if a person does that, they must be sick. How could you ever hurt the person you love the most? This is a pretty interesting topic, thanks for talking about it, it just makes me want to love more on my hubby. ~Peace~ Marilyn
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Dec 08
Yes, I'm in a much better relationship now. A man that truly loves me, and would never, ever think about hitting me. I feel blessed. You are very welcome!
@808nala (640)
• United States
21 Dec 08
Glad to hear that he's your "ex-husband". I'm sure you're in a much better relationship now and are extremely happy. I totally agree with everything you said. Thanks for responding.
1 person likes this
@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
8 Jan 09
Right now the world has laws on abusive marriages that are skewed towards the woman. With the evolution of society, the roles between a man and a woman is starting to blur at some points. When a man abuses a woman, the law steps in pretty quick. But when it is the woman in the marriage that is abusive, most of the time, the men suffer in silence. This could partly be due to the man's ego. And also the perception in general that woman are not the violent ones in a relationship. Depending on how bad the beating gets, if the man is seriously hurt, and the beating doesn't stop, then it is time for the man to get help from legal sources. It really depends on the situation. And you cannot jump to the conclusion that the woman is abusive just because she hit him. Find out the story from both parties before deciding on the conclusion that this relationship is in an abusive phase or not.
@808nala (640)
• United States
12 Jan 09
Thank you for your well thought out response. I do think that men have an issue reporting domestic violence in the home especially if they are the ones getting hit. They should report it though just so it's on record and if it continues to happen the law can see that there has been previous reports. In my friends case, I don't believe it's abuse. She just hit him while they were arguing about something. I don't believe it happened often, but once is bad enough.
1 person likes this
@AnakSuNamun (2084)
• United States
20 Dec 08
No,it's not OK. People should be able to solve their problems without any violence,regardless of who does it. However,I don't think women can do as mcuh harm as men due to their body weight. Some women are pretty big,though and weapons help everyone. I would say give her a second chance but tell her you don't appreciate being treated this way,it's disrespectful and bears bad fruit. I had a friend who used to do that but got quite thoughtful when asked what would she do if he hit her back.
@808nala (640)
• United States
21 Dec 08
He told a select few of his friends and family members about the issue. Half are saying to leave her because she will keep doing it and the other half is saying to give her a second chance. I'm torn because I understand both sides. I hope she thinks about my suggestion of anger management if they decide to move forward with their marriage. Thanks.
• United States
21 Dec 08
You're welcome. Good luck to you and your friends,try to find a good counsellor. Most people find it hard to talk to strangers about their personal life.
1 person likes this