Would you put spy software in ur teenage children mobile?

@agrim94 (3805)
India
September 27, 2009 9:50pm CST
It was in The Hindustan Times couple of days ago that the demand for phone spy software is so much in Delhi that the shops have run out of it. It costs about 2500?- rs ie about 55 American dollars. They now can know if their girl is having friendship with the kind of guys they shouldn't have and can even know by spying on their gps system where they are in dead of the night. it does help in parents knowing children if they are in trouble that where they are right now but it does spy on the kids privacy. SO would you present your children a phone which has this software. Remember the phone and software together would cost you about 500$.
2 people like this
17 responses
28 Sep 09
Difficult to say at this point. My daughters probably would never forgive me for intruding in their private lives. Already at this time, I just happen to glance at their chatting sessions and they tell me already not to peek. This would really be intrusive.. Hower, if I feel that they are in danger or in too much trouble, I would not hesitate to invest in this.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi involaved, thanks for the response and well if they are in danger then you have no way to know because it is already late, so i dont know when i would have kids i would invest in this or not but it does look like a nice software and privacy may be a thing but in name of privacy kids can not be allowed to do anything they want.
29 Sep 09
If you are a parent, you will know when they are near danger. It's that intuition which most (if not all) mothers have. Which is not to say that I am in total control of their lives. You just know when to step in and when to step out.
@cherrc (661)
• Philippines
28 Sep 09
hello there. as a daughter, i would disagree. each member of the family has his or her fair share. each member needs to be respected. with or without the spy gadget, people, like kids have free will to choose their path, be it good or bad. spy gadget can only help their parents to find out. but of course, i have no idea what is really happening in ur country. am only speaking for myself as a daughter. i have all the opportunity to get drunk, high, or get pregnant not just because of the free will but also because i was totally away from my parents, but i chose not to coz i love life and i live for my dreams. ü
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
Hi cherrc, thanks for ur response and may be you were good girl but not all the girls are like you and 14 or 15 or 16 years is an age where children are not mature enough and dont know whats good or bad for them and they are easily attracted to the things which they shouldnt be doing .. It is a big headache of parents then and if they are not careful enough then it can mar the life of the child. I am not saying that if this software is good or not.. just wanting to know what people are thinking.
@cherrc (661)
• Philippines
29 Sep 09
lol, i may be good but not that good coz i also had and still having some flaws in life. most especially during that age of exploring and discovering what i wanted in my life. honestly, i observed that kids nowadays are more wise in coming up with their decisions. i believe orientation matters and that will make them street smarts, not just learning from the book but from the life itself. of course, i may not like the idea of having gps on my cel but still, it's the parent's call. i'm only against it when it only pertains to the issue of trust but in terms of safety, c'mon, bring it on! that's the brighter side of being techy. tnx a lot. :)
• United States
30 Sep 09
All of my kids are grown now but I still think that it might be a good thing in some ways. To me its not always your own kids that you have to worry about doing something wrong. Look at all the crimes that are committed against children everyday anymore. If something like this could help save a child's life, I'd say it would be worth it. I guess it would depend on what you really use it for, if you have it on there just to listen to their conversation, then yes that's wrong.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
30 Sep 09
Hi sweetashoney, thanks for the response and yes i fully agree with you about the crimes done against the children these days and it is always better if you know what your kids are up to. Have faith in them but not blind faith and it is always better to be safe now than sorry later.
• United States
10 Feb 11
HI Agrim94, I think if I had girls instead of boys I would wont to know what they are doing. I know my parents did not like the guys I was seeing. If they had it back then they would have got it. I'm glad I had to boys so I don't really have to worry about things like that. If you raise your kids right they should know right from wrong. If you kids are that bad that you can't trust them you should get it. Later
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
10 Feb 11
Thanks sterra, Yes i totally understand what you are trying ot say. The girls are so much responsiblity on parents if one understand it. This is how society is and it is girls who get pregnant and guys go scot free. so i totally understand you.
10 Feb 11
Im not a mommy yet! So its kind of difficult to anwser something like that... But here in Brazil its so commmon hear something like a teen girl met someone in internet ang go on a date with him and diseapear... so i guess il buy something like this but not to spy (too much in my opinion) but to know where she/ he at, like a tracking device... But of course each one have their culture and tradition, here in brazil this kind of technology never itll be a best seller...
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
10 Feb 11
Hi suyanchan, Thanks for responding to one of my discussions and yes i fully agree with you that many teenage girls and boys can be easily made fool of and taken advantage of and by the time the child realise it is too late so it is never bad to know what your kids are up to.
• Netherlands
12 Feb 11
No i won't do that...you just have to trust your child and make arrangements with your teenage child.Give your teenage child the room with friend and you don't need to put spy software in the mobile. if you don't give your child room with friends they do things in secret...and that's not good.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
12 Feb 11
Hi Rietje, I fully agree with you to give child some room but you must also agree to me that teenage is such an impressionable age and child can easily be influenced by bad company and it is always better to be safe than sorry.
• India
28 Sep 09
Omg! I am so glad my parents are not aware of it. In future I would definitely respect my child's privacy. I have got very little of it and I so crave for it now. So I would understand and never do such a thing. If they are on the wrong path there maybe other better ways to do it. And I would try my best to be there best friend so that they confide everything about their friends/ boyfriends etc. But if I would be very affluent by that time I would talk to my child about the probability of him/her getting kidnapped and with their approval I would install it i neither phone. If they would be close to me to share everything they wouldn't mind it, and in case they do mind it I would give them two cell phones :P One with the software installed which would just help tracking them if they go missing and the other for their own personal use. This way I would give them their privacy as well as ensure their safety.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi anweshadas, thanks for the response and since you are from India i dont think you would have gotten any privacy as a kid nor u would expect much privacy. I think kids in eastern part of world are better behaved because there is no such thing as privacy here otherwise everything would hide behind privacy. I hope when you have your kids as teenagers they would grow up just the way you like them and not the way they most of the kids would grow up in 20 years.. but as purnima said it is better safe than be sorry.
@ravinskye (8237)
• United States
28 Sep 09
Heck yea I would. Are they able to listen to her phone conversations too? I don't think I would go so far as to listen in on her conversations, but I wouldn't mind being able to track where she is at on gps. There are probably some things I wouldn't want to hear her say. But it would be nice if for some reason she is missing or late that I can check where she is at. It would be expensive, but at least I would know my daughter is a little safer and that would be worth it to me.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi ravi, thanks for the response and i dont know that if they can help you listen to their conversation or not but i think it does.. or may be sends you a record on your phone or some website. and you are right we can not be too careful of our daughters during the impressionable age of say 16. It is always nice to know if she is far too away or in some danger so timely help can be given.
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
29 Sep 09
My youngest is almost 19 and living away from home but, no, I wouldn't consider putting spyware on her phone if she were still a minor. I was able to see her phone activities on my monthly bill and I knew who her friends were so I could tell what she was up to on the phone. I do have a "special" program on the computer that is in her former bedroom though and I told her that it was there. My theory was that I would rather keep her away from certain websites, prevent her from having certain chat conversations, prevent her from taking and sending certain types of digital photos beforehand and avoid the hassle of confronting her with the evidence of misbehavior after the fact. It worked out very well.
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
28 Sep 09
It is a good idea for those parents who have reasons not to trust their kids due to regular bad behaviour, lying or trouble. My daughter is almost eight and not quite a teenager yet but, and I hope I’m not kidding myself when I say this, I like to think that she is been brought up to be trustworthy and very unlikely to lie about her whereabouts or her activities so to answer your question I would not feel good using such software with my daughter and would not infringe on her privacy unless I had very good reasons to; I trust her at this stage...Talk to me in five years! (LOL)
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi paula, thanks for the response and yes it is very useful for the parents whose kids give them lots and lots of reasons to doubt them and paula to be very frank how good you may bring up your kids they would lie to you sometimes or can fall in wrong company. It is always better to be safe than sorry later.
1 person likes this
@Archie0 (5652)
28 Sep 09
Hello agrim well i think i wouldnt put one, because that wont make them stop doing things but infact make them more anxious about what it really has and that is why we are stopping them from using certain things, infact i wont give my children a mobile phone until they are capable of handling one.Somethings are to be given to them at the right time, i am not the person who will react as the world does because i want them to get the good and not the worng.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi archie0, thanks for the reply, i understand that what you are talking about but if you are in a big city you would know how much they need cell phone simply because they can be stranded somewhere and no way to call you up or their vehicle may get problems and would want to call you up. And they are not going to know it has software unless you tell them.
@schentil (98)
• India
28 Sep 09
hi, there is nothing in the world like this to steal the privacy of children. It could really hurt their feeling and freedom that they are being watched by someone. So they could act like who they are actually. We have to instill in them the good behaviors and moralities so that they will not commit any bad things in their life. Ruling them like monorchies will lead to something different what we wanted them to become. If you use that software in a way that it helps with safety of the children then it is okay.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi schentil, thanks for the response and privacy is only seen in western world, the kids in east are not given nor ask for privacy and since you are from india too and you know you can any moment check computer of your kids or anything and suppose if your girl falls in bad company unknown to you esp if you are living in big city like delhi and no one to tell you. In small places everyone knows everyone and thus it is easy to get information but not in big cities..so i guess software like this can be useful.
• United States
29 Sep 09
i don't have children....ut lets assume in this matter that i do. A few questions first. first off...would the child know that the software is on the phone? and secondly, am i the one paying for the phone? If the asnwer is yes to both of these questions, then i see no problems in using this software. I am paying for the phone, i would then expect the right to know what is going on with the phone, though i wouldn't want to feel like i was sneakily spying on my child by installing the software with out them knowing. I would respect their privacy that much. I also think that just them knowing that i COULD access this information would in turn cause thm to behave better.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi fruitcakeliz, thanks for the response. No child wont know that you have put software in the phone unless you tell or your actions can lead them to suspect it. I suppose it has to be you who is paying for the instrument and the software, you can not expect children to get that software in their phone on their own and let you know everything. I think it is always wise to keep a track of the friends of the children and be safe than sorry later on.
@clarkbody (141)
• United States
28 Sep 09
No. To me, that is an ivasion of privacy. Instead, I have always taught them to be careful and that they can trust me with anything. They are pretty open and honest because they know all about my past and they know that I'm not judgemental.
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
28 Sep 09
i think parents who have taught their children well, those children who knows the values they should have picked up with their parents should not be monitored, and should not be spied on. if you are a responsible parent, spying on your kids won't do you help and could only make matters worse, why wait for them to commit the mistake and scold them? just try to guide them, lead them to the right path to make sure that they are doing the correct things all the time, this way, they need not be spied on the phone and on the internet activities.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
28 Sep 09
hi chiyosan, thanks for the response, well India is changing very fast where values which were so high few years back are going down so suddenly. They may be teaching them everything which they think is right but with advent of freign tvs and movies and everything available here , children are just not ready to listen to what their parents are saying. I am not a parent yet only 22 but i have seen this to be true and children are getting much more disrespectful then even i can ever be no matter how old i grow up. So i think not every parent is wrong in doing so.
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
28 Sep 09
My kids know that they have to be where I expect them to be, that I can go through their things if I feel like it. I rarely do so, but there are times when I will pop in to check on them where they are supposed to be or I will go through their book bags, generally looking for homework. The element of surprise that I provide doesn't allow them to get away with much and has helped them be a lot more open with me. Would I give them a phone with spy software in it, no. I won't give my kids cell phones until they are driving and at that time, I think it would largely depend on how they have helped me be able to trust them. If they are always where they are supposed to be, if they continue coming to me when they should, even if it involves a friend, then I won't need to worry. If they become deceitful and begin hiding things from me, then, I probably would.
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
hi lynnemg, thanks for the response and i understand what you are trying to say. SO long the kids keep your confidence in them you wont need to do anything but when they would break your confidence in pieces then you would have something like this. This is very nice way to keep control on the kids and also the surprise element is also good thing to keep in check.
@Craicha (801)
28 Sep 09
no i dont think so .....i trust my kids and they are following my rules at home..:)
@agrim94 (3805)
• India
29 Sep 09
Hi creicha, thanks for response and good thing they follow you a lot:)