Am sad, Shiobhan was sent home tonight, buhuhu..

What is that skinny, young guy's name? Of the remaining, I think he should have been the one to go. I liked Siobhan as well. I haven't watched it in the last couple of weeks, but I did started watching it when it was down to 14 contestants. I spent the weekend with my brother-in-law and sister way back then, and they are big American Idol fans. So Siobhan became one of my favorites, along with the Bowersox girl. Siobhan seemed to fade the last couple of times I saw her, but she is incredibly talented. I think she has a very bright future ahead of her. She's unique, and with guidance, could make an awesome record.

Hi my4casts I was really sad and shocked when Shiobhan was gone, she was my favorite and i wanted her to win. I think judges should have reserved saving someone like her and not Mike(not a bad singer though but not worth the saving card). Its so sad, now im going for lee or for crystal, but i still believe siobhan should have been the winner.

Yeah I was upset about her being sent home also. I thought she sounded alright myself I even voted for her the night before. She was my favorite out of the girl singers this year.

I didn't have Shiobhan picked for the top three. But I thought she'd hang in there about one more week. I'm not crazy about Michael and think he should be going soon. Aaron will be gone this next week. I have the final two as Crystal and Lee.

I love American idol because you won't know when a person is going home and because it is so much fun to watch them sing.But, I still can't believe the Shiobhan was sent home because she is such a good singer and she really makes the song different . And because her performance was good so that's why I still don't believe why she was actually sent home.

Shioban really was unique, very alternative. Pity she had to leave this early. Bowersox and Lee will probably make it to the top two.

Sorry but I had predicted earlier today that she would be the one to go. She was really good in the beginning of the competition and I thought it would be Crystal and her at the end. As the show progressed every week it became harder to connect with her for some reason. At this point every week it will be sad to see someone go but she made it far into the competition and now she will be in the summer show with the top twelve. I'm sure she will get a record deal and she will be on Ellen tomorrow.

Hi my4cats, I didn't see Shiobhan bagging the title, but I was surprised that she was booted out this early. I honestly thought she'll make it to the top 3, but looking back now, I guess American voters were right. I didn't like her screaming at all, and her last performance was my least favorite. Among the bottom 3, she was the one I was most willing to let go.

Sorry my4cats but i'd rather see her go than Casey James. I like Casey's performance rather than Siobhan and like Simon i don't like the screaming at the end of every song. Although everybody gave their best last night, one will go home and sorry it's her.