misconceptions about doctors
@doc_alma_jones (822)
Philippines
February 21, 2009 3:01pm CST
are there things you hear about doctors which, after some time, you eventually find out are not true?
let's see how many we can dredge up. ^_^
i am both a nurse and doctor, so i would love to hear what you think: do you think doctors are mere technicians and nurses are the true healers?
do you think doctors have an easy job? what do they do exactly when they have "rounds"?
do doctors usually get rich?
do you know of any other issues that may be relevant when it comes to misconceptions about being a doctor?
6 responses
@TLChimes (4822)
• United States
21 Feb 09
I think doctors are humans and can make mistakes, that they are over worked and can't know everything. (My kid's doctor is great because if she doesn't know she doesn't act like she does but admits it and looks it up or makes calls.) I think there are great doctors and really bad ones. Again they are human.
Nurses have it rougher. They aren't paid as well for nastier jobs. They have to deal more directly with people who don't feel well and aren't in the best of moods. But they too are human and sometimes have bad days too.
I think that neither job is great but one is harder and one is better paid.
@doc_alma_jones (822)
• Philippines
21 Feb 09
speaking of overworked, i should stop and sleep now, lol ^_^
well, i don't know about doctors being overpaid... maybe some, but in my country, doctors are actually taking up nursing because they aren't earning enough from being doctors. in the philippines, nurses who go abroad earn tons more than doctors. young doctors even earn less than janitors! (a young doctor gets 41 pesos per hour at best; a janitor gets 45 pesos minimum.)
some doctors do get lucky and filthy rich, though. i hope i get to be one of those lol ^_^
and you're right on when you say doctors are just people. they scream, they try to destroy other colleagues, they lie to patients, they hide their mistakes. nurses, too.
but nurses are actually a bit luckier than most doctors, at least in the philippines. for example, in one batch of 400 junior interns, only 200 become senior interns; out of these, only 120 get to be licensed doctors. and out of those, only about 30 get accepted into residency. the rest? they take up nursing... :o
1 person likes this
@TLChimes (4822)
• United States
21 Feb 09
It is different here in the US. Here nurses are paid way less then the doctors and the doctors get nice cars and houses.
Depending on what they do and who they do it for. There is one major draw back money wise... They spend half their adult life re-paying loans that got him through school.
@doc_alma_jones (822)
• Philippines
22 Feb 09
i see... correct me if i'm wrong, but they say that in the U.S., you can pretty much get almost anything you need via loans, like cars, houses, and such. so i guess even educational loans are quite common.
loans are not that common here. there are a lot of loans, but they're usually not for education or cars or houses. usually, they're for business. there's also this screening among the medical schools here... they actually ask you how many houses you have, how many cars, and if you think you have enough money to finish med school. i think they only want to accept people who can afford it so as to minimize drop-out rates.
the older physicians are earning better than the younger ones (by old/ young, i am referring to the number of years in practice). those are the ones who probably earn more than nurses abroad. ^_^ otherwise, the young ones are really struggling.
hmm... after reading your post, i'm thinking of moving to your country! lol ^_^
@cortypants (604)
• United States
21 Feb 09
That's interesting that you are both a doctor and a nurse! What kind of doctor are you, if you don't mind my asking? And would you mind having a look at this rash... (lol j/k!!) I think doctors have it tough because most people look to doctors as a kind of God. Not to be worshipped, but if you are sick or something's wrong with you, you expect the doctor to know what it is and how to fix it. And heaven forbid you are wrong! Then you get sued and lose your house. -sigh- I have worked at a pharmacy for 7 years as a tech and I have had some experience with doctors! What kills me is when people go to see the doctor, the doctor gives them RXs, the person brings them to me and asks why the doc is giving it to them. I always ask, why didn't you ask the doctor? He/She is the one who wrote it! And the answer is ALWAYS: "well, I didn't want to bother him/her." :D
@cortypants (604)
• United States
21 Feb 09
One local doctor always writes "for _____" in the sig of the prescription. I love that he does it because it's now right on the bottle ... cholesterol, blood pressure, sleep, etc. No one reads the inserts we give them! lol.
1 person likes this
@crazydaisy (3896)
• Canada
22 Feb 09
I would say they have ruff time at times the same as any body eles they only try to do there best and as far as nurses go they help them a long to plusas far as being rich not really because they work hard for what they got...
like the saying is if you want it bad enough you will get it,
cd
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
22 Feb 09
Firstly I think nurses are angels on earth, I really do. My sister in law is a nurse and upon learning what she does I am really convinced.
As far as doctors go, fortunately I don't share my father's view; he thinks all doctors are money hungry and will purposefully find illnesses just so they can keep on treating and charging the patients! I think there are good conscientious and caring doctors and the some who would fit my father's view but those are few and far.
I have never studied medicine and I would imagine it is not an easy path and unless you are dedicated you probably would not succeed.
I don't necessarily think a doctor would be rich. I met one who has a practice in a poor area and only charges the occasional patient which would explain why he drives an old beat up car; he comes across very content with his vocation though.
I don't think doctors are just technicians because a good doctor would not get away without a good bedside manner which includes understanding and empathy.
Having said that,there is a young GP at our local medical centre who has ambitions of becoming a surgeon and if he can cut out a mole or give a few stiches he's right in there, he's not the warmest person either!
@mariposaman (2959)
• Canada
27 Feb 09
I think there are not enough doctors in Canada and this results in them being overworked and some of them become arrogant. They cannot spend enough time with their patients because they cannot and maintain a good balance between having a personal life and a professional life. What happens here is that some people do not have a family doctor so they rely on walkin clinics and the emergency department at the hospital. Some doctors when they take new patients are now requiring certain conditions so they get low risk patients that will not bog them down with long office visits.
I do not know about them getting rich in Canada, you have to be a specialist to get paid better. I think they probably are not paid enough when you consider the skill level required and the resposibility. If we can pay certain men to play baseball and football, the doctors do not get paid well by comparison.
@doc_alma_jones (822)
• Philippines
26 Mar 09
that's pretty good insight about doctors. when a hospital is understaffed and a doctor works overtime all the time, he becomes tired, cranky, frustrated, and all in all nt a good person to talk to, lol ^_^
yes, some doctors are not paid enough at all, while some charge way too much. in my country, 11 dollars (roughly 500pesos) is considered a large amount for a mere 3 minute consultation, but that's the going rate here. that's a wage earner's entire day's salary. some charge way more. i'm not saying this rate is too much nor too little; i'm saying that most people can't seem to afford it...
unfortunately, doctors should charge that amount. according to medical ethics, it's actually unethical to charge way too little as this drives patients to just one doctor because of his super cheap charges. it's of course also unethical to charge too much - but this doesn't stop some doctors from being unethical at all.
that's true; some careers pay much better than doctors, which may embitter a doctor, knowing that he really went through a lot of continuous sleepless 36 hour hospital duty days just to graduate. all the expenses, the books that cost 200 dollars, the expensive tuition of ten years of schooling... all in all, these things run through a doctor's mind when he establishes his going rate.
thanks, mariposaman!
@Anora_Eldorath (6028)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I think we feel they get rich and have all the time in the world, but in reality they are human just like the rest of us. I love our doctors, and don't envy their jobs.
I had a really great chiropractor for years that once told me how much he spent on loans, equipment, etc and his take home was next to nothing. It's a tricky business and those that make great doctors went into it because they wanted to help heal, and I think the majority of them went into it for that, not to make money.
Namaste-Anora