Do you think baking bread or other food items saves you money?

Canada
August 19, 2007 3:41pm CST
One tip for saving money I've recently read is to bake your own breads. I just don't really see how that can save you money, because you have to buy the ingredients - most of which, actually, I have on hand, but it still costs money - and you use your oven, when a loaf of bread costs maybe $2. I can definitely see the benefits in terms of taste - home baked bread tastes great. But I don't see how it saves money. Do you bake your own bread? Do you save money by doing this?
5 people like this
26 responses
@clocks123 (1225)
• United States
20 Aug 07
i don't bake bread the ingrediants cost too much i would rather buy wonder grain bread it is nutritious as well
2 people like this
• Canada
20 Aug 07
Yes, I think the ingredients cost more than a loaf of bread. I buy whole wheat bread.
1 person likes this
@ccyap003 (28)
• Malaysia
21 Sep 07
Dear Ms, I have a small family and 3 little children. I agreed with you that baking healthier bread cost more but at least for the sack of a healthier life. I usually bake twice a week for small quantity of cookies and cake with Microwave oven. Baking with Microwave oven saves electricity and duration of baking about 50% less. For that me family and chilren can eat for breakfast and bring to school and office. It's very expensive to buy even chocolate cookies. 200grms cost about $5 - $10. Not even enough for 1 time tea break. Baking cookie and cake actually save us some 50% and furthermore it's fresh. Can even make different variety each week so my kids wouldn't conplaint of buy similar cookies and cake from store outside. After some 5 years of doing so, I am use to it now. Anyway, it lowers my hosehold food expenditure.
2 people like this
@SaraCate (184)
• Canada
24 Aug 07
I realize a number of people have weighed in already, but my answer is: yes, I bake our bread, and yes, it saves money. The cheapest processed wehat loaf I can buy on sale at a discount grocery store ( in Toronto) is usuallyin the range of $1.50 a loaf. I can make a loaf of whole wheat bread without all the additives and preservatives (antoher bonus) for about $0.50 in indgredients - maybe $0.55 or $0.60 if I make an herbed bread or add onion or something to it for variety. I bake four loaves at a time and usually give away one loaf. The labor works out (with hand-kneading, etc) to about 5-7 minutes a loaf, so it doean't even really take that long. And as the first poster said, part of frugal grocery-buying is also getting the best nutritional band for your buck. If making bread cost the same as buying processed bread, I would still make it because the nutritional value of home-baked bread - assuming you use whole grain flours, not too much sugar, etc. - is far better than processed bread. Now, if I could get a loaf of good quality, whole-grain organic bread for the same as if cost me to bake, I might rethink some of the home baking! ~Sara
1 person likes this
• Canada
25 Aug 07
People seem to be split on this one. I would like to eat healthier bread and making it at home, although my husband does already buy pretty healthy bread.
1 person likes this
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
24 Aug 07
we have and make home made bread alot in the winter to eat with soup, stews and chilis and the like. i dont think you really save any money because home made bread does take a little bit of time to make, but in the long run, it is sure worth it!
1 person likes this
• Canada
25 Aug 07
I'm not too worried about the time, I just was wondering whether people actually save money. Although it does seem like a nice comforting food to eat. (And I have a feeling it will take me a lot of time - I'm not always so good at new things).
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Aug 07
In the long term, yes i think making your own is less expensive ( even though bread IS cheap) its also much better or you and tastes so much better. Most people keep the basic ingreadents for bread on hand anyway, flour, a bit of sugar, water, baking soda, yeast is probably the odd ball out there, however its very easy to make self rising bread without yeast. If its something you like to do then by all means do it. It saves you money in the cost per pound. Sure you have to buy the flour, but thats 5 lbs of flour for a few dollers. Devide up the cost of flour by how much bread you get out of it. A loda of bread takes what 3 cups of flour? thats a ton of bread for the cost of the flour.
1 person likes this
• Canada
25 Aug 07
That is true - we do buy flour in 10 kilogram bags. (LOL - I don't even try to lift them).
1 person likes this
@Nardz13 (5055)
• New Zealand
20 Aug 07
Hi. Yes we bake our own bread sometimes, in which we only use self-raising flour and water... The breads is great and for us, saves on money big time...
1 person likes this
• Canada
20 Aug 07
Okay, so now it seems that people are saving money by baking their own bread...
• Australia
23 Aug 07
I sometimes bake my own bread, only when I want to have the nice aroma in the house, eat a lovely warm loaf or Ive run out and cant get to the shops. When you can buy bread at $2 to 99c a loaf and stock up when its on special, its surely not worth making it. I do buy my ingredients in a massive bulk quantity due to being in a remote location away from shops but it still works out cheaper to buy it.
• Canada
25 Aug 07
That's what I thought too. The bread my husband likes to get is about $2 per loaf. It's going to be hard to beat that.
1 person likes this
• Australia
26 Aug 07
The only way you could keep the cost of making homemade bread down is 1. Buy an electric bread slicer to slice your bread into tiny slices. 2. Keep to the basic flour, water, yeast and salt ingredients 3. Make your bread by hand or purchase a breadmaker which makes extra long loaves. 4. Buy your ingredients in bulk. I have noticed that when making bread by hand you can actually double your loaf's using the same quantity of ingredients that you'd use if using a bread maker (ie one for the breadmaker = two loafs for the oven). So this is the most viable method for saving money. But of course you need to know how to make a proper loaf of bread or spend hours and days practicing this which will result in loss of $'s due to failures unless of course your lucky. I also found that breadmakers use more ingredient weight than purchased loaves of bread, comparing a 850g bought loaf to a 1kg homemade loaf. Then there comes the slicing part of bread. Id be interested in knowing if anyone can match slice for slice on a purchased loaf to a homemade loaf. I havent even come close to a purchased loaf yet, even when using a slicing machine, my slices are no where near the size of purchased bread. Purchased bread can sit on the shelf safely for one week, homemade bread is pretty useless after 1 days and is only good for bread and butter pudding. Homemade bread doesnt freeze as well either. And you have to admit, Im yet to come across one person who wont admit they had to go make another loaf of bread as they stuffed themselves with the first loaf cause it smelled and tasted so yummy, that they ate it within half an hour of it being cooked.
• United States
22 Aug 07
The bread I bake is $.33 a loaf. It isnt a big loaf though and I need to bake 6 at a time to get this price. If I evened it out two of my loaves are equal to one loaf at the store. It is good healthy bread which is a great plus but for me the real benifit is not having to go to the store for bread. Everytime I walk into the store I spend $30 or more. If I bake my own bread I stay out of the store and save my self that money. Plus there is nothing like bread right out of the oven!
• Canada
25 Aug 07
okay, this sounds good. I wonder if I can bake bread for this cost?
• Canada
25 Aug 07
Oh, I just plain always stay out of the store. I send my husband with a list. Sometimes he goes over the list, but if we're tight I'll tell him not to get anything that's not on the list, and he won't.
• United States
4 Sep 07
My husband is the worst shopper ever. If I ever had to send him intothe store I know my food budget would be blown for the month. Everyone has their own tallents and shopping is not one of his.
@alindahaw (1219)
• Philippines
24 Aug 07
I don't think you can save money by bakign your own bread. In fact, you could end up spending more money than saving any. Just think about all the ingredients that you need to buy and the effort that you exert bakign your own bread.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
7 Feb 08
Yes! absolutely. Especially if you buy your grains at a sale price or in bulk. It costs about 50cents a loaf where as a comparable loaf in town might cost $2 more or less. Time put into it is really not much - sure it takes time to rise and time to bake - but you do not have to be sitting on it doing nothing else - it can do the rising while you are doing the dishes or some suchthing.
1 person likes this
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
23 Aug 07
If you bought the frozen dough it might be cost effective but for the price of the bread in a store, it's probably not the biggest way to save money. Unless you bake alot of it at one time.
• Canada
25 Aug 07
That's kind of what I thought too. But maybe I'll try baking 6 loaves at a time. We have frozen dough that we bought for something else I was making, and we bought extra, so I've been baking it. It's actually pretty nice.
• United States
4 Sep 07
When I bake my bread I freeze some of it. I roll it into rolls or a loaf and let it rise about half way then I pop it in the freezer on a baking sheet until it is hard enough to put in a freezer bag. It does not raise as well but it still works good enough. Plan for extra rize time since it is cold.
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
25 Aug 07
Especially when it comes out of the oven and you have peanut butter on it! Love it!
@archer1811 (1098)
• Philippines
20 Aug 07
Maybe yes, but im sure about the quality of the home made breads, the cleanliness of the equipment and of course the ingredients, at least if you are the one who baked that bread you are very sure in yourself that the ingredients and the preparation of your bread is clean and safe for your family to eat unlike those bread that you buy from the bread house or bake shops around you, and of course no preservatives at all. Its not only saving money that you can get in baking the quality the cleanliness and of course the assurance that the bread you are going to serve to your family dont contain so much chemicals.
1 person likes this
• Canada
20 Aug 07
Yes, that's very important - that the food I serve be healthy. I don't worry as much about bread because we get it from the bakery. It costs $2 a loaf.
1 person likes this
12 Feb 08
Personally, I dont think this would be worth it, as you point out - bread is not an expensive food item. If you are budgeting, probably better to look at items which you could get for less, e.g. only buying ready meals that are on offer.
1 person likes this
@wjolene (265)
• Malaysia
14 Feb 08
Recently I baked muffin. Although still trial and error but I find it fun. I get to adjust the quantity of sugar and other ingredients. Ya, it seems to cost more than you buy outside but when you're making it, is up to you what you want inside your food and how much you want to put in. You get to taste fresh food from the oven, home made.
1 person likes this
@nancygibson (3736)
• France
20 Aug 07
I find it cheaper to bake, but you have to bear in mind the cormaritive quality when you lok at these things. Sure, I could buy a fluffy pre sliced while loaf for 20p in the 'no frills' range at the supermarket, but the stuff is disgusting and full of additives and preservatives. If I bake a oaf myself I control the ingredients and get something reallynutritious and satisfying in taste. Comparable quality would cost ten times what the cheapo bread cost, but mine cost less than half that to make, less again if I buy flour in bulk. As for fuel costs, always bake a full ovens worth, maybe toss some potatoes in to bake at the same time, and make sure you use the residual heat of the oven afterwards to cook something like meringues or a baked custard as it cools down. Most people forget to make use of that heat in the oven and that is where the waste occurs.
• Canada
20 Aug 07
Thanks for the tip on saving by baking things in sequence and together. I often forget to do that.
@TerryZ (22076)
• United States
21 Aug 07
Hi cutepenquin! Ive been thinking of baking my own bread. And Ive asked for a bread machine for christmas!LOL I think it would save alot of money. And I think the taste would be fabulous. You can make all kinds of bread.
• Canada
25 Aug 07
One of my uncles has a bread machine, and he makes fantastic bread. He makes it for family dinners and it's always well appreciated.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
25 Aug 07
I'm not sure it saves alot to fmoney but I do like to do it regardless. AT PEACE WITHIN
• Canada
25 Aug 07
well, it does seem like everyone prefers to eat homemade bread. :)
@beauty_ph (2749)
• Philippines
20 Aug 07
I am not lucky to have an oven at home. Baking is what I actually love to do. But since we do not have an oven, I fail to master it. LOL. I only do baking at my friend's house. We love eating bread at home. But I think we can only save money for breads if we buy. If we bake it, I think it will cost us more. Homemade breads are more costly. It will require time. Time is gold. LOL. Next it will consume our energy for preparing it, also the electric energy is involve which is expensive too. I think the savings mentioned is about baking at home with more than 50 breads or more. If produce more breads it can lessen the price, which means we have some savings. God bless!
• Canada
20 Aug 07
Yeah, although I can't imagine baking 50 loaves of bread. It's too bad you don't have an oven. I am lucky to have an oven, even though it is a really small one.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
7 Feb 08
I suppose it depends on where you live then, here baking our own bread is less expensive than purchasing a similar bread at the store. plus it tastes better and gives satisfaction. yes there is the energy used to bake it, but at the same time that oven is helping to heat our home in the winter. we could also bake it in a wood cooking stove or in a fire place on hot embers. perhaps a brick out door oven would be something to look into building if the energy costs are too great in your area or if you do not have an oven.
@Malyck (3425)
• Australia
20 Aug 07
I definitely think it CAN save you money, but it depends on your approach. Personally, I would be buying the ingredients in bulk, which first off saves money, especially since so many of the ingredients are used in many other recipes and foodstuffs. I also have a gas oven, so it doesn't affect my electricity bill. And then there's how you preserve your food, if you're buying and baking in bulk, and then freezing the excess, I definitely think that it saves you money in time. As a family who goes through 4 or more loaves a week, it's saved us a great deal!
• Canada
20 Aug 07
Hmmm... We eat about 2 loaves a week. The math is tricky, because we do buy the ingredients for other things, and we have an electric oven.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
20 Aug 11
hi cutepenguin here in Southern Ca;ifornia good bread costs more than 2 dollars, more like three. oh you can still get Wonder bread white gooy crap for probably a dollar fifty but its really not good nor good for you. Making your own bread if you use whole grains is not as expensive as you think but you must know what the heck you are doing. It sure does taste so much better and better for you I must admit Von's store does have a bakery and oh my they do make multigrained bread that's to die for and just 2.22 a loaf so for those who are not bakers Von's stores make Delicious home baked bread.Trader Joe's is also a great store for home baked bread.