An "honest" Police killed foreingers in a hostage
By babyEj
@babyEj (1522)
Philippines
August 23, 2010 8:42pm CST
I think all have watch the hostage crisis. I am sorry to drag this discussion out here. I am sorry for Filipinos, Chinese and HongKong who shared grief from what happened....Please share your thoughts on the questions below....
1.) What do you think about the personality of Senior Police Inspector Rolando Mendoza?
2.)Is he really a good police yet just something put him to an edge? What was it?
3.) Do you think this crisis is a result of incapable court of justice?
4.) HongKong declared "NO travel to Philippines:
5.) Should Filipinos be judge from what Senior Police Inspector Rolando Mendoza did?
4 people like this
9 responses
@eden_shii (506)
• Australia
24 Aug 10
Yeah. When I saw this, I told myself well, the Philippine peso will surely decrease in its purchasing power so if you have dollars, you can earn a lot. But this is not a good situation since this involves lives of many people. It was just so disappointing that it was not solved without shedding blood.
Well, I can't judge Insp. Mendoza since we don't know him personally. He might be a good police and being framed of doing something so that he won't be given his benefits. I think this is so, because I've heard of some good government workers who were suprisingly charged of wrong doings even if they didn't actually committed it. I think this was done to avoid paying retirement benefits to these workers. But, thinking of the possible negative side, this ex-police officer could be a narcisist. I don't know, maybe I watched too much CSIs and Criminal Minds kinda show. It has been said that he's been having awards. A narcisist being someone who loves himself wants to catch others attention. And when the attention was diverted to something else (like his brother was caught), that might have touched the nerve and so he killed randomly. But, I don't know. I really pity this ex-policeman and the family he left.
This crisis might be a result of his incapable court justice. You know, as I have mentioned I've heard and even knew a government worker who was dismissed from his job and wasn't given his millions-worth retirement benefit because they charged him of corruption.
Now that Hongkong declared "NO travel to Philippines", this is surely a bad news to us. This can affect our economy. That crime affected the entire nation. HK should have atleast made a travel advisory prohibiting to travel in Manila area but not in Visayas. Places here are quite peaceful though there are petty crimes.
We can't blame the people if they'll judge the ex-policeman. THere are many people to pinpoint on who to blame. Not just him.
@jamed28 (1903)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
He never claimed that he is innocent. During the negotiation, he never told the negotiator that he is innocent. All he wanted was a reinstatement. He is after the retirement's benefits that was removed from him, after relieving him from the PNP.
THERE ARE MANY PEOPLE INVOLVE IN THIS MESS, BUT IT IS THAT PSYCHO COP (MENDOZA) WHO STARTED THIS, SO HE IS TO BE BLAME PRIMARILY.
ABOUT THE PNP, ON HANDLING THIS HOSTAGE NEGOTIATION, They are in the STONE AGE, when it comes to this matter.
@eden_shii (506)
• Australia
24 Aug 10
Okay, I missed that part. So, he might not be innocent. He is to be blamed and yeah, those cops are indeed from stone age. They should've bought some spy stuff online. Good gadgets can be bought online but the police department, they are just way beyond. The good thing though was they at least saved quite a few.
@gaiza12 (4884)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
I think that Senior Police Inspector Rolando Mendoza is a good police officer because he won't be awarded as one of the Top Policemen in the Philippines, as what i have read in one of the discussions here. I believe that once again the results our court of justice is incapable..justice should have to prevail on this country and should hear both side of the situations and results should be based on the truth and not on the money a party can provide. HongKong has its rights on the "No travel to Philippines" policy for it's their only way to protect its people. And Filipinos should not be judged in general for the mistake of one is never a mistake of all.
@greenpeas (998)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
Even the medals wont matter if you decided that killing innocent people because you feel wronged is your only recourse in life.
@jamed28 (1903)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
Whatever awards or good complements that psycho cop received before they are all worthless. What he did is not a doing of a normal human being. It is a selfish act. They should had shot him already in the earlier time where he is still showing himself. What he did is a bad example but probably influence others to follow him.
@prettyauds (258)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
Right! Whatever awards or if he was a top cop during his service couldn't cover up what he did yesterday. He was doing a crime that time,an you're right jamed28, the cops should have taken him down earlier. I think they were reckless for prolonging the suffering of the victims in the hands of the hostage taker. The police made themselves looked dumb to everyone for doing that. I pity so much for their incapabilities.
@jamed28 (1903)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
By the way, I don't think he is an honest cop. With the cases charge against him, I don't think it is right to call him HONEST. We may hear from TV interviews about people saying he is innocent, and he was just the commanding officer that is why he was involved in this case, well the fact that he was charge, then maybe he is involved. I don't think it is right to give this man a credit after what he did.
@boogzter (52)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
I think he was so desperate because he won't be getting anything when he retires because of his robbery extortion case with the ombudsman. I still firmly believe that there was no intention to harm the hostages, it was his brother who started everything. If he did not make a scene the lives of the 9 including the his brother could have been spared. Our justice system is still in transition phase that's why I can say the "incapable court justice" can be referred to the previous administration. Every government's goal is to ensure its citizen's safety so its safe to say that the travel advisory was just to protect their people. What I'm worried is the discrimination, I've heard over the news that a Filipino domestic helper was handcuffed by her employer because of the incident.
@Sphinx30 (286)
• Philippines
25 Aug 10
I do not personally know about Senior Police Inspector Rolando Mendoza but as portrait by the media men here in the Philippines, He is an awarde police officer, he was dedicated to his work, he's reputation being the police is highly recommended to one of the finest police officer in the whole police organization. But this good reputation that he hardly earned to his career was totally junked when he was accused with the crime that prompt the department of ombudsman to dismiss him to the police organization after a thorough investigation to the case. According to the ombudsman he could still appeal the decision made by them to the court of appeals to reconsider the case and to grant him T.R.O to prevent the execution of the order to dismiss inspector mendoza to his post. this was not materialized because he felts injustice at the very beginning of the case that prompt him to commit such crime and sacrifice the innocent lives. if there is going to be blamed about this situation, it should be the government officers itself because if they only think the welfare of the people and delivered the transparency in the whole justice system this would not be happen. But the selfishness of those government officers and all those people compose the justice system brings suffering to the people. i believe inspector mendoza is also one of the thousands victims in this particularly incident. Although We condemn such crime committed by mendoza but lets not judge him because he is only of the victims of such injustices... it's so unfair for us filipinos to be judge by the whole world of what could happen, people should remember that nobody wants to do such thing,that situation could occur anywhere,anytime and any place.
@youless (112481)
• Guangzhou, China
24 Aug 10
It is a big disaster and things should not be ending like this.
Now I really wonder that Mendoza was innocent. At least at first his purpose was not to kill the people. If he wanted to kill people, he could have killed much more as we could watch it from TV. His demands were not that much. He just wanted to be back to work. If he was a real bad person, he would not ask for this. He had an unfair judgment and therefore he had to use another mistake to correct it. At the beginning he was still stay calm and set free several people. His attitude was still peaceful. Until his demands were rejected by paper officially, plus his brother was caught, then he was totally annoyed. Then the situation was out of control at the end.
This case will somewhat have a negative effect on the tourism in Philippines at present. Because the negotiation and rescue are both so failing. The tourists won't feel safe to it. But I won't judge that all the Filipinos are Mendoza, I believe that the people in Philippines are kind and nice and it is a country which I like to visit one day.
@o0jopak0o (6394)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
i find it ironic that he wrote making a big mistake to change a big wrong decision.
its really understandable with the travel ban, when the sars came to hongkong philippines was one of the first and one of the last to put a advisory in hongkong. its an understandable reaction. but i hope its not long lasting.
@GreedyMoney (146)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
what he did was wrong but they should look on to his case. am sure a lot of good officers suffers the same fate.