Brain Lara or Sachin Who is best cricketer ? why?

India
December 25, 2006 9:24am CST
Hi all, Indian cricket super star is Sachin also West Indian cricket super star is Brain lara. Do doubt about these statements. among these two players who is best player in international cricket both test match & one day match. My opinion is Brain Lara is a good Test match player than Sachin. Sachin Tendulkar is a great player in one day cricket. But Sachin Tendulkar is a all rounder.Sachin gets some good wickets it helps some time turn the match and india won the match. So I think sachin is little bit best than Lara while we consider the over all performance of Test match and one day match. I here want your thoughts about my question. advanced thanks for your replies.
6 people like this
79 responses
@vik87391 (169)
• Spain
25 Dec 06
Although I am an Indian but still I rate Lara ahead of Sachin. Only one reason:SACHIN HAS FAILED IN IMPORTANT MATCHES WHEREAS LARA HAS HELD THE FORT WHENEVER THE TEAM IS IN TROUBLE. U see the stats.They say for themselves. There may be a couple of matches where sachin has played in crisis but they were an exception.
1 person likes this
@vik87391 (169)
• Spain
25 Dec 06
You are misunderstandng me.I am a great fan of Sachin but when you compare him with Lara,boy he looks weak.You tell me, In how many matches has Sachin played superbly when India were 20 or 30 for 3 down!Only a handful....and Lara plenty.This is what is the difference.Anyway it is a personal opinion.Lara has also played in the era when the west indies cricket was in tatters....and see his stats.No doubt sachin is a master batsman...but I differ when you compare him to Lara.
25 Dec 06
Why are the matches played by lara are great and why sachin's mathes are an exception can i know this first?
• India
26 Dec 06
i think sachin coz hes very talented. he knos all the strokes and he is very experienced
@kutchi (12320)
• Pakistan
25 Dec 06
Hi I like Brian Lara more than Sachin. He is a great player and his performance always leads his team to success he had great records in test and having good average in one days. While sachin is not a match winner his centuries did not worked well for India
1 person likes this
• India
25 Dec 06
hi friend, Sachin is a match winner only see last worlcup what happen sachin only got man of the serieas also dont forget his useful runs against srilanka & pakistan 97&98 runs brings victory on that past match & enter in to final match. But I agree his runs on final match of the any past 4 year records is not good.
• India
28 Dec 06
Yes i agree with you lara is great batsman . But we can not compare him with Sachin thats my thinking.
25 Dec 06
His centuries havent worked for india!This is not at all true as the match cant be won with a 100 runs score if all others fail in batting and sachin makes a century.So there should always be a team effort,so there is nothing like his centuries havent worked out for the team he is always the saviour.
@abhiroop85 (2826)
• Scottsdale, Arizona
25 Dec 06
both of them are great.both of them proves their class.i think lara is bit better than tendulkar.even in recent days lara is carrying his team with his bat ,but i cant remember tendulkar doing same thing for his team
• India
25 Dec 06
hi, Sachin also lead indian team once upon a time and he brought some victory like Titan cup match Many time he help indian team to win tha match.Brain Lara also lead the team many time than Sachin also Lara lose many match than victory. any way your point of view Brain Lara is little bit better than Sachin ok thanks for your opinion. Best Regards
25 Dec 06
Lara has also faced a bad situation for a more time than sachin every batsman needs some time to come into action after a break sachin is already back into action after a break because of the injuries.
• India
28 Dec 06
No i am not agree with you. Yes you are right both are great player. But Sachi is best.
@taruha (559)
• United States
25 Dec 06
Sachin is in the category of the all rounder while lara can only be considered batsman only.But, as a batsman, laras calibre is superior to sachin.he has comeout of his bad form number of times in his carrer but sachin, perhaps is still strugling to get back into the form after no. of injuries.lara has remained captain of the team for a longer period than sachin and that way also, he is superior to sachin.
1 person likes this
• India
28 Dec 06
Yes i think so Sachin is best than lara. I like his cool attitude and his playing style.
25 Dec 06
Sachin is not a bad captain and lara is not a good captain the performance of the team depends on many aspects like selction,performance of the team etc.so everthing must go fine and moreover captaincy is not the aspect that made them great players it is "BATTING"
@brazilian (263)
• Brazil
25 Dec 06
I dont know. Brazilian TV dont show Cricket.
• India
29 Dec 06
oops. sorry guy.
• India
26 Dec 06
Sachin Tendulkar is a good all rounder unlike Lara...Sachin is a good one day player...Lara is a good test match player...Sachin is cool...Lara is tempered..Sachin has variety of strokes for every delivery....Lara has fixed set of stroke play..Overall Sachin is better than Lara..
• India
26 Dec 06
I agree with you.of course your statement is correct only.My point of view sachin is a good all rounder. Thanks for your reply
@sanumuri (145)
• India
26 Dec 06
both of them are great players.but there are distigushing facts about both of them .yes sachin is an all-rounder and he can take some good wickets whcih helps india in crucial times.sachin made higehest centuries in both the test and in one-days.as a indain i regard sachin as the best player.and one more interesting point is my birthday matches with sachin tendulkar birthday date.and the fact i know anout lara is that i don;t much about him.but he is regarded as the best batsmen in the world recectly glenn mcgracth too agreed about this point.sachin had won many one days and test for india.he is the only youngest player to enter into the cricket world.there is a lot about sachin to telll.he is very friendly with the teamates and never diappoints any of his fans all around the world.
1 person likes this
• India
26 Dec 06
hi! inspite of being an Indian, i'd vote for Lara. i believe Sachin is a more copybook batsman who's scared to take risk more and more. But Lara being a temperemental batsman, seldom plays consistently. but on the day Lara plays well, he has no equal, not even Sachin. I like Lara for his adverturisms!
1 person likes this
• India
26 Dec 06
lara is best in test matches while sachin is best in hitting hundred in oneday.
@areeb124 (243)
• Pakistan
29 Dec 06
I think Sachin is the best because he bats superbly as well as bowl too. He is an gr8 allrounder when his team in trouble he played marvellous sometimes and sometimes with the bowl also.. If we compare Lara and Sachin i think Sachin is the best his overall performance is awesome..
1 person likes this
• India
26 Dec 06
hi all...though the west indian team became a better one nly after lara's entry he cant be called as better than sachin..as u wud hve seen in most of the test matches lara doesnt play to win..he plays for his personal records...but tats not the case with sachin...sachin has many times been a match winner for india(like the one at 2003 world cup league match against pakistan)...n more than that if he feels he cant give out his best he just leaves the place for the next player to do the job...also he has a credit of over 100 wickets some of which were came at a crucial moments n not to mention tat he has always been a good fielder....so obviously sachin stands ahead to be better not nly than lara but than any other player....
1 person likes this
@buzz123 (11)
• India
26 Dec 06
My opinion is Brain Lara is a good Test match player than Sachin. Sachin Tendulkar is a great player in one day cricket. But Sachin Tendulkar is a all rounder.Sachin gets some good wickets it helps some time turn the match and india won the match. So I think sachin is little bit best than Lara while we consider the over all performance of Test match and one day match. so undoubtly sachin is the best.
1 person likes this
@luckyjohn (169)
• Pakistan
26 Dec 06
i think both player has his own quality and style and both player are match winner so its very difficult to say who is the best.. but i think sachin is littlebit better then Lara..
1 person likes this
• India
29 Dec 06
Of Course.. Sachin Tendulkar, There has been a question of Who is the best all the time.. when sachin is in poor form and brian lara in great.. and vice versa.. There is an exception that lara can play long innings.. but it cant be as good as a sachin's 50, This is just because the range of strokes he has and the way he play his natural game..
1 person likes this
@shyam4uall (1002)
• India
26 Dec 06
Both are class players and are perfect in their own respective fields..I think Sachin is a great player for ODI as we can see it while we search in record books and Lara is ahead of Tendulkar in the Tests..I think Lara has more stamina and class while considering the test form of the cricket.But now a days the basic need of the teams is of all-rounder players..So i think in this matter Sachin takes the tropy from Lara and gets much ahead of him.. So lastly I think Sachin is the best cricketer the world has ever witnessed..
@angnima (772)
• Nepal
26 Dec 06
Definately , Sachin has a nice record as a batsman & fielder. He is now bowler also. He looks allrounder and it is good for team like India. If you check the record and performance of Lara he has already proved himself in his long cricket career that he is exceptionally good by age criteria. He is a dynamic person and you can watch him playing and making team winner becasue of his own talent and leadership quality. One can hope for west indies because there is Lara in the team. Sachin has to prove himself like Lara . He has got his age to prove. Let us see.
• India
26 Dec 06
Shane Warne the most succesful bowler had nightmares due to Sachin in late 90s Murlidharan is not effective against him... and there are many more example which proves Sachin's supremecy.... he can instill terror in the opposite camp.... so sachin is the best.........
@musha_ali (391)
• Pakistan
26 Dec 06
Sachin for One days and Lara for Tests.......
1 person likes this
@phani407 (51)
• India
26 Dec 06
in my opinion sachin is the best than lara as sachin is the greatest player of all time ..he is having more than 14000 runs to his credit in one day internationals and more than 10000 runs in test cricket ...with many world records in number of hundreds in one day and test ... he is obviously my favorite bats man ........
1 person likes this
@2613563 (148)
• France
26 Dec 06
sachin is the best in odi and lara is the best in test cricket.