honesty in a marriage - how far should it go

August 29, 2012 5:02am CST
So I read a book about this guy, his life story, and part of the book talks about the relationship he has with his wife. He is a pretty full on sort of guy and from the outset he told his wife everything - and I mean everything. When reading this I was inspired and thought how good it would be to have that level of openness in my marriage. But when it comes to the crunch, some things seem to cause more conflict and trouble when you tell the whole truth. Is there a limit to how much honesty is good in a marriage or is the short term conflict created by some honesty worth the long term gain in the relationship?
13 responses
@Brachuss (47)
• Philippines
30 Aug 12
The old saying "Honesty is the best policy" is true yes but at the same time not always applicable. This is especially true if being honest will hurt your partner. That is why there is also what we call "White lies" and it is forced by the situation more than anything else. To have a healthy relationship it does not mean always telling the truth unless you got all the bases covered and would not result in hurting your partner.
30 Aug 12
Is hurting your partner always a bad things. what about the saying you have to be cruel to be kind. Sometimes people need to hear the truth even when it hurts. If they are living with an idea that is not true then what they are experiencing is not reality. Surely in a marriage we can tell the truth in love and even if it does cause some initial pain at least the long term benefit is that you are open to the reality of the situation and you can move forward from there.
• Philippines
30 Aug 12
"To be cruel is to be kind." This is like mercy killing and I would not say it is applicable to me. Also, your reality may not be the same with the other person's reality. The idea of a long term benefit out of telling the person something that hurt their feelings is also imaginary as you cannot really tell how the other person would take it. At any rate, we all have our own appreciation of things and its only after you do it will you realize if it is good or not. Goodluck.
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
29 Aug 12
Honesty gain Trust and these two make the best aspect for a strong relationship. It is easier to start and build confidence between you and your partner when there is honesty from the very beginning. There is no use of keeping secrets especially in marriage life- it will only brings trouble between the couple. SO I believe that honesty must always comes first.
@rikell (25)
• Philippines
30 Aug 12
Honesty is the best policy. Patience is a virtue.
30 Aug 12
I think what you hae said is really the key. From the very beginning of a relationship you need to start being honest because it is hard later when you have already told lies and then have to come clean bout them. THe only problem is that in the beginning of a relationship we are trying to impress the person so we often try to hide or slightly alter the truth to make ourselves appear more attractive.
@Fulltank (2882)
• Philippines
30 Aug 12
Aside from "love" it is honesty and trust that comes along with marriage. If either of these is broken, it would be difficult for marriage to last forever. Conflicts are a natural occurrence in a married life. But as long as conflicts doesn't involved any one of the above, then it can be called a healthy conflict. As conflict adds spices in a married life, the conflict should not be in terms of honesty and trust.
30 Aug 12
I think you are right. Conflict is a natural part of any relationship. If we are constantly trying to avoid conflict at any cost then we will never have an honest and real relationship. Also we need people to be honest to us otherwise we never grow and mature.
• India
30 Aug 12
We must be loyal to our hubby/wife and keep our honesty throughout our married life. Trust and understanding is very important in any relationship to keep it for a long time. Be open and share every thing with your life partner to show you are genuine to him. As we know honesty is the best policy and it will give a good image about you. There is nothing wrong in telling each and every thing about us to our life partner, if we try to hide some thing and our life partner comes to know about the thing it will create a great problem in our life, if we share the same information to them, it may create a temporary issue, but our honesty will avoid a great problem in our life and create a good image about us. I am from India, in our country we give a lot of importance to marriage and husband and wife relationship. Most of the people in our country trying their maximum to be loyal to their partner and share every thing with them. This kind of activities help us to live a happy life for a long time and avoid unwanted break ups in the great relationship. A person whoever keep honesty in his/her married life don't have any hidden secrets and share everything with their partner, they will get peace of mind with their activity and lead a happy and peaceful life for a long time without unwanted fears and issues.
30 Aug 12
Coming from india I can imagine that the dynamics in marriage might be quite different also to what I have experienced as I assume there is a lot of arranged marriages in India - so I believe anyway. I can imagine that people could enter into an arranged marriage with all sorts of emotions and feelings about the marriage that perhaps they don't want to be completely honest about in case it causes problems in the marriage - especially early on.
• Canada
29 Aug 12
we always have to be honest in relationship. If you are honest and your partner is cheating you, just exercise patient and be good to him or her, he or she will also surely change and if the person is not changing, God will let you get another one who will also be honest to you.
30 Aug 12
I think it would be tough to just stick around if you found out the person you were married to was actually cheating on you. But I have heard of people who have done just what you are saying - prayed and trusted that the person would change and in some cases they did and things worked out well. In other cases the person did not change and they did end up separating.
• United States
30 Aug 12
I am a strong believer that trust and being faithful is everything in a relationship. Without that and honesty there isn't a relationship. This man in the book is a good example and most men to my opinion should follow him or take into consideration of being a better man. No offense meant towards any guy what so ever. I've just met some serious well I won't use words but you get where I'm going. However, I believe that every man and woman in a relationship should share everything from decision that have been made between one another to where he's going when he leaves the house. And when we ask to know all of this it is not because we think you're lying or cheating. It's to know where you are so we can have good feelings knowing that you're safe where you are. The only time we think negative is when you give us a reason. Guys please don't be shady. Be trusting faithful and honest men.
30 Aug 12
I think one of the main reasons people are not honest is because they are afraid of the response of the other person to their honesty. So often people judge or give such a negative response to someones honesty and openness that it stops them from repeating the same thing next time. It is the responsibility of both partners to be honest and to react in a way which encourages honesty from the other person - i.e. not being over judgemental or reactionary.
@GemmaR (8517)
29 Aug 12
I think that it is very important for us to be honest about the major things that might be happening in our lives. You should never tell a lie to your partner because you don't think they would be happy for you to be doing what you're really doing. However, there is always the chance that telling a small lie might be able to make a situation a lot easier, for example if you know that people have been talking about your partner behind their back then you might not want to tell them about this because it could be upsetting to them. But it's all about learning what they can and can't deal with, and being able to make that decision about what you can do without upsetting them.
29 Aug 12
I know what you are saying about trying to protect the person by not telling them some things that may just upset them and not have any real benefit. But the problem is that when you start making those decisions about what you should and should not tell them because it may hurt their feelings, it gets more and more difficult to share other things that may also hurt their feelings, and potentially be damaging to your own reputation, but in the long term would strengthen the relationship. I guess what I am saying is that if you just have a blanket rule of honesty regardless of what it is then you remove the trouble of having to decide whether or not you are going to tell them something. There will be times when this leads to hurt feelings, but is it possible that the benefits will out way the negatives?
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
2 Sep 12
There should be honesty in every relationship to keep it flow smoothly. But sometimes, too much honesty can crumble a relationship, too. It is better to get honest on things that you think your partner can handle. Not that you do not want to be open on certain things, but if you think it would only cause trouble, then might as well keep it to yourself. But the best thing that you should really do is to do things the right way to avoid having the guilt of not telling your partner about it.
@kaeirole (668)
• Philippines
29 Aug 12
for me, both party must be ready for the openness..total honesty in the relationship is a must..but the persons involved need to be ready to accept the pain that may accompany honesty..but in totality, there shouldn't be any secrets inside marriage..because they are considered already as 1..and honesty is one of the main ingredients of a successful marriage/relationship..
29 Aug 12
I think you are right, and when you are writing it down in this sort of forum it sounds nice and easy and idealistic to implement. Of course we all know that it is harder in practice, especially if we have been married for some time and developed bad communication habits. Once you start on the wrong track it is even harder to change direction!
@Shavkat (139937)
• Philippines
29 Aug 12
If the guy remains faithful to his wife, then well and good. I am not referring as in general, there are some of them still play fire in a marriage life. The wives might had caught in the act, but pretend nothing had seen. They are the martyrs.
30 Aug 12
I am not even talking necessarily about things like cheating on your partner in a marriage. If you are cheating on your marriage partner then you are a long way down the path of not being open and honest with each other. I am talking about little things as well. Things that might not seema big deal but can develop over time I suppose.
@nupur123 (392)
• Hyderabad, India
30 Aug 12
Yes , honesty is very impotant in every relation , but sometimes it can create a big trouble for us . One day i and my hubby went to a mall and there he saw a girl which he found really attractive , i noticed him and asked him what he is up too so he said nothing but u should also go fir some makeover like her so that u can also look preety like her, Then what i got very angry but after words i thought about it so i felt that he was so true and so faithful to me.
• India
29 Aug 12
Hi. Yes you are right. Being honesty is so good for a relationship to be fair and healthy. But that should have some limits to avoid some sort of conflicts. But is the other person is a type, who can take everything in positive way helps in maintaining honesty in maximum levels. To my extent that level depends upon the person we are being with.:)
29 Aug 12
It certainly does depend on both people in the relationship. Some people can't handle certain levels of honesty because they take certain things so personally. So I think you are right when you say that the other person has to be able to see things in a positive sense, or at least work through the emotions effectively so that a positive comes out of it somehow!
@freedang (320)
• China
29 Aug 12
hi,inmyopinoin i think that honesty is the most important thing in a marrage. we should totally open to our partner.but if you tell her a lie,it doeant mean that you are not right as long as you meaning good for her.a white lie is important in a marrage .
30 Aug 12
The only problem I see with what you are saying is deciding what is a white lie and what is a straight out lie. Once you start telling white lies, you have to keep on telling white lies and so the cycle begins. But honesty isn't only about the lies that we tell or don't tell, it is about the things that we don't say at all but we should.