Linux/ XP...... to dual boot or not to dual boot?
By rdolphingirl
@rdolphingirl (361)
United States
March 1, 2008 9:43pm CST
That is my question tonight ...
I have a friend who has been after me for a LONG time now to switch over to Linux.
I finally ordered one (Ubuntu) and have the disk, but have found myself procrastinating about trying to get everything on here saved and backed up.
My friend suggested I dual boot, therefor being able to use Linux without messing with the Windows XP install I am running on now.
Does anyone here have any suggestions? Should I dual boot? Any reasons NOT to dual boot?Thanks!~Rachel
11 responses
@rwalker (1)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I'm running just that a dual boot Ubuntu and winXP. Its works, I perfer to run linux however this is a pro dominate windows world. Sometimes you just need a windows machine. One bit of advice I could give is create a third partition and use this to store your files on and you can access them from win or linux.
-RW
1 person likes this
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
2 Mar 08
If you are using a single drive then your suggestion of a seperate partition for storage is good because this will save duplicating such files as images or music etcetera.
However, remember to use FAT32 or NTFS when formatting the partition because Windows XP cannot read Linux formatted partitions.
1 person likes this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
2 Mar 08
rwalker,
Thanks for the suggestion, I will look into that!
Still doing some research but think I will most likely dual boot for now.
Asylum,
I am using a single drive for now, 40g at that. Thanks for the help. My XP system is currently NTFS so can Linux read that then?
~Rachel
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
2 Mar 08
Yes, Linux will read any Windows formatted drive. It is the other way around were the problem exists with Windows not reading Linux formatted drives.
I am not sure whether Vista would be able to read Linux formats, but Windows XP certainly will not.
1 person likes this
@ubuntujason (196)
• United States
3 Mar 08
hey all~
i suggest dual booting. for a few reason. a big one being that not everything will work (yet) in ubuntu. for instance, i have a lexmark all in one....well lexmark and linux don't get along all too well yet (suposedly they are working onit) so in order to scan or copy i need to be in windows....but i can still print in ubuntu!
right now thats the main reason i ever use windows...also to play a few games that haven't quiet been ported to the linux world.
with the ubuntu cd, its a snap to set up dual boot too....
~j
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
3 Mar 08
Thanks for the encouragement , concern over things working has been one reason I have yet to switch over.. my printer (Brother MPC420c) is now supported though. I am pretty sure everything (but maybe ZooTycoon2) I do and run now should work in Linux ... but of course thats not 100% sure. I already use firefox for most my browsing, and Pidgin for my IMs so that should minimize the change on my part LOL
Good to know the CD is easy to use to dual boot! Thanks!!
~Rachel
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
2 Mar 08
I would suggest that dual booting would be more practical than a direct switch to Linux. Since you have no doubt been using Windows for a long while then you will be far more familiar with it, so it is worth keeping.
Linux is quite user friendly now and a stable environment to work in, so you should have no real problems. However, you will need to take the time to become familiar with the overall system, so it helps to have the option of booting back into Windows to perform a certain task. You are far less likely to abandon Linux if you do not have to depend on it totally, so you could always consider a totally Linux system at a later time.
If you have the space then I would also suggest installing a seperate hard drive for Linux. Dual booting from a single drive is not a problem, but seperate drivesis a better choice.
1 person likes this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I have used Windows for quite awhile and am familiar with it all right... and am quite disgusted with it .. LOL
Since the CD-ROM I have can be Live Booted I have played around a bit with it already and so far it seems to be quite user friendly now!
I do have a game that I am not sure will run in Linux (ZooTycoon2) and of course all kinds of logs, pictures, etc on here already. I only have one drive to work with right now, but I will keep your suggestion in mind. Thanks!
~Rachel
@Dominicc2003 (57)
•
2 Mar 08
I have the PERFECT solution for you :-)
Go to http://wubi-installer.org/
Download it and follow the instructions. I think it'll ask you to let it download ubuntu for you. It may seem a bit frustrating since you have the disk but trust me, Wubi makes it so easy:
Basically just download it, follow the instructions, choose to install ubuntu and how much of your hard disk space you want ubuntu to use. Then Wubi sets it all up for you and the next time you load your computer it'll ask you which OS you want to boot into.
It worked for me :D
1 person likes this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
2 Mar 08
Thanks for the suggestion, I will keep it in mind.
I have a friend who will be helping me so I may just use the disk, but this is nice to know in case. My download speed isn't great right now so I would like to avoid this route.
~Rachel
@spectrum42 (393)
• United States
2 Mar 08
The only reason I can think of NOT to set up a dual boot machine is if you have very limited disk space. If you have the hard drive space, go ahead and do the dual boot. Still, make sure you back up your stuff before you set up Linux because there's a chance that something could go wrong and you could lose files. Better to be safe and have that back up just in case you need it.
I kept windows for times when I run into a program that only works in that or when I need it for work related things. The rest of the time, I use ubuntu. For easy access to files, I have them in a separate partition that's FAT32 format so it can be read by both OS's.
1 person likes this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
2 Mar 08
Thanks, as I posted a bit ago I have a 40g hdd thats about half full right now. (I do need to clean it out though) Space is only a minor issue right now. I tend to feel like "Better safe then sorry" is a good idea as well! I also tend to procrastinate when it comes to change though .. lol. Thanks for sharing.
~Rachel
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
2 Mar 08
Thanks for the welcome ... I think I have one foot about halfway in to the linux community so far!
My friend has been trying for YEARS now to get me to switch!
~Rachel
@relics_aoe (458)
• India
17 Mar 08
If you have a XP installed on your computer and the data on the disk is not that much importance to you you can surely run Linux as a single OS.But I will recomend you dual boot till yoou get experienced with linux.What makes dual boot a better choice is that you can surf internet over XP to get your problems in Linux solved.When you will become intermediate user you will certainly go for linux and dumb "Dont send ".
@suprema (297)
• Philippines
2 Mar 08
Go on, dual-boot. In my laptop I dual-boot XP and Ubuntu and it has no problems. The only reason I can't think of why NOT to dual-boot is both installations will take up more space in your hard disk. But that isn't really a problem, no?
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
2 Mar 08
Space is only a minor issue, I have a 40g hdd, and about half of it is empty.
~Rachel
@anotherbirthday (810)
• Malaysia
7 Mar 08
I believe there's need for dual booting. Virtualization and emulation always suck. If you are really want to be free, never use windows software, just make single boot to linux and use freeware software only. There's much people that can live and do their works without having to use windows. You just need to be smart ;)
@tbourke45 (56)
• Australia
2 Mar 08
Yeah I would backup xp, then reinstall xp, create a new partition and install ubuntu with NTFS support to write data and xp will be able to understand it.
@mnsrwt123 (2057)
• India
3 Mar 08
I also got a problem when i installed a linux ubunto in my PC. And it gave me a lots of problems i hv to format my whole Hard disk to recover from that dual boot problem. As it harm my whole partition table.