The Question.

@Kandae11 (55010)
April 24, 2023 9:40am CST
In the height of rising crime and dysfunctional families l hear this question being asked : What if women had followed the old time beliefs that men should go out and work while women stay at home to look after house and children? Would that have made family life more stable and children more disciplined resulting in less crime and violence in society? What do you think? Would it have made a difference? Did you grow up in a home where your dad worked and mom stayed at home? Pixabay image
23 people like this
22 responses
@snowy22315 (180689)
• United States
24 Apr 23
I am a firm believer that the break down of the traditional family is mostly to blame for the crimes and dysfunction we see happening. Your question is too narrow though. I would say people feeling that it is OK to have babies out of wedlock and provide no spiritual underpinning for them is a big problem.
11 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
I agree but that would make a whole other post. Like children having children? What on earth could they teach them?
5 people like this
@JudyEv (339930)
• Rockingham, Australia
24 Apr 23
I would agree with that too, Snowy. There is no shame whatsoever and I'm not saying there should be a lot of shame involved but there seems no morals either.
6 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Apr 23
Part of the issue is lawyers too...not everything needs to be fought so bitterly for.
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (471500)
• Switzerland
24 Apr 23
I grew up in a traditional family. My father worked, mom stayed at home and took care of my brother, me and the parents of my Dad, who lived with us. I am convinced that children grow better with a Mom staying at home to take care of them.
5 people like this
@LadyDuck (471500)
• Switzerland
24 Apr 23
@Kandae11 - Exactly, the children grow up with "strangers" most of the time. They lack the education that comes from their parents, who are the best positioned to teach them the basic from very young age.
2 people like this
@TheHorse (218828)
• Walnut Creek, California
25 Apr 23
I am convinced that children are best off when they see their parents happy with their roles, whatever they are.
2 people like this
@LadyDuck (471500)
• Switzerland
25 Apr 23
@TheHorse - I fully agree with you. I am glad that my niece decided to stop working and to take care of her two kids now. My neighbor did the same, she stopped working when she had her first baby.
3 people like this
@FourWalls (68000)
• United States
24 Apr 23
I think the destruction of the family is in large part to blame for society’s problems. It’s not completely true that women never worked outside the home. I’m sure you’ve heard about school teachers having as a requirement for employment to be single but married women worked, too…especially during World War II. Yes, both of my parents worked. But I was raised by them, not by television or a video game, which seems to be the case anymore.
5 people like this
@FourWalls (68000)
• United States
24 Apr 23
@Kandae11 — I read headlines on the AP website the other day that mentioned the problem that social media is playing with the mental health issues that kids, particularly teen girls, are facing these days. That’s another problem: my “social media” was actually playing with people at the playground or in my back yard!!
3 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
@FourWalls. No doubt social media is a big, big part of the problem.
3 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
Yes there are some families who balance it quite well - both parents working. With proper planning , they still manage to spend time with their children and be the kind of role model kids need.
2 people like this
@Tampa_girl7 (50250)
• United States
24 Apr 23
I did grow up with my mom being home. She only worked outside the home when my dad was in Vietnam.
5 people like this
@Tampa_girl7 (50250)
• United States
25 Apr 23
@Kandae11 I am the oldest of 4.
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
@Tampa_girl7 l am the third of four.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
How many siblings did you have?
3 people like this
@DaddyEvil (137257)
• United States
25 Apr 23
My parents followed the "traditional" roles until I was around eight years old when my dad couldn't work anymore so mom found a job. There were still crimes back then and rude kids everywhere. Each older generation thinks the kids that followed them were horrible people and hoodlums. I think there are just MORE people on the planet and media plays up each thing that happens. We're only finding out about the bad things faster, in my opinion.
4 people like this
@DaddyEvil (137257)
• United States
25 Apr 23
@Kandae11 That's true enough. I wonder how much stuff is reported and how much isn't?
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
That could be true, but lets face it. Do you recall teachers being attacked in school when you were of school age? Schools here have a Dean of discipline assigned to each school. I have heard many times of those officers being attacked by a student. Recently a male student fought with a female teacher and broke her glasses. Nothing like that when l was going to school. Of course no kid was perfect back in the day, but these times are extreme.
3 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
@DaddyEvil. Well l was there and it didn't happen in my school. Even now the level of criminality varies from place to place.
2 people like this
@JudyEv (339930)
• Rockingham, Australia
24 Apr 23
We lived on a farm so the roles were fairly traditional although Mum did a lot of outside work as well. That was probably traditional for farmers' wives in those times.
4 people like this
@JudyEv (339930)
• Rockingham, Australia
24 Apr 23
@Kandae11 When I was at school and before that, female workers mostly had to give up their jobs if they married.
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
@JudyEv. Yes, women have come a long way , but there are sacrifices one must make in the name of progress.
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
My grandfather was a farmer. My father was the headmaster at a small island school and my mother also went into the teaching profession - after her last child reached 8 years.
2 people like this
@m_audrey6788 (58472)
• Germany
24 Apr 23
I`m not so sure about that. It really depends on the person because I grew up with both my parents are working and they only can remind us on things that what they think is right and wrong. although, I learned on my own while I started to handle my own life
2 people like this
• Germany
25 Apr 23
@Kandae11 Yes I think so too
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
Most children turn out quite well with both parents working.
2 people like this
@allknowing (136383)
• India
25 Apr 23
It looks to be so without a doubt
2 people like this
@allknowing (136383)
• India
25 Apr 23
@Kandae11 That homely atmosphere that we enjoyed when we were kids is not seen these days
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
@allknowing. Everyone is busy doing their own thing.
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
It gets worse every day.
2 people like this
@RebeccasFarm (89882)
• Arvada, Colorado
24 Apr 23
Yes I think so.
2 people like this
• Arvada, Colorado
24 Apr 23
@Kandae11 Yes I agree
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
Indeed it would have, even though it would have halted the progress of women.
1 person likes this
@Fleura (30390)
• United Kingdom
24 Apr 23
To answer your last question first - no I didn't. But secondly, it isn't really an 'old-time belief', it seems to be an idea of what family life should be for middle-class families around the 1950s. At every other period of history parents have worked when they needed to.
3 people like this
@Fleura (30390)
• United Kingdom
24 Apr 23
@Kandae11 Which is your country?
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
@Fleura. Guyana , South America. It has six races - Indians (the majority) Africans, Portuguese, Chinese, Amerindians and mixed races.
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
In some cultures it is definitely the mom stay at home tradition. I know of families in my country who did not even want their daughters educated.
3 people like this
@TheHorse (218828)
• Walnut Creek, California
25 Apr 23
I have wondered that too. But I also wonder what would happen if more men were actively involved in raising children.
3 people like this
@TheHorse (218828)
• Walnut Creek, California
25 Apr 23
@Kandae11 Men have to want to have an influence of their kids. And society has to accept that fathers can have a positive influence on their kids.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
@TheHorse. They certainly can . A very positive influence.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
Good point. There are some dads who are hardly ever there. Maybe the institution of paternity leave will make a change...
2 people like this
@just4him (317041)
• Green Bay, Wisconsin
24 Apr 23
Yes, I believe it would have been better for the children. Yes, it's the way it was in my home.
3 people like this
@just4him (317041)
• Green Bay, Wisconsin
24 Apr 23
@Kandae11 Yes, it is.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
It is harder for children to conform without a parent's guidance.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
It is harder for children to conform without a parent's guidance.
1 person likes this
@Laurakemunto (12862)
• Kenya
24 Apr 23
I grew up in a family where my parents were working and we would stay home with our house help. Times have really changed and everything seems to be falling out of place
3 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
Some families really need the income of both parents to survive.
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
@Laurakemunto It is like technology , it brings good things , necessary things but there is the bad as well. Women get the opportunity to be independent and make their mark in society , but.....
• Kenya
24 Apr 23
@Kandae11 especially with the economy of nowadays, women have careers too not like in the past and the sensitization everywhere regarding equality
1 person likes this
@Beestring (14554)
• Hong Kong
24 Apr 23
My dad worked. My mom stayed home taking care of us. In HK most couples work and their kids are taken care of by grandparents or house maid. I think it makes a difference if the mother can stay home looking after the kids. But the cost of living in HK is really high nowadays.
3 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
That is so very true - most families need the extra income. Some men prefer to fall in love with someone who has a job - modern times for you.
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (92711)
• United States
24 Apr 23
Initially, when my older sister was born my mom quit her job, and only my dad worked. When I was old enough to start kindergarten, my mom went back to work, and she really had to after that because of finances. Would traditional familial roles benefit society today? In a mother/father household I believe it would. But so many households today do not consist of a mother and a father.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
24 Apr 23
Very good point many children are brought up by single parents. Then you have those parents who fight all the time in front of their children.
1 person likes this
@Jenaisle (14078)
• Philippines
26 Apr 23
My mom worked like my dad, but at home, everyone does his/her assigned chore. Having the mother stay home and focus on the kids' problems could help a lot in stabilizing homes because there is always someone home to lend a helping hand or a listening ear. Many kids need this to feel loved and secure and be good citizens of their countries. However, we grew up well, anyway. Thanks to a healthy environment even outside of the home, and loving people all around us. So, I say that family, the people around us, and the surrounding society would all contribute towards the stabilization of families. Of course, the primary focus is the family first. How well a family has been nurtured.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
26 Apr 23
Well said. I agree totally with your observations. A loving caring environment both inside and out the home can make a huge difference.
1 person likes this
@1creekgirl (41427)
• United States
25 Apr 23
I did grow up with a dad who was in the Coast Guard and my mother stayed home to raise three of us. I do believe it's vitally important for kids to be raised by two parents when possible. But I know that can't always happen and there are many well adjusted bright kids who were raised in a single parent home.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
26 Apr 23
I agree with you wholeheartedly.
1 person likes this
@cacay1 (83480)
• Cagayan De Oro, Philippines
26 Apr 23
I think there are many factors to consider why children of today are far better than the children of yesterday and one is exploitations from peer and influences from technology they made ugly. They want to explore.I also grew up my dad working as a military official and mom at home caring us her children. We're under military command hehe.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
26 Apr 23
Ha, You grew up in a very disciplined home for sure.
@Dena91 (16636)
• United States
25 Apr 23
I don't have any kids but if I did, I would stay home with them. I believe it is the proper way to raise a family, the man is the provider and the mother is the home/child caretaker. I read what @snowy22315 wrote and completely agree with her thoughts My father worked, my mother stayed home until my brother and I went to school.
2 people like this
@Kandae11 (55010)
26 Apr 23
That is a very ideal situation.
1 person likes this
@aninditasen (16389)
• Raurkela, India
25 Apr 23
I grew up in a home where my father worked and my mother stayed at home to look after us but my brother did become a wayward irresponsible person. On the other hand my husband and me went out to work and my sons still grew up responsible men.
1 person likes this
@Kandae11 (55010)
25 Apr 23
Yes indeed , some situations may be the same, but the results may vary.