Duggar family looses baby number twenty

United States
December 8, 2011 10:47pm CST
I don't have cable so I don't watch their show but many people know of this couple who have a reality tv show with 19 kids and they were expecting number 20. Well there's sad news to report that Michelle Duggar has lost baby number 20 http://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/wireStory/reality-show-star-duggar-suffers-miscarriage-15116819#.TuGP11aVpkY It has to be expecially hard so far into the pregnancy to find out your baby has died in utero. However, as many have said they've been blessed with 19 healthy children it's time to stop. Do you think they should continue to add to their family? Or do you feel with a miscarriage and the 19 being born premature as signs that they should count their 19 blessings and leave things as they are?
2 people like this
20 responses
@katsmeow1213 (28716)
• United States
9 Dec 11
They won't stop. I don't watch the show either though I've seen small clips of it while flipping through channels or whatever. I have heard them say that whatever God wants for them, that's what they'll do. Hopefully God makes that woman hit menopause soon.. for crying out loud! Personally, I believe God gave us the tools and materials necessary to create birth control for a reason! If we weren't meant to create birth control, it would not have been possible, just like creating a time machine is not possible.
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
12 Dec 11
Kind of what I have been saying...She says she will have as many children as the Lord wants them have. Well, the Lord gave everyone common sense too... for a reason...and expects us to use it. She is saying that since God gives her the ability to have babies, that she will just have babies. Well, God gives us alot of "abilities" but he expects us to use common sense putting those abilities into action. I mean, he gave us the "ability" to get snot-slinging drunk every day...but expects us to use our common sense and not do it!
• United States
12 Dec 11
Yes, but a lot of people lack common sense.. like those that drive while "snot-slinging drunk", and those who keep having babies when they shouldn't, especially those on welfare or whatever. I believe these people have a purpose too.. as a reminder to the rest of us of what not to do!
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Dec 11
First of all, though I grew up always thinking that I wanted to have a large family, I honestly don't think that I could imagine to have 19 children and I do believe that Michelle and Jim Bob Duggar are very blessed to have the 19 healthy children that they have. With that said, I also see why Michelle made the choice many years ago to not use birth control and to leave the number of children that they are going to have in God's hands. However, I do think that there are things that people can do without using contraceptive to keep the size of a family to a reasonable size.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Dec 11
I agree with you. there are natural ways like abstinance or withdrawal that is not a contraceptive. Frankly with all those kids who'd be in the mood anyway? JMHO
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
9 Dec 11
miscarriages, though never easy, happen for a reason. they should focus on the wonderful children they already have.
1 person likes this
• United States
11 Dec 11
Exactly! And so far along to have one is truly a sign.
@ersmommy1 (12588)
• United States
9 Dec 11
It may have been a blessing in disguise. There are many reasons women in there mid forties don't have kids. I just wish them all the best with the 19 they already have. Here is hoping they don't try and have any more.
1 person likes this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
9 Dec 11
ersmommy1 ..Good point in saying maybe it is for the best...I don't think they try to have children, it's that they don't prevent pregnancy...same thing in a way...
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
9 Dec 11
3SnuggleBunnies I used to watch the Dugges..wow this is sad news...whether anyone feels that 'should' have this many children or not, this is very sad...
1 person likes this
• United States
11 Dec 11
A loss of any child is still a sad event, no matter who you are or aren't.
@Mashnn (4501)
10 Dec 11
You cannot simply give birth throughout the life. This is the high time the family should realize that the time is over and just stop giving birth again. I think she should now settle down and wait for her granchildren from ther older children.
• United States
13 Dec 11
We have 3 and that's how hubby feels we'll be grandparents soon enough. Enjoy the ones you have and can afford.
@ElicBxn (63638)
• United States
9 Dec 11
I can NOT imagine having 19 kids... I have thought these people were crazy since I first heard about them, at about 15 kids. I think she is getting up there to an age where she might need to think about not having more children, heck, if she had had this one, it would've been younger than her grandchild!
1 person likes this
• United States
11 Dec 11
That is very true. I think her body is saying enough.
1 person likes this
@carolscash (9492)
• United States
10 Dec 11
I feel sorry for this family as they truly were looking forward to this baby. Jim Bob is a hard working man who takes care of his family and they have learned to live on what they can pay for and not be in debt, with 19 kids. Maybe we should learn something from them. I think that they will have another child in the future and I hope that Michelle can carry it to full term and it will be a healthy and happy baby. They are a happy, healthy family and the kids truly seem to love one another.
@dodo19 (47336)
• Beaconsfield, Quebec
10 Dec 11
It's really sad that they lost their child. It's not something that you want to have happen. But at the same time, they do have 19 children already. Having so many healthy children really is a blessing. They are lucky that they are all healthy.
@wongchoiyee (7413)
• Malaysia
9 Dec 11
I would not want myself with so many children maximum two is enough. One boy and girl. I heard they have been with so many children and I think its time to stop now.
1 person likes this
• United States
12 Dec 11
We hoped for one of each but ended up with 2girls and my last was a boy and we are done.... plus we've run out of room.
@Fortunata (1135)
• United States
9 Dec 11
That's sad that she lost the baby, but maybe it's for the best. I think this woman needs to give her body a rest and concentrate on other things rather than being a baby making machine. I've never seen the show, but I wonder how her relationship is with the rest of her children. My Mother grew up in a large family, and her mother resented having a lot of children, so I wonder how her mental health is, and if she has any hidden resentment towards the husband or her kids. In other words, when the cameras are turned off, what's really going on? For example, my grandmother had a good relationship with maybe two of her children, the rest, not so good. My Mother bore the brunt of most of my Grandmother's resentment, and she was the last to the youngest in the brood.
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
12 Dec 11
Yeah, that is what they don't tell us...what goes on after the cameras are turned off. There is not enough awake time in the day to have a personal relationship with each child. THat is why she has appointed them "buddys"....she pairs an older child up with a younger one and that older child is the one the younger child has the close relationship with. THe older girls are the ones "raising" the younger kids. That is even shown in the show! I have seen most of them (morbid curiosity!) and I see the kids bonding, but never, never have I seen the parents bonding with any kid. I guess that is cause they are to busy bonding with each other!!!
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
9 Dec 11
I think that I would have had my tubes cut. I had five miscarriages and gave birth to 4 children. I do not believe in abortion but would have had it made sure not to conceive any more children. Her body must be worn out when you think about it. yes, they should count their blessings and it is time for her to call it a day and not have any more children.
• United States
11 Dec 11
((hugs)) Cynthia. That's a very positive way to think of things.
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
9 Dec 11
It was horrible. I lost 3 babies before I had my first live child. I would not have had nine children as I would have tied my tubes off. My faith helped as I believe they went back to God where they are perfect. I get comfort believing that those children and my husband are now together and they pray for us here on earth. I found a quote once in the Bible that said that they would know me when I die. I feel so blessed to be the mother of my children. Then I live my 2 DIL's and one SIL plus I have four grands now. I have been widowed 11 years and it seems lie yesterday. I still miss him.
1 person likes this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
9 Dec 11
cynthiann Wow that must have been an emotional roller coaster for you. You were blessed with 4...
@blue65packer (11826)
• United States
9 Dec 11
I think having the number 20 is not meant to be! I hope now the Duggars realize it is time to stop having kids! I think God is sending them a message that 19 children is enough! No more kids! I have always thought Michelle and Jim Bob Duggar were crazy to have so many kids and alot of it had to do with them being conservative Baptises. They also have 2 grandchildren and will have more in the future! So why try to have more kids? It makes so no sense to me and I think Michelle's body is warn out having so many kids! I hope a doctor convinces her and Jim Bob to stop! What is even more distrubing is they know a couple in Tennessee who have 18 kids and are having 19 this coming spring! I don't remember the couples names but I do remember seeing them on a ABC news program. Mom has been having problems staying pregnant,lately but still wants to have as many children as she can! She has had no break inbetween kids! I thought they are worse then the Duggars! Even the younger kids pray that mom has more kids! Now this couple is crazier then the Duggars! I think this couple should be told to stop! Mom's body is wearing out! With so many pregnancies Her and Michelle will die before they are 60! Listen to your body! It is saying "enough is enough" to these 2 woman and they aren't taking the hint!
• Philippines
9 Dec 11
I have seen the clip of the interview online and I was really amazed that even with the financial crisis that everyone seem to feel at some point, they still say that the is still room in their house for another child (given that some of their older children are already married). We have 2 daughters and my husband and I are still worrying about making ends meet. Maybe they are just good at budgeting and all those money-saving techniques but raising that many children is another matter. It seems hard to spend time with each and everyone of them, help them in their studies and especially growing up issues, without some of them feeling neglected.
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
10 Dec 11
They get tax deduction for each kid, freebies from all kinds of people and places (just went on a trip to Europe with all 25 of them...can you afford to do that? I can't!) and since they don't buy decent clothes, have a school issue to pay for cause they homeschool and live on tater totes and and get I am sure a nice huge "paycheck" from their tv episodes and public speaking things and the like...the current economy hasn't effected them at all! I am sick of hearing about them and if they are so into "God decides how many children we will have" theory of birth control... God's taking this new one home...what part of "that's enough" don't they understand? Good grief...they and the media act like they are the first to ever loose an unborn child.
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
12 Dec 11
They have only mentioned one real estate thing he has and rents a warehouse kind of thing. And land for a cell tower. but where did they get the money to buy those things...while having dozen or more kids? The dependent deduction on the 1040's is a huge "income" in reverse. THey get tons of freebies and discounts. I saw one show where Disneyland in California paid for their whole family of like 20 to come out to the park and hotel for THREE days!!!! Admission for anyone over 3 is $65 for one day! Not to mention food while there and you can't bring your own. And a night at the Disneyland Hotel...not sure but I am very familiar with the area and upper to $100 a night is normal. ANd DIsneyland GAVE it to them for free! Yes, they should count their blessings and stop living off their children
• United States
11 Dec 11
I thought the husband was big into real estate ventures of some sort, so they weren't exactly "poor" in the first place. And yes there are many unborn babies that are lost everyday, sadly they don't make the news, just prayers. This should be a big ol' we need to quit and count the blessings they do have.
1 person likes this
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
9 Dec 11
Counting blessing always works for me.....and I hope they see it as a sign. Maybe 19 makes a nice number to end up with. However it's not my life so I shouldn't say anything....I would hate to have people think they could judge what I do!
@Shar19 (8231)
• United States
9 Dec 11
I could never imagine anyone having that many babies. However, whenever someone loses a child it is a terrible thing. I do feel though that this is God's way of saying that she needs to stop having children and be thankful for the family that she has. Especially with the trouble she had with the last pregnancy.
@cwong77 (2010)
• Malaysia
9 Dec 11
oh.. I salute this couple.. they are really daring in caring for 19 kids.. despite with the help of the older children, it's really taxing in terms of financial and physical. In addition, it will be difficult to give fair treatment too (but heck, where did we have fairness here). It's sad to know the news of the 20th child, but I am sure GOD has plan for them in his own hand.
@nezavisima (7408)
• Bulgaria
9 Dec 11
Oh but it is not at all pleasant. Too bad for people. obviously this is a terrible thing I can not imagine it if I am I can not stand this anxiety and many times to lose her child. honestly in this situation do not know what I done within. nice day!
• Valdosta, Georgia
9 Dec 11
I think maybe she should stop. Her body seems to be telling her enough is enough. She has had plenty of children that she can enjoy and grandchildren. That should be more than enough joy for them. It is still sad that this happened though. Anytime you have a miscarriage it is heartbreaking which I know from experience so this must be really hard on them... =(
• United States
9 Dec 11
Truthfully, I think it's about time she stopped having kids. Pregnancy wreaks havoc on the body and I can't imagine putting my body through that experience even half as many times as she has. The fact that she's starting to get on in her years is also probably a sign she should stop having kids. 19 is more than enough. Heck, 10 was more than enough.