Punishments,discipline for children

@bamakelly (5191)
United States
January 28, 2009 9:13am CST
Do you think it makes more sense to punish your child or would you rather not spare the rod? I was wondering if you have a certain type of punishment in place each time your child gets unruly.
2 people like this
7 responses
@okasan (14)
• Philippines
30 Jan 09
i am a mother of 3, and they are already in their 20's. my oldest is already 27 years old and my youngest is 23. all of them had experience punishments administered both the wrong and the good ways. methods of punishment in themselves are not necessarily effective or ineffective. the determining factor in whether a punishments is effective or not depends on how the parent administers the punishment. if a punishment is given unfairly, inconsistently, or too often, of if it is perpetuates bad behavior, it can bring about the opposite effect than was intended. discipline-based parenting is consistent, predictable and whenever possible involves predetermined consequences. punishment-based parenting is consistent, unpredictable, and it minimized the importance of predetermined consequences. by the way, this is my very first response on a discussion here on myLot. i am glad that i had been able to maximize what i need to be said LOL. good day everyone and happy posting!
@phoenix25 (1541)
• United States
1 Feb 09
You're exactly right. When a parent administers punishment too often or unfairly, that is called the authoritarian parenting style and is just as bad as the uninvolved parenting style. An authoritarian parenting style results in low self-esteem, subdued or aggressive behavior, or out of control behavior. These results were found among kids in high school who were raised with the authoritarian parenting style throughout their childhood. Authoritative parenting, on the other hand, is the best method of parenting because it exerts a high amount of control over the child, but also results in a high level of acceptance by the child. Authoritative parenting invovles setting limits for children but also responding to a child's individual needs. Kids raised with the authoritative parenting style have higher self-esteem, are self-confident, are more independent, are achievement-oriented in school, and are more likely to comply with parents' requests in comparison with all the other parenting styles. The other two parenting styles are permissive parenting, which involves a high level of nurturing but low levels of maturity demands, control, and communication, and the uninvolved parenting, which has low levels of nurturance, maturity demands, control, and communication. Permissive parenting tends to produce children that do slightly worse in school during adolescence in comparison with other children and that are likely to be more aggressive (esp. if parents are permissive about aggressiveness) and somewhat immature in their behavior with peers and in school. They are also less likely to take responsibility and are less independent. The uninvolved parenting style produces children who tend to have problems in their social relationships for many years, and adolescents raised by the uninvolved parenting style tend to be more impulsive and antisocial, less competent with peers, and less achievement-oriented in school. I know I gave a lot of info, but I find it interesting.
• United States
31 Jan 09
Hi bamakelly, I do believe punishment is in order for doing something wrong. Otherwise, how will the child learn right from wrong. The best punishment I have tried, and actually worked was time out. Children hate it, and I'm sure you have already heard how that one works.
1 person likes this
@sunnypub (2128)
• United States
28 Jan 09
I don't punish my daughter. In fact we don't even use the term in our house. However, there are consequences for her actions, and she knows that. I know it is splitting hairs by calling it consequences and not punishment, but when she gets older and out into the real world she won't get punished, but there will still be consequences. She rarely knows the consequences before hand, but she does know they are there. Most of the time it just depends on what she did. Basically she knows the rules, she knows what is right and what is wrong, and she knows there are consequences that she won't like if she breaks the rules or does something wrong. She also knows, just like in the real world, she has a choice. She can and does sometimes chose to break the rules all the while knowing she will have to face the consequences. I think I am lucky because I have a really great daughter. I also think this consequence thing keeps her honest with me. She doesn't really lie to me and if I catch her doing something wrong, she admits and accepts her responsibility and consequence.
1 person likes this
@kezabelle (2974)
29 Jan 09
If my girls do something they shouldnt its explained why they shouldnt have done it and if warranted they do time out to think about what they did I find though normally telling them it was wrong and why is enough time out happens more when they are too excited and wont calm down time out gives everyone a couple of minutes to calm down! When they were under two though they didnt get told off simply told no and removed from what they are doing.
1 person likes this
@abhi_bangal (5532)
• Ahmednagar, India
31 Jan 09
Parenting. The word says it all. Parenting is quite a tough task these days. These "Little Masters" make the life of the grown-ups a balancing act. The kids are as whimsical and naughty as energetic and mischevious. The parents enjoy these naughty pranks as long as they are in good mood. And once the parents are off-mood, the same pranks start troubling and annoying them. And they lose their cool. Some parents force their kids to behave exactly the way they want. There is no compromise on it. This means T-H-I-S is their attitude. This makes the kids to retort and deliberatly do exactly the opposite of what they are told to do by their parents. The parents fail to understand after the kids are kids and should only be treated the 'kid's' way. But there is nothing wrong in it either. These parents are more ambitious about their kid's futures and so just out of pure love they force their rules on them. On the other hand, some parents allow their kids to be just kids. This allows the children to relax and understand the things more seriously. They are mentally relaxed. And this mental relaxation helps in building a kid's overall personality. But afterall, as no two kids are the same, in the same way no two parents are the same. They have their own ways and habits to train thir children, which they think they have got from their own experience. But I will say there is nothing wrong in it. Because being tough or not, it's all for the sake for their kids and again I will say, out of love. Ain't it?
1 person likes this
@Jae2619 (1483)
• United States
30 Jan 09
We deal with things as they come... some things we can over look if they are minor things. Most generally we punish our 6 year old by letting him choose his own punishment. If he was to hit his baby sister, he'd get stopped right afterwards, told he knows the rules, which hitting isn't allowed, and asked what his punishment should be.... he's come up with, letting her hit him back, taking away a beloved toy for the day, not being able to play the playstation/nintendo DS to not getting allowance that day. This seems to work well with him. Our 17 month old daugher on the other hand, needs a very hand on approach... stopping her, telling her no and then time out, and time out again... and again... She's very hard headed and doesn't seem to care she's in trouble. Too funny, but stressful...
1 person likes this
@phoenix25 (1541)
• United States
1 Feb 09
We used to spank our son more often when he was younger and nothing else worked for him...during his temper tantrum phase, especially. Now, we try to avoid the unruliness before it happens. If he starts trying to control me and get his way, I give him a choice. For example, if I'm doing housework and singing and he tells me to stop, I tell him he can either stay in the room and deal with it, or he can go in the other room. If he doesn't want to clean up, I tell him he can either clean up or go to his room. Really, sending him to his room is the biggest punishment right now. He has always hated being sent to his room, so that became his "time out". We will sometimes take his video games away when he gets out of hand as well. He has to behave himself to get them back. I haven't spanked him in months because I've been able to get around it because I can reason with him more now than I could a couple of years ago.