Children need to socialize; but they can't talk to strangers?

@cyberfluf (4996)
Netherlands
September 3, 2009 3:56pm CST
There are some strange rules out there that we adults make. For example: - Children can't talk to strangers, but how will they ever learn social skills if they obey this rule? If a child would literarly obey this rule than we would never get to know people from outside our own house; unless there is an extention to the rule that says you can talk to people that are not strange to your parents (or that your parents think are thrustworthy). But in it't essence, it's non-sence to teach a kid not to talk to strangers. - Well then, don't talk to scary strangers than en don't take their candy. What's scary? Are we making our children prejudged by giving them an idea of what could be scary? And if someone was to kidnap a child, wouldn't they make sure that they look nice and not scary at all? And if that's the case: how cán we teach our children about safety? Some things are hard to make sence. I know teaching children to stay safe is important, very important, but sometimes we adults make up some awkward rules . Tell me about the most ridiculous, non-sence rule you heard!
1 person likes this
3 responses
@angryeve (684)
• Philippines
8 Sep 09
Hi cyberfluf, it's funny you notice that, how parents love to set a rule that is a bit confusing for their children. Anyway, I've read a comment from one of the mylotter, I think it's loverbear. It's about the "picking your nose in public" rule. Now that was so funny and embarassing for a parent to be reminded by your own child about your own rule, haha how ironic. Well, I remember one rule my mom always reminds us when I was little, the "Don't interrupt me when I'm talking to someone cause that's rude". I have to say it is a bit rude to be interrupting adults talking. But how were you suppose to ask, "where's the bathroom" or "Can I play with this" without interrupting? So when you don't interrupt them and just try to explore the things you wanna know yourself, you're scolded. Saying that I should just stay right beside her. Duh.. first of all it takes them long hours chatting, plus I can't interact with them or whatever, and she expects me to stay put for that long, I don't know any kid that is normal that could do that.lol
1 person likes this
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
8 Sep 09
I have to agree, the time span is way to long for a child to keep focussed on one thing; if any, because most of the time a child has nothing to know when waiting for an adult conversation to finish. I used to interupt conversations a lot because I was so eager to participate in them. My mom "punished" me for this by asking me to keep my mouth shut for 2 minutes. I took this very serious and I was about to cry, but I didn't even do that in those 2 minutes. She had no idea I would take this so heavily and comforted me. It was more a joke than anything else, but this reminds us that children can take things way more serious.
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
10 Sep 09
Too bad it got deleted, but it's a valuable lesson learned. Some things we need to find out by trial and error and I guess this was yours. Luckily it won't cause your earnings to deduct big time if it's just one discussion. You'll earn it back in no time now you know what to watch out for. I can also give you the tip to add images to your discussions (non copyrighted) as this will also boost your earnings. For example, I took a picture of my own birkenstock slippers to add to the discussion on which type of birkenstock model is your favourite .
@angryeve (684)
• Philippines
9 Sep 09
Hi cyberfluf, I agree, we should always be sensitive ragarding to how our child would react. Cause one thing about kids is that they tend to exaggerate feelings and things sometimes most especially when they are being scolded or punished. By the way, about the discussion I wrote on real online job, it got deleted by the admin.lol I don't know when, I just noticed it yesterday when I was trying to check if I got any new comments. Hope that never happens to any of my discussions ever. =)
1 person likes this
@VANILLAREY (1470)
• India
10 Sep 09
By strangers parents mean older strangers who don't live in the neighborhood or the kind you meet in the streets. Children can be encouraged to make new friends of their own age group. However if the child does not talk to a policeman or concerned citizen when the kid gets lost would be a problem. In school teachers used punish students when found talking, even when there was no teacher in the classroom. How can they expect children to be quite for 5-6 hours. I understand student being punished for making noise, but for simple chatting its a bit extreme.
1 person likes this
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
10 Sep 09
I agree that is exreme, Vanillarey. I do know that parents mean no harm with learning their children this, but the rule itsself is a bit awkward as it does not point out which strangers we can and can't meet. I am taking this a bit far, I know, but children can take things very literarly so I was wondering how different people would react to a discussion like this. Yes, we know what is meant with this rule but the rule itsself I find unclear. Thank you for taking time to respond! .
@theprogamer (10534)
• United States
6 Sep 09
Well in terms of adults making awkward, weird or unnecessary rules I could give you some from my childhood and several that seem to prop up in current western world "parenting" Don't play outside your way [the entire alphabet] could happen to you -_- - never happened Don't talk too much - See next entry... Don't be silent - Usually said after 'don't talk too much', also leads to 'don't talk too much' if this rule is obeyed Don't fight (directed at boys almost always) -_-? - grandpa's generation fought as kids - dad's generation fought as kids - my generation either stabs, shoots or is pretty much "let's weakling it up!" (but of course, its no one's fault... -_-) Don't cook you'll [burn] the [yourself, stove, food, house] -_-' - ironic since BOTH parents have done all of the above while I never have Don't drink its [bad, very bad, sinful, omg hell for you] -_-? - ironically said before, while or ugh...during drinking Don't smoke its (ah forget it, see "don't drink") - ironically... (nevermind just see "don't drink" for this too) Don't bother me when I [insert anything (very)pointless here] - "Don't worry TV will be your parent, back to (see 'don't drink' or 'don't smoke') About the don't talk to strangers. Its meant for kids not to talk to adults they don't know. However, I'm not too sure (and wouldn't be surprised) if current "parents" applied this to stranger kids and not just adults. If that's the case its even worse than I thought -_-. The strangers are also adjusting by dressing nice like you said Cyberfluf, but they are also using costumes of police, security, authority, etc. There is also a growing sentiment against normal looking guys for being potential [any crime in the alphabet, and of course the obvious crimes -_-]. I've seen stories of fathers being questioned, scrutinized, suspected, for being out in public with their children. And pretty much you've got it. A generation full of people with self esteem issues, social issues, ethical issues, unable to talk or interact with others... and a society hellbent on being overprotected and idiotic. "Fun times ahead (well fun times now too if you think about it)" [/sarcasm]
1 person likes this
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
6 Sep 09
Thank you for your wonderfull comment. Whilst it made me laugh, you have some valid points in there that need serious consideration by all of us. We have to take time to stand still and look at what the world is becoming too. The rules we supply for our children will have a lot to do with how our children and the future generation will turn out to be. I am studying to become a pedagogue, so these questions intrigue me not just out of personal curiosity but also as a part of my studies. Thank you for taking the time to reply.