Being FAT is now illegal in Japan.
By nanajanet
@nanajanet (4436)
United States
November 22, 2011 1:00pm CST
"One by one, belly by belly, the guts came out and got measured... At 36.6" he's overweight, according to the Japanese government. And that just won't do under new national guidelines. And if he doesn't lose weight, his company faces massive fines and increased government health premium... Companies and local governments must now measure the waist lines of all employees and family members over the age of 40. Men over 33.5" and women over 35.5" are considered overweight."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=L1hqHo6lyUU
Good strategy? Effective strategy? Worst idea ever? Incredibly discriminatory? Promoting health? Can we (US/UK/other fat countries) learn something?
Personally, I think they're being generous with 35" being considered the overweight line. If you're going to implement a ridiculously discriminatory legislation in order to get money for the government's nationalized healthcare system under the guise of "promoting health," don't half a## it. My 27" waist would be a size Large there - if I gained 8" I'd have no clothes to buy. /end sarcasm, well, only partially sarcasm...
3 people like this
12 responses
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
23 Nov 11
I bet, because it's like our athletes, here in the USA, that they will be given special privileges, but a good point!
@polaroidsredwine (509)
• United States
23 Nov 11
Sumo wrestlers are like big name celebrities over there. It is a form of wrestling so weight class does matter, and the guys, despite looking rather chubby, are actually pretty fit and just look stout.
1 person likes this
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
22 Nov 11
I think overweight is a huge problem, a huge health problem and financial problem in more and more problems.
Biggest problem is all the fast food and the change of habits if it comes to food.
What one culture/group can digest makes the others fat.
There are many countries who do fight this problem.
Hungary has a new law (called already potatoe chips tax). They raised the prices of: sugar, salt and everything where you find sugar and salt in (which includes also all the fastfood...) + after that raised the tax you have to pay with some extra % as well. Not something to be crazy about if you live in a part of the country where you are still making our own food and save it in salt-water etc.
Which many people still do over there.
1 person likes this
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
23 Nov 11
Yes, fast food, and processed food, and even microwaves, on top of people sitting in front of tv's and computers, has been a huge problem.
You want to eat, in the old days, you had to take the time to cook and leftovers needed to be reheated the old-fashioned way. Now... bing! You have a meal in minutes.
You want to eat a meal, why not McSuper-Size? Just stuff yourself, and your kids, with fries and a meal worth almost a days amount of calories.
Eat all of the processed stuff that messes with your entire chemical make up.
It's all bad... BUT, it's still free choice. Have some sort of incentive to not do it, but do not punish those who, for medical reasons, and if you have been on certain meds, or through some cancer treatments, like me, you may not have any choice but to gain weight.
@polaroidsredwine (509)
• United States
23 Nov 11
I wouldn't just blame food for people being overweight these days. Granted, certain kids' meals from fast food chains are equally sized to what used to be adult meals, so it does play a factor ...
If people want to lose weight, it's a matter of realizing that these days its common to sit inside because there's so much more to do inside the house than there used to be. Kids have all sorts of entertainment indoors. Lots more people have jobs that have them sitting down all day instead of labor jobs that have them moving around and on their feet. As for medical reasons, I think the companies would make exceptions for those since it's kind of unavoidable.
1 person likes this
@youless (112481)
• Guangzhou, China
23 Nov 11
Hard to believe it. Although it seems to be good as it will push people to pay attention to their health. But sometimes I think it is not so fair for everybody to be thin. Some people are just born to be fatter than others. And some people are plus size because of a certain disease. Besides, actually Japanese diet is good and healthy. It is not so necessary to have such kind of rule.
I love China
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
25 Nov 11
Government should not force people to be healthy. They can teach them, and give them incentives, but to punish a company for their people being fst? Many times, medicines can, and do cause weight gain. What if that happens? Is that THEIR fault?
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
22 Nov 11
not being sure of how fat that is, id still say, its discriminatory. that is if it was here where theres no nationalized health care system. but if they have that there, i guess they have a certain right.
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
23 Nov 11
It is discriminatory! I put on 60 lbs, in 6 months, from cancer treatments. Would I be fined or punished?
@m_perez (506)
• United States
22 Nov 11
I think it's a stupid idea. I mean it will promote health. But still this is an act against human rights. This would be considered discrimination. I get that the governments is worried but they should reduce obesity with free programs or other similar things.
1 person likes this
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
23 Nov 11
I agree. Free choice. I had cancer and the treatments caused me to put on a lot of weight, in a short amount of time, so would I be punished, even though it was not due to me being an over eater?
@enelym001 (8322)
• Philippines
23 Nov 11
this is discrimination. okay they're concern about their people's health. But what if you are suffering from obesity and no matter how you tried to lose weight, you just can't?
1 person likes this
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
25 Nov 11
I agree. I understand their concerns but we are free and should be able to choose, good or bad, as long as we are not trying to hurt others.
@enelym001 (8322)
• Philippines
25 Nov 11
Yes they're not hurting someone else. In fact they're the one who's probably hurt.. I'm sure there are people who mocks them for being fat.
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
26 Nov 11
But thin does not insure healthy and a little overweight does not insure bad health. In fact, I have had people in my life, who are thin, die young and many who are big, live long lives. It's discriminatory.
@bhanusb (5709)
• India
23 Nov 11
Hi nanajanet,
my belly is 36",chest 44", height is 5'10", and weight is 73kg. Then you can say I'm fit. I am in fifties. I have not to pay any fine. But in my country none bother about health. Japanese are very health conscious and that should be.
@Masihi (4413)
• Canada
22 Nov 11
Actually I like this. I myself am concerned for us being overweight in Canada/US/UK, and there's a huge strain on people's health and the gov't healthcare system. I do agree that the fast foods and preserved foods are to blamed, and this is precisely one reason why I'm starting to cook and eat the old fashioned way. I certainly think it's a step in the right direction, and I wish Canada would do something like this as well.
1 person likes this
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
23 Nov 11
I can see pushing to be more healthy but, honestly, I cannot see people being "busted" for it. I, myself, put on a lot of weight from cancer treatments, and I had no control over that.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
23 Nov 11
I also believe that japan government is still lenient as to what waistline is still considered not overweight. Weee, i am still way below the overweight waist, if i were in Japan.
This move of Japan is a nice one. at least, the people will now pursue healthy living so as not to get overweight.
I wish they could implement that too here in the Philippines. If it is, a lot of companies will be fined , consequently will not want new hires with waist of 35 and above.
@ramonah (211)
• Romania
23 Nov 11
To be honest it should be a global law, else mother nature will do her own work anyway.
I remember an experiment about this done with antelopes somewhere in Indonesia. 25 members were transported on an island where they had plenty of food and no predators. In a few years the population went to 150 fast and then antelopes started dying at an earlier age and when they analyzed them they couldn't find anything like a disease. The only thing they could find was either undeveloped brain cells (retarded members), overdeveloped and aged brain cells (stressed members), overweight lazy members. When the antelopes didn't have any reason to move, no predator, food at discretion they started to "go crazy". After another few years though the population went down to about 75 and stayed that way further. The scientists were surprised that somehow the species controlled itself.
So as we are now, we don't move, we're not afraid of anything, we don't have any real predators, we have food under our nose, we're gonna be either stressed, retarded or overweight. I think this law is a kind of encouraging of the natural law of surviving. If we encourage acceptance and helping of those weak individuals, well, it might sound harsh but we will only get more and more weak individuals. I don't wanna seem like I'm encouraging discrimination, but it's a proven direction we're going along with. We're just gonna be so many we won't have enough space on earth and more than half of us will die young or have an awful life due to those 3 major issues, among others. Discrimination is bad for a certain individual but if we think globally and to the future it's what nature wants, it's the law of the jungle, the strong survive, the weak strive, the weakest die. If we keep being stubborn and protect the weak, nature will act for us anyway one day and we'll call it an epidemic then. History has proven this. Laws for health and fortifying the population should be applied more and more.
@jtj_hello (627)
• Philippines
23 Nov 11
OMG, this is racist. I cannot believe that in that country where SUMO wrestling is considered as a sport will illegalized being fat. I think their government should rethink this as this is against human rights. Being a UN member nation, the UN council should do something about it.