Marriage between two religion, Issue for child?

India
June 13, 2010 12:59am CST
My friend and her guy are in love but they are both from different religions. They have understanding between them and they have decided to stick to their religion but will also support other person's religion. There was discussion among other friends if they will have any problem after marriage when they get a child, will there be understanding between them on religion or its best for them to talk about it before. My point was that - if they are good at this point and ready to follow their own religion with respect for the other, they will have know problem whether their child choose any one religion or follows both. What do you think?
6 people like this
27 responses
@Galena (9110)
13 Jun 10
well it may turn out that the child doesn't follow either religion. it sounds like they both have a healthy attitude to the others religion, and that should rub off on the child. it's an ideal grounding in the fact that people do follow different religions, and that we can all get on if we respect that. and that each person has to find their own spiritual path. it should work out quite well.
1 person likes this
@Galena (9110)
14 Jun 10
not necessarily. I do believe that someones religion is a personal thing. and when you love someone and their spiritual path is different to your own, it doesn't make your love less. just like if your career paths are different it doesn't make you love each other less your spirituality is a personal thing. when you love someone with a different religion, that doesn't mean either of you should turn your back on something as deeply rooted and personal as your religion. instead you each support the other in their exlploration of their path. they don't have to believe the same as you for it to be important that you support it. because it's about showing the person you love that you care about the core of their being, and the journey they're taking. if these people become a parent, no difference between the relationship the two have where religion is concerned and the relationship they have with their child regarding religion. the child too is on their own spiritual journey. you can offer guidance and knowledge, but you can't tell them which way to go. so really, they're setting out in their own way, with knowledge that different religions needn't come between two people. which is an excellent start in life. to know that wherever their spiritual path takes them, their family will love them, whether that path is the same as the mother, or the father, or a different path altogether.
• India
14 Jun 10
Gelena - what you are saying is quite possible if the boy fall in love with a girl of different religion or did not like either of the religions his parents followed. Yes, it should work with trust and understanding. palkmae - So it was not a co-operation and understing from both the sides, as a child you did right, there will have no conflict between you father and mother for religion. Thank you for sharing your views.
• Japan
13 Jun 10
Im an example of your reply, Galena. My mom is a Protestant and my dad is Roman Catholic. I grew up confused. And while they were raising me up, my mom tried to respect my dad's beliefs but it wasnt the same on my dad's part. Anyway, to make the long story short, I ended up not following either practices. Instead, I became a born-again Christian attending a non-denominational church.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
14 Jun 10
I was a kid who grew up with parents of different religions. My parents never forced me to follow their religion. They gave me the freedom to choose the religion that I believe. I personally very grateful to have parents like them, they did not choose the religion for me, but they let me choose myself. They advise me, to believe in religion I choose. I now choose the religion that is different from my parents. We respect each other.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
15 Jun 10
yes I am very grateful to my family who respect each other, though we have different religions.
• India
15 Jun 10
This is great, they gave you freedom to choose religion as per your belief. This is what should ha[[en in this scenario. So there are 3 different religion in your home and all respecte each others , too good.. Thank You for sharing.
1 person likes this
@skysuccess (8858)
• Singapore
14 Jun 10
AjaySinghBaghel, As you've already stated ideologically and I quote: "... if they are good at this point and ready to follow their own religion with respect for the other, they will have know problem whether their child choose any one religion or follows both." Well, how much of this is actually true? If this is really the case then this discussion would not be raised at all, right? I think a lot of discussions have been centered on this topic and I have seen enough to tell you that it is really a big "IF" when there are such differences. I can understand along with everyone in theory, besides theory is nothing but merely a chain of ideal thoughts or unachievable ideologies when it comes to real life. Let's not forget that there are certain religions that comes with customary rites and observances for their believers and in some quarters these observances are mandatory for everyone in the household and for a new member of the family to be fully accepted - he/she will have to convert to this faith before being accepted. The code could be so strict to the extent that severed family ties can happen or honor killings can be conducted when any member(s) of the family fails to observe it. It is of these people that I am concern with when you talk about marital union here. Don't talk about the future or even the kids to come when these customs have to be conformed before any marriage can take place. So, I just do not see any independence or freedom to exercise one's belief independently when one party can be so dogmatically traditional?
• Singapore
15 Jun 10
AjaySinghBaghel, Thank you for your appreciation but I am just stating some facts here. Please do not get me wrong that I am not supportive of inter religious relationships / marriages and/or these relationships / marriages do not have a chance. I feel that your friends really need to realize and consider their relationship's future the minute they know of their religious differences especially when either party belongs to a religion that cannot compromise and has strict traditional observances. Couples should realize that they are walking on a fine thin line here where one party will really have to consider a rather big sacrifice which will include giving up one's current faith and undergo a religious conversion to the other. As you can see from here, I do not think anyone could decide and act on their own accord without the knowledge and concern of either party's immediate family. Because, marriage is not only about the linear integration where it involves both peers i.e. your friends but there is also a vertical integration involved as well where it involves the works of their immediate siblings, parents, paternal or maternal grandparents or blood relatives as well to facilitate the structural and symptomatic changes to make the integrals of marriage merge and work. Ignoring such observances will just have its dire consequences and effects. Hence, I always would make it a point that couples consider and seek to start off on the right foot, where a good foundation is vital to a successful and promising future for both parties. I just hope your friends know what they are doing and that they should face the facts and realities here. Take care.
• India
15 Jun 10
Wish I could arrange a meeting with that couple for you. As of now I do not them being narrow minded about the religion and thats the reason they are together otherwise fight on religion could end their relation long back. I believe that they will have no issue in this regard because its matter of child and nothing about husband or wife. Thank you for being descriptive.
1 person likes this
@jdyrj777 (6530)
• United States
15 Jun 10
I think its sad that Jahovah's people are supposed to be AS ONE. Ina one love. But all these different denomanations only tear people apart.
1 person likes this
• India
15 Jun 10
Thank you for sharing.
@reckon21 (3479)
• Philippines
16 Jun 10
I think this is a good and interesting post because two people who have different religion and was able to make a compromise to remain in each others religion and married at the same time. When it comes to their very own child they should give the child the freedom to choose what religion he or she would follow. But then when it comes to baptism what religion should do it. Well I think both parents will have to decide about it which religion of theirs will do it. When the child is old enough to decide for his or her own religion I think the parents will give him the freedom to choose.
• India
17 Jun 10
I agree that child should be given freedom to choose religion. Thank You for sharing.
• United States
15 Jun 10
I think these situations are why the Bible tells us not to be unequally yoked with unbelievers. For those times when the couple ignores that warning, I think the child or children should be exposed to both religions; and when they get to the age of accountability, they can make their own decision which religion seems right to them. If they make the wrong decision, the parent can keep the child in his/her prayers that they will eventually see the light.
• India
16 Jun 10
Correct, It should be child who will decide about religion. thank you for sharing.
@efc872 (1077)
• Jamaica
14 Jun 10
It would be best to leave the child completely out of religion and don't get into the fight
• India
15 Jun 10
Yes, let the child decide what s/he want to follow. Thank you for the response.
@efc872 (1077)
• Jamaica
15 Jun 10
They may allow the child to decide in this case but if the religion were the same for both then the child would not be given a choice.
• Malaysia
17 Jun 10
I personally feel that there will be a problem when they have children. The children will get confused in which religion is the best and which one they should choose. However, the confusion can be eliminated if both the husband and wife promise to have a strong sense of respect toward each other's religions. By doing this, the children will see that each parent respects the other's religions, so that they should respect both religions as well. When they are matured enough, it is up to them to choose their own religions.
• India
18 Jun 10
Parents need to be carefull till the time child is mature enough to understand about religion. S/he can decide about religion only if given a chance and not forced. Thank You for sharing.
• United States
13 Jun 10
The key thing is respect and understanding. They seem to have both. They respect each other's path and they understand it can be done, blending two religions in a relationship. As long as they agree on which religion the kids will be brought up in , everything will be ok. I hope the child or children get to practice both until age 13 and then is let to decide for him/herself.
• United States
14 Jun 10
So it works. Their child gets to choose. Fantastic!
• India
14 Jun 10
Yes they have both, Once child is old enough to understand religion its his/her choice to follow religion. Thank you for sharing.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
13 Jun 10
In some family it is a greatest issues that need to be settle. Especially those belong to conservative religion they would not even allow their own loved ones to marry someone who does not belong in the sect or unless that person agree to be converted to the religion of their partner. While it also depend to the open mindedness of the two partner as their child grow they need to decide whatever religion they like to choose and they were given all the rights.
1 person likes this
• India
14 Jun 10
yes, I had seen this around me but things are changing now. I have not seen any issue for few public faces in the country already married in different religion and feel that it will not affect the child if Parents can have better understanding. Thank you for sharing.
• India
14 Jun 10
Well if they have decided to stick to their basic religion and honor each others, there should not be any problem, one neednot bother for the child, because after 20 years this will not be an issue at all Well is he from your village, if so you know, the leaders may play foul, Thanks for sharing. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
1 person likes this
• India
15 Jun 10
Good point, after 20 years there will not be much talk about religion and all these scenarios. Thank You for sharing Sir.
• China
14 Jun 10
Well in this situation one child will decide which religion will they follow. Usually child follow there fathers religion but in this purpose if child want to follow mothers religion then it's also possible and okay with the law.
1 person likes this
• India
15 Jun 10
It should be child's choice to which religion s/he want to follow. Thank you for sharing.
@chanlot (189)
• Indonesia
13 Jun 10
I think religion is married to different people will experience many problems,especially psychological problems of children. Our children will feel confused to choose the religion that they believe will in the future and in their hearts,wondering "Who is right between the father and mother ...?" and the question will remain in their minds until they are big and it will not be good for their lives.
• India
14 Jun 10
chanlot I think there will be some common understaing about day to day activities and how often does we care about religion in a day. Its only when there is a festival. There are few stars married to different religion and nothing came out wrong for them. I believe its all about how you grow the kid, let him grow to a level when he is able to understand things before you start forcing your religion to him. adel09 yes its about how you care for your kid, educate correctly and it will never be an issue. Thank you guys for sharing your views.
@adel09 (490)
• Philippines
13 Jun 10
If you do your part as a good parent, you will educate him/her in a right way. Try to expose him/her but don't criticize other religions.
@adel09 (490)
• Philippines
13 Jun 10
At first, they have already known what is best for that issue. Why shouldn't they apply the same way they have to their child? All they have to do is educate their child on both religion and let him/her choose when the right time comes. However, the best way to solve any issue is to seat both parties and talk about whats best.
@chanlot (189)
• Indonesia
13 Jun 10
I think parents will find it difficult to educate their children, because they both have different ways in accordance with their religious beliefs.
@adel09 (490)
• Philippines
13 Jun 10
Yes, it might be difficult. I think they could find a way to this.
@adel09 (490)
• Philippines
13 Jun 10
Correction: find a way to do this
@reene0225 (351)
• United States
16 Jun 10
My boyfriend is Catholic and I am Baptist. My boyfriend's parents are both of different religions as well. His father is Catholic. His mother is baptist. We are both non practicing in our religions. We both respect each other for our own beliefs. We have a son together. When he is old enough he can choose what he wants to follow. After all I believe that parents shouldn't pressure children into believing something just because that's what they believe. We have talked about it a few times and that's what we came up with.
• India
17 Jun 10
I am happy to hear that most of us respect other religions as well. This is such a good thing. Thank You for sharing.
@smiley83 (1534)
• Malaysia
15 Jun 10
hey Ajay!! yeah it does happen a lot though..different religious do get together as long as they do understand each others' rules... Personally, I don't think i can make it..I have no problems to have friends from different religions backgrounds but that doesn't mean I can go into a deep relationship with.. it is totally hard for me to do that
• India
15 Jun 10
I Appreciate your thoughts, its not easy for everyone to accept this. Thank you for sharing.
@calixto21 (103)
• Argentina
14 Jun 10
well, my parents forced me to be a christian but i took the desition to be an atheist, so i think that no matter what ur parents try to frce u to beliebe, the one who will choose is always the child.
• India
14 Jun 10
Thats bad, I do not like religion forcing. Its upto the child what he believe in, he will choose religion as per his thinking and understanding. Thank you for sharing.
15 Jun 10
The key word here is respect. I don't think there will be a problem for the child but it should definately be discussed within the relationship. My husband and I don't follow any religion and so our children do not. We live in a catholic cpuntry and if my daughters marry into a family who are religious then I will respect their choice because I am bringing them up to have a wide knowledge on all religions and then they can make an informed decision for themselves in later life.
• India
16 Jun 10
Your thoughts on religion are very clear, it shoul dbe individual who will decide what religion s/he want to follow. Thank You for sharing.
• India
15 Jun 10
hello friend we do follow each others religion because it is written in each and every book the basic teachings are same and we tend to follow that so i dont think so there is any person in this that do not tend to follow the basic idea of humanity i think the religion that everyone follows is work and we should follow that we should do great work that will help us and god resides in our heart and soul
• India
16 Jun 10
Well said manish, respecting all the religion is humanity and no one should go against it. Thank you for sharing.
• United States
14 Jun 10
My parents are both athiest, but I grew up always knowing that I could believe whatever I chose to believe. I went to different services and was able to make an informed decision on my own. I think your friends should just let the child make their own decision and just be there to answer any questions.
• India
15 Jun 10
Yes, let the child grow up and decide with proper understanding instead of someone forcing any religion. Thank You for sharing.