Abort or Not???

United States
June 9, 2007 9:28am CST
Do you feel it's selfish to abort a pregnancy if Doc advises the baby will have serious birth defects? I know it's a sensitive topic, think before answering please. Thanks in advance!
2 people like this
6 responses
@massageeh (965)
• Taiwan
10 Jun 07
Hi Stiffler07, Yes, it is a sensitive topic, but a good one. Personally, I would probably get my wife to abort. I don't think it'll be fair for the the child and the mom and even myself to go through the pain and struggles through life. I don't think it is selfish to make the best decision for oneself and others. But, I can't stand those who abort because of a great time they had one night. That is just irresponsible of them. Anyway, that's another topic itself. Good topic again.
3 people like this
@Gorgeous24 (1091)
• United States
12 Jun 07
This is a very sensitive topic but also one that makes you really think about what you would in the situation. To be honest part of me would want to have my child even though the child was going to have birth defects because if God blessed me with being able to carry this baby long term than I should be able to care & provide for my child as if it didnt have any birth defects..I would think maybe God hade something planned for me that I didnt know about by giving me this child. Now the other part of me would want to abort my pregnancy because I would not want to be selfish just because I wanted a child. I would think about how bad my child would suffer in the long run (depending on the birth defects) I guess I would have to be in this sitaution to really know what I would do..so my answer is I dont know ,I would defnitely be torn between the two.
2 people like this
• United States
14 Jun 07
I can see where you would be torn,its a deep sitaution. Ty 4/answer!
2 people like this
@TiffanieC (827)
• United States
24 Jun 07
This one is very difficult.. I'm not sure. I suppose it depends on what the defects are. If the birth defects are purely cosmetic then I would have to go through with it. If the birth defects were so bad that the child would have no or low quality of life then as hard as it would be, I would have to give up the pregnancy. It would probably destroy me to do so. For those of you out there who are thinking of aborting because of some small birth defects I want you to know that my husband was born with many birth defects (his hands are deformed, his spine is all messed up along with his jaw which makes him have a tongue thrust aka. lisp and even his insides are twisted.. both of his kidneys are fused together and sit on the left side and his intestines are reversed) I'm not even sure if I listed all of them but he is a wonderful man and an Elementary School Teacher. He is in his early 50's and I feel so blessed to have him in my life. I can't imagine my life without him!!! What if back then his mom and dad knew he would be like that? What if they had decided to abort him? Then I would probably be single forever and not be able to start a family of my own with the love of my life. Just think about it. Also.. I'm sure you are wondering.. and YES I am concerned about what defects will be passed onto my child.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Jun 07
I see that this question hit home for you! ..... Thanks for a great detailed answer, I'm sure there is much more of you to bring to the table & I look forward to it:-) ..... Enjoy your stay,& welcome.
@34momma (13882)
• United States
11 Jun 07
of course i think it is selfish. does that make it wrong or bad. i think not. i know in my heart if i was told that, i would not continue with the preganancy.i know how hard it is being a parent, and having to be a parent of a sick child is not something i would want for myself, my family, or my child. life it's self is selfish.
• United States
14 Jun 07
"Life it's self is selfish" ..... Hmmmmm, you might just have a point:-) Ty 4/answer!
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Jun 07
Selfish? No. Humane? Probably. Sometimes, not being born at all is much more humane than what thousands of unwanted and adoptable kids are suffering every year living as wards in the system, in abusive foster care homes, etc. I dont think there is any "criteria" a woman must meet (birth defect, result of rape, Mother's age at pregnancy, etc) in order to receive a "stamp of approval" from society regarding her choice to abort. It should always be her choice and no one else's business.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Jun 07
Yes, that can happen. In fact, there was a good chance my third child would have been born with birth defects as shown by some test they did while I was pregnant. He was, and is, fine. It was my choice to take the chances, as it was your friend's choice also...no one else should have any say about it. Smiles, DL
1 person likes this
• Philippines
26 Jun 07
I know someone pregnant that when she consulted the doctor, she was informed that her child could have birth defects. But still she carried the child and gave birth. And you know what? She delivered and healthy and bouncing baby boy. The doctors are not perfect, they could make mistakes too.
• United States
1 Jul 07
DesigningLife, you have a great point. Ty 4/answer.
@nitzel (79)
• Philippines
14 Jun 07
Abortion is morally wrong. It is taking the life of another human being, but in the situation you've mentioned wherein the baby will have serious birth defects, personally I will go for abortion. It will be selfish to let the child be born and be miserable. The parents will have a hard time, too.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Jun 07
Oh, I agree, nothing would be easy. Thanks 4/answer, & welcome!