What to do for Christmas

United States
December 1, 2012 9:01am CST
How in the world does one determine the 'fair' visitation schedule for the holidays? My husband's family has a conflict with my family on the celebration expectations. I want this settled before the children are older. I think that my husband and I should spend the Christmas morning with each other and our children. I really don't want to haul the kids over to the grandparents and take them from enjoyment of their gifts from us. If we go to one grandparents home on Christmas Eve, then the expectation is that we go to the other grandparents home on Christmas Day. How in the world do you decide what to do? Please give me some ideas of how this is done with your family!!
11 people like this
24 responses
@leeandrew (1225)
• Philippines
1 Dec 12
Hubby and I are planning to go up in the mountains this Christmas with his family, but it's not a hundred percent sure co's we don't know if we can borrow our company van yet. Also going there with hubbies family means we need to pay more for this trip co's they are depending on us on everything, from food to lodging not to mention the transportation too. I am hoping though that God will give us more financial blessings before Christmas comes so that we will be able to pursue our plans this Christmas holidays.
@leeandrew (1225)
• Philippines
2 Dec 12
Well, with our case, it seems that it's a package deal. They live with us now and they were telling us that they hope to go somewhere for Christmas, and that is what we want to do too. Hubby and I will never enjoy it knowing they are being left behind if we pursue it without them. Such a hassle though, but it's okay because this would gonna be the last time for hubby and I are planning to move and leaving them behind, so it means we can do then whatever there is we want to do as a family (just me, hubby and our daughter).
• United States
1 Dec 12
Wow now that is something to think about. Everyone go to a central location and have the event last Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, and the day following. That way those who want to can all gather and bring as many people as the location can house. I can see renting out a family sized lodge somewhere and inviting all the in-laws and out-laws. That would be a fantastic fun-filled time and all the kids would surely have a blast. I don't wanna suggest it or I'll be the hostess and have to do all the work. Hhhhmmmm. Maybe not such a grand idea.
3 people like this
@atv818 (1980)
• United Arab Emirates
1 Dec 12
Christmas should be a joyous thing that should be shared among family members. I know that it is tedious to be taking the children to their grandparents but isn't it the best time while their memory is still intact and they are still in good health. They won't be with your family long since they are already of age and I'm sure that they are excited to see their grandkids who they consider the fruit of their children. Of course, that is only my opinion. In the end, this is something that has to be decided by you and your husband. Christmas should be a merry event so work something out to make this a win-win situation.
3 people like this
• United States
1 Dec 12
Thankfully the grandparents are close enough that the kids see them very often throughout the entire year. This is not a pilgrimmage that must be undertaken at all. However, just the thought of the mad dash around to the two different houses and the coordination of when to be where in order to maximize the greatest number of contact with out of town siblings is the kicker. Of course, I want to be with my family because that is my norm and my husband desires to be with his. There will be a compromise so we all have equal time, or we'll choose to just stay at home and let others come when they have an opportunity. I have a week off and my husgand has just the two days. Really, the kids and I can go to the folks after Christmas and I think it would still be okay.
2 people like this
• United States
1 Dec 12
Well in my family my wife's side always celebrates Christmas after the 25th because my sister-in-law is always at her daughters hous on Christmas day which is ok because on my side of the family we usually celebrate Christmas before the holidays because of other family get tog-ether's that my brothers have with there in-laws. It all works out in the end but some years it has been difficult to plan. Hope everyone has a safe holiday season this year.
• United States
1 Dec 12
And that's what I wanted to sidestep...all the phone calls and emails and texts back and forth to try to set up a convenient time for all players. I don't want to be the bad guy and say we can't do that and everyone has to shuffle around us. It just seems so complicated now with the addition of the other family memebers. Well, it will be good to see if we can all agree and keep it that way until one of the kids gets married and the negotiations start again. Whew...I need a Christmas egg nog just thinkin about it all!
2 people like this
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
1 Dec 12
Unless your parents are not able to drive over or travel, I would insist they come to your house. When I was growing up we spent Christmas morning at home then rushed over to one grandparents' then the other set. We also did it every Sunday. I loved my grandparents, all of them, but we could make no plans because Sundays were mandatory. I would rather have spent holidays at home and be flexible on visiting schedules. Your family traditions were great for growing up but now you have your own family and everyone should adjust to the traditions you are creating. It's nice to see family for Christmas but your little nuclear family of husband, wife, and children are the most important now. Don't disrupt your cozy holiday for others' convenience.
3 people like this
• United States
1 Dec 12
I can't decide, really. I want to selfishly keep my husband and children to myself for that day and just spend a day enjoying each other and the thoughtful gifts. We can have a late brunch and casual dinner. I would rather we have supper with his folks on Christmas Eve and evening snacks at my folks and the obligatory midnight service at church. That way all the travels are done and I can relax the day of Christmas. But one set of grandparents wants to see the kids open the gifts on Christmas Day. I don't know how we will all compromise, but I'm sure by the 24th we'll have a plan in place. I am so glad that responses will give me a lot of options to chose from!
2 people like this
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
1 Dec 12
So... it's christmas and you fight about how to celebrate it? I am happy I do not have these problems and if I would stay at home and not invite anyone. It's terrible to have fights first about a celebration and as soon as the celebration is there you have to fake the happiness and love. My eldest daughter asked me what my plans are. Told her we (the 3 children still living here: 22, 9 and 7 years old) will have our pyama day. No cooking, no visitors, watching old movies, slow down, de-stress. She said that is exactly what she likes to do as well (we did as she was still here). So no forced christmas dinners (one day with the in laws and next day with me/parents). I told her to spend those days the way she likes. She wanted to bring us some presents/food but told her not to. It's not a habit, we won't need it and since we won't cook, won't have visitors there is no need to help me with that (food etc) either. We will manage. I think you should ask yourself first what you like. How do you like to spend these days? What is possible for you without any stress? This all is not about what is fair but what you need. Visiting people while you are full of stress, too tired or after fighting about it first is useless and also not very honest.
3 people like this
• United States
1 Dec 12
Hey, that sounds like a possibility. Perhaps I can suggest to the in-laws and out-laws to drop off food and gifts before the holidays begin and my husband and kids will video tape the opening and the meal and send them a copy. That was there are no fights with the kids about leaving the new toys behind. I have found that if we take the new toys that sometimes the toys from gramma or granpa are ignored. PJ's, movies, and no cooking...yep utopia! I'll probably spend time on mylot though wishing all my new acquaintances well!
2 people like this
@JDaw2006 (428)
• United States
1 Dec 12
I hear about these problems all the time. Thank god i dont have to worry about that right now my hope to be soon ex husband gets to see our kids when ever i get over there. He dont drive. But i will try and help you out as best as i can. Do you have the kids more offten then he does? If you do i mean the kids will be waking up with you on christmas morning so they should do their christmas with you first no matter what do not change your plans for someone else. If i were you i would do his side of the family on christmas eve just because he will want to get the kids on christmas day at some point. so i would maybe do my christmas with the ex's family on christmas eve, then the kids wake up with me on christmas morning. Then depending on what your familys plans are i see them plans through. I have to go to two different grandparents on christmas day and thats just my family. We go to one for lunch and then the other for supper. If that is the way it is with your family then you could take the kids to see their dad either between the trips and just sit there and wait or you could wait till you are all done with your family and maybe be nice to him and let the kids spend the night with their dad christmas night. Just to make it a little fair. Now if you are not close to your ex or he has done things to make you very mad then if it were me i would so not do that at all. I would have most of my childrens time and only give him an hour if he was lucky lol. Hope it all works out for you and hope that this helps a little. Let us here at mylot now how everything works out for you.
3 people like this
• United States
1 Dec 12
Well, he's not an ex-yet...if this Christmas stuff doesn't get settled he may be! Not really. We want to have our own Christmas with the kids, but also don't want to leave the grandparents out. I would not have a problem at all if they wanted to come by the house for supper and everyone could watch this kids open presents again. It just seems that by having to stretch out the holiday over two or three days that it takes away from the novelty of a single day. If kids get presents all week long because of scheduling conflicts, it just seems that it will be all that they associate the holiday with. I want them to recognize why we celebrate. I want them to have quiet time to reflect on the day and I want a slow peaceful celebration and not a lot of fighting and harried running around. We'll see and I will let everyone know what we negotiate.
2 people like this
• United States
1 Dec 12
What is wrong with going to one grandparents house on Christmas Eve and the other on Christmas day? You can still stay home in the morning with the children and go there in the evening. I don't understand what you're trying to say exactly. This is how my kids do it and it works out fine. Christmas Eve is spent with our family and Christmas Day the kids either go to the hubby's family, or they have that family come over. We don't have any bickering on this at all and have been doing that for years.
• United States
1 Dec 12
Seems like a good plan to me...I guess we'll do the family meeting and determine who we will see when. Perhaps alternating will be good so that we can see all the family members who's schedules differ from ours. Thanks for your input, Kashmeresmycat!
2 people like this
@cerebellum (3863)
• United States
3 Dec 12
Maybe you could spend Christmas Eve with one set of parents or grandparents and Christmas Day with the other. When I was married that is how we did it, of course it is more difficult when there are children. Since your children are still young, let both families come to your house and then the kids can enjoy their gifts more. When you have kids, they should be the center of the holiday, and rushing from home to home is for other people to do.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Dec 12
I think that every time I pack kids in and out of the car, with all the stuff ya gotta take, why am I doing this. I also wonder if I'll be the good granny that goes to the kiddos and not make them drag the babies around. It is so difficult to make sure you go and there is consideration for the nap time and the bed time and the cranky kids when they get out of the routine. Yep, I'm gonna be a granny that goes to the babies!!!!
@allknowing (137589)
• India
2 Dec 12
We have always thrown a party for orphans at different locations. The planning that goes before the party is so fulfilling and so is watching them enjoy what is in store for them.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (137589)
• India
3 Dec 12
There is no tradition here either. It is just that we love doing it. Any one can invite orphans and give them a good time. You too can, if you wish to.
• United States
2 Dec 12
Yes, I know of families that it is the tradition that they serve meals for the homeless or pass out presents for the kids in shelters. That has to be really fulfilling. I think that would be a great way to teach kids to give back to those less fortunate, but I don't think we have anything like that in our town.
@gaiza12 (4884)
• Philippines
2 Dec 12
I don't have kids yet nor any husband, but I'd also like to know where to spend Christmas when I have my own family. If I were in your position, I would spend Christmas eve with my kids and husband. Christmas only happens once a year and I believe I have to spend it with my own family. I could ask my husband to spend the morning with one grandparent, either his parents or mine and then we could celebrate New year on another grandparent. That's a fair think for me because those are 2 holidays where we celebrate here with the family. We could have next year the other way around so the grandparents won't feel bad or anything for not being able to celebrate a holiday with them. I hope it all goes well with your family!
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
Yes and I think maybe we could even throw in the Thanksgiving holiday as a pot sweetener. If we did Thanksgiving with one set of family and Christmas with the other, and alternating years, it could certainly be an option.
@natliegleb (5175)
• India
2 Dec 12
well join with team and discuss wonderfully and also catch up with friends and chat a long and gift them and spend quality time together.and also pacifiying all the time
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
Yes, it is the getting together to visit those we don't see very often that I enjoy the most about the season. It takes time to catch up with a year of happenings, but it sure is a nice time. We don't really put a lot of emphasis on the gifts, although we do have them mostly for the children. The food is one of my favorites because everyone really just pitches in and we go to different relatives and get different dishes.
• India
2 Dec 12
jus celebrate with happiness ...festival is the best way to show our love n happiness to our family members..so pls be happy n forget all ur conflicts from ur husbands side n tak ur kids to both of the grand parents home n celebrate with a big cake n gifts....merry christmasss....... This christmas,am going to celebrate with my husband first time bec am a newly married couple......so gonna cut cake at 12am with my hubby n go church n pray god....so for whom all this is first christmas , pls celebrate liks this n be happy with ur hubbys...:)merry christmas...
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
Congratulations on your new marital status! Happy for you. I like to include church in my holiday plans, especially Christmas because it is associated with Christ's birth. I have read several great options through the responses I have and I think we'll talk those over and see what is best for us. I'm rather leaning to the Christmas Eve with one side and Christmas evening with the other.
• St. Peters, Missouri
2 Dec 12
In my family, it was complicated even more by the fact that my parents were divorced. So it wasn't just my family and his family, it was his family, my mom, and my dad. Something has to give somewhere. It's not your job to make everyone happy. You say it's important to you to be with just immediate family on Christmas morning. Then do it. That's your Christmas tradition. As far as everyone else, who says it all has to be done on Christmas Eve or Christmas? Who says every year has to be done the same way? Don't let it take away your joy of Christmas. Look at everyone's schedule. When will they be having dinner? Who's going to be there? Can they come to your house? If it's a problem with the one on Christmas Eve feeling they are visited at a less important time (or vice versa), can you just rotate holidays or rotate years? Maybe go to hubby's family on Thanksgiving, yours on Christmas, use the day before or after to visit the other. Thhe following year switch. Or if one family makes a big deal out of a holiday and the other doesn't, see them on that holiday and the other grandparent on the opposite holiday. Try not to get too wrapped up in scheduling everything. It might not be worth it.
1 person likes this
• United States
3 Dec 12
Oh my. I can't imagine factoring in divorce and adding even more into the mix. I have pretty much settled on Christmas Day with just our immediate family. I'm guessing that we will settle in a routine of one set of grandparents on one Chrismas Eve one year and alternating the next year if their traditions can't be changed or rescheduled. I really don't want anyone to change their traditions because of us either. I think we can come up with a way to work it all in without wearing ourselves out.
@betty1989 (751)
• China
1 Dec 12
it is really hard to decide where to go. Just have a good schedule and try your best to be perfect. maybe you can visit your home at noon and then go to your hunsband's to have Christmas eve.
2 people like this
• United States
1 Dec 12
I know! It is so hard to decide. I really want to see my siblings and their families at my folks, but I don't want to be selfish and keep my husband from his family. I wish we had three days. One for the immediate family, one for his family, and one for my family. Unfortunately, by the time you factor the siblings and the spouses needs to see their sides of the family, I'm gonna miss someone over the holiday or my husband will. We'll work it out and may have to just alternate plans each year to accommodate everyone!
2 people like this
@shaggin (72184)
• United States
2 Dec 12
Thankfully when my husband was alive his family always did a christmas party on christmas eve and my parents had always done ours on christmas. It worked perfectly so we never had to split the day with the families. It just happened to be perfect. I know a lot of people who have to go to both parents house on the same day. I wouldnt want to have to do that but when your with someone you do what you have to.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
I'm sorry for you loss of your husband! I hope that you still have more than enough loved ones to share the holiday with. I like the idea of Christmas Eve and Christmas evening. One side likes to do the midnight church service so I suppose that will be the one we do Christmas Eve with. I really can't give up my own Christmas Day with us. Hopefully, we can work out a Christmas dinner with the other side. Great options.
• China
2 Dec 12
here in China, more and more young people would like to spend time and money on Christmas, although this is not the tranditional holiday in China.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
Thank you for responding. Do you have a similar holiday that your families get together and exchange gifts? I realize that this is a Christian based holiday and that not everyone celebrates. However, I know that you must have New Year's holidays or something that is similar? I would love to hear of these if you can share with us?
@bjc66bjc (6730)
• United States
2 Dec 12
I am so so happy I do not have those holiday issues...and it just seems like a loving family would not be bickering over when/who is going to see who...If you need a family meeting to decided that, then I can not help you with what our holiday are like.. Are you children new born twins?...what have you been doing for the past holidays...that should give you an idea.. Who are you pleasing yourselves or the grandparents...who??....Christmas I think should be a holiday of harmony...what on earth is going on... I tell you its times like this (your situtation) when I believe we are out own worst enemies...
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
No, not newborn twins here! I don't think I would be able to do more than one baby at a time. My heart goes out to those mothers who can! We have spent the past holidays running around doing different things each time and I want to have a set holiday tradition that the kids can look back on with fond memories.
@ARIES1973 (11426)
• Legaspi, Philippines
2 Dec 12
Hi friend! You can set a schedule beforehand. I'm sure they would understand your situation.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
Yes, we will do a schedule this year that will become our traditions. I hope that the next time the schedule is changed is after the kdis are married and have to choose their own traditions for the holidays!
• China
2 Dec 12
Well firstly I agree that Christmas should spend with your family,so why not you all just join together I mean you can invite all of them to your house then you can celebrate Christmas together.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
Yes, I could invite them all to the house. I just don't want to do that much work. I don't want to be so wrapped up in cleaning, cooking, then cleaning more. I want a relaxing holiday that's one of the reasons for not wanting to make all the added trips. But I will have to for the kids. Just need to get a workable schedule.
@kokomo (1867)
• Philippines
2 Dec 12
It is not a problem with us because my mother's side is very far so it is not practical for the whole family to spend Christmas in there. I think better you talk with each other's side. Better to arrange the attendance in Christmas Eve. Why not, spend your Family's Christmas Eve with your husband's side this year and by next year it is then time with your side.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
I like the idea of alternating holiday schedules. I hope that they will agree.