what sentence would you give to a father who raped his daughter?

i would castrate him. simple as that, sick men like that are freaks so we might as well give them the physical appearance of one too. i hate people like this. they're SELFISH and they have no regard to others around them. if i could personally get away with destroying them all myself, i would with no hesitation. i wish i were a judge just so i could send these disgusting animals where they belong.

yes it happens all over the world that is true, yes I would want a tough sentence, probably one that fits the crime, he goes to jail for the rest of his life and is raped by other male inmates over and over again.

I think the punishment that they had many years ago was very effective, it is called castration. And then the offender had to support the victim for life. Simple, effective and punishment will be for every day of his life

wow yes i agree with you these men should be dealt with severely and painfully ... my only problem is that the child involved will have longer to move on because they will have the constant reminder there and until the man is out of their life for good they can not move on. I feel for these children and so sad that the people who they should be looking to for protection are the ones they need protection from .. its heartbreaking.. we really need to find a painful way to deal with them but one that works quickly so the children are able to move on with their lives and get the help they deserve.

i would give a long and painful few years then kill him, i dont think people like that should get the easy way out buy just killing him i say make him suffer of the things he had done.sick sick people!!!

I would give him more of a punishment than I would give the person who did it if they were a complete stranger... but sadly and sickly in the United States, the punishment against those who rape their daughters is a walk in the park compared to what a stranger would get for doing it.... I say cut off their willies and feed em to the dogs!

Well, the biggest thing is it has been happening for many many many yrs. all over the world, and it is so hard to prevent and Stop things like this from happening. And the biggest thing sometimes is getting a Court to believe you. As someeone who has physically and sexually abused by my Step dad about 40 yrs. ago, and he has never been arrested, even though people have said things about him doing this, I feel that every man that does this does need help, but at the same time they should be punished for their actions. Personally I would wonder why they result down to this, but seriously wish there was a way to Stop this from happening everywhere as it destroys so many lives for sure. As for an appropriate punishment I am not sure what would be the Best for them.

Castration and life in prison!

I have no idea what do with these kind of people. My darker self says do horrible things to them, but then I realize that if we do that we risk becoming "the evil we deplore." Parents (either parent) are supposed to protect their kids, not abuse them in this horrible sort of way. I'm sure that this father ought not get out of jail ever!

Honestly, I think rapist should be hung. I also think that if more hardcore criminals...murderers, rapists, child molesters...were hung that less ppl would attempt to do the same thing knowing what the punishment is. The problem is that instead they get a life sentence of three meals a day, medical treatment, possible education, a prison job, recreation and visits...doesn't sound all that bad for breaking the law. [b]~~AT PEACE WITHIN~~ **STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS**[/b]

My punishment would be short and sweet - publically surgically castrate him and let him spend the rest of his miserable life never being able to get it up again.

Would prefer him to be imprisoned all his life, to the dark room with no one to talk to. Thereby he would realize all his criminal acts and no matter how regretful he is, no way for him and no chance for him to even ask forgiveness from his victim.

stone him

I read about that case too and to be frank i was shocked. It was beyond belief that a father can do this to her kids.. He should be punished and punished what law can give him maximum but i wont go for cruel punishment and we live in civil society so i would just put him in a cell for rest of his life.. have a holy man preach him about religion and let him repent what he did.

I would tell them they are Going to Hell! That is so sick for a person to do this to there own child or any child. I hate people like that!

is castration still allowed? well i would employ those methods they use in olden days china where the emperor was still alive and had eunuchs running his palace. if castration is not allowed, than a life imprisonment.

i can't think of any word or phrase that would fit this very evil act of a father raping his child. I pity this children who suffered from her own father who must be her shelter and will keep her from any harm.

I want to cut his head infront of all people.

I would make him like eat a worm that would eat him from the inside out because that is just WRONG

See,These fathers are animals and they don't know the value relation of human kind.......They must treated with respect they deserve and punish them to the ultimun.