Immigration to the U.S.

United States
March 29, 2007 9:03am CST
I'm not really clear on my take on the immigration laws in the U.S. On the one hand I believe that people should obey the laws and should have consequences when they don't. But on the other hand we need to change the laws to permit more people to come in to our country. I think part of the resistance to accepting immigrants is the fear of losing jobs to them. But must immigrants come with few professional skills. They usually, at least at first, take the menial jobs that most Americans are too proud or too lazy to work. And immigrants increase the job market at higher levels because they have the same wants and needs as other people - creating a demand for goods and services. There must be a better way to provide work visas that encourage people to come legally so that we don't have to be so rigid about people crossing the borders. Another part of the resistance is the cost of providing immigrants with all the social services benefits of U.S. citizens. While on the one hand we have a moral obligation to help all people, the reality is that we can't afford to support everyone's medical and health care if everyone doesn't pay into it. But if they are paying taxes that support the programs, they should be allowed to participate in the benefits. I understand the issue is more complex than this. But surely something can be worked out that is fair and equitable that allows more people to come into our country to share their lives with us.
1 person likes this
1 response
29 Mar 07
I think that people should be able to live in whatever countyr they like. It is unfair that some people have much better livesjust because of the country that they are born into.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Apr 07
Well, yes and no. [See what I mean about being conflicted? :-)] On the one hand, we want to share the opportunity with others. But on the other hand, we don't want them to be people who don't respect our laws. And should we reward people with benefits if they broke the law to get them? And how can we turn our backs on children who need healthcare? I just isn't a simple problem.
• United States
2 Apr 07
you are right it is not a simple problem but nothing is,I dont understand why we want to lock down the border to them coming into the us but we want to enjoy a vacation on there beaches without a problem it works both ways.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Apr 07
I don't think there is a problem with someone from Mexico crossing the border through the gates for a vacation in the States. I think the problem comes with people coming in illegally, working illegally, and taking advantage of services paid for by taxes of people here legally. At least, that is what I hear on the news. The burden on towns and cities and states that border Mexico to take care of these folks should be shared by the whole country, I think. That way we would all share in the issue and not be able to say, "Oh, I live far away and don't have to really worry about all that." I see many ways that immigrants are good for the country and I think the immigration laws need to be changed to let more people come legally. My daughter married a Canadian and moved there. She had to take care of lots of red tape to become a permanent resident of Canada, but it was doable. She has to have a passport to cross the border, but other than that there is no problem with visiting. She still can't work in Canada until she's been there a certain length of time. I suppose she could work illegally, which is what many immigrants to the US do. Seems to me they'd want her to work and pay income tax! :-) Why aren't we welcoming people legally? Where could I get an explanation of that? Maybe some politician?