Should people who immigrate to America be expected to learn English?

@manodogs (415)
United States
October 18, 2006 12:01am CST
Is it ethnocentric to expect them to learn English or does it facilitate communications?
4 people like this
29 responses
@dellion (6698)
• Malaysia
18 Oct 06
Yes, I think they have to if they facing any difficulties to use the language otherwise he/she going to have lot of problems to be living there since there is a communications problems.
@dellion (6698)
• Malaysia
18 Oct 06
Thanks!
1 person likes this
@manodogs (415)
• United States
19 Oct 06
That's what I say, too. I would never think about moving to a country that spoke a language I didn't know -- especially not if I expected to get a job there! But they do it here all the time...
@getjimmy (2242)
• India
22 Oct 06
yes they have to learn english if they wanna stay there.it applies for all d countries.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Oct 06
YES!! People should learn to speak the language of the country they live in - any country! And I am pissed as hell that I have to foot the bill for interpreters, etc., for people who refuse to learn English. And we all pay! We pay higher prices for hospital care, for phone service, cable service - you name it - any place that has to spend extra to provide interpreters passes that extra cost on to all consumers, not just the ones that use the interpreters. It would be totally different if the people who needed the interpreters were the only ones required to pay for that service. But then there's still the government - Federal, State and Local - spending required to accomodate people who don't speak English - and that all comes out of our pockets and cuts down on other government services because the money is being spent on foreign language accomodation..
1 person likes this
@manodogs (415)
• United States
21 Oct 06
I agree 1000%. It's really not our problem if they can't read or speak the language and we shouldn't have to pay for it. Having an interpreter to help them should be a bonus, not mandatory, and it shouldn't be at the public's expense.
• United States
21 Oct 06
You know, I wouldn't really mind helping out initially with refugees. Sometimes, when things blow up and people need help fast, it's understandable if they haven't planned on learning English - or even planned coming to the US. But when it was something they planned for - I just don't understand the arrogance of them planning to come here and not learning the language first and then expecting the entire country to accomodate them.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Oct 06
Yes, I think they at least need to able to carry the conversation. They are coming to America and America speak English and it their job to learn the language so they can communicate with others in English.
1 person likes this
@manodogs (415)
• United States
19 Oct 06
I thought that they had to take a test or something when they immigrated, but apparently not. Of course nowadays, it's hard to say just how many people come to the country legally. :cD
@neon2000 (2756)
• Philippines
22 Oct 06
yes of course. To live in AMERICA you should learn how to speak english. you cannot be able to work if you do not understand english.
1 person likes this
@manodogs (415)
• United States
24 Oct 06
Actually -- believe it or not -- here, you cannot "discriminate" against someone because they don't know the language. So they can not only get a job without knowing the language, they are actually sometimes preferred over those who do!
@Trishzen (281)
• United States
29 Oct 06
The world is becomming such a small place with our ability to communicate with people from all parts of the world and people moving to differnt countries to America. I think immigrants should be pushed to learn English, but at the same rate I think America should push our citizens particularly children to learn foriegn languages. It would be to the benefit of us all.
@manodogs (415)
• United States
2 Nov 06
I see where you are going with this, but the national language here is English. And even though English is one of the most widely-spoken languages in the world, I wouldn't think that people should be expected to learn it along with their own national languages in their own countries. I mean, I wouldn't expect them to have to learn it just because it is a popular language.
@erielle (1280)
• United States
19 Oct 06
No, but that shouldn;'t get frustrated when people cannot communicate with them.
1 person likes this
@manodogs (415)
• United States
19 Oct 06
Yeah, I've said this too. I know some older people who came to the country when they were already advanced in age and didn't bother to learn the language and if you can make it through like that, then great! But I agree -- you can't get mad when others don't understand you or find it hard to talk to you. After all, Americans speak English!
• United States
29 Oct 06
I think people that come to the US should learn English. I hate walking into a store and right away the employees start speaking Spanish to me. I live in San Diego so there are many nationalities people from all parts of Latin America and most jobs here want bilingual people so it would be a great advantage to them to know both languages.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Oct 06
Yes, I think it would benefit them in the long run. Since that is the English is spoken America. It would be the same if an English speaking person moved to another country they should learn the language. God Bless
1 person likes this
@nannacroc (4049)
18 Oct 06
If you move to a country where English is the language spoken, then you should learn English. I live in England and I am fed up with people who cannot be bothered to learn English. A lot of money is being wasted in schools from the special education budget for children who's parents can't be bothered to teach them English. This means that children with real special needs are losing out.
1 person likes this
@manodogs (415)
• United States
19 Oct 06
Yup, and it goes further than the schools -- the businesses, hospitals, and government offices who have to keep translators on-hand and so forth. It's a real drain on the country's economy.
@jzcb87 (1797)
• United States
27 Oct 06
I think whatever country you may move to you should be expected to learn the language spoken there.
1 person likes this
@jazed37 (117)
• Philippines
27 Oct 06
where u from?
1 person likes this
@hush5605 (674)
• United States
29 Oct 06
I think that anyone who moves to America should learn the native language (English). I don't think it matters which country you move to...I think the same rule should apply. If you wish to become a Citizen and live in any country other than your native-born, I feel the only way you can actually belong is if you adopt their culture and their language.
1 person likes this
@ArsonCuff (3114)
• United States
18 Oct 06
If they want to succeed and survive in the country then it would be for their own good and benefit to learn the language...I do not care if they choose no to, however if they need something from me and I cannot understand them I guess I will mutter "baboobaboo" back at them and walk off
1 person likes this
@manodogs (415)
• United States
19 Oct 06
Haha. You should run for office!
@b_leyte (77)
• Canada
29 Oct 06
YES!! and it should be the same in Canada. I think they should have to take the Grade 12 English Provincial (i'm canadian) in order to become a citizen They can still be a landed immigrant But to get their citizenship they should be forced to have english
1 person likes this
@bhchy1 (6047)
• United States
19 Oct 06
Yes..just as if I went to another country that did bot speak English I would expect to have to learn their language.
1 person likes this
@ahmar2 (682)
• Pakistan
22 Oct 06
Yes they should as it is native knowledge of USA then wo can live without it..
1 person likes this
@morenita (331)
• United States
29 Oct 06
Yes, I think they should have to learn how to speak english. If you go to any other foreign country it would be expected. I live in a large hispanic communnity and you have no clue how many times I am approached to translate, funny thing is. When Ive lived in other countries like France for example the new spanish speaking immigrants from Latin American countries make an effort to learn french so they can go to school and work. Here in America we cater to spanish speakers, I think if we made it somewhat of a requirement they would be a little more responsive and try to learn in the many years they are here.
@exodamus (1625)
• India
22 Oct 06
It is better to learn english for everybody.
@tentwo67 (3382)
• United States
22 Oct 06
I think that they should aquire at least a rudimentary understanding of the language. I've never heard anyone question whether someone moving to France should try to learn French, etc, and so I don't know why some people seem think it's unfair to expect people living in America to speak English.
@Jellen (1852)
• United States
27 Oct 06
Learning English would facilitate communication. Should it be required? I think it could be expected and help offered toward that end. But learning is a subjective thing. It happens for some, not for others. If I were to go to another country, I would learn the language for my safety, my success, my comfort. Should I be ordered to learn it? I hope not. But I would have the intrinsic desire to want to learn it.