Do You Think Academia is Crap?

United States
December 20, 2006 12:51pm CST
I am in my last semester of undergraduate work and I have a 3.94 and am in the process of finishing up grad school applications which are really a pain in the butt. All these statements of purpose, irrevelant stuff, writing samples that dictate my ability to think/write clearly and conceptually. Look, I have a 3.94 in Communications & English Studies, I can write. I mean, I know that what I've done SHOULD help me get into a good grad school which SHOULD help me obtain a better, higher paying job if that's what I desire; however, I can't help but think that it's a lot of crap. I mean I could get the same education reading books from a library and spend a lot less money on an education. Does an education just tell your employers that you can work under pressure? suceed? articulate yourself? etc? Because that's what I think. I could do all the things I'm doing now without my education. Sometimes I just feel like it's all a farce. Discuss please.
1 response
@sunnypub (2128)
• United States
21 Dec 06
I consider myself a pretty intelligent, entertaining, happy person and I hate school. I love to learn, however, but I do it on my own time in my own way. The internet has really helped out with that since distance learning is becoming terrilby popular as well as ebooks, articles, online tutorials etc. I think employers believe that getting an education shows that you can stick with something and follow through with things. On the other hand learning on your own shows that you are a self starter but you don't have the degree to prove that. Of course if you want to go far in a particular company then the degree will come in handy. Nine times out of ten when deciding who to promote a company will promote a person with a degree who has been there one year over a person with no degree who has been there 15 years. I don't think that is right. To me experience means more than a degree. A degree does not teach you how to deal with irate customers or clients. I know there are probably things that you get from a higher education that you can't get without it but I don't know what that is and it probably varies depending on the degree you are going after. All I know is that when I am in the position to have to hire employees, who they are, what they can show me in practice, how they act, and the skills they have no matter where they learned them are what will be the factors is hiring...not if they hav a degree.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Dec 06
Thanks for the the reply. I totally agree with you. I mean I am doing VERY well in school, but I just think I could've learned all of it in WAY less time reading books, etc. I think the way you communicate with people and your ability to pick up the skills necessary to succeed are far more important than the fact that you can study all day and make an "A" in a class. That doesn't mean that you can deal with people and be personable, etc. and I think that's more than half the battle. You'll probably get the best response for this topic. Thanks.
• China
24 Dec 06
You mean you got 3.94 in 4.0? If so, you are really good at your study. I'm also a senior in my university, but I'm in Shanghai, China. I only get 4.46 in 5.0, and I will pursue a MS . I think you don't have to complain about the education, because education in America is the best in the world. Thousands of international students are struggling to study in American Universities and colleges every year. I think the school study sucks too, but complaining doesn't do any good. So, I just do my best, and wish to get out of this place quickly with my master's degree.
• United States
24 Dec 06
You do have a good point, and I am thankful that I have the opportunity to get the education that I have. I'm thankful that my parents were able to pay and I didn't have to take out a lot of loans and I'm hoping to get into graduate school to get my MS in marketing because I'll have a BA in Communications and I think taht would make me pretty versatile. Thanks for your response.