Separation makes the heart grow fonder? yes or no?

@Hatley (163776)
Garden Grove, California
April 30, 2010 3:23pm CST
I have noticed that since we have had to live in different places this last year and a half that my son seems to think more of me and we seem'much closer than when we lived as everyone else,in our own two bedroom apartment. maybe its an instinct for survival or a renewed feeling of love for each other but its so gratifying to me as it gives me hope for this year that he will get a great job and we will finally move into an apartment of our own again. Have you noticed that your own adult children seem closer to you once they are on their own so to speak?
11 people like this
28 responses
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
30 Apr 10
My Children and I have always been very close so really it is just the same I am glad though that you and your Son have the closeness Yes it will have been what you have both been through together also it proves that he is missing you Big Hugs
3 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
30 Apr 10
hi gabs yes we are closer now than before and we somehow will get through with this and maybe one day look back and smile or maybe not smile but be glad it was all in the past, but for now I am so grateful I have my computer and monitor so I can myhlolt again. and yes even grateful that I am not drifting arund homeless like a piece of driftwood on the beach.hugs for you a nd Gissi too.
6 people like this
@celticeagle (167015)
• Boise, Idaho
1 May 10
I think seperation does make the heart grow fonder. I know these last weeks I have sure missed and felt pure love for my little grandson. I see him and he is so amazing to me. I hope that you two get to move into a nice apartment and live happily.
• Mexico
1 May 10
Hi celticeagle: I hope this too. I can imagine how beautiful could be the moment when you see your grandson again, must be a very emotional moment I think. And yes, i think that, when we have to pass our time far from the people we love we think more about them and heart grows fonder. Thanks for your answer. Have a nice day. ALVARO
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
2 May 10
hi celtic and Star yes when you are separated from your loved one eeven just a few miles you really appreciate them a lot more. and my son seems to appreciate me a lot more than when we were in our own apartment as he sort of just took me for granted there. I also hope we can get into an apartment when he finds that job.
4 people like this
@celticeagle (167015)
• Boise, Idaho
2 May 10
It is sad about my grandson. I feel bad for the little guy.
1 person likes this
@moondancer (7433)
• United States
30 Apr 10
Yes, I too have noticed the same thing with my son. He recently moved out and back down south to the coast which is 600 miles from me. He calls me at least 3 times a week and we talk on the computer through yahoo IM at least a few times a week. We were really close when he was here too. We just didn't seem to talk so much. It's strange though now that he is gone, he calls me so much or talks to me a lot on the computer. It's really nice! Hatley, I really do hope your son gets another job and a good one so that he can get you and him in a place together. Many many blessings for a bright future!
2 people like this
• United States
1 May 10
I even noticed that when my son came back home the last time that he never asked me to get him this or that or to cook and he would say thank you each and every time I gave him something. Or if I asked him if he wanted something he would say if I wanted to do it for him that it was up to me. He was much more appreciative of what I did for him and of me being here for him and with him than he was before. He was before too but not like he was this time. When he was gone before he got in touch too but not not this time. lol it's funny how time and age changes things as well as the time away.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
11 Dec 10
hi moondancer here I am in dec now trying to resolve all my unresolved discussions. and finding responses I had not commented on so am doing my best to get up to date.
5 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
1 May 10
hi moondancer my son also emails me and phones me fairly often. we are only a couple of miles apart but he had to depend on the bus service to come see me so each visit seems more precious to me, and apparently to him also as he seems more open and more caring now.
5 people like this
@zandi458 (28102)
• Malaysia
1 May 10
My two sons are now working and living in different towns. They become more closer to me than they were before. Though they might not be able to come and see me because of work commitments but make it a point to call me every now and then to find out how I am doing. And am always looking forward to christmas season when they all come home for family reunion. I agree that absence seems to improve the relationship more.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
1 May 10
hi zandi it is as though my son is looking at his mom in a different light. whenwe were together in our own ]apartment he just assumed mom would be there for him all the time and now we are a couple of miles apartment I get phone calls and emails from him, and he seems to feel closer to me too. If only the relatives of some of the people here would just phone them once in awhile it would make such a difference to these residents. some of them might even decide to smile occasionallyh.
3 people like this
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
30 Apr 10
Hi Hatley, I think this is somewhat true. My son has not lived near me for years, he is only 50 miles away, but it's too expensive for us to drive that distance. :( Though I miss him, I don't think he misses me, he prefers to call his dad only when he has a problem. I didn't even have his phone number until yesterday when his dad finally gave it to me so I could call and wish him a happy birthday, but he wasn't home.. I think it depends on the relationship, obviously I don't have one with him or his sister who only live 3 miles away, she won't talk to me either..Just their little sister talks me and of course my 7 y/o son..:)
• United States
1 May 10
I guess that is what I was between my youngest daughter and my husband. she is going to be 21 this year and I was always standing with her when her dad did or said things that were not right.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
11 Dec 10
hi carm here it is Dec11 and I am on my second day of resoling unresolved discussions and finding I did not finish commenting on all my responses. That makes me ashamed as I am always fussing because some make so many discussions and never comment back.I really do not know why I had not finished these.sorry but I am catching up although mow I am behind in responding to my friend's discussions.
6 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
1 May 10
hi carmelanirel yes sometimes our loved ones dont return thatlove and no matter what you do, it still does not work, fifty miles can be like a hundred if one is without funds. Its sad when an adult child sort of deserts his family. I am so glad you have your seven year old who does love his mom. My son and I always had a good relationship but my husband for some unknown reason did not create that male bond between himself and his son, he got upset with me because my son always came to me, but you cannot turn your back on a child for years then want him to really be close to you when he is grown. I was always the one in between as when they did react with each other it was only in anger and quarrels, and I was the peacekeeper of course trying to soothe both son and husband.
6 people like this
• Philippines
30 Apr 10
Yes. I think my mom have grown closer ever since I moved out. Now we are on the same boat. I am now able to realize how hard it is to raise a family. Whenever we see each other, I can easily tell her my troubles and I know that no matter how I relate each story to her, she would understand because she has been there. We send each other "missing you" notes over facebook or a simple email and we have never done that when I was still living under one roof with her.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
1 May 10
hi melloncollie yes I think when we all lived toghether my son'jus took me forgranted, mom would be there any time he needed her now as we live in different places just a few miles apart, he looks at me so differently as if we were a lot closer. feels good too.
5 people like this
@balasri (26537)
• India
1 May 10
True.Even in the case of Mylot.I always begin to like it more whenever I come back to it after a gap.
1 person likes this
@balasri (26537)
• India
2 May 10
Nice to know that.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
1 May 10
hi balsari you have been here awhile too haven't you. I am also stuck on mylot and when I had my computer being repaired for four days I was so bored,no mylot no nothing. now myson and I living in separate places I think we have become much closer now. I love it when he comes to see me.
3 people like this
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
30 Apr 10
My two sons appreciate me much more with 1800 miles between us! I miss them like crazy but I hated where I lived and wanted to come home. Seeing each other once or twice a year doesn't really suit me but I'll probably move closer in a few years. They miss me, too, and when we all lived in the same house they took me for granted.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
30 Apr 10
hi dragon thats it really whenwe were in out own apartment he was just used to me being there and just sort of took it forgranted but now things are so changed.I am just so glad hes not really' far away. now i need to check on my best friend nelda as she emails me every day.
6 people like this
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
3 May 10
I'll let you know in about 10 years! :-)
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
4 May 10
hi dawn well If I am around Iwill be 93 then maybe this will keep me hanging around til then. he he
4 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
5 May 10
sure of course I will be. he he.
3 people like this
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
4 May 10
Well of course you will be...
1 person likes this
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
3 May 10
In my case it is that I moved away from my mother for the first time a little over a year ago. She and I have always been very close, but I do think that now my family and myself are on our own I have come to appreciate her far more than I did when I lived under her roof. We have less tension between the two of us than we had when we lived together and our relationship continues to grow stronger. So, from my point of view I would say that yes, being separated from your parents or from your children will make your relationship grow.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
4 May 10
hi dorannmwin yes in my son's case it seems to make him appreciate me more as before I was there if he needed me and if he didnt maybe he would talk to me for five minutes now he actually talks to me for much longer . I think there has to be a little distance at times,I know he and I did not always agree on things and we too has some tension as I have a quick temper but am over things quickly too.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
2 May 10
Hi Hatley, there are some things that are difficult to reconcile, and I am a bit confused on how I should react on them at this stage of my life. So I have just put them in a separate chest or compartment of my mind and locked them because no amount of thinking on them is really getting me anywhere to an answer that would not punish me further. I leave that one on god. But other than that, there are very few differences between me and my parent now. Somehow the past issue once out in open has brought us closer, possibly because my parent thinks I have forgiven it. I for one am torn between gratefulness, and denial of love to myself on one hand, and standing up for right on the other hand. I guess he has his regrets. In so far as he has wronged me, I do feel I have forgiven but every once in a while the feeling of self-pity takes over, and the frustration that accompanies it gets aggravated when my father wittingly or unwittingly does something hurtful. I guess I am giving him a tight rope to walk. Its like - you have had all your chances, now no more. Wish my mom had been alive. :(
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
3 May 10
hi vandy You seem to me to be a very nice kind sweet person so do not put yourself down.You know we cannot change other people as much as we would love to. for ex I tried my best to get my husband to stop smoking but I ultimately failed as he just did not have enough courage to just ry to stop. Iam so glad that you have a lot to be thankful with your dad. I did really try to love him again, but it was just that I could not feel I could really trust him, they wanted to babysit my daughter for awhile while I recouped from her birth but I did not trust my dad,wrong of me I know but I just could not get past that. I really should do that family history thing for my friend. maybe yet, I will see. take care vandy. love you.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
3 May 10
Hatley, I cant hate him! He didnt do that type of wrong, but nevertheless the wrong that he did makes it difficult for me to obliterate it. It has lost me my mother, and spoilt a major chunk of my life. Yet he has tried to be a good father. He has educated me well, looked after me when I was sick, and recently stood up for me against many people who were accusing me of wrong when in fact they were wrong. There is a lot to be thankful for Hatley. But every once in a while, the heart craves for that mom, and life of a normal child. I guess we each have our failings. Wish I was more innocent.
1 person likes this
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
5 May 10
My kids are still young, so there is no separation yet. The closest I could relate it to is when the older kid goes on sleep overs. He does seem so loving after a sleep over. Maybe he misses us. One time he even called late at night. I got worried thinking there was a problem. As it turns out, he just wanted to say good night.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
5 May 10
hi bounce that made me thing back to when I was ten or twelve and I went to Girl scout camp for a week, while I had a lot of fun I felt so homesick and so did some of the other kids that were in my tent, I had looked forward so to go then wanted to be home.I think that was the first time I had slept away from home too.
3 people like this
@junrapmian (2169)
• Philippines
30 Apr 10
Yeah, if the one who is away from you is someone dear to you, just like my son. When he reached 21 and found a good job to fend himself, he started to move out of the house. But the good thing is, he makes it a point to call or text me every now and then asking me about my health, if I have worries, if I have been taking my vitamins...such I miss you and visits me on his day-offs. Unlike before when he was still here and lives with me, seldom that he talks to me becasue he was busy with his activities. Yes, I guess so, separation makes the heart grow fonder!
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
1 May 10
hi oh yes its my son and I think its making us closer as we are our only family. my husband and little daughter are gone so we are all that is left now. I love to see him on his visits and he is always so good to me'now and not just thinking oh shes always around anymore.
5 people like this
• China
6 May 10
hi!hatley.i don't think you turned out to be an old man.in my view,the number of old people who love to internet and is able to surf the internet.if i make you feel unconfortable,i apologize.to your question,i think different people have different views.almost all of old people hope their children live with them even their children have grown up.if the children get along well with their parents,they will be happy.if not,all of them will be unhappy.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 May 10
he he hi m eimeibaobei I am not an old man, I am a senior woman citizen and yes I am elderly, so what I am happy and my son really seems to miss me now we are not together all the time.We always got along well, but still both of us had our own ideas and occasionally would disagree but that was no biggie, no we get along just fine. check my profile it now shows my gender he he.
3 people like this
@neildc (17239)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
2 May 10
for almost two years now, my son lives with his mom in the province. we don't communicate a lot but when we do talk on the phone or chat on the internet, we have lots of things to discuss than when we were together. my step daughter seems to miss his little brother so she make it a point to call us everyday. she is now in the province spending their summer vacation.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
2 May 10
hi neildc I am so glad that when you do get to talk with your son either on phone or the net that you two enjoy discussing all sorts of things.its odd how some things seem easier to do that way than when you are all together, guess its that old thing about taking one another for granted then distance makes everyone realize how much they miss the other person.
3 people like this
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
2 May 10
I don’t have grown up children because my daughter is only eight and, at this stage I cannot even imagine her not living with me! I would imagine that being apart and the sons and daughters having to deal with everything on their own would cause them to miss home and their parents. My daughter is young and we are very close but after a few weeks of school holidays together I start craving for my own space and look forward to her going back to school but when she’s there I miss her like crazy! Go figure...
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
2 May 10
hi paula oh I remember those days and being glad school had started again then missing my son .With us its so different as my son is fifty and I am 83 but we lived together to afford an apartment that we cou ld not have afforded separately. he got used to me being there if he needed something and really sort of just took me forgranted. now when he comes to see me he really seems like he had missed me.
4 people like this
• Philippines
1 May 10
Yes, if i truly love the person i would truly miss her company and no, if i am just playing games and just for fun. Up to the point the length of times of separation is just a test or challenges as true love stay no matter the distances is and foolishness know it's over when one of the partner forget and keeps other company. then it is a close book...
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
2 May 10
hi neelianoscet yes thats it if you really love your son or other person you will miss them so much. when we were in our own apartment he seemed to sort of just take me for granted that I would always be there if he needed me. now we both have to stand on our own two feet and really do appreciate the other person so much more.
3 people like this
• Mexico
1 May 10
Hi Hatley: It's nice that you tell us about this feeling. I have no children but I'm a young adult that will be out of his parent's house very soon and I think I can understan the reason of this approachment. When we are far from the people we love, we start to understand in a deepest way the reasons why we love them and we start missing the good memories with our family. I think that, being far from your house at some moment of your life makes you gro up. Thanks for sharing with us your experience. Have a nice day. Alvaro
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
2 May 10
hi starsailover Its only a few miles but as i cannot get there easily he has to come see me, so I love it when he does come to visit and he seems to really miss me now. before I was just mom, who will be there 'if i need her. Now he seems to appreciate me much more.
3 people like this
@udayrao2 (781)
• India
2 May 10
can't say- I have one daughter who stays with her family in Europe and the younger one staying with us ( unmarried) but independent meaning that she is a working professional and doing many other things ( like choosing her line of higher education, extra curricular activities, etc) on her own. Both are very close to us, though as you say whenever we visit my elder daughter's place or she comes down here- which is normally once every one and a half years- she seems to be closer than she was during the the previous visit.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
2 May 10
hi udayrao2 yes we were close before but still my son seemed to just sortof feel oh moms here when ever i need her,but now being separated a few miles we do appreciate each other more I think, and he seems to] think I am a tad smarter than i was before he he.
3 people like this
• Philippines
3 May 10
Maybe it's true during the first days you were apart but as the days passes by, it will be a no. Just keep the communication because if you don't, he might learn to live without you by his side.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
3 May 10
hi saranggola i think you have not read all of t his or just misunderstood ,I was talking about my adult son not a lover or husband. Of course he can live without me by his side, hes an adult but we did share a two bedroom apartment to cut costs and because we are our only family.
3 people like this