Can our scriptures hold all answers?

@vandana7 (100604)
India
April 7, 2023 10:43pm CST
There is a wave in India hailing our ancient texts. They are great...really. Aren't pyramids great? Can we figure out how they were built and can be rebuild them in our times? Similarly lot of Indian scriptures have extraordinary science in them. That said....knowledge cannot be confined to books. Nobody can write everything down there. There is also churning of knowledge. What seems good today maybe found to have serious flaws tomorrow while what seems outdated can become extremely important with new discoveries available. No knowledge whether ancient or that of the day needs to be discarded ...maybe it can be used tomorrow...that should have been the attitude. We Indians accepted that our books had everything in them. So stopped our research. Result? Those who had progressed came and won over us. We cannot hate them for that when we were at fault...our laziness and complacence .. had taken over. Now we jump with joy when any western body appreciates something in our ancient texts....haven't we accepted our inferiority when we seek their approval to our discoveries. Some discoveries are theirs, some ours....combined fetches royalties to somebody. The thing is we stopped after having been provided really good foundation. Pretty much like a father who gives all riches to the next generation and the next generation doesn't know how to struggle so squanders it away. Are we learning yet? We need to let go of clinging to the past glory ...that will keep changing in every era. We need to focus on research and development such that we leave good things for future generations...we owe the future that. Time to stop bragging about scriptures and claiming they are deciphering our scriptures...if research is open source...why feel cheated? Can't they discover such things? Don't they do research? So more schools ...yes, more schools.
9 people like this
8 responses
@ptrikha_2 (47077)
• India
8 Apr 23
I concur with your thoughts. I had a little discussion with a friend about changing city names a few years back. His argument was that many cities were renamed by invaders so we need to restore their original names. My thought is : Yes many bad or we can say tragic things happened in the past : Invasions, Killings, Rapes, forcible religious conversions etc which one cannot forget. Yet now we have certain city names which are a kind of brand. We have to live in the present, have good economic growth, raise our Human Development index and focus on better standards of living for everyone. Changing city names would put paid many things. Plus the administrative and other costs. Bombay to Mumbai was ok. Madras to Chennai - I still am not clear about the reason. Gurgaon to Gurugram and Bangalore to Bengaluru - I have big problem with that, since those were internationally known names and kind of brands. We scored a kind of self goals with that. People still prefer calling Bangalore. Coming back to the scriptures, many scriptures still talk of "Putra Prapti" (getting a son..). Now that was fine during the times of Ramayana and Mahabharata when people would routinely have 10 or more kids and there was nothing like Female infanticide. Going by those scriptures in the present times is not good and could encourage discrimination against women or female infanticide. Some talk about blindly following what parents say. Yet at times, parents are not that good or that wise. Can we follow blindly then? Can we follow those religious rituals everyday which take 1 hour to complete when at times we don't even have 15 minutes to spare on our work days? Can we explain that to our employees? Yes, some knowledge in ancient scriptures about respect for elders, our brothers, sisters and family, diet to be followed, sleeping and waking routines can be adopted. But blind adherence .... A strict no. So everything should be based on rationality.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
8 Apr 23
I agree...discrimination against girl child is terrible....in our culture. We should definitely say it is not alright even if it is part of our culture. We are in rush to condemn Islam for whatever we hear or read about it. But we don't want to accept things not ok in our culture. In ancient times, men were given special privileges. They had to earn do job ..risk their lives for their families......that could only be achieved with some incentives. Fast forward situation has changed. We need to discard ancient thinking correspondingly too. One of my colleagues lit the pyre of her father even though he had a son by first wife. She had looked after him so she fought and argued for the rights, and nobody could deny her that. Time........we acknowledge our girls.
4 people like this
@ptrikha_2 (47077)
• India
8 Apr 23
@vandana7 Celebrity Mandira Bedi (remember 1990s Soap Opera Shanti ...) lit the pyre of her husband, breaking many taboos. Now a Woman leads a big Missile Squadron of the Indian Air Force. But we still have many women being ill treated. And well, such things never justify false dowry cases and harassment of husbands and their families. So we need balance, rationality and justice. Take good from wherever it comes and discard bad of any kind.
3 people like this
• India
9 Apr 23
Why was Bombay to Mumbai okay? That was a brand too. And renaming didn't hurt it.
2 people like this
@TheHorse (220275)
• Walnut Creek, California
9 Apr 23
Do you really think you stopped your research?
2 people like this
• India
9 Apr 23
Some research goes on. Not the types I would like... but I don't fund anything so have no rights to moan about it.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
9 Apr 23
@hora_fugit Very little. I have a tenant who has developed a herbal product that is effective as antibiotic for chicken. The product has been tested in Hyderabad's CCMB and is being tested by FDA... the man cannot stop feeling proud about his achievement. He says I am the world's first to show that we don't need those chemical antibiotics for chicken..plants are good and cheap. But.......should FDA approve the product, he would have to collaborate with a foreign company for manufacturing and would get royalty rights...equivalent to 30 percent of the profits...he says I am not rich enough...so their investment ..I will produce ...and profits...will be shared 70 : 30. Not happy with the ratio...but that is how it is. He said he was developing another product a few years ago, but his accountant shared the information with the competitor, so ..somebody raced ahead of him. We do have brains. We also have orientation...which has been possible because of access to internet etc. Else foreigners would be doing research on the same product or for same purpose as we Indians...at multiple locations...lottery...whoever succeeds first gets royalty rights..LOL Marconi and Jagdish Chandra Bose ...had it like that. IP ...Tesla lost quite a few of his research like that. It is all in the game.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
9 Apr 23
I think so. We Indians have essentially become folks who are the middlemen. We buy from one, sell to another for profit with very little value addition. It is not as if we are not intelligent. But activities get oriented based on whatever infrastructure and facilities are available.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (140129)
• Philippines
8 Apr 23
I agree with you. There are some manuscripts that need to be proven like Charles Darwin's Evolution Theory. Another one, the Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs should be revised.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
8 Apr 23
What is relevant should be retained, what is not should be sorta ..put a stub there, use this provision only when it is relevant kind. As to Maslow...I have realized that there is slight overlapping so there is no clear cut boundary there, but food clothing shelter medicines remain the priority ...speaking from my life.
1 person likes this
@jstory07 (139996)
• Roseburg, Oregon
8 Apr 23
Research and more research and every time you get a different answer because no one knows for sure. No one has the answers.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
8 Apr 23
Knowledge is dynamic. It keeps changing with slightest variation. :)
1 person likes this
@JudyEv (342176)
• Rockingham, Australia
8 Apr 23
No-one - government or individual - seems to learn much from the past, more's the pity.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
8 Apr 23
So true. Our leader has actually started reducing schools. That would make education so expensive.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
8 Apr 23
@JudyEv If people are educated, they become more aware of the political leader's shortcomings...my annoyance is because of that. Reducing schools to favor ancient texts is nonsense. People need food in their bellies. Not hatred that others are eating away their food. That is so Hitlerish.
2 people like this
@JudyEv (342176)
• Rockingham, Australia
8 Apr 23
@vandana7 Reducing schools seems a very backward step. Does he want everyone to be ignorant.
2 people like this
@Daljinder (23236)
• Bangalore, India
7 Jun 23
This post reminded me of this: Tough times create strong men, and strong men create easy times. Easy times create weak men, and weak men create tough times.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
7 Jun 23
I wonder in which times we are...more likely the last sequence.
1 person likes this
@Daljinder (23236)
• Bangalore, India
14 Jun 23
@vandana7 Yep! Became complacent and stopped growing
1 person likes this
@innertalks (22093)
• Australia
8 Apr 23
Research and development are only as good as they go in the right direction, being done for the right reasons. If their direction is being directed by profiteering corruption, we might find more answers about navel-gazing, but the world will still end by global warming, and mass extinctions will still continue to occur too. Research has to look at areas that are beneficial to all, not just to those profiteering companies, profiting from them, by foul means at times, which leads to many a disaster in our times too. Perhaps, the Scriptures try to guide us into researching, and living our life, for the right reasons, in the right directions too.
@vandana7 (100604)
• India
8 Apr 23
No research is bad per se. Whatever be the goal. It leads to many discoveries on the way. I may find a way to improve speed of a bullet. But it may also be used to improve the speed of a vehicle. How then is the basic aspect bad...it is the user who needs to decide for what am I using it. As to global warming...when I said research for future ...I was hoping discoveries would lead to finding ways to break down carbon dioxide into oxygen and carbon, which would mean availability of oxygen.Similar breaking down of pollutants might help. Very few researchers may want to come up with a method of mass extinction. They are only in it for unraveling the mysteries of nature and harnessing it for the benefit of mankind. But then...yes, mismanagement of available information for harmful purposes is possible. I saw one movie Live Wire I think....Pierce Brosnan. He uses regular things at home to make bombs. So ... yes, it is the user who decides the usage, not the researcher. Researcher just seeks what will happen if I try to do this...will it result in this...his or her objective is not to kill. But just record the outcome. Outcomes that may actually prevent harm if they are recorded upfront.
1 person likes this
@innertalks (22093)
• Australia
8 Apr 23
@vandana7 Research is a big word, and can include many variations. If a doctor does research on his wife, cutting her up (killing her) in the process, most people would call that bad research. Research using animals as victims some see to be in a similar vein to that too. An ethical researcher's research could be said to be more beneficial to all.
1 person likes this
@LindaOHio (181821)
• United States
22 Apr 23
Knowledge is a powerful tool. We should never stop learning. Hope you have a great weekend.