I left my four years old daughter at home..ALONE..

@humairaku (2038)
Indonesia
October 27, 2011 8:31pm CST
Hi Mylotters! I think yesterday was really really bad day of mine. My four years old daughter didn't want to go to school cos she preferred watching new cartoon movie aired on TV to going to school. she never did like this before. maybe because the cartoon movie is new so she was so excited to watch it. whereas, I should go teaching at 7.30am. I asked her whether she wants to join me going to my school or not. she said she wanted to watch the movie. so I left her, alone...I have nobody to watch her. I just prayed to God, He would take care of my girl. then I went home at 11. thank God she was just fine. but I really really don't want it happen again..
6 people like this
23 responses
@rose1717 (190)
• United States
29 Oct 11
You should have told your daughter too bad , she is going to work with you. She is only 4 years old and you are the parent. She should never get the say whether she gets to stay home alone or go with you. Where I live, it is aginst the law to leave home any child alone under the age of 12. I pray that you never do this again. Anything could have happened to her. What if the house caught on fire and she got scared so she hid somewhere inside? It happens!
1 person likes this
@SIMPLYD (90721)
• Philippines
28 Oct 11
I think you should not do that again. Should you be in that situation again, perhaps you should just force her to come with you to school. Or maybe if your parents or parents in-law are just nearby, then you can have them come over to look after your child. Many accidents and bad things could happen while she's alone at home.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
29 Oct 11
actually I had asked my aunt who doesn't have a job to watch my daughter. but I was so unlucky so I missed her help and I was too late to know this. I knew this when I tried to call her on her cell phone (I'd already at school), but I failed. then I called to her husband's cell phone and it worked. I told her that my daughter was alone at home. she promised me to watch my daughter. then I send her message via her husband's cell phone and asked how was my daughter. she replied that she was just fine and she was in the bathroom defecation. I know I was so careless and I admit this for many times. maybe it doesn't change anything but it's really a lesson for me. I will remember it for all my life.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
I'm sorry if my story was confusing.. I did leave my daughter at home alone. but, actually, before I went to school, I had sent a message via cell phone to my aunt who lives near with me, to watch my daughter. I didn't check to the status of my message whether my message had been sent to my aunt or not cos after sending it I directly went to school then teaching. I knew that my message didn't delivered o my aunt when I tried to call her at 9.30am (I wanted to ask my aunt what did she do at that time). I failed to call her cos her cell phone was out of work. from this I realized then that my daughter was all alone for about two hours! I then called her to her husband's cell phone and thank God, it worked. she was so panic to realizing that my daughter was all alone during the time. she went to my house immediately to see my daughter and she found that my daughter was at the bathroom. start from this, my daughter was not alone anymore. i hope you can get my story. if not, I'm so sorry. it must because of my bad English..
@SIMPLYD (90721)
• Philippines
31 Oct 11
I get a little confused with your story. So, after all, there the aunt who looked after her, while you are in school, right?
@momof3kids (1894)
• Singapore
28 Oct 11
You are feeling guilty that is why you post this discussion. I think all mothers do this. I have a friend who suddenly came up to me and confessed what she did wrong to her daughter too. I do that too :( Now I hope you know that you shouldnt leave your daughter alone at this age. Pulling her away from the TV and making her scream is better because she will be with you. Now what you should do is to explain to her why she cannot stay home and watch the TV all alone. My home has always been 'visited' by door to door salespersons. When we go out, I frighten all my children (which includes my nieces) telling them if they leave my side, naughty man or woman will get them. I think a bit of reality is never harmful. Real people is scarier than ghosts, I assure you.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
28 Oct 11
actually my daughter is good enough in understanding what I say. I usually try to explain about anything to her. that day was my tough day so I lose my self control and patience. yeah, you're right, maybe I need to be tougher than before in facing her. I have plan to hide TV remote control so I can avoid her from watching TV in the morning. I know that I'm not a good mother, but I do love my daughter..
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
29 Oct 11
you're right..I felt so guilty. I promise to myself that I won't do that again. I do love my daughter and I don't want something bad happened to her. I was so careless that time cos I was little confused then I made bad decision leaving her alone at home. yeah, I promise I won't repeat my bad action..thank God cos saved her at that time..
• Singapore
28 Oct 11
You're not a bad mother.. if you are you wouldnt feel this guilty. I feel I am a bad mother and I am not ready to tell anyone yet of how bad I have been. I think this guilty feeling is good. It will remind you not to repeat things that may be regrets later. Take care.
@ferbjohn69 (1127)
• Philippines
28 Oct 11
That wasn't really a good idea because a four year old girl won't be able to protect herself if something bad happens.But I am very glad noting happened to her.Did you ask her to tell you everything she did while you weren't around?Her story might be interesting.:)
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
29 Oct 11
only you people here tell something funny for my discussion. no, it's not bad, sure. I am little bit entertained cos there's someone her see this from funny side. I know it was not good for her, not even for me as her mother. but, the situation is not as scary as imagined. I live in a very peaceful area with good people around me. I won't leave her if our surrounding is not good. maybe I'm careless but I'm not that ignored to the possibilities may happen to my daughter. I left her only for three hours. ya..ya..I know i was wrong whatever it takes. I know I shouldn't leave her alone at home cos she is only four years old. I tried the best and I failed. I asked her what was she doing during I left her. you know what is her answer? she said that she only watched TV while ruffling our bedroom..
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
she wanted to stay home alone again this morning. she didn't want to go to school. I forced myself not to repeat what I did before. so I persuaded her to go to school. I didn't care to the time limitation anymore. I didn't care whether I would come late to school or not. all in minds was succeeding to persuade her to school or go with me to my school. luckily, I was succeed sending her to school. I said to her that it is forbidden for a child to stay at home alone. I also told her how about being kidnapped by a bad person? mom won't have you anymore. and it worked to send her to school. I think she was afraid of being home alone. I think she also doesn't want to do it again..
• Philippines
29 Oct 11
I am right that she was going to tell you an interesting story.Did you ask her about the tv show she watched?Did she tell you about what she felt when she was alone?
• Philippines
28 Oct 11
You should never leave your child alone in the house. She's still four years old. At that age, the child still doesn't know what to do. Maybe the child wasn't able to eat during lunch and dinner. If you really have to leave her, you should ask someone to take care of the child while you're away. Also, if the child will not want to go to school again and instead will just watch t.v, you should not allow her anymore because she might not want to go back to school anymore. She might just be finding excuses just to avoid school.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
29 Oct 11
she never been lie that before. it's so usual she watches cartoon in the morning but I'm always be able to persuade her to go to school. so I was little shocked knowing her didn't want to go to school. I was not ready to face this. I mean, I got prepared for myself and when I asked her to take a shower, she denied. I was so confused an little angry cos I was not ready with this. I wanted to be with her but I should teach. I tried to think hard and fast to make decision. and my best decision was I sent message to my aunt to watch her. but I was so unlucky cos my aunt's cell phone was out of work and I didn't realized it when sending her message. my big mistake was I didn't call her. I should call her actually to make sure that she was there for my daughter. I regret this till today..
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
yup, I didn't prepared for that possibility so I was so panic then I couldn't think clearly. I'm little bit angry to my daughter so I just left her (after sending may aunt a message of course), but I was so careless why I didn't wait for my aunt coming to my house. yeah, thank God she was safe. I was speechless when I saw her after going to school. she's so precious, I just can't understand myself why I could do that to my precious one..
• Philippines
29 Oct 11
Oh I see. You weren't prepared for the situation. Well, don't feel bad about it. At least your daughter is still safe. It will just serve as your lesson. If ever you leave your child at home alone, you have to make sure that someone will be there to watch her.
@JulyKing (110)
• China
28 Oct 11
Good afternoon,humairaku! From what you said above,I advise you should take this case seciously!She is just a kid who need someone to take care of!As her mother,why don't you persuade your child more patiently? Don't you know?There have been much more cases occured from our realistic life that the children without their parents were involved in danger!Undoubtedly,you are such a good mother that you submitted your daughter's longing,but you just doted upon her in that case,don't count on god to take care of your daughter from now on!Just count on yourself!^_^ Everything goes well!
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
28 Oct 11
I know how my daughter is. when she said no, she won't change yes no matter the condition will be. she had a new cartoon movie that day and she said obviously that she wanted to watch TV. i had told her that I will leave her alone at home cos I will teach to school she did understand to what I say. I know if I forced her to go to school or ask her to go with me to my school, i wouldn't work well. she wouldn't stop crying and screaming and blame me why didn't allow her to watch TV at home alone. I know I was just thinking of myself. if I knew that someone I told to watch her actually didn't receive my message I sent to her, I would force my daughter to join me going to my school. no matter if she would scream or cry all the time during I teach..
@rose1717 (190)
• United States
29 Oct 11
See this is what is wrong with the world today. Kids do not listen to their parents, and their parents are not even parents. If they were their children would do what they say. It doesn't matter if it is a new cartoon or not that she wanted to see. You are her mom and you must do what is right by her! Leaving her home alone at 4 yrs old can get you arrested in the States and CPS take your child away. I do not understand why you keep aying that it was a new cartoon that she really wanted to see? Is that supposed to make you leaving a 4 year old alone ok? I seen all over our news a few years ago about this married couple on vacation left their 4 year old alone sleeping in a hotel room while they ate dinner with friends. The child was kidnapped and they still have no idea what happened to her. You would think that this would make parents want to actually parent their kids and not be like whatever!
@JulyKing (110)
• China
29 Oct 11
Good afternoon,you guys! I very agree with rose's view because I also think humairaku should have left her child alone at home as that was really dangerious from various aspects! As her mother ,you shouldn't have doted upon your own child much more,you play a role of her mother should not only love your daughter from all aspects but also tell her what is right to do and what is wrong to do,you couldn't have overindulged your daughter's unruliness not matter how upset she cried! Have a good day!^_^
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
6 Nov 11
Hi Humairaku, Well, I can see from reading down through some of the discussion that you are well aware that leaving your child as you did was wrong. Where I live, if it got found out that a mom did that then the child would be taken from her.I understand that you were not expecting her to act this way but if it were me, I would have turned off the tv and gave her the choice of coming with me or I would carry her out to the car. My job was always important as it was my only means of supporting my girls and so I understand why you felt pressured. Still, my kids always came first. I was late to work a couple of times due to unexpected situations but my kids KNEW that if I was late or missed work, that was less money for us and for them that might mean a treat or an extra that they won't get.If I lost my job, then we all would be in a world of trouble. They knew at a young age WHY my job was important and how it affected their lives. Well, I'm glad it all worked out and your daughter is fine. You should have a list of available sitters just in case you run into another situation where you can't take her. I'm surprised that your boss allows you to bring her while you teach. What grades do you teach?
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
8 Nov 11
the only person I can ask help for is only my aunt. she is always there for us. she doesn't have a job and she also doesn't have baby to raised, so she will be ready to watch my daughter every time I ask her. actually it's not allowed to bring children during teaching. I don't enjoy it at all. but I have no choice. I have been doing this for about three years. but my daughter started to go to school this year. but sometimes I still bring her to my school cos nobody at home. when she was two or three I always bring her to school. it's only me who brings child while teaching. there is no other teachers do like what I do. i think my boss allows me cos nothing he can do. I think I can do my job well though I should bring my daughter to school. yeah, sometimes she bothers enough with her crying or whining. I say again that I don't enjoy it at all but I really don't have any choice. my situation is so complex. believe me that I have tried many possibilities but bringing her to school is the best way after all. I don't think it's hard as long as my boss allows me. I teach elementary students.
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
28 Nov 11
where did you teach humaira? i do hope you find the way, you can enjoy your work and there are somebody else can take care your daughter when you are still working.. what about your mother or your mother in law??
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
28 Nov 11
wow..your daughter must be proud of you as her mother.. whats subject do you teach
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
28 Nov 11
I teach in an Elementary school, Sir. It's common for me to bring my daughter with me while I'm teaching. I started teaching when she was about one year old. It's a new school and the headmaster allowed me to bring my daughter during teaching cos nobody could take care of her at home. I did it till my daughter went to school in last August. So I don't bring her to my school again and I don't need to find someone to take care of her during I'm teaching. It should become easy for me, but it's hard sending her to school in her first school days, then that accident happened. Yeah, I live with my parents in law actually, but both of them are also teachers, so I can't ask them to take care of my daughter during I'm teaching. This accident taught me many lessons. It taught me how to be a more patient woman and mother. People here give some valuables opinion and I will apply it to us, I and my daughter..:)
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
28 Oct 11
Thanks God nothing happened to her. I never leave my kids at that young age. I always keep an eye with them and never leave them alone. Now that they are young teens I am not even comfortable leaving them alone in the house when I go to work at night. So,I decided to quit my job and tried to look for a part time job.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
actually I'm not that busy so I should leave my daughter without my guidance. but the situation that day was so out of control. I didn't think before that she wouldn't go to school. i had calculated the time for both of us and I was not ready when she finally messed my planning. the best effort for me at that time was trying to find someone to watch my daughter. this was not first time I left my daughter at home, but usually there is someone takes care of her till I go home from work. so I did it like usual. but unluckily, I was failed this time so it seemed that I just left my daughter. no, I wouldn't do that. I do love my daughter and I don't want something bad happened to her..
• Indonesia
28 Oct 11
Oh my God, I am totally speechless! Just promise you would never do that again. I am glad that she's okay. Next time maybe it's better for your to drop a call on your work place to tell them that you're going to be late. Leaving a child alone unattended is risky, especially these days. You'll never know what's going to happen. Better safe than sorry.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
28 Oct 11
I was speechless too when I realized that someone whom I intended to watch her didn't received my message actually..unluckily, I realized this after hours..I said frankly that, that day was so bad for me. I had prepared anything to do my best like the day before. but she screwed up in the last minutes and I was not ready for this. I didn't like to be late. so I tried to find someone who were able to watch my daughter. but I was so careless cos I left my daughter before she came to my house. I knew then that actually she didn't receive my message (I regretted till today why I didn't call her, why I only sent her message.. )
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
Aww, it's okay. The most important thing is your daughter is fine . Lesson learnt though, to always give a call. Everyone makes mistakes, all we can do is to make sure it won't happen again. Send my hugs to your daughter
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
yeah, it's also hard for me. I do love my daughter and don't want something bad happened to her. so I was so so mad to myself why I can be so careless and stupid not to make call to my aunt. sure, I'll be very careful after this. I hope I can be a better mother for her. thanks for the hug, dear friend. she must be very happy to accept your hug..^__^
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
28 Oct 11
Hi humairaku I am glad to read that she is fine and more important that you dont want this to happen again. On the lighter side(if you may permit) - Was the home all okay when you arrived back because the only time when they left my nephew all alone in the house, when they returned, they found almost nothing was at its place. oh my nephew was 7 then.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
1 Nov 11
actually I found it too. I found some of my stuffs were not in their place. My daughter is a very active child so she won't just stayed where she was without anything to do. but it didn't matter at all cos the most important is she was safe and just fine when my aunt got her. I won't do this again. this experience almost killed me inside. I didn't stop blaming myself cos made this happened to my daughter..
@omchesunche (1755)
• Indonesia
29 Oct 11
Well, I observed you really brave to let your daughter stay at home alone. Understand sometimes we face situation when our children refuse to go but sometimes we must able to be more creative to ask them to go with us,let say by promising something or anything that she likes.I prefer to do that rather than left them alone which riskier and make ourself unable to focus as well. However, television or any other technology sometimes make our children addicted to it, that's the reason I limit my children to watch television,only weekend or holiday is allowed to watch.
@Jessi_T (379)
• United States
5 Nov 11
I have a 4 year old and if she told me she wasn't going to school and was staying home to watch cartoons I would think "How funny" and tell her she is most certainly going to school. At 4 she shouldn't be giving any power to decide. I sure would't leave my child home alone at that age. Anything can happen when a small child is left alone. Yes thank God she was alright and please don't leave her again and please understand she shouldn't tell you at four, you should tell her you are the parent not her.
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
7 Nov 11
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
8 Nov 11
I couldn't think clearly at that time. everything run so fast and finally I got the decision. Frankly that I was upset at that time facing her stone head. I had persuaded her to go school with me but she rejected while screaming. yeah, it was my mistake why I gave up persuading her to go to school. I just couldn't imagine that she will scream and fought against me if I forced her. all I can do was only asking a help. but my best plan also went off from my calculation or prediction. this gave me lesson that I should be 'tougher' than before. I should be able to measure the situation though in a very hard time and condition, to make my daughter safe, for her best. and never ever take wrong decision. thanks for all comments I gave from this discussion. I need to be measured as a mom and I got it from this discussion. all of you open my mind of being good mom. I won't stop learning to be good mom.
@friendme (10)
• United States
6 Nov 11
I dont think i could ever leave my baby at home alone. no matter the reason my child want be left home alone.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
8 Nov 11
yeah you're right. I was so careless. actually it's not the first time I left my daughter due to my job. but I never leave her without someone beside her. actually I did like usual, asking for help to someone, but my planning went so wrong so it made my daughter left alone at home. i hope I can fix myself so I can be a better mom for my daughter and also hope God will forgive my mistake of leaving my daughter alone at home..it's hard for me..really hard facing the situation that I had left my girl alone at home though I NEVER mean it..
@youless (112586)
• Guangzhou, China
28 Oct 11
Fortunately your daughter is fine. I hope you will never do this thing again any more. It is too risky. You will never know what happens to such a little child. As they are too little to know what will be dangerous for them. We can not afford any kinds of accidents. So please be careful, patient and responsible to your child. I love China
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
29 Oct 11
yeah, all the bad things were around my head during I teach. I really wanted to run away, forced her to go with me no matter how loud she cried or scream as long as she was with me. I was so sorry to her. I was so careless. I counted to someone but she didn't know that I counted on her to watch my daughter. I won't do this again. this is the hard lesson of me, and I know maybe the situation could be worse than that day so I will be much more careful than before. I do love my daughter..
@louievill (28851)
• Philippines
28 Oct 11
Good nothing happened, not only are there very dangerous things inside the house like what the others said but in out country, we have a law concerning negligence, in case something happened to your child because you left her. you could be criminally charged or go to prison for doing so, , hope you don't do that again.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
I know that it's not good leaving children alone without parents' guidance, and I really didn't want to do it. I do love my daughter and she is everything to me. I was so confused at that time so I can't think clearly. I was little angry to her cos she didn't want to go to school and rejected to go with me to my school. so I just left her after sending my aunt a message. I asked a help to my aunt to watch my daughter. but unluckily, my message sent failed. and that seemed that I left my daughter alone, whereas I didn't mean it at all..
@sjvg1976 (41290)
• Delhi, India
28 Oct 11
Hello Humairaku, Thats not good you should not left your daughter alone she is so small and i also thank God that nothing happened. You know i have twin kids and whenever my wife has to go somewhere she takes both the kids of age 3 years along with her and don't leave kids even with their grand mother too.She says she don't like to leave a kid alone at home. I am surprised how you took the decision to leave her.Plesae take care in future.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
thank for worrying about my daughter, sir..yeah, I was so careless at that time. I was little panic cos I was not ready for that possibility and I took a bad decision then. though I had to do the best by asking someone to watch my daughter, but I missed my effort. that experience really gave me a tough lesson and I will remember it along my life. I just can't forget how was my feeling when I left my daughter alone at home. I was so anxious, couldn't concentrate and got little stomachache..and ya, thank God my little girl was fine. cos I can't imagine if there's something bad happened to her, I must blame myself along my life.. Give my regard to your great wife and the twins..They must be lucky having good mother like their mother..
• India
28 Oct 11
Yeah this was very sad leaving your child alone at home. As she was still 4 years old she can't do anything if something happens at home. If you want to leave your child arrange someone at home or ask your neighbor to have an eye on her.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
28 Oct 11
actually I did it. I sent message to my aunt to watch my daughter. I ever did this before and it worked. my aunt never relies my message but she did what I told her (watching my daughter I mean). and I did it too, I sent her a message and I was so sure that she will come to my house without replying my message. but I was wrong. I didn't know that her cell phone was out of work. I only thank God cos there's no bad thing happened to my beloved daughter. I will be more careful than before.
@LISBELLA (115)
• Brazil
28 Oct 11
Oh my gosh... This is unbelievable !!! I don't want to judge you but this is no acceptable. I my neighborhood we have a lot of nanny work because the parents are working and their children are at home during the whole day ever if they are at home part of time they need somebody to care of them. I think this is not a good reason to left your daughter at home alone, I mean, doesn't exist a good reason to do something like that. I think if your neighbor knew it probably now you will in jail for left her alone. For example here in my neighborhood a nanny she was arrested because she left two kids, three year old, twins in the car when she was doing groceries, one costumer from the supermaket saw the children crying and called to the police at the same time. The police man came and when the nanny came back she was arrested. The police man called to their parents and told them what happened with their children. So you need to be careful and responsible in this situation, if you need to go work and your daughter can not goo to school try to find a nanny or some neighbor that can stay with her for a while so you will go to work feeling safety about this!!
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
actually i had asked somebody to take care of my daughter. but I did mistake by jut sending her message text not by calling her. why was it a mistake? cos my message sent was failed. I knew it after my daughter was all alone at home for about two hours. I didn't mean to leave her alone without somebody take care of her. no, no at all. I tried to find someone as her nanny during I worked. but my effort was not good enough so she left alone then. finally someone whom I asked help came to my house and got my daughter is a good condition, but it had been two hours. I knew I was so careless. I regret it till today, why..why I didn't call that someone so i knew whether she could take care of my daughter or not and not just sent her a message instead..
@wulania (1524)
• Indonesia
28 Oct 11
too ofetn watching tv is not good. it gives bad bad impact, esp kids. kids just imitate what they see on tv.
@humairaku (2038)
• Indonesia
28 Oct 11
yeah I know..but I prefer my daughter watching cartoon to watching drama. their topic is different. cartoon is a group of funny characteristics then do some funny works. I think it's okay. even some cartoon movies are useful to add children's knowledge and imagination. however drama only performs quarrel or romance. I think children will imitate drama more easily than imitating cartoon movies acts.