Who created men God or Darwin ?

i heard this story once from my sister.. i think it was some kind of a text message from her friends.. it goes like this.. God and man were talking.. the man said that he can create anything and God said, go on show me.. then the man took some dust to make something out of it.. then God said, make your own dust. so i guess there's really no contest..

I'll ask any Darwin believer why the monkeys, apes, gorillas, etc., haven't become extinct if we evolved from them. And why are women having babies? And why aren't animals having CHILDREN, if we evolved from them? It is a stretch of the imagination to think we came from an animal. Of course, there is always somebody who will question whether there is a real GOD or if he had anything to do with anything. I will have to say, though, that there are some people who do act like monkeys!

Of course evolution by natural selection is correct, the evidence is overwhelming, the theory ranks along side our best theories of all time, like the theory of gravity, Euclidian geometry, Einsteinian relativity, etc. It does not however, invalidate the belief that God created man, rather it describes the mechanism all the best urban

Hi krajibg, I think that there has to be a first cause or as most people say God. It is possible to believe in both God and evolution because we are spiritual beings and Darwin only talks about the physical. Blessings.

God created Darwin and made him smart enough to realize something that should be pretty obvious to everyone but which everyone never thinks about because their minds are caught up in another idea. I think God is smart enough to create the mechanism for creating stars and planets and insects and animals and plants. The building blocks of the universe are exactly the things we have in our bodies, oxygen, carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, etc. I think we should give God more credit than just the god of genesis which is fine as a story but I suspect creation is a bit more complicated than that described in genesis. For one thing, God would not need to rest, the concept of god and resting is a bit too mundane. Cheers!!

I don't really know who created man, all I know is that he was not made by evolution. We are too complex to have happened by accident. But everyone thinks that someone else createdus, and I really think that there is no definite proof of who did. It will just one of those everlasting questions.

The answer to your question is that neither god or Darwin created man. The human species is a result of natural evolutionary processes. Darwin did not come up with the idea of evolution. The first record of a discussion goes back to Empedocles, a Greek philosopher born in 490BCE who proposed the idea that animals adopt to there surrounding as a result of natural selection. Al-Jahiz, a Muslim theologian and scholar born in Basra around 776CE proposed a similar idea and many others played with the idea before Darwin. Darwins controbution was years of work to develop the evidence to support the idea and his presentation of it in an understandable fashion. The amazing thing is that his ideas have been proven right over the last 150 years. He got most of it right using thought and intuition. It has been only as science has developed and his ideas put to the test that it is possible to realize how large his contribution is. His idea may be the most important single contribution ever made to science.

this is a silly comparison. believing in evolution is not the same as believing that mankind was created by one of its own. or do you believe that Newton created gravity? coming up with a theory does not mean creating it. because theories describe things already there. I do not believe in the God of book based religions. but I do not believe that you or I or Darwin created us. we are products of Nature, and Nature creates change through evolution.

This is where reason comes in. Too far gone is a man who is willing to stick to the literal interpretation of his holy book, despite what facts are thrown at him. There's a fine line between faith and delusion, and many people cross with with their denial of scientific facts. Many religious folks have adapted their beliefs to encompass evolution - often times with the belief that evolution was a tool used by God to create life on Earth. I don't see why one can't believe in a god and accept evolution at once.

As a person who has always been sort of a science geek and nerd, I've always had a great love for the sciences..from astronomy, geology, paleontology, archeology and anthropology. One can't say Darwin "created" mankind but was responsible in establishing the evolution concept to explain how species evolved, yet even he wasn't exactly the first as scientists and researchers started to think the evolutionary process long before he did and wrote his book "Origin Of Species" (which I happen to have a copy of). Even though I do believe in the process of evolution I also believe in a higher creative force that "sparked" life as we know it...all life, from the very beginning of the universe and that one initial spark that created the Big Bang which would ultimately spark the existence of galaxies, planets and so forth...from there if the conditions were right, life would eventually "evolve" on planets suitable for life Yes, according to paleontologist/anthropologist, mankind did evolve from the primate line but there were two separate branches...one branch was to remain the "monkey" line, while another would evolve into the human species line...this was not something that happened in a twinkling of an eye as the Bible would have you believe, but a long process taking millions of years. I know there are many die-hard Christians that truly take every word of the Bible as literal fact, and they never question it..and while as I said I do believe in a higher force, I can't imagine mankind just suddenly appearing "out of nowhere" fully grown as the Bibl suggests. You have to realize too, the Bible and any other religious source of creation were explanations made by people thousands and thousands of years ago, to try to understand how things came into being...the "creation" story, and every culture and religion has it's own Creation story, from Judaic, Christian, Hindu, even Native American..the ancient Greeks, Egyptians, Mesopotamians too had their own creation stories.. You might just say, with science that scientists too are doing a retelling of the creation story but by scientific means...but at least with science there is proof of "creation" and evolution via fossil records and evidence.,

Hi friend I will say god is the power behind all activities in the universe. So according to me though darwin say we are all through evolution then to god is only the one who made those evolution. What do you think? will you agree with me? happy myloting.

Hi, I only say that the "Missing Link" is still missing. Upto that day(when the missing-link will be unfolded with evidence)I 'll believe in that SUPER POWER! =Lahiri,Kolkata,India.

i believe in Darwin theory as it is more simple. And if you look at the apes, you must believe Darwin theory as they do really look like us.

If you believe that God created the world in 7 days then you have to believe that Eve was producing children with her sons and the sons with their daughters. People need to understand that the old testament is not a literal translation. It's my opinion that the words of the Old Testament have been given way too much credence. Darwin found the evidence and put forward the theories, he didn't create anything.

I have no argument with Darwin, nor with the tale of Creation. God (or whatever you choose to call him) did not create the earth in seven of our days, but His. Nor did he create man in one brief moment. God has to be a scientist, just look at the seamless way that all of nature interacts! It would make sense that He evolved us into His image through a gradual process. He also gave us the brains to recognize this if we will only use the intelligence He gave us. The Bible and other holy books were written by men, inspired by God or not, in such a way that the people of that time could understand them. That is why they say that things were created in a short span of time. The more science I learn, the more my faith is reinforced.

Well have we evolved from animals I don't know...? But who created the animals? Where does life itself come from? It has to be a Higher Power of some sort. Even if we were not to believe in God surely we can all see there is a force running things here. Every day things happen that are not necessarily our doing and are beyond our control. There is something in charge here. Some of us choose to call him God but his name is irrelevant, the important thing is what He stands for; love. Now that's evolution!

To be totally honest who cares,it is more likely we came from the sea or ocean.It is so long ago why not just be satisfied we are here and living,does anyone really care how we got here.

Well, Rajib, what I say is that man existed before Darwin. My other half says that the answer is both because thoughts are things and nothing exists without thoughts. He said Darwin creates man, we create man, God creates man and man creates God.

Well, apparently some scientists have tried to create a "person," of course, they failed. Darwin was "man." So, therefore, if scientists can't make a person or even remotely close to it, it had to be God. I would love to see someone create stars, humans, trees, etc. I think it would be something fun to watch at least. No one is as experienced as the almighty creator. Think about it. God creates a big picture in the sky every second of the day. The Big Bang theory is outplayed now. I actually had an argument with my science teacher about this. She was teaching on the "Big Bang" theory and I was arguing with her to reach my point. She had scientists and I had my Bible, haha! I never in my life have ever got sent to the office for disagreeing or speaking my mind until that day. Now, if you go into that school, Bibles are allowed and we have the right to wear religious shirts. Go me! You can't argue with someone that is greater than us. I know people are entitled to their own opinions and I respect that but I will fight whoever disagrees with me, nicely, of course.