The pitbull controversy is only increasing the popularity of pitbull ownership

United States
January 10, 2007 3:03pm CST
That's what it seems like to me. Pitbulls have become a very very popular breed of dog to own, and the more controversy comes about because of pitbulls attacking people, the more people tend to start buying pitbulls. I honestly don't have much of a problem with it. Pitbulls being ferocious and bloodthirsty depends on the trainer. Many of the people who buy pitbulls, buy them for this reason. Many other pitbull owners, though, do not train their dogs to be ferocious. I know nobody who has had anything but good experiences with pitbulls, and all of the pitbulls I've been around were very sweet and friendly. And if you wanted a guard-dog, wouldn't a dog that can be one of the meanest, toughest dogs around, be your first choice?
6 people like this
30 responses
@lonewolfnan (4366)
• Canada
10 Jan 07
As you mentioned,the problem of the reputation the pitbull has is because of what the owners trained him for.I as well know a pitbull that sleeps with the kittens and cats and is a blast to be around. Maybe it is time for the owners to accept the full responsibility for what their dogs do.
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
11 Jan 07
Bullseye.
@rebelann (112770)
• El Paso, Texas
26 Mar 20
I can agree with some of that but I have owned a mixed breed who had a high kill instinct and would kill mice, he was the best mouser, cats and anything else the got into his yard. He was sweet as pie with me and my other two pets but did not like men or little boys ... and no, I never allowed him to be too close to any children. He was a mix between American Bull Terrier, German Shepherd and some other breed I could never figure out. I saved him from a life on the streets when he was a puppy of about 10 weeks and he was neutered at 3 months old.
@babray06 (1787)
• India
12 Jan 07
I don't find anything wrong with Pitbulls. They are a natural animal with a certain instinct. People who are keeping them as a pet should be well aware of their habits and instincts. It is the job of the owner to control the animal. Now if someone keeps a leopard or a wold as a pet it should be the responsibility of the owner to look after it. We can not blame the pet from attacking others. Unfortunately whenever anything goes wrong it is the pet which suffers, in many cases it is with their life they lose. I think pit bull owners should be made aware in official way that they are keeping a dangerous pet and they should be held responsible for the acts of their pets.
2 people like this
@rebelann (112770)
• El Paso, Texas
26 Mar 20
Pitbulls were originally known as Nanny dogs because they were so good with little children and would protect them. The only real problem was that when they got excited their tails could wag so hard they would leave welts on a persons legs.
@suedarr (2382)
• Canada
11 Jan 07
Pit Bull ownership was banned last year in my province. I think you are absolutely right in saying that people ruined this breed which is no more dangerous normally than a jack russel terrier. Unfortunately the sensationalistic media encouraged would be gangsters and thugs to run right out and breed and raise them. People ruin animals not the other way around, and now that they are gone here I'm left wondering what breed will next be ruined, Sheppards, Rotties, Dobermans ... it really makes me sick. Thank you for an interesting and timely topic.
2 people like this
@coolcatzz (1587)
• Canada
11 Jan 07
I agree with you I think it all comes down to the training. When we got our rottweiler everyone would say "oh that is such a mean dog to have" and yet our rottie is a sweetheart and wouldn't hurt a fly literally. With these guard dogs it all comes down to training them.
2 people like this
@rebelann (112770)
• El Paso, Texas
26 Mar 20
Any dog if raised in a loving environment will be a good dog to his/her family and many will make wonderful guard dogs. The ones that worry me are the ones purposely trained to be mean in some way, that's the fault of the person not the dog.
@nuffsed (1271)
11 Jan 07
There's something about your tone that I can't help respond too. lol Wanting to buy a pitbull, just because it gets bad publicity is just the sort of thing that a stupid juvenille would admit to. And no. If I wanted a guard dog, I'd want the smartest dog on the block!! Not one that would gulp down a lump of sedative laced meat at the first sniff. Pitbulls are generally owned by people who have a fear of being a target. Usually a target of the Police. But the Police do not stop doing their job because somebody has a stupid musclebound monster waiting to take someones face off. Pitbulls are of little use for anything other than fighting with each other. The origin of the breed. This practice is still carried on today as has been shown in Liverpool UK where 17 of the dogs were discovered at a training establishment. Another camp was found since in Leeds I heard through my family. Unlike most dogs, the pitbull does not give warning through body language such as moving it's ears back or barring his teeth. The pitbull is a psychotic reactionary that acts without warning. If having such a cuddly animal on the end of a lead is what it takes to make someone feel safe, then all I can say is that person has a persecution complex or some such mental problem. Failing that they likely have a lifestyle that attracts violence.
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
11 Jan 07
I don't believe its making them more popular, just more noticed. Owners are getting attacked by close minded people and forced to defend themselves. Apparently people are only supposed to keep those little yapsters as pets anymore.
2 people like this
@canadabis1 (1952)
• Canada
11 Jan 07
I know what u mean....last yr was the big debate about pitbulls here...all the hooplah and crap...until they finally made some rules like muzzling and no new pups...as soon as they made the new laws...the crap went away...and the cops dont enforce the new laws anyways....so it was all for not.
1 person likes this
@TerryZ (22076)
• United States
10 Jan 07
I would say yes the problem with the pitbull they have interbred thats why their temperment is so bad. I have only me acouple of good pitbulls in my life time. Thats not saying to much for them.
11 Jan 07
I would say that it is more to do with the mentality of the owner. If the owner is a thug then they are likely to teach their dog to be vicious. But at the end of the day, a baby or a small child should not be left alone with a dog- no matter how trusted that dog might be. My mum and dad have a gorgeous golden retriever called Mr Pickles and he is the softest dog you could ever meet, but none of us would ever leave my one year old alone with him, because when it comes down to it, he is still a dog, a wild animal. Unfortunatly its peoples mentality that is to blame and not really the dog itself.
@amber81 (288)
• United States
11 Jan 07
I currently have a pitbull actually, and have had one before but its the owner as well as what you said that makes them so mean, They have trained them in that manner, how ever they can be very nice dogs, such as ours are not being trained as guard dogs or anything like that. Their around kids and very good.
1 person likes this
@destroyer (784)
• Pakistan
11 Jan 07
pibulls are ferocious and bloodthirsty only if you train them to be that way! i've got a friend who owns the most fun to be around dogs in neighborhoods and guess what they are pitbulls! However sadly most people buy pitbulls with intentions of making them fight and hence train them to be vicious, mean and blood thirsty! In the end it all comes to their upbringing. You want them to be friendly and adorable they'll be that way and if you want them to be killers they'll be that way too!
11 Jan 07
I would never own a pitbull anyway but after the case here in the UK at new year has put me off even more (5 year old girl killed by one). I'm not saying that they're all bad I just don't personally like them, love my huskys!!!!
2 people like this
@biwasaki (1745)
• United States
11 Jan 07
I agree that a Pitbulls attitude is based on the way he is raised. My dad has had several litters of Pitbull puppies, and every single puppy has been incredibly sweet, even tempered, and mellow. For people to make a generalized assumption that "all Pitbulls are bad" is wrong. I believe the saying "There is no such thing as a bad dog, there are only bad owners".
• United States
11 Jan 07
Yea, society shouldnt blame the dogs. Its the trainers!!! I have a pitbull also. He never barks at people unless they get real close too me. He doesn't even bark at other dogs until he senses their aggression. I think people should be punished for their dogs action. All pitbulls arent killers as potrayed.
1 person likes this
@mishang (498)
• Philippines
12 Jan 07
According to some television show that I've watched, a person's inner behavior can be reflected by things that he is interested with. Most people who buy dogs because of the bloodthirsty and nasty brawls these dogs are attached with only shows that it is not the dog that's into those things rather the owner or the buyer of a dog. I highly agree that it also depends on how one raise and trains the dog. If you treat it kindly with respect and love and discipline, then nothing can go wrong. But, treat it with much anger and beatings, then let's just see when the dog got all fed up with it.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Jan 07
I just got a pit about a week ago. He is the sweets dog I have owned in a long time very good with my infant and I believe that its all in how u raise them. Dogs only learn from there trainers just like in children. They learn what they are taught so for those people that complain about the pits just dont understand its not the dogs fault
• United States
25 Jan 07
I have two rescued pits, and they're the sweetest, most loving dogs ever. I hate when people see me and ask in horror, "Are those pit bulls???". That would be like me asking them "Gasp. Are you Irish?". C'mon
11 Jan 07
Very few dogs are born to be violent. They become violent because of their owners. You're right, the more fuss the media makes about pitbulls and rottweilers being 'devil dogs', the more inclined disturbed individuals are to own one! In many areas it's a status symbol to have a dangerous dog. It proves how 'hard' you are. I don't know why anyone who just wanted a family pet would go for a pitbull when there are so many other breeds to choose from, though. Even if they don't train the dog to fight, people are obviously still buying them for their tough image.
1 person likes this
@patootie (3592)
11 Jan 07
I like dogs .. but I don't like pitbulls .. or certainly not as pets, they are quite ugly looking brutes and aren't playful or amusing in any way .. just seems to me that owning a pitbull is some sort of kudos thing .. And I simply can't understand why anyone would want to keep a dog of a breed known to be dangerous in their home .. if they were told to let a violent person into their house they would be outraged ..
1 person likes this
• United States
10 Jan 07
I have the sweetest pitbull i have ever known and i have known AT LEAST 10. She is not full pit, she is also Rotweiler! Rotweilers are also in the category of "mean dogs". She acts more like a human than a dog and her best friends are the 8 cats that i own. she does not have a single mean bone in her body. i read a book on pitbulls when i first got mine. the book was written by a veterinarian. they stated that the reason why pitbulls become aggressive is in fact that they have not been raised right. in order to properly raise pitbulls, you must be able to be devoted to them 24/7. since me and my husband have work at home jobs, we were able to provide her with enough attention! the owners of the other pitts that i have known were not necessarily around 24/7 but you get the idea. if you own or deciding to own a pitbull, make sure you have enough space for them to run because they are high energy dogs or have them inside and NOT tied up on a chain in the back or front yard without any attention or affection!
• United States
11 Jan 07
I hate it when people say that pitbulls are only mean when they are trained that way. Pitbulls are bred to have aggressive personalities. It is in their DNA to be aggressive. Almost all of the attacks that I have heard about was caused by pitbulls whose owners said they were never trained to be mean and that they had never attacked before. Why do people want to take a chance on a dog that might rip off a face of an innocent child or anyone else? Even if a person was on your property without permission, do they really deserve to be horribly mangled for the rest of their lives? I don't think so!
• United States
11 Jan 07
Do you think ANY pitbull owner whose dog just attacked someone would admit to raising them to be tough, whether they did or not? The correct answer is: no, they did not.