Did You Watch American Idol Tonight?

I also thought Haley would have gone over Gina. I think Haley is only there for her looks. She can sing, but not as good as some of the others who have been eliminated already. I love Michael Buble, but I have to agree that some parts of the song he sang were not so great. I liked Gina a lot...I figured she would be leaving soon, but some of them should have left before her...at least this is my opinion. :)

I thought he sounded okay but I don't care for that type of music, was that his or Tony Bennetts' ? I thought for sure Phil would be leaving cause we all know they're keeping Sanjaya a little longer....why..I like Haley and don't understand why the judges always pick on her when the other two girls (Lakisha & Melinda) sing older type of music, they're not my favorites. I hope Chris wins , he's more AI type.

I did not see that one coming. I though for sure that Haley or sanyaja would leave... Oh well - thats american idol =)

After last night I picked Haley, PHil, and Gina to be in the bottom three, so there was no surprise there for me. I did however think that Phil was going to go home. I don't think he deserved to go home, but that is what I thought. I really don't think Gina deserved to go home. Of course I don't think anyone deserves to go home before Haley and Sanjaya. Until those two go home I will always be unhappy, and I am getting closer and closer to not watching the show anymore. It is just becoming rediculous.

I am very upset that Gina was eliminated, I thought she was one of the best. And her song was great last night. Tons better than Sanjaya and Haley.

I am still upset about the whole thing. I am not sure who Michael Buble is but I am not fond of that kind of music so I didn't enjoy it anyway. About the elimination I am horrified Gina did not deserve to go home the least little bit but of course neither did Chris daughtry last season. America is voting for all the wrong reasons and it is unfair to say the least.

I thought he sounded okay but I don't care for that type of music, was that his or Tony Bennetts' ? I thought for sure Phil would be leaving cause we all know they're keeping Sanjaya a little longer....why..I like Haley and don't understand why the judges always pick on her when the other two girls (Lakisha & Melinda) sing older type of music, they're not my favorites. I hope Chris wins , he's more AI type.

i thought haley or phil was going tonight. i did not expect gina to be leaving. Gina deserves to be in than haley and phil. i hope next week phil will go home next week. does anyone know the theme for next week?

I thought he sounded bad tooo He may have been am sure singing in front of the judges is really hard... to me gina should still be there I saw her grow and adapt to any challange and for a rocker girl that's not easy. am suprised that sanjaya is still there. he's my least fav. Melinda is my fav...

The dude with the bald head sucked and so did the guest. Tony Bennet wasnt going to do it?

If anyone should have gone home it should have been Sanjaya. He can't sing and he can't dance either. He is terrible. I agree who ever Michael Buble is, he sounded bad also. He sang worse than some of the idols.

I havnt seen one spisode this year usually I watch it just didnt feel like watching it this year