Is it ok for Parents to be friend with their children?
By 34momma
@34momma (13882)
United States
23 responses
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
28 Apr 11
I have always had great communication lines with my kids ever since they were very little and understood how to carry conversations. I have always been known as Ms. Huckstable, as they called me because when I was upset with them and or punished them I always sat them down and explained the reasons.
I have always considered that although they were my children and kids they were still people, little one but still people. So although they understood I was in charge, as soon as they became teens we naturally developed a great friendship as well. Although my methods may not work for everyone I can certainly say that not only do they respect me as mom first they are the best friends I could ever have.
@34momma (13882)
• United States
29 Apr 11
what you are talking girl is being a mother! and being a fair mother at that. I am the same way with my children. friendship comes as they are much older. my son is now 21 and we are just redefining our relationship to more of a friendlier one. The one thing I have always told my children is " we can be friendly, but i will not be your friend." for me it's a line that i will not allow them to cross. I am your mother
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
28 Apr 11
hehehe, you are so right. I would sit at that kitchen table and explain the reasons why I was upset. Both my kids till today call me Ms. Huckstable. I like it too, because it reminds me that I was very fair.
It also afforded me a great deal of respect. Neither one of my kids to date can hold a full minute grudge with me.
Hi Mrs. Hatley.
1 person likes this
@SpikeTheLobster (6403)
•
28 Apr 11
Until children become adults, I don't think it's a good idea. There should never be any question who's the "boss" (not in a bad way, but who has authority) while children are growing up.
It's tempting to want to be your kids' best friend but the problems outweigh the benefits. One of my brothers is like this with his children and they're horrible. Another brother maintains his authority while being reasonable, understanding and friendly (but not a friend) and he's the best parent I've ever seen.
Once kids grow to adulthood, I think it's a lot easier for this to work. I was fortunate enough to become more of a friend with my mum after I finished University: I was old enough to make my own decisions (and mistakes) and she didn't interfere, which meant we could go shopping, laugh, chat and joke like friends without ever forgetting that she deserved my respect as the lady who'd brought me up.
It's a tough line to walk, isn't it?
1 person likes this
@Kirinx (1688)
• United States
1 May 11
exactly I dont have kids (thankfully) but I have experienced this with my nieces.
children arent mature enough and will often take their parents,aunts,uncles etc
acting like friends badly.
they will think they can do whatever they want and they wont have respect for you.
@trinale (1479)
• United States
29 Apr 11
That's a good question momma! My initial thought was that sure it's ok to be friends with your children as long as you keep being a parent first. But then I thought, I going to ask my 10-yr old daughter if she thinks I'm her friend.
If she says yes then I will stick with my answer here. If she says no then my new response will be no, parents need to be parents and friends after kids have moved out on their own.
Cheers,
Stan
1 person likes this
@stephcjh (38473)
• United States
29 Apr 11
I think it is great if you can be friends with your child or children. I think you should not mix parenting with the friendship though. They should know that you are their parent but you are also there for them as a friend. I don't think there is a certain age. I guess it is when the child can understand the friendliness.
1 person likes this
@34momma (13882)
• United States
3 May 11
Being friendly and being their friend to me is two different things. Like i play jokes on my kds and we laugh and joke around. that's me being friendly, but in now way does that mean we are friends. if you ask my kids what's my number 2 rule, they will say, my mother always say " We can be friendly, but not friends." M
@cream97 (29086)
• United States
28 Apr 11
Hi. 34momma. I have a strong relationship with all of my three kids. It is very fun too. I love talking to them and enjoying their company. They are special to me and they are close and dear to me too. As they become older, I will have a stronger relationship that is maintained into a mutual friendship. So as they get older they will call upon me. They trust me enough to share with me many things that are on their minds.
1 person likes this
@34momma (13882)
• United States
29 Apr 11
cream i have that same close relationship with my three children too. I love the closeiness we have, and how the older two feel comfortable enough to come to me with most of their daily issues. we are talk, laugh, share, joke around. my older son is 21 and we are not becoming more friends/mother and son. but my younger 2 will not be ready for that kind of relationship until they are adutls as well
@keshia2007r (2880)
• United States
29 Apr 11
No, I don't think this is good at all. Often when parents treat there kids like their friend nothing good comes out of it. The children start to talk to the parents any way, they feel they don't need to listen to their parents. Why because "we're friends" friends let me stay out late, or I don't need to listen to you, you're not the boss of me. Often kids loose a lack of authority respect for their parent because they are use to getting away with certain things. Then the moment the parent decides to act like a parent instead of a friend, things are no longer the same and they will tend to walk over you regardless. I've see this happen to may time, you can see this for example in the supermarket and tell who's the boss the children or parents.
1 person likes this
@maidangela7349 (1191)
•
30 Apr 11
Of course you should be a good friend to your child whatever the age. Of course as the child matures so should your friendship mature. If your kids can't rely on you as their friend then who can they rely on
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
28 Apr 11
hi 34momma yes as long as you do not forget you are the parent and he or she or they are your children. It should be a gentle gradual thing with mom and children so that by the time they are teens they will not be afraid to come to you with any problem.then is the time to be sure all lines of communication are open. ANd always make certain that your child knows who is the authority around your home, YOU not your children. This way they will love and respect you always. respect them always as they are your little ones and human beings too that way as they grow up they will never be rude and disrespectful to you you. Many parents do not tend to respect their own little kids.they are your children and they do not need to earn your respect as it should always be there.
1 person likes this
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
30 Apr 11
My children are in their 40s and 50s now, and we are best friends. However, we were not friends when they were children and lived at home. Children need parents.
1 person likes this
@rosegardens (3032)
• United States
22 Aug 11
I do not believe a parent should be friends with their children. The parent is the parent, not a friend, not a peer. A parents job is to guide, to love, to encourage good behavior and to punish bad behavior. A parents job is not to be liked by the child, but to form the child to be liked by others. A child needs guidance to be the best person they can possibly be and if they are not raised with a clear definition of right and wrong, the society around them will suffer. I often wonder what kind of childhood and parenting people like Bernie Maddoff and those involved in the Enron scandal had. Greedy people, who had no eye for the good of their companies, employees and those who invested with them. Children who are raised with a clear definition of what is right and what is wrong, rarely do such things. A parent who is a friend blurs those lines. You can have fun with your child, yet still be the parent.
@danishcanadian (28955)
• Canada
21 Aug 11
My mother and I are friends, but I am an adult living my own life, so it's fine. For a parent to be a friend during the childhood would be a conflict of interest.
@gitfiddleplayer (10362)
• United States
29 Apr 11
I think that parents cannot be friends with their children because that is not the relationship that's intended. Parents are to be guides until their children can stand on their own. You can be a friendly voice to your kids but never their friend, your friendship will allow them to make mistakes that will cause a casual relationship to form. Kids need to be able to rely on their parents as givers not acceptors.
@sender621 (14893)
• United States
29 Apr 11
A parent can certainly be a friend to their child. it is not the only relationships they should strive for. It is important to know when to just be the parent and when friendship should intervene,
@adnileb (5276)
• Philippines
29 Apr 11
I don't think so. It's better to keep the parent role for the children so that the same respect will be given. I can site an example of that basing on my cousin. Her parents' treatment to her was like a friend so my cousin used to yell and get mad to her parents. Which makes me wondering how can her parents let her do that attitude to them? But I guess it's too late for them to change the relationship because whenever they want to scold their daughter, she will definitely shout at them. Too bad for a daughter. They can't do anything else but to go with their daughter's attitude so as not to make their kid rebellious and stop studying hard. By the way, my cousin became a CumLaude upon her college graduation. Such a good gift to her parents indeed even though she acts rude.
@ronica1234 (30)
• United States
29 Apr 11
No it is not okay for a parent to be friends with their child because then the child would think that they can talk to them any way they like as if they were an actual friend. Also, The child wouldn't want to listen to someone they see as a friend so this wouldn't work any way you put it because parents aren't meant to be friends with their kids.