should we americans keep dying for Iraqi's?? how long?

______ NO!!! we should get out Immediatly and give a ____ what happens to them, and stop paying Isreal and arabs might leave us alone...they been fighting each other for thousands of years for some family fued... they will never stop... its part of thier Culture and Religion...

Americans are dying to protect our country. Although the battle is not occuring on our soil, it is to defend our nation from the Muslims who want the infidels killed.

i think that we should take the troops out of iraq because it is useless having people dying and no progress is being made i think that americans should use their soldiers for other things

I can't see a solution! This is the worse affair that I ever seen made by a democratic state as the USA are. I was against the initial invasion but naw I can't see if is better to stay or to leave.

nothing will happen by yur comments ....... till yur president sees that thing that y r dying and killing.........

First, the American people need to acknowlege that the initial invasion was all about oil, precipitated by George Bushs' frustration that Saddam Hussein had thwarted every move that Bush made to try to provoke Saddam, or get a UN resolution authorising military action. This was the enduring mistake. The "sexed up" lies about WMD's, should be a matter for justice, both for Bush and Blair. That so much effort has been applied to the situation in Iraq is irrelevant. The US removed Saddam without a plan for restoration of infrastructrure or security. All they can hope for now, is to impose a peace, untill such time as the sharing of oil amongst the Iraqui tribes is settled one way or another. Common sense will not prevail. Bloodshed will decide who gets the lions' share of the oil. It will not be USA, so they may as well just pack up and let the tribes fight for their own spoils of war. Patching holes with the lives of fine men and women, is no way to run a campaign. Let the disaster unfold without Western interfereance, as it surely will anyway. Dafur,Sudan,Zimbabwe,Nigeria and other areas all deserve long overdue, humanitarian peace-keeping forces. Why just "care" for Iraq? The fact that the U.S. economy is propped up by the war efforts is not insignificant.

it's a stupid for americans to die for Iragi's. Stop get involve in their politic. Bush is fooling American for his name. American should not die for his name, and the more american involve in Iraq, the more innocent peoples will die.

From everything I have read, the Iraqee people or not fighting hard enough to stabilize their country. I think they should start take the lead and handle their own affair. I think there should be some plan for the troops to start moving out in 2007.

That was a bad ideea from the begining of the war. But you american people, you have been manipulated... It is not your war, and you know that very well.

Until your president get ready to pull them out. They might as well make residents there.

I believe that it was anouther viet nam war, we really didn't need to do, too many deaths on both sides, but we should help rebuild before we pull out, also put yourself in the iraqi's shoes, would u like anouther country to come and attack on our presidant and kill people and bomb us? no, we didn't like it when we got bombed. 2 wrongs don't make a right.

The situation in Iraq is crazy. How do you change a culture who are taught as youths to sacrifice their life in the name of Allah to blow themsellves up and others in the name of religion. They are not taught religion, they are taught propaganda.

Very tough question. In my opinion, these would never end and will get worser and worser as time passes by until no another country would came to take the lead to let american and iraq at peace.

they should stop it and let iraqi government handle it themselves. so they'll be independent on americans once more.

No americans should not die for them any longer. They need to step up and die for themselves. My fiance is over there right now and I dont want him to lose his life over something as meaningless as this crap over in iraq. If these people are not willing to grow up and defend themselves why should we do it for them. Bring my fiance home to America where he belongs

the government dont know what they are doin.

I think is so sad we keep loosing our soliders in these other country I see one ever night on Nancy Grace and it breaks my heart I think they need to settle there own battles. and let our troops come hope.

I am hoping with Gates in the office that things will change a little bit now that Rumsfield is out of office. Having been in the military myself, it is time to bring out troops home!

Hey guys, you are not dying for Iraquis, you are dying to protect the world from the tyrany of terrorisme... not the same thing... Thanks to all of you, your boys out there, for giving us this hope, and if only the US was less influenced by Europe, this war would be finished long ago. That's what I think.

bush should stop doing that