Father or motherless? Does it really make a negative impact?

United States
February 24, 2009 12:59pm CST
Does a child growing up in a home without a mother or a father have a BIG impact on them? I grew up with my mom as the primary person raising me along with my grandmother and my aunts. My father was around, and had remarried and had other kids. My mother too had remarried and had other children. But I know that it had a significant effect on me not having him around as my stepdad was around all the time for my brothers. It made me feel awkward at times knowing that I was the only child from their love, and whenever I was around my brothers and sister with my father, I felt alone, and the same with my brothers by my mom. Though we all love each other, it still had positive AND negative effects for me. However know some people that grew up like me and they were just fine, and I know some who had only their dad or their mom and they have had tragic relationships in their lives. I know some people who have grown up with BOTH parents and later admitted they wished their mother or father would have just gotten the divorce, because the kids were just that unhappy... So what do you think? Does the absence of a father or mother make a negative impact on a woman/man's life?
1 person likes this
10 responses
@katsmeow1213 (28716)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I don't think a child needs THEIR mother or father, but they do need A mother AND father. My oldest son's father is not around, but my husband treats him like he's his own. He's treated no differently than hubby's bio kids, and that's what's important. My son has both a mother and father, and I do think that's important. I grew up with no father, the closest I had was some male family friends. It wasn't enough. Kids learn a lot from their fathers, and from watching their parents interact with each other. It shapes the way they interact with their spouse someday.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Feb 09
My son called my husband by his name up until I got pregnant for the twins (hubby's first kids). At that point I demanded that my son be treated no differently by anyone on either side of our family. I told my husband that my son would be his, and that he'd even adopt my son (which didn't end up happening). So from that point on he was dad instead of called by his name. We also told hubby's parents all this, and from that point on they were grandma and grandpa to my son. They were a little shocked at first, which actually upset me because it seemed they weren't thrilled with the idea, but in time they got used to it and were fine with it. Now even they don't treat him any differently.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Feb 09
I am glad you did that :) Your son will remember that when he is older. My stepdads parents were always Nanny and Grandad to me, even before he and my mom married and had my first brother. They bought me gifts and at Christmas I was their granddaughter. It makes things so much better for the child knowing that the entire family treats them AS FAMILY :)
• United States
24 Feb 09
True, having both does make a difference. I am glad your son has your husband to love him like his own. It does make a difference in a child's life. My Dad (stepdad) always loved me like I was his, but when I was growing up before they married (I was 6 when they met) my mom told me to call him by his name. So up until I was around 17, I always called him by his name. Then someone asked me, "Who is that" and I said "My dad" and they said "Then why don't you call him 'DAD'". I didn't have an answer other than I have always called him by his first name, and even after saying that I knew it was odd to call him dad to others and not to his face.... So, from then on he was just DAD. It took me until my daddy (bio dad) got divorced from my stepmom to start calling her Mama. I just realized that I never called her that (though she loved me like her own) because my mom would have gone nuts! I guess what I am saying is, having both parents is a good thing, and even if they are not the biological parents, as long as the child is loved that's all that matters :)
• Philippines
24 Feb 09
i am only child and it;'s sad to know that i would have been a better being if i have a sibling to share my life. i have been alone most of my life because my parents seperated when i was 10. my father left us for my stepmom. though eveything is good between us now but my mom and i were never the same. my mom can i only spend some time whenever she comes home from work abroad. she's been there in KSA since i was 8 years old. my father too that's why i was left with the care my grandmother and my aunt (father's side). but i grew up parentless. my grandmother can only attend to my concerns whenever she's home. she's a politician there in our province and my aunt, is also busy working. we can only meet after their work which is after dinner. so, i can say i am misguided in a way. though i know i have a happy childhood but all i think about was play. when it comes to school activities, i am very poor with my academics. but my teachers were kind enough to give me passing grade because my grandmother was well known in our place. when i was in high school, that was the time my mother decided to transfer me to the city. under the care of my aunt, her sister. she wants me to have a good education. that was the time i became familiar with the world. i was a loner in my high school because no one can understand my humor (since i came from the province) and the school i got in was a private school. some classmates of mine bullied me until sophomore year. it was quite sad for me. but i gain some "friends" when i was in junior year. i never told my mom about that because i don't want her to worry. my grades we're low too but thankfully, i still passed. i know my response is quite long and boring. but i guess, a parents guidance is very, very important. until now, whenever i get myself into trouble, my mom, after the lecture of course lol, will apologize to me on her absence when i was growing up. i understand her in a way because the reason why she has to work abroad is that, she can earn a big amount and she has to sacrifice being a mother to me so that she can give me a good future. =)our relatinship now is still a struggle but getting better in a way. we all have our stories here and i know i can't just judge anyone because i don't know the journey in their lives. but i would really wish that whenever a child is born here on earth. he or she would have a parent by their side. to support them al through the way as they grow. =)
1 person likes this
• Philippines
25 Feb 09
=) thank you so much for the heartwarming response. your advice is greatly appreciated. cheers to us all here in mylot. =)
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Feb 09
You're welcome :) And thanks to you too! Have a good one!
• United States
24 Feb 09
Totally, thanks so much for your response. I was NOT bored at all, and I actually felt that I could connect with you. Not because I have had similar experiences, but just because I could empathize with you, and with having a mom who had to work and support me. My mother went to work full time everyday, then would come home for an hour, have lunch, then head off to school at night. She wouldn't come home until 11pm and I'd be tucked into bed by that time. My Nana and my aunts took care of me and my cousins, while the moms were away at work. So even though they were there it was hard not being able to talk to my mom when I wanted. I do understand :) The journey your life has taken you on will lead you to be able to advise another young woman, or even your own daughter one day. It will also help you to make decisions for your children, because you saw how your mom loved you and did what she had to do to take care of you, even though it meant being away.
@celticeagle (168136)
• Boise, Idaho
25 Feb 09
I really believe there are negative impacts in not having the daily influence of a father or mother in a child's life. It has become the norm for those absenses to be taken into acount in the small psyches of our youth. Sad. Very sad.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Feb 09
Yes it is very sad. I believe that there needs to be a balance, there should ALWAYS be a father and mother in the picture. I know there are times when this cannot be helped and I am definitely not against those who are single parents and raise their children alone. I commend them for being strong to do that, my mom did for 12 years. But I know that having the other parent there helps more than anything else.
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (168136)
• Boise, Idaho
26 Feb 09
Afew decades back the entire family lived together and usually in very cramped quarters. It takes a village. Family is very important.
1 person likes this
• India
25 Feb 09
ya it hurts.we need someone to really care on us.no one in the world could love u more than a mother r father..anyway it happens sometimes..be sure tat we help people we lost their parents.love can overcome it
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Feb 09
Yes, love can overcome it, I agree. And for those who don't have their parents, I would only hope that they have another family member (grandmother/father or aunt/uncle) who would try to love them like their own. These things help out a lot.
@acmj1985 (25)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I think that a household with both parents is always better but is not always possible. I think that if the parent that is there can play both parts then the child should be fine. I do believe that every boy needs a strong male figure to guide them and do boy things with them. If you as a mother can do that then more power to you. Also, I think that little girls need a strong independent mother to teach them about being a woman and how woman should be treated is also important! When I was younger I remember my dad trying so hard to do girl things with me an dmy sister and I appreciated that but it wasn't the same!
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Feb 09
That was sweet of your dad to try to do the girl things for you guys, and you are right, it's just not the same. My dad (step) had to go out once because my mom wasn't home (she had just had my 3rd brother) and buy my feminine napkins. Talk about embarrassed to have to ask him and even have him bring them back. But he was really nice, and brought me chocolates, my favorite soda and some chips, since he knows that's what I usually craved around that time lol. Still, it's like you said, not the same as having mom. Oh, and I agree, both parents is better, but unfortunately not always the way it works out :( I think people who have even one parent that loves and cares for them is truly blessed still. :) Welcome to Mylot :)
@Zass101 (66)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I feel it does. i lost my father at an early age, and i feel i missed out on alot of lifes lessons due to this. i mean i had no "father son" good times. ill never be taken out for a drink with my old man. i can go to him and ask for advise. its realy not very fun. iv had to go into the unknown without a father behind me to back me up. but then again it has also made my emotions alot stronger too.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Feb 09
Zass, thanks for sharing that. That can be very hard, but you hardly ever hear a guy admitting that not having his dad around actually did effect him in that way. You know, guys (some) are always like, "I did this or that without a father, I didn't need him, I taught myself how to be a man" or other phrases like that. It's really hard when they are gone before you get the chance to know them, but it seems like you have also gotten some positives from it. There is definitely nothing wrong with a man in touch with his emotions :)
@jillbeth (2705)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I also think--it depends! There is a reason we have both mothers and fathers, and it's hard for a single parent to be both. I have to give them credit for trying, because I've been there, although briefly. I think that children who don't have both parents at least need a strong role model, perhaps a relative, whom they can relate to as the absent parent. I think the absence of a father is especially hard on a daughter. Her father is the one who teaches her, unconsciously and by his behavior toward her, how to accept love from men. A father who is absent, maybe not even physically but emotionally, from his daughter may end up with a daughter who becomes sexually active at an early age because she wants a man, any man, to love her. But a father who does not behave appropriately toward his daughter can also cause serious problems! I'm speaking in general terms, of course. I don't mean to imply that all girls who have an absent father become promiscuous, I'm sure many don't, but it's a common cause of such behavior. But all families and the individuals within them are different. Pehaps some of the positive effects counteract the negative ones!
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Feb 09
You know, Jill, you were speaking directly to me in your response. I will get a little personal now, lol. My dad was around when I was younger, but he was not THERE. And you are right, it did teach me about men and how to accept their love and what love from a man was. My mother told me I was totally crazy about my dad, so much so, that when he would fail to come pick me up on his days, or fail to call me after he promised, that she would spend WEEKS trying to get me out of the stupor I would fall into. And I was just a TODDLER! I do remember the most catastrophic time, was when I was 3 and my dad had told me he would come to get me later that evening. For reasons that I know now, but didn't then, when I got home and packed my weekend bags, already to go, and he did not show. Every day for 2 wks I would sit at the window hoping that one of the cars would be him coming to get me. And everyday he didn't show. Finally one day he did, and I remember (as well as my mom) that I just jumped up from the dinner table and ran to get my things EAGER to get his attention and make sure that I was ready before he left me (again) just to make sure that I was going to. I remember hearing my mom crying and yelling at him for how sad I had been for his not showing and it's just convenient for him to come when he wants, etc. etc. etc. To this day, when my husband leaves the house and does not return when I think he will or comes home from work late, I get paranoid and anxious, and I start to worry and cry. I am always eager to jump up and please, because I don't want to be left alone. Also I hate when people break their promises (which is hard on my husband) because if they say they will do something, I expect and wait anxiously for them to fulfill that promise... Sorry for getting so in depth, but you just hit the nail on the head about the ways a father can influence his daughter. John Mayer sings a song that says "Fathers be good to your daughters, daughters will love like you do; girls become lovers, who turn into mothers, so mothers be good to your daughters too" And this cannot be more true! :)
@jashley1 (746)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I definately have to say that I really believe that an absence of one or the others as role models in your life can really make a difference. For any child the amount of positive role models that they can look up to and learn from while growing up really impacts the way that they turn out as adults. If a young boy does not have his father around, nor any positive male influences, then how can he really learn how to be a man? Yes, he can turn out to be a great citizen and person - I'm not saying that - but when it is his turn to be in relationships and get married, become a father himself, he will have missed out on learning from that male image that was lost. Please don't get me wrong - anyone can teach him or herself to do and become whatever they want - I'm not saying that if you did not have one or the other around that you will never become great or anything like that. All I'm saying is that it is probably harder and that the absence of a mother or father can really have an impact on a child's life. I think that as long as they are given tons of love and have other types of positive role models in their life while growing up, that it can definately also help cushion that impact and help them along the way though!
• United States
24 Feb 09
I understood EXACTLY where you were coming from. I know girls who were raised by dads and were just fine, and grew up to be wonderful women, and I know some who were the opposite because they didn't have that female influence in the home. There are some guys I know who (for their own reasons) grew up and made the choices to be homosexual and other people have blamed the mother for not having a man around to teach him how to be a man; and I know some guys that have grown up without a father and have turned into WONDERFUL men. I suppose it all just depends on the person doing the rearing and the child doing the learning. I do agree, without a man to really show a son how to court a woman in ways that a woman doesn't get or understand, some men will be at a loss. My husband didn't really get much teaching about how to love a woman and court her from his dad, and so when it comes to doing some things he is awkward and just won't do it because he doesn't know how. ::sigh:: I don't know. I have seen so many instances where things turn out great and things turn out bad from the absence of one or the other parent. My heart tells me though (because I was there) that nothing feels better than being raised by a father and a mother, whether biological, step or adopted.
@mermaidivy (15394)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I had a happy family when I grew up. But I'm sure it has impact either way. Because mothers and fathers are role playing different things to their children. It won't be a good thing at all to not have either one. I think kids or I should teenagers are easier to "go bad" growing up in a broken family.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Feb 09
Yes, the teen years are hard on the ones that don't have both parents in the home. I can recall acting out a little more with my dad (bio) because he didn't live in my home and wasn't the one who raised me, and acting out with my stepdad because he wasn't my "daddy"... it was hell on them both at times :)
@forslahiri (1042)
• India
25 Feb 09
Hi, Instead of 2 personality's influence,the child will be getting one. naturally, his behaviour-bloom will be influenced by one only. It's a Loss, for the child. =Lahiri,Kolkata,India.
• United States
26 Feb 09
Yes I agree with you. Which brings me to the point that I believe they need a balance in their life to help them grow up to the best of their potential