Clemency for Murder?

Tweet

At what point does killing someone become justified? Certainly, I support self-defense cases and am a proponent of stand your ground and castle law. People not only have the right to defend themselves, but also to protect themselves. This puts me on the fence a bit regarding New Jersey Gov. Murphy's decision to pardon three women convicted of murdering their abusive boyfriends. I don't know all the details regarding the decision, but I would assume the abuse was clear in their cases. In that sense, is it murder? Or simply self defense? And while abuse is never okay, what level would constitute justification to kill someone? I mean, if I feel my life is in grave danger, I am allowed to remove that danger, including by killing someone. But who really determines the level of the danger in the case of an abusive relationship? A few whacks in the face? It's wrong. But is that enough to warrant killing someone? Or is it abusive enough to justify killing someone that lands you in the hospital with serious injuries? Where does the line get drawn may be another question? Can a woman kill her rapist? Yes. On the spot. But can she go back and kill the rapist a week later? No, that would be murder because the threat to your life no longer was present. I am not going to have too strong an opinion regarding Murphy's decision to pardon these women considering my stance on abuse. But I do think it leaves more questions than answers, and I am not sure it is necessarily a good idea nor a good precedent to establish. Or then again, maybe it is. What say you?