Homer Simpson or Peter Griffin?

I'd vote for Peter Griffin, I don't think Homer Simpson has it within him.

See your thing about Simpson is that he can take a punch and get right back up again. He'll take abuse all night long and still be there clinging on. Now I'm worried about the boy Griffin. He carries an even bigger girth than Simpson. I think Simpson will still be standing when Griffin has the heart attack.

Homer would win any matchup you can think of He beat the robots didnt he?

I think that they would both get winded and pass out before they even had the chance to really fight they are both so huge.

Homer Simpson is my hero!

I like both shows but comparing both characters I definitely choose Homer Simpson, ever that he is a fatty drunk, he loves his family and children, but I cannot tell that about Peter Griffin. He is more like the opposite. I mean how many times we have seen him to act good with his children especially Meg who is always mocked by him. I think i got into many theories :D My final answer is Home Simpson

I think homer. Though, I like peter better. I think homer would only need to punch peter once and he would go down for the count. Homer would just keep getting punched and not fall down.

I have to give this one to Homer.He can take a punch,a fall off a cliff and catch cannonballs with his stomach.Peter on the other hand twists his ankle and sits on the curb and says 'ow' for 5 minutes.;-p

Both of them are crazy drunks and I love them equally but Homer has been around longer and he would probably kick Peter's butt.

Homer by far