Why do people who know they can't win American Idol audition?

@wsue1023 (1395)
United States
January 26, 2007 2:11pm CST
I really don't understand this. On Larry King last night this woman who had auditioned and been rejected was complaining because she had to wait 35+ hours for her audition and then was treated badly by the judges, but why was she there anyway? She said she knew she didn't have a chance, that she wasn't that good, but was doing it for the experience. One of the reasons she was there so long was that there were probably thousands of others there who shouldn't have been. So, what is she complaining about? Also, she wasted the judges time, so why shouldn't they be a little irritated with her?
7 people like this
35 responses
@stephcjh (38473)
• United States
26 Jan 07
I think they just want to be seen and heard and publicly recognized, LOL. they know whe they get on that show, that they are going to be judged and insulted, most likely. LOL, if I knew I didnt have a chance, i dont think I would have audiotned to begin with. I think I would have saved my self the embarrassment. I do believe that Paula, Randy and Simon are burnt out from judging though and they are just there for the publicity also and that money LOL.
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
26 Jan 07
You're so right! Thanks for your comments.
1 person likes this
@daryllau (284)
• Malaysia
26 Jan 07
Since the days of William Hung, AI have been a platform for fame seekers. It doesn't matter if they can sing or not but more importantly to make themselves known to America. What is sad though in my opinion is for those who REALLY are there to seriously participate but thanks to the thousands of fame seekers, they would have to waste hours of their time just to get to the audition.
2 people like this
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
26 Jan 07
Good point. I think most of these people are egomaniacs looking for a spotlight. It's cool to be on TV right? Even if you're making an idiot out of yourself? Pretty sad if you ask me.
3 people like this
• Canada
27 Jan 07
As soon as I saw the heading for this post Williams name came to mind. I think that because he has a couple cds out, people get the "if he can do so can I" mentality.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Jan 07
I am quoting Jay Leno of the Tonight Show, from his show last night..."No one forces these people to audition." They do it all on their own, mostly out of a narcisistic need to prove they are better than someone else. She has no room or reason to complain. If she didn't want to wait, she could have left at any time. These people need to take responsibility for their own actions, grow up, and quit blaming others. Sorry, just had to rant about it. It's ridiculous for these "potential contestants" to complain about waiting, or that the judges were "mean". They made the active choice to go through with the audition.
1 person likes this
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
26 Jan 07
I agree with you. Thanks for your comment!
2 people like this
@polachicago (18716)
• United States
26 Jan 07
I think people should have evaluation form few honest friends before even getting into audition. Most of tham are terrible. I don't believe they show up and complain. There is nothing to complain about.
2 people like this
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
26 Jan 07
Sometimes friends think they're not being friendly when they speak the truth. I think this is part of the problem. Other times I wonder if these so called friends aren't just setting their friends up for embarassment.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Jan 07
because somebody tells them they're good and they're not so they think they arew really good when they go in and they're not so the judges reject them
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Jan 07
I agree with you! These people who expect some pointers from the judges or whatever need to be slapped! LOL That is not their job or their responsibility! They want to hurry and get on with the business at hand. I agree the judges can be rude, but you know what, sometimes they need to be! LOL Now, I do not agree with them attacking someone's physical appearance. I mean, like that guy with the big eyes and he was called a bushbaby. That was rude...this guy can't help the way he looks..it's the way he is. BUT...when they say things like "that was awful" and "singing is not for you" and other rude things, these people deserve that. They can't hear that they are tone deaf???!! LOL
1 person likes this
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I'm glad you brought that up. The physical insults really need to stop! I just told my daughter this morning, when you insult someone's appearance or something else they have no control of, you're the one that looks bad. I believe this too. When Simon bad mouth's people based on the face that God gave them I think he's showing his true dark nature. It's just not cool and shouldn't happen. He's like a bully on the playground who never grew up.
@sunrisekn (1466)
• United States
27 Jan 07
That drives me crazy. American Idol judges are being critized for "picking" on these people, but they know from previous seasons exactly what is going to happen when they get in front of them. They sign the waivers. They know that Idol is looking for a singer an someone who is promotable. These people need to get over themselves. Take respobsibility for their actions and move on.
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
27 Jan 07
Very good point! Anyone who has watched this show, knows what can happen inside that room!
@delina123 (2453)
• Canada
27 Jan 07
I think they do it just so they could be on T.V and I think that is just crazy.
1 person likes this
@emarie (5442)
• United States
27 Jan 07
i probably agree with the judges. most of the ones they show, they judges pretty much hit it on the nail. i mean, sitting there for hours listen to lousy person after lousy person with a few good ones here and there, but probably most of them bad. i would have gone off if she really didn't think she could make it. they just want their 15 seconds of fame. its stupid, but good tv.
1 person likes this
@timish (128)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I think many people audition on American Idol for the publicity and attention when they know they don't have the talent. They want that few seconds of "fame". I personally think the best part of American Idol is the auditions and watching people make a fool of themselves. These people may not have talent but they are entertaining to watch.
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I agree they are entertaining! For me the only part of it that's not entertaining is watching some of them blow up in anger after leaving the audition. Seems immature to me and if the judges thought they had any talent at all, possibly might accepting them the next season, that chance is no doubt lessened when they storm out in a rage or say something stupid to the camera after leaving!
• United States
27 Jan 07
well first they might get pressured by friends or they acutally think they can sing or they just want to be known maybe like the suckiest ones who dress funny they get to see their selves on tv then
1 person likes this
@diannebcrs (1549)
• Philippines
27 Jan 07
if i were friends with people who didn't know how to sing and who were planning to go and audition, i'd stop my friend for his/her sake! i don't really know how they're able to muster all that confidence to sing in front of national tv... in front of simon! i mean, wouldn't your parents, friends, or family tell you that you're not fit to sing in front of simon? just to save you from embarrassing yourself
• Indonesia
28 Jan 07
I agree, i will whoop my friend till black out if i found him will join Indonesian Idol audition(Indonesian Idol version of American Idol) with his bad voice, ahahahaha.... Or may i just let him embarasing him self and broadcasted in national TV, xixixixi.....(^_^)
@fedge098 (1330)
• Philippines
27 Jan 07
you got your point in there. let's just think that she was there for the experience. lol!
1 person likes this
@adobeman (212)
27 Jan 07
Its because people beleive that they have a chance to win the thing. The human brain will always go for easy money and many people go to american idol for easy money and fame.
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
27 Jan 07
That's funny if that's true, because I think the people that get accepted to go to Hollywood and then the final 24 and 12 work pretty hard! I don't think it's an easy road at all. Don't you agree?
@kgwat70 (13388)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I think that people just want to get on tv so that people think they are cool or that they can brag to their friends about being on tv and meeting the judges up close. Some of them are so into themselves that they think they can do anything. I know that I would not audition since I do not have singing voice at all. It is funny to me to see them make fools of themselves and then get the responses from the judges that they get. You can't blame them for trying though as you never know unless you try and usually Paula and Randy are soft and let people get by who should not get through.
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
27 Jan 07
What gets me is when they see the looks on the judges faces and keep on singing! Sometimes the judges, even Paula and Randy look like they are in pain, yet the person auditioning keeps on singing! lol... wonder what that's about.
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
19 Feb 07
yeah really. i have seen alot on there that has tried out and sounded awful. I would never embarrass myself of course I am to old now to try out anyhow.
@Boer84 (102)
• United States
27 Jan 07
People go to auditions in American Idol because it gives them a moment if their lucky to get aired on TV. This will give them their moment of fame even if they do horrible. Look at that William guy with his hit song "She Bangs".
• United States
27 Jan 07
I know there are some people who don't know that they can't sing. They must not have an ear for music. I spoke with someone who auditioned for Phantom of the Opera so I asked him to sing for me and I tried so hard not to laugh... he thought he was great.
@wsue1023 (1395)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I don't get that. You'd think he would have taped himself singing and played it back and heard what you hear. If you've ever heard yourself on tape you know that you sound different to yourself on tape than you do in your own head. I think maybe some of these people haven't considered this! lol
@Alexc123 (126)
27 Jan 07
some people audition because people tell them they are good, when everybody else knows they arn't, others just do it for a joke.
• United States
27 Jan 07
Just look at William Hung. You don't need to win to be famous.