If your baby was to be born deformed, would you go for abortion???

A deformed child. - 450 x 600 - 14k - www.bhopal.net/.../dioxin_affected_child.jpg
India
January 6, 2009 12:39am CST
This is a tricky question. Ive tried to see the pros and cons of both and am still undecided. Is it fair to kill a baby in the womb and save it from all the unhappiness and helplessness in this cruel world, or is it that you take it as a part of your self and let it live. But then, who will look after it after you are gone. It will be subjected to the cruel world and its barbs. How will it cope as it grows older? This is a burning question in my mind as one of my cousins has a down syndrome baby and needs constant attention. After them what?????
5 people like this
34 responses
@shannon76 (1232)
• United States
6 Jan 09
I really don't think it is our right to make a decision like that. We do not know the outcome or the future of that child in the womb. We do not know if he/she will suffer or lead a life that is unpleasant. Doctors are wrong ALL the time. If someone were to actually go ahead with killing their baby inside the womb and then, later realize the doctor was wrong that infact there wasn't anything wrong with the baby, how could you live with yourself? And with all the medical advances every second, who is to say that baby can't be helped? We aren't God nor are there any fortune tellers.... My son was suppose to never have been concieved nor even born (or so I was told by doctors) and then when I was pregnant, they said he was going to be huge so they decided to make me have him early. My son was only 6 pounds and healthy as can be. Doctors are just that: doctors. They are only equipped to make educated guesses with the knowledge that they have been provided. And even then, there is room for error. Taking a life before it is given a chance only because someone "thinks" it might have problems later is, to me, selfish and ignorant.
3 people like this
@shannon76 (1232)
• United States
9 Jan 09
I long ago gave up on caring about my star rating :) But I do thank you for the warning. It sucks that people can't rate based on anything other then their opinion. :)
• India
7 Jan 09
With todays science, and its miracles, it is possible to know the defects of the child. Drawing fluids from the womb or some such test tells us if a baby is healthy. I know they are not infalliable, but just for the sake of argument, they are right and you end up with a totally deformed child like the one in the photo I posted then the problems start. You were lucky and blessed with a beautiful son, God Bless him. Life for such abnormal kids is awful and more so for the parnents who know they will be neglected after their deaths and will die a thousand deaths every time they see this c hild. Its better to be safe than sorry. Just my thought, I totally respect your view point too.
• United States
9 Jan 09
Shannon, I understand what you are saying here, but be careful. This person stated a discussion about those that "don't agree with her". Watch your rating. I think you'll know where it comes from if it drops.
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
6 Jan 09
This question has been brought up before. I think I would say no. I believe that God helps you handle what you are given and to see the gifts you are given is a blessing. It's funny because I was online about a month ago, in a yahoo chat room with parents of disabled children. Then this woman comes on, she'd been drinking and she was talking about how'd she'd never have a child that was "retarded"; however, another person knew her there - she's 5 months preganent and she was drunk. You know there are parents out there that have these children and love them with their whole hearts and when I see a expected mom drunk and then make the comment that if somethings wrong she'll just get rid of it, that just turns my stomach.
2 people like this
• India
7 Jan 09
Yes, God helps us handle. But we can safely say all this when its somebody elses child, would you have the same opinion if it was yours. We all love and respect life, but in such cases it is better to abort. I think the main cause for the woman to drink is because she has a retarded child and she wants to forget all the pain and suffering both are having. Its so easy to sit on judgement, but only the wearer knows where the shoe bites. My sympathies with than woman totally. I dont say drinking is the answer, but then I dont know her agony.
• United States
7 Jan 09
Sit in judgment? I do have a diabled child so I wear those shoe everyday.
• United States
9 Jan 09
I also think you missed a point here. If you actuall READ what I posted, you'll see that the drunk expected mother said that if she was to have a "retarded" child she wouldn't. The key word her is IF. She didn't know one way or another the mental/physical health of her child, she was just drunk. So when you say you feel for the mother, are you saying that you agree with her opinion? That she can feel that if she WERE having a special child she should just kill it? Because from what I posted, this mother was saying an opinion, she didn't know what she was having, she was just drunk.
@lingli_78 (12822)
• Australia
6 Jan 09
this is a very hard question to answer because i don't have a child yet and i never have to experience this before... but i think i will make a brave decision to still keep the child and give him/her the chance to live... i believe that a child is a blessing from God and whatever the condition is, God will look after and take care of the child... even though i am already gone, God will still be there to look after the child... take care and have a nice day...
2 people like this
@Fortunata (1135)
• United States
6 Jan 09
No, no, a thousand times no!! From a moralistic viewpoint, the answer is no. I have seen people who are 'deformed' and they've gone on to have normal lives. In the old days they used to drown deformed babies because they were ignorant. There are agencies now that will help parents of downs syndrome children. I think it is selfish to deprive an unborn child the right to live. If you're such a wuss you think you can't handle the stares from people because you're child doesn't look like a Britney Spears or a Tom Cruise, then give the baby up for adoption. It deserves to be raised by someone who appreciates life, no matter what form it comes in.
@rberon1985 (5359)
• Philippines
6 Jan 09
You have a great topic for discussion. definitely, I won't agree of doing abortion if ever I found out that there is a problem with my baby. he / she has the right to enjoy the world. to see the beauty of the world created by God. As parents, we should accept whatever is the outcome of our babies. we should consider it as a blessing from God. there are lots of technologies that can help the child whenever he / she wa already born. for those people who has done abortion, let be their conscience be their problem. it is just like killing one people. How will it cope as it grows older?this is the question in your post that i want to answer.You,as parent will be his/ her strength when he / she grow up. you should not let him / her feel that he / she has a physical defects. guidem him/ her. hope i gave a wonderful response to your wonderful discussion.
2 people like this
• Philippines
7 Jan 09
if he / she has siblings, they should take care of him / her when you are already gone.
@Llonorra22 (1150)
• Philippines
6 Jan 09
Of course I will!! Given that situation, I'll let my baby live no matter what happens. It's a blessing from God and I don't have the right to kill her. I know that everything has a reason. And God has His own reasons why He gave me that baby. About her future when I'm gone, I'll let God handle it.. I'll just pray hard and ask God to take care of her when I'm gone... And I know that my mom is doing it for me right now....
2 people like this
• India
6 Jan 09
You are a darling and very soft hearted, so of course you will let her live and love her. Maybe as you say, God has his own reasons and ways of working, but it does put a mother in a tricky situation. We hope and pray God takes care of her when we are not there, but maybe He wants her to suffer so as to cut loose the sins of some past births. Its then that our heart breaks, for the world is indeed cruel. God Bless dear.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
7 Jan 09
Hello Ketty, You're starting to know me better huh.. And you're right I'm a very soft-heated person and I can't really afford to loose my baby because of her disability. It's like I'm seeing myself in her.... Hope to hear from you soon dear friend! God bless you always....
@WebMann (4731)
• Canada
6 Jan 09
This is a tricky question because I believe that it is wrong to take a life but it's easy to say that when all is well. We have been blessed with a healthy son, he is now 23. However I don't how my resolve would hold up against the horror of finding out your unborn child will be deformed. It breaks my heart and I hope I would love life enough to stick to my beliefs.
2 people like this
• India
7 Jan 09
Its never easy to stick to our beliefs when our own life and child is at stake. For we can look after it and love it till we live, then the problems start. Nobody will love or take care of such a person, and the world is cruel to its fullest. Lip sympath is always there but how many will come forward to look after such a person after we die. Think about it.
• Philippines
6 Jan 09
Hi ketybhagat. Nice question indeed. I would still let the baby live if that that is the case. I couldn't bear depriving another soul the chance to live and experience life. I'd take the chance of letting the baby live in the hope that one day, a cure could be found for the baby's condition. Until then, I will take good care of the child the best way I can.
2 people like this
• India
6 Jan 09
Thats very brave of you, but you are only thinking of taking care of the baby till you are alive. After that what ??? The child is left to defend itself, it cant, the world is cruel and children like these mostly end up hurt and disappointed with life.
1 person likes this
@Seppy1984 (2145)
• United States
7 Jan 09
Hello, I do not think I would be able to abort the baby because of this reason. Only because the way I see it is that the baby was made out of love so why should the baby not be born to get the love that you put in to having this precious child. I feel that all people who have disabilities and are deformed can still live a happy loving life it just will be challenging.I in fact know a child named Sammy and she is now disabled because her father shook her but she is the happiest child and is now learning how to talk. She still has problems with some stuff but she is a happy child because she has people around her that love her. I feel that a child deserves to have a chance to be loved. Well thanks for listening. Happy Mylotting
1 person likes this
• India
7 Jan 09
Sammy seems to be a normal child under the circumstances, not deformed as the picture ive put alongside my discussion. Being emotional and harming the childs future is worse than being practical and keeping it away from the harm of the world. Life is precious to all, but there are times when one has to be stern in order to be kind.
@Seppy1984 (2145)
• United States
7 Jan 09
She is not exactly normal now because she will always need help walking, and she can't see well because of it and she in fact has trouble even holding stuff because of it. But I do understand what you are saying though.
1 person likes this
@ds6413 (2070)
• United States
6 Jan 09
Hi, that is something hard to answer. I have a friend that is a nurse and she told me when I asked the same question what are the odds of having a healthy and normal baby at my age. She told me straight out if was her decision she wouldnt even put a child thru that sort of life. The care is tough and expensive for the family. I have a 3 percent chance of having a baby with downs. I wasted the time because I didn't know if the guy I am with was the one who would stick around. Well at least I know now he is with me not because of giving him a child, he is with me because of me. If I found myself in the same situation, I am not really sure I could have the baby.
1 person likes this
• India
9 Jan 09
Its always wise to think with the head than with the heart. You have chosen wisely and not put a little life in problems just for some illogical aspect of your thinking, call it emotional thinking.
@ktosea (2026)
• China
6 Jan 09
yeah,I guess it's really hard if you have to make the decision since the odd of success is low.you can go and adopt if you and your lover want a baby.but of course you can try to have a baby yourself. God bless you.
1 person likes this
@ktosea (2026)
• China
6 Jan 09
this is such a burning question that just the thought of it made me thrilled.I've never sit and think about such a problem. although people say that it's unfair to kill a bady in the womb and God have its reason to let a life begins,it is really a cruel and helpless world for it without its parents.if I am the parents and I know the life will be born deformed, I'd rather choose to go for abortion. for a long time viewpoint,it will be good for the parents and the little baby.
1 person likes this
• India
6 Jan 09
Much as it would hurt me, I would also go in for abortion. i know the Christian community and others who do not believe in abortion will not like it, but then, its better to kill the baby in the womb rather than let the child suffer at the hands of ruthless people in the world.
1 person likes this
@Tinna_He (300)
• China
7 Jan 09
i will choose to go for abortion too.Now many hospital advise you to do the prenatal screening when you are pregnancy for four monthes.They also hope you can be born a baby with health.
@har360 (95)
• Indonesia
6 Jan 09
Your question really hard to answer. That question should back to the woman who have the baby that deformed. This very subjective question, and if we say no you should not abortion it, the question will comes "what if this happens to you ?" can we still say like that ? we appreciate of living creature, but the world seems not accept the not good one. And Finally This reflect of each people, do they have a compassion or very unconditional love ? So i prefer not to answer this question.
2 people like this
• United States
7 Jan 09
I would have the baby and love it just as i would a child with no health problems. its not a question its a life. and so what if a deformed child needs attention? All babies and children need attention. Just because a child has a deformaty does not mean he or she is incapaible of having feelings and thoughts. yes,it is a cruel world out there for is it not a curel world for everyone? Say you have a child and during his or her life an accident occurs that causes a deformity what would you do? kill them? Children are precious no matter what color they are no matter what part of the world they come from no matter what they may or may not have wrong with them. deformed children are very able to have happiness. i personally know a couple of people that were handicapped throuh out their lives and they are very much happy and loved and aware of what is going on around them. Killing an unborn child for any reason is wrong in my opinion. There are places that take care of children and adults so there is no excuse for killing an unborn baby if you decide not to keep the baby. any real mother will tell you that it does not matter if their child has a deformity or not they are loved the same. I just do not see how this is a tricky question.
1 person likes this
• India
7 Jan 09
Everybody if for life, believe me, nobody wants to kill, but circumstances are different for different people. I agree with you that if a healthy child becomes deformed, we would not kill them, but then thats its fate and we accept it. But knowing a child is going to be so deforemed that it will feel its life a living curse on earth, then Id rather abort. Will these little ones understand why their parents have left them after we are gone. Will they get the same love and understanding in institutions where life is clinical and not personal. Believe me, its easy to say, for Ive seen brave mothers take to drinking cause they cant see their child suffer every day. Good luck anyway.
• Mexico
7 Jan 09
Of course I will love it, is my child anyway
1 person likes this
• India
7 Jan 09
Loving and being logical are two different aspects of life. We all love life and want our kids to be happy, but logic wins hands down when faced with a disabled child. Ive seen mothers, brave mothers who woved to look after such kids, take to drinking, for th ey cannot stand the constant agony both are suffering.
• India
9 Jan 09
If I know the baby still in my womb will be disabled, Id go in for an abortion though it would break my heart. If the baby was born and then I got to know about it being retarded, Id still raise it, for we are humans first. No sense in your wishing I have a retarded child. If wishes were horses, beggars would ride.
• Mexico
8 Jan 09
Well if is logic what you want, then why dont kill it? It will only make our life worse than they are right now. But wait, and if we dont do it logic? if we do it like instict? All animals kill their own children if they are not to life, Like if they were born without a leg. Then why don´t we do the same?! I Hope you undestand than this is obviusly all sarcasm, you cannot be so cold hearted, I hope you got a baby like that so you can decide to kill him, you aren´t brave enought, so stop saying things like "think logical".
@stephcjh (38473)
• United States
6 Jan 09
That is a very tough question but right now I think I would have to say yes to that. I would not weant my child to have to live like that. It would be too hard on me also.
1 person likes this
• India
7 Jan 09
98% of the mylotters share your view. Yes, better to abort than to see it die a thousand times each day, and you with it. Thanks.
• United States
7 Jan 09
There is no question in my mind. A baby shouldn't be aborted simply because they are deformed. Yes a deformed child will go through unhappiness and could be helpless. I have thought this through before. What I would do if I had a deformed baby inside me I would start making preparations to cover his/her life if something should happen to me. A deformed baby as they grow give out so much love. My personal opinion that is just not a reason to have a abortion. That little being inside is a living human being. Who are we to say the baby should be aborted because of things that might possibly happen. But that is just my opinion.
1 person likes this
• India
7 Jan 09
You are brave to have this opinion. Life is precious to all but at what cost. Would the child understand why all of a sudden moms not around to help, and that its put in an institution where life becomes clinical and not personal. Everybody needs love and a feeling of being wanted. Will it get all this after we are gone. NO NO. The child and the parents die a million deaths each day. Its very easy to say, but w hen it actually hits you, it stuns the daylight out of you. Ive seen mothers take up drinking because they cant handle it any more, brave mothers who vowed to fight to the last. After all we all are human and we can take so much and not more.
• Philippines
7 Jan 09
This is God's blessing to us..A child came from God..we should take care of them..as long as we live..no matter if the world if cruel..we should be firm to ourselves..we should give the right attention to the child he/she need..he/she, the child don't know anything about the cause why he/she born like this..well if we could surpass such things like this..well this is an achievement..At least in time you were able to obey God in your life.
• India
7 Jan 09
When God himself gives us the direction to make new discoveries, find out beforehand how the child would be, etc. etc. then we must make use of that discretionary power given to us by God. We shrug off everything saying its Gods will. The world is curel and God does not come to their aid, believe it or not. He in His glory lets us suffer out the sins of births. Can we see our children suffer ?We as normal human beings are not prepared for lifes blows, what chance does an abnormal child have. Its a question of logic and reasoning here, but then its my opinion. What do they do after we are gone, be sent to some institution and left wanting for love and feeling of being wanted. Poor kids, to suffer for our sins. Good luck.
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
7 Jan 09
There is absolutely no way I would have an abortion if I found out that my baby would have a birth defect or be severely deformed. I do not believe that it is my place to decide whether or not the baby should die. I believe that it is up to God.
1 person likes this
• India
7 Jan 09
It needs a lot of guts to have this opinion. Good luck.
• United States
7 Jan 09
This really is a question that a lot have asked me and I really can't come up wiith a solid answer to relay to anyone. I just personally think that it's no ones place to play God and take the life of a human that he created with love and affection. You may ask why God would create a child to look deformed or be mentally challenged, my answer would be that things happen and God would never do anything to hurt us. My brother is mentally handicapped and I can't bare to think of what my life would be like without him. Each of us is put here for a reason. It's just difficult to explain when people come up with questions that I'm not equipped to answer. I just know that my brother is loved and anyone who takes a moment with him feels that love.
• India
7 Jan 09
Such children are loved, Im not denying them. After all its the innocence that surrounds them. But then, your brother has you to look after him after your parents, but God forbid, if something should happen to you, what will happen to the man, who is man but a child at heart. I wish you all the best and your brother and may all his clouds be silver lined. Im sure he is a very lovable person.
• Singapore
7 Jan 09
For me, yes. The burning question who can look after him or her when I'm no longer around and it's going to get a lot of unwanted attention, curious onlooker glaze, is that the kind of life that i want to subject my own baby to. The world is not kind to people with disability unfortunately.
1 person likes this
• India
7 Jan 09
Thanks for agreeing with my view point. Life plays curel tricks on us normal beings, Id hate it to p lay similar ones with these little deformed children who cant even fight for themselves.