"Too Skinny" and being harassed to eat junk food
@allyoftherain (7208)
United States
August 27, 2011 6:10pm CST
Yesterday morning, a group of students brought donuts to class and everyone was invited to partake. The TA told me, quite rudely, "You need to eat a donut!"
And when I did (not because he told me to, but because I wanted a donut lol) he told me, "Eat another one! Eat two!"
So I said, "No, I don't want to eat two." I'd eaten a full breakfast before I left home, and I didn't want to eat another one.
But he kept on badgering me. Saying things like, "You're too skinny, eat more!" Which annoyed the heck out of me. And he's an annoying person who tends to be really mean, but in truth this isn't the first time something like this has happened. Since elementary school, it seems everyone has been telling me that I'm too skinny. I distinctly remember another girl (the popular bully) calling me "Skeleton" on the playground. I've been told, "Eat fast food everyday", "I don't believe you've ever eaten a donut in your life", and "Eat ice cream for breakfast".
I like my weight, but stuff like this really bugs me. I know this happens to loads of girls who are naturally thin like me, so are any of you out there in mylot? How do comments like these make you feel?
And for those of you who see thin people and make comments like these, what's your motivation for doing so? Do you realize how much that it hurts?
4 people like this
24 responses
@RitterSport (2451)
• Lippstadt, Germany
28 Aug 11
poor allyoftherain, I am not skinny but really overweight but I think I understand the hurt you feel. See when I eat something then someone will sure think does this fatty need to eat and what makes her eat THIS, doesnt she have any self restraint when it comes to eating with the way she looks already.... blah blah blah
I believe its everyones very own decision what and how much to eat and drink. Only exception would be if there is really a health problem (if people told me you should not eat it as is contains sugar.... I am diabetic).
2 people like this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
I think calling someone too thin is just as hurtful as calling someone fat, so I do believe that you know how it feels and thanks for the encouragement. To me, I hate the assumption that because I'm thin that must mean I don't eat or something. I think it probably feels similar to someone being told that they're fat and eat too much. Some people naturally have a certain body type, and it isn't fair to assume that everyone over or under a certain weight doesn't take care of themselves.
Thanks for your comment! I know I probably can't stop other people from hurting you with their comments, but I hope my saying don't let insensitive and rude people get the best of you make at least little bit of a difference.
1 person likes this
@RitterSport (2451)
• Lippstadt, Germany
28 Aug 11
hi dear allyoftherain the comments I described hurt me years ago but now they dont hurt me any more. Even if someone would call me ugly right into my face I would not even think about it and could shake it off...... LOL......
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Well I'm really glad you've gained that strength of character! I don't think I have that, so you're an inspiration to me.
@allknowing (136407)
• India
28 Aug 11
This is part of life whether one is thin or fat, whether one has pimples on the face, whether one looks pale or whatever that is considered not in keeping with 'society norms'will be a reason for people to pick on. I was too short in class and I too was a victim then. It is up to us to ignore such slights and move on.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Yeah I know it's a part of life, but I don't think that I have to like it or accept that bullies are just one of the things we have to deal with daily. I think that we shouldn't just ignore, we should stand up to it.
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
I think it depends on the bully. Growing up I never knew bullies to give up when you tried to ignore them, and even though bullying isn't part of my daily life, I still feel like ignoring does no good. They always wound up trying harder and getting nastier. And I when I say stand up to it, I don't just mean to any one particular bully... I mean to the idea of bullying in general. We shouldn't shrug it off like it's no big deal and it's a part of life, we should be pushing to eradicate it.
@allknowing (136407)
• India
28 Aug 11
Standing up is to put these bullies in their place and then move on. Having said this I feel it is not always successful this 'standing up to' thing. These shameless bullies get encouraged and they do it more. We all meet these kind of people and my approach is to ignore them and for me it works.
1 person likes this
@estherlou (5015)
• United States
28 Aug 11
He's a jerk. But there are a lot of them out there. I'm on the flip side of your story. I was chubby as a child and stayed overweight my entire life except for short periods of time after a diet. I remember someone driving by my yard when I was outside watering the grass. The man called out 'hubba hubba' and it was not a compliment. Since I've been made fun of my entire life, I would never say something so rude to a thin person. I might compliment you on your size with wishful thinking! LOL People just need to stop and think before they open their mouths!
1 person likes this
@estherlou (5015)
• United States
28 Aug 11
stary1 I totally agree. I have a friend who would say "God doesn't like ugly" meaning they acted badly and will have to pay for it later.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
He's a jerk.
Oh yes, I totally agree.
As I said to RitterSpot already, I believe calling someone too thin can be just as hurtful as calling someone fat. It's the flip side of the same issue, playing our insecurities about our weight. And I agree wholeheartedly, people really need to stop and think before they open their mouths!
And I hope you realize that people like that drive-by bully are just that, bullies who are rude and insensitive.
Thanks for your comment and your encouragement!
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
29 Aug 11
You see, that's the thing! You shouldn't assume someone's diet habits on sight, that's just arrogant and rude! Someone said earlier that I should respond with, "Who made you the eat police?!?!" Which might be a good response for anyone with this problem on my side and the flip side of the coin.
1 person likes this
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
28 Aug 11
If this is inherited and not an eating problem, eating junk food will not put weight on you and you need to tell these people that..My grandfather and father were tall and skinny, so my son was also skinny that his sister's friend made a comment that he looks like he was from Ethiopia, (this was back when they showed Ethiopian children starving, on the TV) and my husband thought if we fed him junk food, he would gain weight..I think my son loved it when his dad brought home fast food and he got a milkshake, but it didn't put weight on him..He is still pretty skinny and at over 6 feet tall, it's hard to find pants to fit him..
So, if it is in the family, then you tell them that it won't work, it's like telling them to change their eye color. (I mean really change it, not contact lenses)
1 person likes this
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Oh I know stowyk, I didn't mean to imply it was right what was said to ally, but from raising a child that was so skinny, I do admit I was concerned about health issues..
Wow, like I did with my dogs,worried because they had lost weight, but they are healthy and that is all that matters...
1 person likes this
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Ally, this probably won't faze these people, but what if you ask your doctor for a bill of health to show everyone that you are just fine the way you are...
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
That's the thing though, it seems no matter what you tell people... they don't seem to believe that there are people with natural body types. I know eating junk food won't make me gain weight and my poor sister who's never weighed 100 pounds in her life and has always eaten as much junk food as she wants knows that eating junk food won't make her gain weight... but there seems to be no end to the people who think that's how everyone gains weight. There's no end to the people who just can't accept that you're skinny, and you're perfectly healthy and fine just the way that you are.
And Stowyk, that same girl on the playground who called me a skeleton tried to retract her comment when I told her that the teacher wanted to see her because of it. She said, "It's okay that you're skinny, I just don't want you to be fat." But it didn't help, and I still dragged her up to see the teacher. It's not okay to make fun of someone for their weight. The most important thing is to be healthy, and you can be healthy and thin and healthy and not thin. The emphasis should be on healthy living, not on what is a good weight.
1 person likes this
@courtknee525 (3742)
• United States
28 Aug 11
I would just try my best to ignore it. As long as you're naturally skinny and not forcing yourself not to eat or anything, I think you're fine. It's not your fault you're super skinny and honestly, it would be better than being obese. I'm skinny myself and every so often people will try and force me to eat. I eat my fair share of junk food but it's not like I sit and go on a binge. So people are always trying to get me to eat more but really, I eat until I'm comfortably full, not to the point where I'm overstuffed and feel disgusting. I think people should just mind their own business and not try and get others to eat more or in some cases, eat less.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
It's the assumption that because you're skinny that must mean you're starving yourself that really gets me. I eat three square meals a day and occasionally indulge in ice cream, darn it! lol Accusing someone of being too thin is really just as hurtful as calling somebody fat.
@courtknee525 (3742)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Yes, you're definitely right. I don't like it when people assume I'm anorexic or something because I'm skinny or I'm not eating in front of them. I'm usually the first one to get a dessert or any sort of junk food. People should just be accepted the way they are, fat or skinny, and people shouldn't say anything about the eating habits of others, unless it's a harmful situation.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Exactly. You can be really healthy at body weights that aren't typically considered normal or average. But people should have real confirmed proof of a true eating disorder or destructive habits before they jump to that conclusion. Not just "Super Skinny = This person is anorexic", you know?
@YoungInLove (1254)
• Canada
28 Aug 11
Thats a joke and a half. It blows my mind when people think just because a person is skinny and not fat then its okay to say that kind of stuff. Its equally as rude to say that to someone as it is to say to an overweight person, stop eating, stop for a while cause your big. And some people just have fast metabolisms and cant do a whole lot about it, regardless of how much they eat (i have friends who are skinny as a twig but eat like a man) either way the way that person spoke was wrong because if you actually did have an eating issue then that wouuld have been the most rude and horrible way to approach the sitaution. Sorry you had to go through that, Im sure that person will be put in their place some day. Theres alot of socially awkward people out there who dont understand the concept of being courteous and polite.
1 person likes this
@YoungInLove (1254)
• Canada
28 Aug 11
haha i was being sarcastic when i said a joke and a half, i meant it in a ..as if someone thinks this is socially acceptable to say..kinda way ..either way no matter what the circumstance was it was the worst thing that person could have possibly said at that time because no matter which way he tried to say it, it would have made someone mad. Shoulda just kept his mouth shut
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
It's a "joke" but it's not very funny. And I agree wholeheartedly that it is equally rude to say stop eating to an overweight person. It hurts just as much. Now that you mention it, I also agree it would also be the absolute worst way to approach someone with a real eating disorder. Thanks for your comment!
@wilsongoddard (7291)
• United States
30 Aug 11
If I were in that situation, I would go over the TA's head and complain of harassment. I would push to get his rear end tossed. If the school was unwilling to do so, I'd probably consult an attorney and see about filing a lawsuit since this is an ongoing issue of harassment.
I'm thin. I'm thinner than I should be. I tend to eat healthfully, which, unfortunately, means that I struggle to get enough calories to meet the demands of my high metabolism. Some people resent me for being so thin. Not my problem. I have enough problems in my life that what insecure and jealous people (usually, women) have to say about my modelesque size is of no consequence to me. I'm tall; I'm thin, and I'm rather cute when I want to be. If other women don't like that, not my problem.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
31 Aug 11
I thought about it, but he's a well-liked member of the faculty. When I even mention to anyone in authority that he's such a jerk they just shrug it off and say, "Well that's his character." And I hardly want to get into a war with this school... it's a small school and I'm depending on it to help me get my future in order.
The thing is, it's usually not women making the mean comments... it's usually men. Women may say something off-hand like, "I'm really jealous." but it's not mean, it's just a kind of life's-unfair laughable. Even if someone did resent me because they were insecure, I get that and I wouldn't find it too upseting. I've never struggled with my body or my weight, but I have other huge insecurities. But when someone of the opposite gender is tearing you down, at least for me, it hurts much worse.
@jazel_juan (15746)
• Philippines
28 Aug 11
There is nothing left to do but ignore such people. Being skinny or even being fat does not guarantee you of being healthy. There are fat people who may look healthy but are not, in fact more are prone of degenerative diseases and also for skinny people. It is a matter of how we eat and if you do not feel like eating more donuts, then don't! People like them might just be jealous of you or just like to plainly annoy. There are just people who are naturally annoying, its like they are born with this trait. It indeed happened to me, some would say i am big but i just ignore them. It is pointless to argue or reason out to people like them, as long as you are happy with your own skin then there is no problem at all. I even have a friend ( who is also a mylotter here hahaha ) She is also skinny that we often say she should eat more, but i really do not think she minds, or maybe if she is hurt we do not know but we do try to give her critism that wont hurt her or we joke around her being skinny but we know that she is really like that, her bone structure is like that and she is really that way and will be that way. So Just ignore them.
1 person likes this
@jazel_juan (15746)
• Philippines
29 Aug 11
well then maybe they are just plainly teasing you, so you should just ignore them
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
29 Aug 11
"Ignore"... yeah... another method that I don't seem to find effective. But thanks for the sentiment!
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Maybe you should ask if she minds. Personally, my friends have never treated me like that, and they don't feel a need to tell me to eat more because they know my eating habits are perfectly healthy and saying stuff like that really bugs me.
@maezee (41988)
• United States
30 Aug 11
Aww that's sad. Almost as bad as someone who's overweight (like me!!) being excluded from the donut-fest by having the TA say, "yeah... you don't need any more fried food". Ha ha. Just plain offensive. People should really consider taking their foot out of their mouths (AKA - thinking before they speak). I would be frustrated if I were in your shoes. Skinny doesn't necessarily equate to "anorexic" or "unhealthy" by any means...The reverse is probably true actually. People just have different body types, genetics, and different metabolisms and yours is obviously faster than theirs. It seems weird to me how everyone jumps to the conclusion that when you're thin, you MUST be starving yourself. But hey, take it as a compliment. They are probably just jealous - I mean like 70% of the world is overweight, and I guess that might make some people insecure (and therefore mean). Eh, just a theory. I wish I could think of a quirky comeback for you to snap back at these rude people with, but I'm drawing a blank...I'll come back to this discussion at a later time if I think of one (or more!). In the mean time, I wouldn't take it personally.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
30 Aug 11
My thoughts exactly! No one should make assumptions about someone's eating habits at first sight... there are body types on both sides of the scale that aren't necessarily average but are still healthy for that person!
Someone earlier said one that I thought was pretty good, which was "Who made you the eat police?" But if you can come up with another one, then that'd be much appreciated. Maybe I can deliver a new one every time someone takes their foot out of their mouth.
Thanks for your comment!
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
28 Aug 11
I am sorry you have to go through this. I feel for people who are bullied because there really isn't any excuse for anyone to bully another. I always say it reflects there own insecurity on some level.
I imagine it is hurtful but hopefully you can just ignore the doofus...he has karma building and karma is a witch with a 'b'
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Would it be bad to say that I hope I get to see that day? lol I don't think I really believe that everyone gets what's coming to them, but thanks for the encouragement. Such comments do come from bullies, and it's sad that human beings do these things to one another.
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Thanks, I guess I do believe that God ultimately will bring justice, but I don't really think of it as "karma" and I don't think it really happens in this lifetime. I hate that the world has such vile bullies in it, but I don't want to become a bully myself and delight in the pain of others... even if I think they deserve it.
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
28 Aug 11
No that wouldn't be a 'bad' thing to say, it would be a normal feeling.
I know many agree with you and don't believe everyone gets what's coming to them because often the don't see it. Still, I believe in ultimate justice..I believe in God and I think eventually all becomes 'fair' In the meantime, I can't figure out why some have to go though hurts...and it is sad there are bullies.
1 person likes this
@butterscotsh (1012)
• Philippines
9 Sep 11
i totally know how you feel!
i always experience that when i was a kid.
it doesn't really annoy me, thank God i was a kid back then
i didn't take the comments seriously.
now that i grew up, i gained a little weight
so i'm not too skinny anymore.
sometimes i still get the comments from other people saying
"you need to eat more, you're so skinny"
but i just think that some people are jealous because i'm skinny.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
13 Sep 11
Ehhh... I don't like the "they're just jealous" excuse. That's the same thing the counselors said to me when I got fun of for being smart in elementary school. They didn't seem the least bit jealous to me, and they still don't.
But thanks for your comment.
@cattychristina (57)
• China
28 Aug 11
I just like you always being told too thin. But my friend around me usually admire me. They always asked me why I can so skinny, don't need to worry eat too much to become fat. So when I met that kind of comment I usually answer I am inborn.
dear, what you need to do is to neglect the annoying people said. They actually envied you slimer than them, they need lose their weight but they can't. So they want you to get some weight to get balance.
I like my weight too.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
29 Aug 11
Ehhh... as I said before to other posters, I don't really like the excuse or the shrug off that "They're just jealous". It still hurts, and I just can't think they're even the least bit jealous when I'm hurting. Like I said to someone else, back in elementary school when they would make fun of me for being smart, I was pretty sure they weren't the least bit jealous.
Thanks for your comment.
@cattychristina (57)
• China
29 Aug 11
I am sorry to not able to make you feel better. But they made fun of you that thing are really hurting. How could they do this.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
30 Aug 11
Well I do feel considerably better after starting this discussion. Lots of people have told me they experience the same thing, or that they believe such behavior is very wrong.
So in a way you have made me feel better. Thanks for that!
@ImAwesome (13)
• Canada
29 Aug 11
I am also underweight and i am a guy so i automatically get made fun of and get rude comments like "you need to eat" and it is very annoying, but the sad thing is i can't do anything about because i have a high metabellism, meaning i digest food quicker than the average person. i am not happy with my weight i wish i could grow out more but i just can't. there are so many things on the internet about hhow to lose weight but nothing (helpful) on how to gain. So i know how you feel and if your happy with your weight then just ignore them. Its what you think. Who cares what other people think. They are probably jealous because they are overweight [lol].
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
29 Aug 11
I'm really sorry, I imagine that it's ten times worse for guys. It's more culturally acceptable for girls to be slender.
I don't like the "they're just jealous" shrug off because it seems to me that there's no way they're jealous... but thanks for the sentiment.
Personally I've found the best way to gain weight is to work on muscle mass through eating higher proteins and doing some weight training. It may or may not work for you, but I wish you the best and I hope that you don't let those nasty bullies get you down.
@crazynurse (7482)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Oh my!! I am neither naturally thin (but wish!) nor do I make comments like you describe to naturally thin people. How callous and inconsiderate. I wonder how the people who make these comments to you would feel if the situation were different and you were thin due to some terminal or horrible illness rather than just your natural, genetic makeup. Imagine their face if you were to say, "If only having a second donut would cure this horrible liver cancer, I would gladly eat a second one." Surely they would feel terrible and wish that they had not said anything. Then again, as callous as they are, perhaps that wouldn't even bother them. People amaze me with their belief that everyone should look the same. What a boring world it would be if everyone looked the same.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
29 Aug 11
I agree, it would be a really boring world if everyone looked the same. I don't know if it would make any difference if I was someone thin because of a terminal illness. I'm not really the type of person who'd claim it as a joke just to get a reaction... but I can imagine the looks on their faces and that's kind of just as good.
Thanks for your comment!
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Junk food isn't good for anybody, and I don't really eat a whole lot of it. Even if it doesn't visibly stick to me, it still causes loads of other problems with your body, and I don't want to be addicted to it.
@hansraj89 (63)
• India
28 Aug 11
Hi....People those teases you saying skinny are actually jeolous of you because they cant be like you.So dont even listen there comment are ignore them totally.There are some people whose work is to just make fun of others..!!
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
Being "jealous" is no excuse to make fun, and not a good reason for me to shrug it off. That just feels like such a weak reason that I shouldn't feel bad about it. That's the first thing counselors would tell us when we got mad fun of in elementary school for being smart or nerdy. "Oh, they're just jealous!" Except you knew they weren't jealous, they really did think you were a weird loser and nothing in them wanted to have what you have. Maybe that doesn't make sense... but the whole "they're just jealous" thing doesn't work for me, cause I don't believe they're jealous.
@tessa9 (1085)
• Philippines
28 Aug 11
There are just people out there who have nothing else to do than to make people feel bad about themselves for them to feel bigger or what not. But I do know some people who are really not aware that they are being rude. Weight is a topic that most people are uncomfortable about. I'm quite the contrary to you actually. When I was 13 I started to gain a lot of pounds. I did not think that I was fat or anything, I just thought that I was a little bigger than the other but definitely not fat. People were starting to call me a whale! I was about 4'11ish and maybe 45 kg at that time. I started to eat more and more because I was getting depressed. I ate because I was depressed and I was depressed because I was constantly told I was fat.
Have you ever heard the statement "Once a fat kid, always a fat kid"? Because that is how I feel. Even though I lost the weight and it happened years ago, I still feel fat and still feel insecure about my weight. (haha I totally made your question about myself haha sorry)
But I think you just have to deal with it and try to let it get to you. If its really bothering you then you should tell them. Some people are just rude...
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
28 Aug 11
I've told him multiple times that he's mean and rude regarding unrelated things, but it seems to be a trait that he's proud of.
And it's totally okay that you made the question about yourself, because as I've said to earlier to other posters it really is the flip side of the same issue. I imagine being told that I was fat and needed to stop eating would be just as hurtful as being told I'm too skinny and need to eat more junk food. It's just disgusting that people do things like this to each other, that bullies jab at insecurities or make unfair assumptions.
@starrose_ara (784)
• Philippines
28 Aug 11
Some people are motivated with not so caring reasons for making such rude comments maybe it has to do with their sad way of coping up with their insecurities that's why they want to tear other people down. I for my part respect each one's preferences. I do follow this precept that If I cannot help you with what I will say better just shut up my mouth. If I can encourage you on the other hand I would be glad to talk. Dealing with people needs one to be sensitive to what other needs.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
29 Aug 11
Maybe, and maybe they're just being mean (like the guy with the donuts, he's just a mean guy ). Then there's the people who think they're being good, by automatically jumping to the conclusion that because you're skinny that must mean you have an eating disorder. It really hurts when people do that.
Thanks for your comment, it was encouraging.
@enaid_osnam (99)
• Philippines
28 Aug 11
I totally understand how you feel! I also get sick and tired of people telling me how thin I am. I think almost anyone I come across with would tell me that, with no exceptions from my relatives. I mean, who wants to hear being insulted at home, school, at a friends house, and probably all the places you could think of. They would also tell me that I looked like a stick and call me a walking skeleton. Believe me, I eat a lot! I really do and my friends know that but I just don't gain weight even if I wanted to. I didn't even want to wear shorts, skirts, sleeveless, or just anything that would expose my prominent bones because I was so scared that I'd get teased again. One time during Physical education class, my classmate asked me why I was wearing shorts since I was so thin as though he was implying that I should have no right to reveal my thin legs! I couldn't do anything about the shorts, it was clearly part of our PE uniform. When I finally reached my second year in college, I met someone who made me feel good. He was the only person who never called me thin. Because of him I am now able to freely wear shorts and such. He boosted my self esteem and he told me that he was once thin when he was younger and that he also had a hard time dealing with people who made fun of him. He didn't want me to be bullied anymore. I don't know why I suddenly gained weight after we got together. It was probably because we started going to the gym and after that, we would eat a lot of healthy food. I'm just so happy that no one calls me thin anymore.:D I hope you can find someone to make you feel good inside too and I also hope these people who make fun of us realize that they do hurt our feelings.
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
29 Aug 11
Strange how eating healthy and going to the gym might actually help you to gain weight. lol It was probably from gaining the muscle mass that comes from working out. I've managed to gain some weight doing weight training, and that's the only way I've ever managed to gain weight!
Thanks for your comment, you hit the nail right on the head, and I think the shorts comment might have even been a bit worse than anything I've heard, (who made him the wardrobe by body type police?!?!). You've really helped, and I hope I meet a guy like the one that you did.