Wikipedia
By Bonnie
@yoyo1198 (3641)
United States
July 1, 2012 10:04pm CST
Did you know that you can edit a Wikipedia page?
I use Wikipedia regularly...probably daily. It is my first go-to source for information. Usually the articles, definitions are well written without errors in grammar, spelling, etc. However, I just read a short article after a search and saw several errors in both sentence construction and spelling.
So I clicked on the edit button and fixed the errors. Did you know you can do this? Have you ever submitted a page to Wikipedia? Do you use Wikipedia?
4 people like this
25 responses
@alphenor (686)
• Philippines
2 Jul 12
I knew about Wikipedia being able to be edited by users. I am a "user" of Wikipedia, myself. However, I left my user status as it is since I do not find any good reason to stay and edit information on Wikipedia's pages.
For many, Wikipedia is a reliable source of information. Every information there is considered trusted and fool-proof, which somewhat contradicts the reality. I trust most information in Wikipedia unless it is an information regarding my own country or an article with a "stub".
Besides, there are many more places to gather information over the internet, and myLot is one of them.
@Chikezie (385)
• Malaysia
2 Jul 12
I used Wikipedia today and I have always known that it can be edited. However, I have never tried it. But since it can be edited, I thought it is for specific people. If it open for the public to edit anything, then can one really trust the authenticity of the information provided there?
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
2 Jul 12
My husband and daughter like it, but really just because people "think" they know a topic, doesn't mean they really do or know how to write about it. If you take any college classes the first thing we learn is, "we are forbidden to use wiki"
For example: what I think is the best way to prevent fleas on my pets, is not going to be "the way" and only a professional, whether a veterinarian or holistic practioner, should say absolutely what is best. Now I can say what "I think and believe is best" but as one without even a degree, anyone who listens to me should only do so out of what I have experienced, I am not trained in that area.
Problem is, amateurs get on wiki claiming to know it all when just a minor mis-use of a word can cause problems for some who read the article.
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
2 Jul 12
For historical readings I suggest you find a historical site, or even a college site with historical writings, you can learn a lot on these..
@yoyo1198 (3641)
• United States
2 Jul 12
I understand what you are saying. I don't use the site for minor things when I know I can find the information on lesser sites. Mainly use it for my historical readings. I've not found my researches in that to be inferior. Thanks for your response.
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
2 Jul 12
Heyya yoyo! I hope you have been well!
I learned about this when I started back to school a couple of years ago. It is forbidden to use Wikipedia as a reference for my papers or cited info. It is considered unreliable because of the fact that you or me or anyone else has the power to add or edit it. I think that there is some really good info on there but I also think that for something on there to be trusted that the references at the bottom of the page should be referred to as well. I have actually got info on there and followed the references and cited them in some of my papers.
I think that people generally don't know about this though. I never would have. Great post!
@yoyo1198 (3641)
• United States
2 Jul 12
Hi, Jen...nope, I've not been too well. Broke a wrist last week and am waiting for the swelling to go down so it can be cast this week. It hurts like a s.o.b. So now myLot decides to 4X pay and I'm having to peck-type. Not too advantageous.
Anyway...I've not thought to follow Wikipedia references. Never thought of that. Thanks for the suggestion. And thanks for your reply.
Congratulations on the new baby. I bet you're estatic.
@yoyo1198 (3641)
• United States
2 Jul 12
I don't remember how I fell. Don't remember falling, just getting up. I didn't tell the doctor that. He'd have sent me for head studies when I know I'm ok. No concussion. I think I tripped over the cat. I was in the kitchen getting her something to eat.
@sparky3dfan (599)
•
2 Jul 12
I'm not a huge fan of Wikipedia. For the simple reason that its a 'user submitted' info site. Anyone can submit good and or bad information so unless that info I know is correct I will rarely use it if I wanted to post a link to something. Thankfully alot of nice people do decide to correct people on it though and edit it with good solid correct information.
As for if I've ever submitted a page or that, yes I have. When I was part of a game mod we had a Wikipedia setup. Was fairly easy to run and maintain.
@yoyo1198 (3641)
• United States
2 Jul 12
I have always thought that no one would get on there and submit an article unless they were knowledgeable about their topic. I can't see the sense in writing misinformation about something in which one had no clue and knowing it would be judged and most likely rejected. Thank you for responding, sparky.
@sparky3dfan (599)
•
2 Jul 12
It's not always that their giving wrong information due to not having the proper knowledge I've found. Sometimes you will come across articles and so on written by people that are so into it they only base it on fact by about 10%. And thats the good facts the facts they strongly believe in.
For example I came across an article about the Vietnam war. It was painfully obvious a 'full blooded American' wrote it. Simply because they had 1 fact and the rest was from their own mind and made up information. I was annoyed as I am a history fan and even I knew it was incorrect. That was one of the first wikipedia pages I submitted information to. When I checked it 2 days later I was glad to see it was ALOT more factual and not just a biased opinion. I mean no disrespect before any Americans jump on my booty for the previous comment, just giving an experience which happened.
@joneilromana (226)
• Philippines
2 Jul 12
I love Wikipedia, I usually use it as a source of information particularly in school work.I know that anyone can edit a Wikipedia page but I never attempted to do so.
@joneilromana (226)
• Philippines
2 Jul 12
Oh really? i do not know that, well. I have already submitted those to our professors and gladly, they had already accepted it. :)
@GardenGerty (160696)
• United States
4 Jul 12
I use wikipedia often, and I know you can contribute and edit, but I have never done so. It is usually a more complete source of information than anything else. I like to read there and will often choose that as a first resource when searching.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
2 Jul 12
Wikipedia is not always correct, as a writer many clients and sites I work for will not use wikipedia.
Yes I did know you could edit.
@jerzgirl (9291)
• United States
4 Jul 12
I do use Wikipedia and I have done some editing, especially where it says "citation needed". If I can find a citation, I add it. Once it's reviewed, they allow it to post (assuming it's accurate). That is one good thing - there's always a review of what's posted so there's not too much bad info there.
@dismalgrin (2604)
• United States
7 Jul 12
I don't use wikipedia at all. At my school they have banned us from using it because it is not a reliable source of inormation. Because exactly that reason. You can go on there and put information on there, but I don't know you. I don't know if you are a doctor of nuroscience and if you have a right to tell people how to step by step tell people exactly how to tell people how to do brain surgury all by themselves at home. There is no way of knowing if the information is crediable. So, it's better to check out pages that end in .edu or .gov because their reputation is on the line if the information is incorrect and they are more likely to be more crediable and researched.
@RawBill1 (8531)
• Gold Coast, Australia
4 Jul 12
Yes, I did know that anyone can edit a Wikipedia page. That is what Wiki means, it means that anyone can contribute content to the page or create whole pages themselves.
That is all very good and fine, but because anyone can contribute, that means that you may get some information that is not correct. Most times the info will be correct, but not always as peoples opinions and bias can sway the way that a page may be written.
I visit the site often, but do not use the information as my only source or information. The problem also is that many people are just copying Wikipedia information and pasting it straight into their own sites without even checking to see if the info is correct or not too.
So, it is a good source for reference, but not perfect.
@yoyo1198 (3641)
• United States
4 Jul 12
I think the moderators do a decent job of weeding out the incorrect additions. I hadn't thought about the copying and pasting to other sites though. Surely they give reference credits to their submissions being from Wikipedia? Thanks for your response, RawBill.
@garson (884)
• United States
16 Jul 12
Late last year was my first experience creating a Wikipedia page. It is almost like learning how to do programming. I learned programming long time ago. Lots of tools do not seem to be user friendly for many people. They are not really that complicated and I don't use many, but I just need to be patient with just little bit of things.
I have created about 4 to 5 pages so far. All of them are just for a friend of mine. My experience with all of them have been mixed. If I made some grammatical mistakes (thinking that I would get back to it later), a moderator/volunteer would delete it quickly without consideration. Also, if couple of my pages don't have sufficient sources or are deemed insignificant, I would get notice that they would be remove. My friend and I went through the pages. While I would prefer to take time, little by little editing the pages, the people/moderator/volunteers are so quick to point this and that. Then, someone was helpful to add sources to one of two pages.
Wikipedia is a very useful resource. Most of the time, people would come across this when they do searches on internet about virtually anything. Still, like many comments here have pointed out, not all information are reliable since they can originate from anyone that spread false information. Any sources can also be found to be false. Like you pointed out here, anybody including Wikipedia volunteers/moderators can edit any page. They could be misguided by any false information that they know.
I personally would not want to use it that much. I don't seem to like the tools and there are moderators/volunteers that can potentially judge this or that to any page like what I had experienced.
@yoyo1198 (3641)
• United States
16 Jul 12
Thank you so much for your response. It's nice to hear from someone on the 'inside' of Wikipedia. Like most people, I know a little about a lot of things. I know a lot about a few things. And I know nothing about how to use the basic tools of the actual creation. I would never be so brave as to think that I am knowledgeable enough about any one thing to create a page.
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
2 Jul 12
yes, i did know that and my daughter always tells me that Wikipedia is not the best place to get information due to the fact that anyone can put information on and its not known how reliable the information is. however, in light of her advice, i often use Wikipedia when i am doing research (for my own interests.)
@o0jopak0o (6394)
• Philippines
2 Jul 12
I use Wikipedia as my source of basic information but if you are looking for more in-depth information on one subject, it is better if you read a book than wikipedia. Most information you will get from wikipedia is user-written and most users does not have the right information on one subject or does not have enough information on one subject.
As a science major, most wikipedia topics about science stuff seems lacking or wrong. Which is why I hardly use it.
If you are researching about something, don't use wikipedia but if you are just curious on what is something all about, then use wikipedia.
@danitykane (3183)
• Philippines
2 Jul 12
hi yoyo,
I've read somewhere that there are people who edited some wiki pages. Some of them use it to bully the person featured on the wiki article. I find Wikipedia very helpful in research and I think that wiki organizer monitors most of the pages in their site. I believe that you can report a page that is inaccurate. I still use it and I think it is one of the major source of information online.
@cerebellum (3863)
• United States
2 Jul 12
I don't use Wikipedia at all. I have heard that anyone could put information in or edit it, as you said. I have also heard that because of that a lot of it is wrong.
@smurfysmurf (651)
• Philippines
2 Jul 12
Hi there Yoyo,
I did not know about this until a colleague of mine share about this to me...and I was kind a disappointed. Like you, it is also my first source/reference and I did not know that those sources are made by people who doesn't really have that much evidences and even other sources about a certain stuff.
Now, I don't know how it works and don't want to know since I don't want to edit anything.
So...lesson learned for us. Not to make it our first source.