Men from monkey evolution

@visavis (5934)
Philippines
January 16, 2011 6:18am CST
Hi friend my last discussion today. I just remebered my school day when my teacher in science discussed about human race. In a current events published that human or men are from monkey evolution (one I remembered was Java Man). Which human are from the evolution of monkey. Wow it was terrible you know I can't accept now. Before when I heard about I just wondering how comes and now years past I realized that issues of information was totally wrong. How about you? Do you believed that human are from money evolution? Do you have some explanation why? share to us... see you around
3 people like this
12 responses
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
16 Jan 11
Hi visavis It all depends on how you look at it... Religions.. They have different opinions about the Human Evolution and Science... Well they almost are similar views when it comes to evolution of Life - from one simple molecule to the cell to the millions of species. For me, I do believe that we all evolved from the Apes because of the theories they have and logically, we do have similarities with the Apes of today.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
16 Jan 11
hello thesids, If you don't consider my reasoning as perfect one (i never claim it's as perfect) What more with the evolutionists reasoning? I sighted few examples which is true and no one can deny it. Kidney,blood and retina can be given to anyone as long as it matches...thu some were advised to have a donor from immediate relative or family. But...not a suggestion that a monkey can be a donor.(have you ever heard one?)
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
16 Jan 11
Yes, you are quite right and I had not heard anything like this until I found out these - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serge_Voronoff [Note:Not a referral Link] This was an experiment carried out successfully - "His first official transplantation of a monkey gland into a human took place on June 12, 1920....By the early 1930s, over 500 men had been treated in France by his rejuvenation technique, and thousands more around the world, such as in a special clinic set up in Algiers" - From the above page. Today a segment of people are blaming him and his work as they believe it lead to AIDs in humans but the other set of people are tying to work further on his research and I am hopeful that we would have animal-to-human transplants sometime in the future - http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2001/06/0606_wireorgans.html
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
16 Jan 11
yup
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
16 Jan 11
hello friend, To justify that it's not true. So many people are having kidney problems,why not get kidney from monkey? Why not go to the jungle and get blood donors from monkeys? Why not get eye retina from monkeys to use for blind people. I never believed that we came from those creatures. If we evolve from monkey...then why there are monkeys until now. and why people didn't evolve for a higher form? have a great day
1 person likes this
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
16 Jan 11
yes your totally correct, i don't know why such information published and i don't know what some scientist views about that issue. Just wait may be some responses from our friends that have more info about it. just wait and see my friend. anyway thanks to your response. see you around
1 person likes this
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
16 Jan 11
@jaiho, Even it is quite difficult to get the organ transplants you mention from humans - Our Kidneys or blood or retina do not match with every other human out on earth! Even the ones from siblings dont match many a times... I dont see that reasoning a perfect one
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
17 Jan 11
@ islander, OUR ?...sorry but i never ever consider apes and monkeys as my ancestors...!!! Science until now haven't proven that humans have same genes with monkey...
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
17 Jan 11
If you go to the zoo, and stand there watching the monkeys in their cage, and notice all the silly things they do, you will change your mind about Men evolving from Monkeys! You will be able to see just by watching the cage that men didn't evolve from monkeys! Monkeys evolved from men! Yes for certain, Monkeys evolved from Men, and are now doing all the silly things men do! There can be no doubt about it- from watching the monkey cage just a few minutes you will know for sure Monkeys evolved from Men!
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
18 Jan 11
This is an excellent Idea! For a start, All Government officials! Put them in special cages with a time lock on the cage door. Let them out in 10 years, or earlier if they were honest.
@rappeter13 (8608)
• Romania
16 Jan 11
I never believed this, because I believe that God has created everything in this world. For me it is not acceptable this theory, and I find it very odd. I don't believe in evolutionism, but I accept that there are similarities between humans and monkeys and other animals. But for me the world is the creation of God and not a process.
• Romania
17 Jan 11
You have the right to believe in this, I have the right to believe in God. I don't question why is this like this, or why isn't otherwise, I just accept things as they are. Please explain me, why after my operation I wasn't able to see anybody clearly, but a person in green who was standing between the wall and my bed, although there was no space in between. And after I recovered I was asking my parents were the men in green is, and nobody knew who I was looking for. I guess this was also a "process".
@asliah (11137)
• Philippines
20 Jan 11
hi, a little bit of yes, because from monkey to ape and ape to human, and because there are some studies that can prove it. i dont know the thoroughly explanation of this.
@trader22 (232)
• Jamaica
17 Jan 11
All of this was base on theory. What i have notice is that studies are base from this theory. Not many people decide to we approach it. To me the whole idea and theory that man came from ape is study. Not because we have similar characteristic doesn't mean we evolve from them. Did a tiger evolve from a lion? Did a dog really evolve from a wolf? The whole theory and concept of evolution is messed up.
@trader22 (232)
• Jamaica
18 Jan 11
Religion has nothing to do with this. Its just people and there believes and they decide to bring religion into it. I know species adapt and this adaptation might lead to evolution. I also know about natural selection and how the fittest survive. But, when it comes to humans saying that we came from apes by basing it on observation isn't acceptable to me. They can compare the brain and skeleton structure all they want, that doesn't meet with my logic. If that was done then so many species that are far from relation would have been said to evolve from each other. If we actually evolve from apes there would be evidence in our DNA. So far i haven't heard anyone making a DNA link. Evey link is just base on structural characteristics. The thing about people is that we refuse to leave things unanswered so we place things in its place even if it is non sense. Myth is a way of coping with ignorance.
@trader22 (232)
• Jamaica
19 Jan 11
96% i call that into question. Yes we both are mammalians. Yes we have similar organs that are situated into the body in similar ways (as do many other specie). Yes we both have skin and hair(as do many other specie). And thats what make our DNA similar but the differences are quite clear and too far apart to claim we evolve from them. First question, how did our brain evolve to the point that we are now from such primitive beings? How did we develop such awareness and intellectual growth? Most instincts that apes have are natural. Certain things they learn from there parents as do many other animals. I still believe base on certain clear evidence that humans and apes were made separately. Here is another question, why did we leave so many species of ape behind, since you and many others claim we evolve from them? And remember it takes environmental and genetic change to claim we evolve from them. Its not like apes are segregated in one place and we got separated from them and evolve. With these questions in mind and the theories that I have concocted we didn't evolve from apes. No discussion here is going to change any of us point of view and believes.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Jan 11
visavis I believe that God created u s in his own image and have always had trouble trying to reconcile the ape to man thing as I believe firmly in God the father, son and dholy ghost. I have no real information but just the gut feeling that we are God';s children and we all know it for we all have that little God spark jin us that helps in time of adversity and sorrow. He lives in me and that is all I know,how to combat the ape to man thing I am not sure.
@bird123 (10643)
• United States
17 Jan 11
Evolution is part of the unfolding of the universe. There is more to creation than this. Evolution does not address our spiritual being. We are all spiritual beings in our true natures. This is how we are in God's image. It has nothing to do with this physical world. Does anyone really care how the body was manufactured???? If you do then you might end up with a bruised ego. If you depend on the stories from holy books, then you don't really care to get all the answers. Where are the specific details in those stories??? DNA isn't mentioned at all. Creation is a very complicated thing. It will take much study to really understand. The good news is that God created the universe to unfold in such a way that God's children would be able to figure it all out in time.
@ybong007 (6643)
• Philippines
17 Jan 11
I believe in the human evolution theory because it's the credible theory that has not been proven wrong yet.
@madteaparty (2748)
• Japan
17 Jan 11
Well, I think you don't remember your school days well or your science teacher wasn't very good at it. The evolution theory doesn't say that the human race comes from the monkeys, as monkeys are species that are existing nowadays, like the human one. It's a very common wrong interpretation of the theories of Darwin, and I keep hearing it all the time. Human beings are descendants or an ancient species of hominids. You need to review your knowledge about evolution.
@jumesbond (109)
• Turks And Caicos Islands
16 Jan 11
People have difficulty believing what the don't want to believe even if there is proof and logic behind it. But, yes, we are related to monkeys. Just look at the way they move and their habits. Look at the Bonobo monkey especially. They make the same faces and gestures as us. They are very similar to us.
@rushian09 (139)
• Philippines
17 Jan 11
Are you an atheist? it's only a theory of charles darwin, there's no proof that human race came from monkey. Only God created human, from dust! The proof that God created a man from a dust, we can read it from the Bible.