Do you think cash should be abolished?
By Porcospino
@Porcospino (31366)
Denmark
December 11, 2011 10:51am CST
I recently read in the newspaper that some people from my country want to make a new law about cash. They suggest that people should pay a fee each time they use cash instead of a debit card of a credit card. They think that cash is old fashioned and that it ought to be abolished completely.
Personally I think this a very bad idea, because some people don't use debit cards for instanse many people from my grandmother's generation, children and some people with mental disabilities and I think it is unfair that they have to pay more money than other people when buy the same things.
What do you think? Do you think cash ought to abolished completely? Why/why not?
4 people like this
17 responses
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Dec 11
Good point. Those things happen sometimes, and I don't know how they are going to handle that if there is nothing but cards. Sometimes when I visit a restaurant or shop, I am told "Sorry, you can't use cards today, because the machine broke down and we are going to have to ask you to go an ATM and get some cash" Then we go and get some cash and the problem is solved, but what would they do if cash wasn't an option?
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
11 Dec 11
Hello Porcospino. For some people this would be a disaster. Checks for my granddaughter was for a while. She was in her teens and had her first job. She would write a check and check her account through the internet and see a balance and didn't always allow for the check and thought the balance she saw was what she had in the bank. She prefers cash so she knows what money she has.
Not every one has an internet account to keep track of what is in the bank. Now if they had a way of the balance would show up on the cards it might work. And what about transactions between two people such as you and I?
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
11 Dec 11
The transactions between two people is also one of things that I thought about when I heard about this suggestion. It is very convenient to use cash in that situation. We have netbanking we can transfer money to the other person, but it is much easier and faster to use cash for instanse if my friends and I want to split a bill. Many people like your granddaughter prefer to use cash and they would be affected if they made that kind of rule. I think it is unfair that people who prefer cash would have to pay more money than people who pay with debit or credit card.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
11 Dec 11
I also think that there will come a time when cash will no longer exist and when electronic payments will be the only kind of payments, but I hope that it won't happen now. Debit cards were introduced in my country in the early 1980's and before that time everyone used cash and checks because that were the only possibilities that existed. Today a lot of people only use debit cards and that is why I think that it will be the only kind of payment one day, but I don't think that would be right to abolish cash now.
1 person likes this
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
12 Dec 11
That's really a bad idea, my friend. Because your country seems to be back in the old era which people posses no cash but exchange something when they want to buy anything...
Okay! Lets accept the idea of using debit card. What can we put into that debit card to funding it if we don't have cash?
Your government really don't think about the consequences if they manage to pass that law in your country...that's maybe good if all the people in your country are all rich and don't need cash in their possession...
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
20 Dec 11
I also think it is bad idea. The people who made the suggestion think that cash is oldfashioned. They say that cash was a big improvement when it was invented because the alternative was a situation where people had to trade things, but today cash is totally oldfashioned. I don't agree with that. I think that we still need cash and many things would become more complicated if there was no cash.
I think that one of the biggest problems is the people who don't have a card like some people from the older generation or children. My grandmother is one of the people who doesn't have a debit card. The bank persuaded her to get a debit card instead of a bankbook, but she never used it and after a while she went back to a system that she was used to (a bankbook)
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
11 Dec 11
I don't agree with this (if ever my country will also passed a bill of this sortie)
A BIG NO!
Why the need to abolish cash- we are paying taxes for everything that we buy and eat.
Yet, they want us to use debit or credit card -uh uh...
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
11 Dec 11
Fortuneately it is still a suggestion and not something that they have decided, and I hope that the suggession will be rejected and they don't actually do through with this. When I read about the suggestion my first thought was: "Oh no, this is a terrible suggestion" it might happen one day in the future, but I don't think that we are ready for that kind of society yet.
1 person likes this
@davaome (1826)
• Philippines
11 Dec 11
I would never of thought this would be possible, maybe if the world would be in a state where their are no papers at all, then it would be possible,
but with regards to your question, I think that it would be best if we still continue on using the cash rather than the debit, because we would be able to monitor our spending not like when you have a card that after you swipe, you don't know how much you spent, and I guess it would be easier for snatchers to take all your money.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
11 Dec 11
I also think that is would be best if we are still able to use cash, because there are some advantages about cash. Like you say it is easier to keep track of the money that we spend if we use cash. When we use a card it is hard to remember exactly how much money we have spent and we might spend too much. One of my friends had that problem, he used his credit card all the time and today he has lots of debt, because he spent far too much money.
1 person likes this
@peavey (16936)
• United States
20 Dec 11
No, I don't think cash ought to be abolished. There are things that are more convenient to pay with cash, like to a street vendor or at a farmer's market or a gumball machine. Without cash, that would put things like that out of business. We do more with money than just buy things at a store. People who want to do things like this are narrow minded.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
20 Dec 11
A lot of things would be impossible without cash and are there are still some small shops, markets, fairs and other places where you can't use the cards. Every summer we have a lot of fairs around the country and you have to use cash whenever you want to buy something at one of those places. Without cash I don't see how they would survive.
@derek_a (10874)
•
12 Dec 11
It would cause a lot of problems if cash was abolished, but at the same time, it would save a lot of money with the people who make money. But there again, there are lot of people employed in the places where money is made and they would be out of a job. I would find it awkward because I wouldn't want to be using my cards to purchase things all the time. It would cause a lot of problems in stores as it takes longer to pay by card than it does if you have ready cash. Therefor, it there was a vote, I would vote to leave things as they are, so that we will always be able to use cash, especially for smaller purchases. _Derek
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
14 Dec 11
Yes, for small purchases cash is the best option. I have a card, but I don't want to use if I just want to buy a cup of coffee, some chocolate or something like that. We always keep some coins in the car and if I want to buy a small thing while I am driving I just grab some coins and go to the shop. It would find it annoying if I had to use my card all the time. The card is a convenient thing when I want to buy something expensive, because I don't have to carry a lot cash in my wallet, but I hope that we will still be able to use cash for small purchases.
@veejay19 (3589)
• India
12 Dec 11
Its certainly not a good idea to abolish cash and only have credit/debit cards.Most people don`t have them because lots of scams take place and they get lost too and if this happens then you are in trouble.There are millions of people who are poor and who don`t have even a bank account,so what will they do? such people live on a day to day basis,what we call daily wage earners. They can hardly save any money as it is spent as quickly as it is earned.for them cash is the best option and this stands for the majority of people all over the world.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Dec 11
I don't think that we will have a worldwide cashless society, I think that would be a very unrealistic idea, but in my own country I am not sure. The people who suggested a cashless Danish society are very serious about it and they consider cash very oldfashioned. I don't agree, it is true that a lot of people in my country only use cards today, but I still don't think that it would be a good idea to abolish cash.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
13 Dec 11
In my country the majority of people have debit and credit cards, but there are still people who don't own any cards like some people from the older generation or people with mental disabilities, and I think that it wrong that those groups of people have to pay more money for the things they buy just because they don't have credit or debit cards. That is the situation in my country, but seen in a bigger perspective the idea seems even more unrealistic, because you are right that are many people who don't have bank accounts or cards. How would they be able to manage if cash payments weren't an option?
@hvedra (1619)
•
12 Dec 11
This sounds like an idea dreamed up by the banks to con even more money out of us.
Cash shouldn't be abolished and if you look at the people who think that is a good idea you'll soon see why! Like you said, it can marginalise some of the more vulnerable members of society. It also means that small transactions will be charged (both the consumer and the vendor), monitored and be awkward. This kind of thing will kill small businesses.
Also, it is too easy to spend money on a card - or online. If you have the cash in your hand you can't go over a limit and you have to think about each purchase. For a lot of people electronic transfer isn't "real money" so they spend it like that.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Dec 11
I also think that they want money. Some years ago they introduced a fee on credit cards and you had to pay about 10 cents each time you used a credit card, many people were against it, and the rule was abolish after a while. Now they want to create a rule about cash instead and they want us pay a fee each time we use cash. I hope that this suggestion will be rejected.
@kingparker (9673)
• United States
11 Dec 11
Who would come up such dumb idea to abolish cash completely and used those plastic cards for stand - in? When it comes to credit card, you hardly can control your spending habits, and more and more people would be indebted. Using cash is different story. At least you can control what you spend on, once the cash is gone. You automatically know that you should stop.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
11 Dec 11
You are right, it is much easier to control your spending when you use cash. When you use a card you might forget how much you spend. Of course you can write down the amount every time when use the card, but how many people actually do that? When the cash is gone you know that you have spent the money, and that is a much easier way to keep track of the money you spend. I use a combination of cash and my debit card. I pay for expensive things with my debit card, but I prefer to use cash in my everyday life in order to keep track of the money that I spend.
1 person likes this
@CTHanum (8234)
• Malaysia
12 Dec 11
It's impractical for now but in a future who knows?? If we talk about implementing this concept now then it should be NO. Nobody is prepared to start using those cards in full time. We still need to use cash. It is still an important medium in purchasing stuff and business.The one that should pay the fee is the credit card holder. I hope they don't feel jealous to people who can pay in cash while they need to pay the fee and interest for not paying the debt.(^^)
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
20 Dec 11
I also think that it would be impractical if we had to chose cards all the time. Cards are useful in some situations for instanse if we want to buy something expensive. If we use a card we don't have to carry lots of cash around, and we don't lose all the cash if we become a victim of theft, but for smaller purchases I prefer to use cash and I know that many people feel the same way. I think the cashless society might become a reality one day, but I don't think that now is the right time, because they are still many people who don't a card and don't want one.
1 person likes this
@Bluedoll (16773)
• Canada
11 Dec 11
I've wondered when I would see this, I guess it is now. Denmark is advanced in social programs, I wonder if this is considered another one? I don't know about you but I've always thought about money as mine but maybe it is not. Perhaps big sister wants to keep track of us and with plastic cash money coming in .. Australia, Canada I know are a couple of countries ... paper money is changing with technology. It has always had serial #'s though.
The question of which is cheaper to maintain is another question. I suppose with computer systems in place, costs are coming down, and money is more social?
something to think about I guess
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
11 Dec 11
They people came up with the idea say that it is cheaper for society to use credit cards instead of cash, because when you use cash the shops have to count it, spend money on transportation etc and it easier and less expensive when people use credit cards. They hope that they can "force" people to use credit cards if it gets more expensive to use cash. I don't like the idea, because it would makes things more expensive for people who don't use credit cards. There are still many people from the older generation who don't don't know a debit card or credit card and aren't interested in getting one and they would be "punished" for this if we a get a law like they suggest.
1 person likes this
@befrindwithme26 (5805)
• Philippines
12 Dec 11
Yes that is true, i think 90 percent people don't use debit card,and 10 percent use for cash. i think this is another business so they can get more money if cash and pay the fee to it.This is not good sign..
1 person likes this
@befrindwithme26 (5805)
• Philippines
16 Dec 11
Yes hope so will rejected.not good if will publish and there is troubles on that.they should think that some people can't afford it,and also they get money from people.
1 person likes this
@dodo19 (47326)
• Beaconsfield, Quebec
12 Dec 11
I don't think that cash should be abolished. I'm not sure I fully understand the point of abolishing cash. When you're dealing with cash, you have a better sense of how much money you have left, and such. Sure, there are advantages of using debit cards and such, but the same can be said for cash.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
13 Dec 11
I also think that there are advantages about cash as well as advantages about debit cards. I use my debit card when I want to buy something expensive and it is easier than carrying big amounts of cash around in my wallet. It is also safer than carrying a big amount of cash in my bag in case my bag gets stolen. In situations like that I think that debit cards are an advantage, but there are also advantages about cash, and it is much easier to control your spending when you use cash. You know when the money is gone and you don't get into debt.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
12 Dec 11
That is a good idea. Lets throw the cards in the trash and keep the cash I know a lot of people who would find it very hard to live without the cards, but I am not one of them.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
13 Dec 11
When we want to buy something on the internet credit cards are very convenient. I also use my credit card to pay for the things that I buy online. When I visit offline shops I use cash when I buy small things and I use my debit card when I buy big things. I think it is easier to use cash when I buy small things and I would be sad if they decide to abolish cash completely.