Runners - What Shoes Do You Wear?

@Pigglies (9329)
United States
June 8, 2009 5:27pm CST
Or do you wear shoes at all? It seems like every runner I talk to has a different perspective on what the best running shoes are. I'm just starting out and I will hopefully be joining a running club soon to help me get in shape. I have hopes of eventually running a marathon, but it doesn't necessarily have to be one that's coming up anytime within the year. It might take me quite awhile to get built up to that. I don't know yet. So far I've been running in Vibram FiveFingers KSOs, but after getting tendonitis I'm thinking those might just end up being shoes I wear at other times, not for running. Although they are supposed to work for running so maybe once my strength is built up a bit I will try to wear them again. I've read a lot of good stuff about people using their shoes for marathons and even longer distances than that. So I do realize this is probably just my fault for being out of shape, it's not the shoes. The trails out here are not well kept up, so I need to get shoes that can stand up to a lot of rocks, sticks, dirt, etc. So what do you wear currently? Do you like them? Why or why not?
1 person likes this
5 responses
@syndibee (799)
• United States
8 Aug 09
Did you get your new shoes? If so what did you get and do you like them? I'm currently wearing Nike Free V5's. They are a step up from the VFF KSO's that you are currently using heading in the direction of full foot support. I'm actually wanting to step down to the VFF Sprints. If I were doing trail running as you are doing I would entirely go for what you already have. If you want to go for a full out running shoe I would go to a store that is sponsored by your running group and ask them to fit you for a trail running shoe. They would have you run on a treadmill and check out your old shoes (so be sure to bring them) for wear and tear to fit you with the best shoe for you. So all that said I'm interested in your input on the VFF KSO's
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
8 Aug 09
How funny, I got the Nike Free V5's too! They are way more shoe than the VFF KSOs, so I don't even consider the Nike as a barefoot shoe. But overall I like them (except when I get blisters!). I don't like the KSO so much for trail running. Or even track. My ankles just aren't strong enough it seems. My tendons have gotten much better, but my ankles always hurt if I do more than 2 miles in the KSOs. And then of course if you hit a rocky trail you are in big trouble because there is basically no protection against rocks. Try getting bruises on the bottoms of your feet. But I still am happy I bought them. They're good for short trail runs on soft dirt. And if I ever did a mud run, for sure they are the shoes I would wear since they will stay on your feet no matter what. I don't have any wear showing on my shoes yet, but maybe when I get more miles on my Nikes I will go to the running store and see about getting a trail shoe. Sometimes even the Nikes just don't have enough ankle support it seems. And they are horrible on trails since rocks stick in them immediately. But since I'm still mostly doing roads and the track, I think I'll continue to use them for now. Oh, but one really good note on the VFFs... they really make you run correctly. If you heel strike, instant feedback! Pain will shoot up your heel. So right away they fixed that for me (I still occasionally do it in my other shoes though). And you really can feel the work out in your foot muscles, unlike shoes that jam your toes together. But I think you need to have some really good muscle before you can actually race in these. And some trails without rocks.
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
8 Aug 09
You are insane, lol! But hats off to you, I wanted to do barefoot running but my ankles just aren't strong enough. I should try taking the insert out of my Nikes though. The toes are also really tight for me. I don't feel like I need cushion, it's my ankles that hurt, not my feet themselves. I did go for a run on a very sandy 3 mile trail this morning, and thank goodness for the VFF KSOs, because any other shoe would have been filled with sand! I tried on the sprints in the store and they fit me really weird because I have narrow ankles (or had at least, before running). The classics weren't available in my size at the time. I think if I get the classics eventually I'll go with the ones for men. I think I will try that trail run race at the end of this month. I'd probably run faster in trail shoes vs. the VFFs, but since they'll still work I'll just use the VFFs so I don't have to buy more shoes just yet. Funny how I started running so that I wouldn't have to pay for the gym, and it turns out to be nearly just as expensive!
@syndibee (799)
• United States
8 Aug 09
I've been running in my Nike Frees for the past 2 months and they show absolutely NO wear. I say they are very well made. I just took the insoles out as the toes were just too tight for me. I'll be ordering the VFF sprints in a couple of weeks. I actually want to start running barefoot and hopefully do my first 5K barefoot in the springtime. I'm not planning on a barefoot harsh winter outside though.
@jedopi (401)
• Canada
22 Jun 09
I have Nike runners but when my Plantar Fasciitis starts to act up (I have flat feet) I have to wear my special MBT shoes with orthotics inside. They were very expensive and they look kind of odd but they really do help if you have any type of pain in your feet, legs or back.
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
22 Jun 09
Hmm, I haven't heard of MBT shoes. I have muscle spams in my feet, but thankfully that is all because that is already more than I can handle sometimes. My feet just seize up and hurt like crazy and all I can do is wait for the pain to stop.
@halynn (1809)
• United States
14 Jun 09
I like nike shoes to run & exercise in. It seems like anytime i try a diff brand my feet hurt like crazy.
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
15 Jun 09
Thanks for your response! I'm going out shoe shopping tomorrow. I've been looking at Nike's a lot online and it seems like a lot of people prefer them. I would have bought some online except that it seems like Nike sizing is different from regular sizing from the reviews I've been reading. So I found a store near here and will be going to try on different styles. Which ones specifically do you like? Any that you don't like?
• United States
20 Jun 09
For racing distances on road 10K or less, I wear the Nike Mayfly. It has very little support, but is incredibly lightweight. For general training, any trail race, or road races a half-marathon or longer, I prefer the Nike Air Pegasus. It has lots of firm support for us larger runners, isn't terribly heavy, and has reasonable traction.
• United States
20 Jun 09
I use the Nike Mayfly for short races (5-10K or so), since it's extremely lightweight, but has little firm support. I need more support for half-marathons or more, so for those races, I use Nike Air Pegasus. It has a lot more firmness that my overly-large body requires.
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
20 Jun 09
Thanks! That is very helpful. I always wonder how to tell which shoes are for which purpose. I was reading reviews of some shoes and people said if you're heavier you couldn't wear them. Luckily for me, I don't think I'm heavy enough to worry about that. But I still haven't figure out if I need support or not.