Ladies or Gentlemen! When You Follow a Recipe, Does it Work??

@artistry (4151)
United States
December 21, 2009 4:13pm CST
When you have tried to make a new dish, using a recipe, do you get the result that you were hoping for? Or does it take another try to get it right the next time?? Please share your culinary skills, trials and tribulations with us.
19 responses
@sulsisels (1685)
• United States
21 Dec 09
Hi artistry..I'll give you the advice I was given in cullinary school. (I just graduated last June) When you are first learning, its best to follow a recipe exactly. When it's finished, taste it and make mental notes how you would change it next time. You may be pleased with the end result and find no need to change. There are no rules in cooking. You should always make it your own and taylor any recipe to your liking. A recipe is ment to guide you, it is not set in stone. I love to play with ingredients and try different things. Sometimes it works, sometimes it dosen't. It should always be fun and if you like cooking there are no limits to the things you can do. In the beginning, (because I was taking cooking very seriously with the hopes of earning good money some day) I kept a notebook with the recipe and the changes I made, if they were successful. I found that if i didnt it was hard to remember just what I had done last time. Play around with it. Think about what else might work with whatever you are making. Its fun to experiment and even more fun to eat! I'm happy to help you in any way I can in the future. I'll request you as a friend and you can pm me anytime you are stuck or would like advice..Happy cooking and remember "Make it your own" J
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi there sulsisels, Thank you for such an informative and helpful comment. I do like to experiment. I fool around with a little bit of this and that, not so much that I think it will do it damage, but you have to be careful. I love my recipe for fried shrimp that I have used since I watched someone make them and tried to remember how she did it. We were preparing a large dinner for a church sale and she was in charge of the shrimp. I call it my recipe, but she was the originator. I made them for my sister and her family once and she said they tasted better than Red Lobster, but that's my sister. Take care and thanks again.
@sulsisels (1685)
• United States
23 Dec 09
Care to share that recipe? If so, pm me with it..I'd love to try it..I'll add you as friend if thats ok..Joyce
1 person likes this
@sulsisels (1685)
• United States
23 Dec 09
I've already added you as friend, nevermind..sorry
@epicure35 (2814)
• United States
22 Dec 09
Results when trying new recipes do vary, depending on both ingredients and directions. Re cooking, particularly, there's some flexibility, but baking is much more exacting and precise. Usually, my first try of a new dish is to test it, even if it's a recipe I "invented" myself. I'm getting to the point, though, where I don't feel like experimenting too much on my own. I don't like "disasters" because I don't like to waste food, even in small batches, especially now with money so tight. That being said, I am happy with a few standards I have "invented", such as my tuna casserole, which everyone in my family likes. When I try a new recipe, I follow it exactly to get an "expected" result. If it doesn't agree with my tastebuds, I'll either modify it to my taste, if I think it's worth saving, or chuck it. Most dishes allow for variations in seasonings, amounts, substitutions, or modifications of a little of "this or that". Sometimes, even my old standards seem to taste a little bit different - go figure. But, mostly, things are consistent. Because I enjoy cooking and its corollary, eating, I still get interested and excited about finding and testing new recipes. I get disappointed in myself when I "create" a disaster of a recipe! And, now that it's cookie baking season, I'm trying a few new ones, cause I hope they're easy!
1 person likes this
@epicure35 (2814)
• United States
23 Dec 09
Thanks, artistry, for such a thought-provoking discussion and your kind acknowledgement of my response. Many blessings to you and all you love this Christmas and always.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi there epicure35, You have provided such great information for use in the future. I thank you for taking the time to share with me things that are helpful in the kitchen when it comes to recipes and changes that you may or may not make. All of you have been so helpful and I do really appreciate all of the comments. Take very good care and thanks again. Happy New Year to you and to your family. Happy baking.
@Downwindz (2537)
• Netherlands
21 Dec 09
In most cases i seem to succeed if i have all the rawmaterials prepared before i start cooking the recipe, but sometimes it also happens that it doesnt taste exactly as i would expect before i start the cooking, so a recipe can also disapoint you. Once in a while my cooking doesnt succeed and i burn it, or added to many spicies...
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
..Hi there Downwindz, Well it seems you are getting the hang of cooking and having aome success which is great. My problem is that I want to add things that are not in the recipe and then I have to wait to see if what I did doesn't ruin the recipe. I have been pretty lucky with recipes so far. Thanks for your comment.
@Downwindz (2537)
• Netherlands
23 Dec 09
Ahh i know what you mean, i also tend to add extras once in a while to the recipe, but im often a bit more of a safety person in that case, i allready have a good idea if it will be a success or not.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Dec 09
I always follow recipes to a T. Also I was raised in a family where cooking was prominent. Sometimes with recipes there needs a small adjustment whether it be the amount of milk or flour, so occasionally I'll follow a recipe and it will come out not quite as I planned so the next time i'll use a little bit of improvisation to make it better.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi Lostinloveanddancing, I can see the hnd of a cook who knows what she is doing. I once did something brave, I had never made a sweet potato pie before but I new what should go into the recipe. One of my girlfriend's wanted to make one and she asked me. I told her how to make it, she followed what I told her and the pie came out perfectly fine. She was thrilled and I was a happy camper that I was able to help her. Take care, thanks for your comment.
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi Lostinloveanddancing, I can see the hnd of a cook who knows what she is doing. I once did something brave, I had never made a sweet potato pie before but I new what should go into the recipe. One of my girlfriend's wanted to make one and she asked me. I told her how to make it, she followed what I told her and the pie came out perfectly fine. She was thrilled and I was a happy camper that I was able to help her. Take care, thanks for your comment.
@tanchyka (213)
• Slovenia
3 Feb 10
I always follow the recipes completely and I always get what was in the picture next to the recipe. Unfortunately, some recipes have disappointed me, but that's the recipes' fault, not mine, because I use all the right ingredients and do it right. Sometimes I just don't like the taste. I'm very picky when it comes to food and that's why I don't like some of the recipes. Other people do like them though.
@artistry (4151)
• United States
3 Feb 10
..Hi tanchyka, If the way the recipe turned out does not satisfy your taste buds, then that is the way it goes, you did your part and put it together well. That would be evident because other people enjoyed the food even though you didn't. It sounds as though you know your way around the kitchen, especially if the picture of the finished product looks like your food or vice versa. That's quite amazing. Good for you. Thanks so much for sharing your experience. Take care.
@Bellapop (1279)
16 Jul 10
Whenever I follow a new receipe it always works, because it's going to be something from a book or the supermarket promotion so they always have to make sure it works, BUT the taste is always not how I want it! :)
@artistry (4151)
• United States
16 Jul 10
...Hi there, See, you are what I would call a good cook because you take instructions well. Your dishes are probaby fine but your taste buds are discriminating, you know how things should taste. If you embellish the recipes a little bit, and you probably are already doing that, the taste will be more to your liking. I used to cook a lot, even sponsor large dinners at church, not any more as I have gotten older. I admire anyone who can put a recipe together and have it work so that it is edible. Thanks for your response. Take care.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
22 Dec 09
I do typically get the result that I was hoping for the first time that I try a recipe for the first time. It is the second or third time that I don't get a result that I am happy with. You see, the first time that I try out a recipe, I follow the recipe to a T, however, the next several times that I am working with that particular recipe, I tweak it a little bit each time so that I can go from a textbook recipe to something that is truly my own.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi dorannmwin, I try the same thing sometimes, but I don't change it too much, I get scared that, if won't work like it should in the end. The recipes that I try to follow exactly as the book depicts don't always turn out like they are supposed to. But I love cooking something that turns out like I want it to and somebody appreciates it. Thanks for your comment. Take care.
• Indonesia
22 Dec 09
It mostly work for me. When following a recipe, I always make sure that it has a step-by-step pictures so I have an idea what to do. So far the results are satisfying. The cookbook also plays a big role, I suppose, that's why I only choose the credible ones. Oh, also make sure that the ingredients are fresh.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
..Hi there alwayzzcitra, You are almost professional here, thanks for the suggestion of credible cookbooks. I never even though6 about that aspect of the situation. I try to make sure I have the specific ingredients that they call for, when I am making something for the first time, because I figure unless I know how a different ingredient will react, I had better stick to what is called for. Thanks for your comment.
• United States
22 Dec 09
Most of the recipes I have are family recipes so I do follow them to a T. I rarely use box mixes to make cookies and cakes. I love to use my family recipes when cooking because it brings back a lot of memories. I was given a cook book with family recipes as a bridal shower gift. This is the one gift I cherish the most.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi randylovesdar, If the recipe is tried and true and you alreay know how it is going to come out, I wouldn't change it either. What a thoughtful thing for your family members to give you as a gift. Collective love in the form of a book of recipes is really a nice, nice thing to have given you. You have a great family. Thank you for sharing and take good care.
@kareendj (254)
• Philippines
22 Dec 09
Recipes are just guides. Common sense is also needed whenever cooking. You can tweak recipes a bit... except for baking. Baking is an exact science and recipes should really be followed because it's going to be too late already if you forgot something and it's already inside the oven. Cheers!
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi kareendj You make a good point, because you could wind up with something that will never bake to where it should be and has to be poured down the garbage disposal. I don't do too much baking, do have a peach cobbler recipe that turns out very well most of the time, it is positively delicious. Thank you for the useful information. Take care.
• Indonesia
22 Dec 09
Not always. Because the creator's tastes are not always prescribed in accordance with our tastes. And sometimes, we often make mistakes in making the food, so the taste and shape can be different from the recipe.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
....Hi haryosasongko, You speak with credibility, as one who has followed recipes and have seen the outcomes. The pictures don't always look like what is on your table :o). You can't be disheartened I guess. Cooking is fun and it can be trial and error but overall most things are usually edible. Thank you so much for shedding more light on the situation. Take care.
@kuloor (93)
• India
22 Dec 09
When i am confident then only i follow the recipe. If it is long process or difficuilt then i will not try that recipe.
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
..Hi kuloor, Welcome to the ranch, it's a fun place to be. It takes a lot of cooking for me to be confident, but I will get there hopefully. I tend also to cook the same things again and again, so that does give me a little confidence with what I am preparing. Thanks so much for the words of advice and for taking the time to give them. Take care.
@acer5540 (354)
• China
23 Dec 09
First, i will see if the recipe is possible for me to finish it. As you know, some material on the recipe are hard to buy on the market.If i can get all the materials , i will decide to have a trail. Usually, the recipe works.I follow the instructions step by step strictly.So finally,i can get the result,when i heard my husband said"it is nice",i feel very happy.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
....Hi acer5545, Thanks for your very interesting comment. You are very precise in your cooking method. I would think with the process you use, most of your dishes turn out very well indeed. You try to put everything together so that there is limited chance of failure. You are good at what you do. Thanks for sharing the secrets of your kitchen skills. Take good care.
@eysiojo23 (141)
• Philippines
22 Dec 09
Sometimes, but most of it no. Maybe because I'm not good in cooking. But atleast I tried right? One of the good things happen to me when I was trying to make a Cake is when I made a cake a lot more different than the original one and it taste delicious. Maybe experimenting some recipes will help.
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
..Hi eysiojo23. Welcome to the ranch, enjoy yourself, it's a fun place. I think that is one of the keys, not being to afraid to try. Also as you said experimenting, seeing what works and what doesn't so you try again and possibly get it like you want to to be. You can always take a messed up cake, crumble it up and put some ice cream on it and call it a day. :o) Thank you for your nice comments.
• Philippines
21 Dec 09
Not really, do youtube tutorials on dish considered as recipe? lol ^_^ I've tried making sushi but it's kinda weird. haha but it's fine though still edible ^_^
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi tyronie4cash, Well if you are going to tackle sushi, then you must have some culinary skills. I thought it was supposed to be raw anyway. What do you do with sushi, marinate it in special sauces or something like that. I don't think I have ever tasted sushi. Any recipe would count, where ever it was taken from as long as it was for a food item. Thanks for your comment. Take it easy.
• Philippines
21 Dec 09
I love cooking. And just like you, I do follow recipes sometimes in those things I haven't tried cooking before and I would say I get the result I wanted. It is also something delectable and sumptuous. The secret in cooking is not merely following the recipe but making modification into it as you cook. I mean, you don't have to follow every single detail of the recipe. You can change or modify details on the recipe itself and that would make a well-cooked food. Don't just follow recipes, change something if you think it needs a change.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi babyfiona08, That is great. I will start with a recipe and then I'll do a small adjustment and see how it turns out, if it is okay then I might try the next time another little tweak. Most things that I try and follow the recipe turn out fairly well, but those things I alter seem to turn out a little bit better. I love it when it turns out well. I am then so proud of myself. Take care and thanks for the tips.
@kokila19 (102)
• Kuwait
22 Dec 09
It happens sometimes.. :( First, I will search for a recipe and do check it all many sites and if get a satisfactory one then I will try for it. One dish I remember, it was a fish gravy. I tried and it came out very well, but do not know my husband did not like it. I was little upset on that day.:((
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi kokila19, That's a shame, he did not like it. But you are probably a good cook in spite of the fish gravy. I like trying new recipes as well, they turn out alright. But my dishes that I prepare with a few minor adjustments turn out better. Not all the time though. Thanks so much for your comment. Take care, good luck with the gravy next time.
@rene12 (794)
• Philippines
21 Dec 09
I really don't know how to cook and online recipes just keeps me in the line. I cook while reading the recipes and I'll just adjust for how many serving it would take :D
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi rene12, I think you are selling yourself short. If you know how to cook for many people and adjust to accomodate them, you certainly know how to cook. That takes a talent to know how to increase the portions and how to make enough with the proper seasonings, to make sure the food tastes good. You are a cook for sure. Thank you for sharing. Take it easy.
• United States
22 Dec 09
I usually get the result I was looking for when I make up a recipe. It takes a lot for me to screw it up. Although I usually modify a recipe. Last night I made a recipe for the first time which was basically breaded chicken, linguini and olive oil. I added mushrooms, yellow squash and red bell pepper. It was delicious. I'm sure it would have been just fine without the veggies but I find that it's always missing something if it's that plain.Like everyone else has stated, play around with the recipes and make them your own.
1 person likes this
@artistry (4151)
• United States
23 Dec 09
...Hi canwillmca, First of all, welcome to the ranch, enjoy. That sounds delicious, like something you would find in an Italian restaurant. I love mushrooms, and squash. You are a creative gourmet in effect. You probaly should write down your recipes when you create them, you could put together a recipe book of your own, and maybe publish it. Thank you for your great comment.