What is so great about the American flag?
By soadnot
@soadnot (1606)
Canada
August 21, 2007 11:20pm CST
many people get pissed off when they see others burning the american flag..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qqSEctaoyLg
hm, all around the world people seem to be doing it..
even americans are doing it..
how do you feel when non-americans do it?
how do you feel when americans do it?
would you let them burn it if it was your choice?
"I may detest what you say [and burn], but I will defend to the death your right to say it" - Voltaire
that is my stance on it.
1 person likes this
6 responses
@AmbiePam (92993)
• United States
24 Aug 07
You are Canadian so it's not your flag. I'm an American and I find it disrespectful and tasteless. I know where my values lie, and being a rebel just for the sake of being a rebel, is better left for the man without a country.
@soadnot (1606)
• Canada
25 Aug 07
um im an american living in canada.. stop generalizing... plus, canada and america are basically the same thing except canada is much more liberal on anything...
frankly, when i go to europe, i call myself a canadian, you figure out why.
and nationalism blinds you.
@elshaddai123 (3981)
• Kottayam, India
22 Aug 07
Whether American or non American sovereignty & integrity of any country should be respected that is for sure.
@ConservativeArtist (201)
• United States
24 Aug 07
It makes just as much sense to get offended at the burning of any national flag as it does for someone to be offended enough at the country to burn the flag in the first place. If the flag-burner thought it was "just a piece of cloth", then they wouldn't bother burning it. Flags are steeped in symbolism.
I don't get offended when someone burns the flag, but it does tell me a lot about them and who they are. It is akin to egging the house of someone you don't like- you are are frustrated because you can't persuade others through more respectful means, like using the press to make your case. I don't get offended by flag burners... after all, they have a right to do so... I just chuckle at their inability to bring anything meaningful to the table. And they wonder why they feel marginalized in the political process?
@Latrivia (2878)
• United States
24 Aug 07
I think it's pretty disgusting how some people can revere a piece of fabric to the degree that some do. People have actually been killed for mishandling the American flag. What does that tell you?
I'm a somewhat patriotic person. I hate our current government, but I like the country I live in. I'll even admit that I feel a bit of pride or excitement on days like the 4th of July. I do enjoy being an American - but I won't take my patriotism to such a degree that I'll hate someone for burning the flag to express their opinion. If that's the medium they want to use to express what they think about this country or what's going on in the country, then by all means let them do it. American or not, it's their right to express themselves by any non-violent medium they choose.
This flag worshiping ideal some people have is disturbing. If you're proud to be an American, that's cool, and if you're proud of our flag, or rather, what it stands for, that's awesome too. However, if you think people shouldn't be allowed to burn or desecrate a flag to express themselves just because it offends you - you're not a very good American, not in my opinion, anyway.
@soadnot (1606)
• Canada
25 Aug 07
i really dont understand how anyone can be patriotic.
patriotism is basically saying that my side of the line where i was born is better than your side of the line where you were born.. you know?
its by luck that you are in america, its by luck that you are a christian [i dont know if you are, but you see where im going with this?] and its by luck that your a girl and not a guy.
i mean, thats why the concepts of racism, sexism and nationalism are completly stupid in my eyes.
and i do agree with you, the flag basically says "you can burn me" on it lol...
1 person likes this
@pismeof (855)
• United States
22 Aug 07
The freedom to do so is exactly the reason why you shouldn't!!!
Were else in the world are you able to express ones feelings and opinions so openly.That is why the American Flag needs to be respected !!! It is one thing for a foreign land to burn the flag
for what ever reason But,It's quite another for a citizen to do it.
If you have a problem with something that is happening to you there are other ways to annunciate your anger, But don't show disrespect for those that fought for that flag and the "FREEDOM FOR WHICH IT STANDS"!!!
As a matter of fact I personal turn off anything that you may be trying to communicate by doing so.
@theprogamer (10534)
• United States
24 Aug 07
I actually understand what you are saying there about the citizens protesting. It is interesting to watch people really argue and protest the country (many of them benefiting from the handouts and loopholes of the government or other corrupt organizations). There are reasons to protest and stand up, but if you look carefully you can see a power interested group, not individual citizens. If you look real closely you can see organizations that want certain people in power (or out of it), you don't see individual citizens. Again, don't take this as a slam against free speech, far from it. They have every right to go out there and say, protest for whatever it is they want. I just had that observation and thought it interesting.
But here is one thing to be cautious of about Europe and Canada. Some things that would be free speech in the states would be hate speech there, even if almost no hateful connotation exists in what was said (the magic word "Offended" strikes again). But at the same time they can burn flags too and nothing is done (clearly the word "Offended" is on its lunchbreak). Of course I have no right to tell these countries or their people how to function. That doesn't mean I'm not allowed to have a say about what is going on.
One thing that is encouraging however is real blogs and forums like this. Its the individual and its all free speech, free will too. None of us will agree 100% on everything, but so far in this discussion, everyone seems interested in free speech, protest, opinions and what could/should happen. I find it rather encouraging.