Sea Salt?
By Marie Anne
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
United States
March 2, 2008 12:19pm CST
Most of us have seen the commercials about the guy creating the soups and the idea comes to him to use sea salt.
Do you use sea salt? Would you? Do you know if there really is a health benefit over regular table salt? Does it taste better? Different? Do you use the same amount?
I bought a container of it the other day while at Aldi's. It came in a shaker like a pepper mill and is very easy to use.
I thought it tasted just like the salt on your lips when at the beach.
I haven't decided yet whether it makes any difference in cooking. I've only used it a few times.
5 people like this
23 responses
@dodoguy (1292)
• Australia
2 Mar 08
Hi Ldyjarhead,
I believe that Sea Salt and Rock Salt are the same thing, that is, the salt obtained by evaporating sea water.
Although they taste pretty similar, the big difference between ordinary table salt (sodium chloride) and sea salt is that the latter has a whole bunch of other stuff in it besides just sodium chloride. Lots of minerals, seaweed juice, sea slug slime and fishy wee-wee, one would presume.
So it goes without saying that it's probably better for one's health than just plain table salt.
I try to use rock salt whenever I can, because it does add more than just salt to the cooking. Regular table salt often has iodine added to it (iodised table salt) to combat iodine deficiency in the modern diet, but that doesn't need to be added to sea salt because it's a natural part of the sea water from which it came. Probably bleeds from the kelp into the sea water or something.
The rock salt is quite a bit more expensive than regular table salt, so if you use a lot it would be tempting to go for the table salt. But the rock salt does have a lot going for it.
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
2 Mar 08
You know, I did some searching after I posted this, and most of what I found said there is no real significant difference between them nutritionally other than the iodine thing (and we get what we need from other food sources anyway).
It probably doesn't make much difference. Most of what we ingest will kill us eventually.
:)
1 person likes this
@dodoguy (1292)
• Australia
3 Mar 08
Hi Modestah,
It's bemusing to read other responses that state there's no difference between Sea Salt and the industrially manufactured table salt, when any half-baked mullet can see they're worlds apart (as far as salt goes, anyway).
Even from a purely mechanistic view, table salt is purified to remove most all of its content except the sodium chloride, while Sea Salt presumably retains stuff that the sea-horses forgot to clean up.
From further reading on the subject, apparently the REAL Sea Salt - which hasn't been further purified to enhance its appearance and marketability - is a dull gray color. Which is what one might expect from aquarium residue or similar - with all the good stuff still wriggling.
Reflecting on the subject further, the crystal characteristics of the two competing products might also have a bearing on their health effects. Even plain water allegedly has fluid crystal properties which imbue it with all sorts of "memory" effects and associated subtle implications for the health of consumers, so goodness only knows what other subtle health effects might distinguish Sea Salt from the thoroughly processed table salt we all know so well.
@Rhoadan (42)
• United States
18 Mar 08
Actually, most sea salt apparently doesn't have significant iodine it although you'd think it would. It does contain other minerals that aren't as prone to sublimation. My reading indicates that while sea salt may taste different from table salt, you can't tell the difference if you cook with it, so you might as well use table salt for cooking. If you decide that you like sea salt, you're better off adding it at the table. Also, the taste of sea salt varies by where it comes from.
Dodoguy: water only crystallizes if you get it down to freezing. Okay, somewhere around 4 degrees C, the molecules start lining up H to O, but it's not quite a crystal at that stage. *sigh* bloody editor won't let me space out the ASCII graphic to illustrate what I'm trying to say. grumble.
That memory thing? Homeopaths like to claim that as an explanation for how homeopathy works, but... 1)The tighter the controls on any study of homeopathy, the less effect it seems to have. 2) There was one, count them, one study that seemed to indicate the existence of water memory, and an examination of the data showed that the apparent effect was the result of one researcher (not the lead), massaging the data, e.g. by throwing out data points that didn't fit the idea. Not only that, but when the controls were tightened by more effective blinding, the memory effect vanished.
@Chey1970 (1186)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I have also seen these commericals. I have also seen where some of the well known Chef's use sea salt in there meals.
However myself, I couldn't bring myself to eat it. For I make balh salt, etc. And one of the main ingredients in it is "sea salt".. I can't eat something, I also bath with. I'm sure it is not harmful, but I am funny that way!
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
2 Mar 08
LOL Chey. I see your point, but I don't know if I'd be quite as finicky.
People do take milk baths, don't they? And of course oatmeal is good in a bath too, very soothing.
:)
1 person likes this
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
2 Mar 08
The table salt that one usually buys is is dried by heat in a kiln with the trace elements removed. The regular table salt is hard on the body. Some times even the salt labeled Sea salt is dried in such a way to remove those element that our body needs. The problem is in know which sea salt hasn't removed these elements.
1 person likes this
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
2 Mar 08
Yea, tough call. I mean, there's not a lot of writing on a box/bottle of salt that tells you from whence it came or how it was prepared prior to getting to our table.
I wonder what the health food stores carry?
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
2 Mar 08
I have always wondered about sea salt It is used I believe in Campbells reduced sodium soups I have to be so careful about sodium as I have high blood pressure and am one of those people who are salt fast according to a heart doctor. sort of likebeing allergic to it I guess. I never add salt to anything and try to always read labels but sometimes good. i have ate some of Campbells reduced sodium soup and do not think I had any bad reactions from it.
1 person likes this
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
3 Mar 08
Yep, the less processing the better. Not sure if sea salt fits that bill, but I'm hoping.
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
3 Mar 08
Sea salt is MUCH better for you then regular "table salt".
Sea salt has minerals your body needs, and is a different form of sodium, however do be careful as it does NOT contain iodine. Iodine is VERY important to your body particularly as a woman (can prevent cancer, and cure fibrocystic "boob" disease)
Studies have been done that show that its NOT sodium that causes health problems rather its the form of sodium in table salt (sodium chloride) that is the problem.
As for if it makes a difference in taste? .. well I don't think so but IMO that is not very important compared to the health issues.
Last note, table salt often contains other chemicals such as anti-clumping stuff, etc. I for one try to minimize the chemicals I eat.
HTH! ~Rachel
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I agree. I don't use cleaning or personal care products with chemicals, and I'd like to get rid of what I'm putting in my mouth too.
I'm a long way off from that goal, but figure any small step in that direction can't be bad.
@dfinster (3528)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I use sea salt all the time. It's supposed to be better for a person than regular iodized salt. I make sure I get the finer ground and not the courser ground and when I use it in cooking it works really well. Actually for the last few months that's all I've used and nobody here can tell the difference so I figure why not just keep using it if that's the case.
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I bought mine with the grinder top, and its working well for me so far.
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I bought mine with the grinder top and its working well for me so far.
@coolseeds (3919)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I think they are trying to push sea salt because they can sell the bi product of harvesting water from the ocean.
There is no difference in the 2. The sea salt might contain some stuff from the sea. But they are basically the same.
1 person likes this
@kimbers867 (2539)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I do use sea salt, thanks to my BIL working at McCormick and getting lots of things from him.
I personally think it hads a different flavor versus salt. I also like garlic sea salt.
I had to restock my kitchen and didn't even bother buying good old salt.
@moneyandgc (3428)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I haven't looked for myself so I can't say if it is 100% accurate or not, but my husband was reading in one of his medical journals that table salt had traces of aluminum in it. He asked me to switch to using Sea Salt instead. I found some fine grain sea salt at the grocery store and we are now using that.
@koalatbs (2229)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I have never bought any before at the grocery store. I have tried it, like at Red Lobster, on the outside of a baked potato. I like it that way. It seems a little courser, larger particles, but I'm sure it can be ground up finer. Let me know if you decide it is worth the extra money... I assume it is more expensive than regular table salt. Am I right?
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
3 Mar 08
It is a little more expensive, but salt on the whole is very cheap.
I bought a large grinder full at Aldi's the other day and I think it was only $1.00-something.
It should go us a long way.
So far I'm liking it, and Tom uses a lot of salt. He hasn't used nearly as much the few times I've used it.
@koalatbs (2229)
• United States
3 Mar 08
My husband uses a LOT of salt too... I'm like, at least try your food first before you dump more salt on it! LoL! He even puts salt on his salads! Yuck! I know it helps bring out the flavor in some foods though. I put a little on my canteloupe. Have you ever heard of anyone else doing this? It sounds kinda gross when you think about it... but, it's actually really good! :) I am glad to hear that the sea salt you bought is still pretty cheap in price. That great... maybe I'll have to try some then. Thx!
@Zairo7 (78)
• Canada
3 Mar 08
There's a reason it would taste like the salt on your lips at the beach... because it's very much the same salt. Where do you think sea salt comes from? (Hint, it's in the name).
Love sea salt, use it all the time when I'm seasoning food instead of regular table salt. That and black pepper and sea salt potato chips are super tasty.
I never really used much salt in cooking beforehand, I think I probably use about the same amount/less.
@lightningMD (5931)
• United States
3 Mar 08
We use sea salt a lot when cooking. I think we use less salt when we use sea salt instead of table salt. To me the sea salt tastes saltier.
@di1159 (1580)
• United States
3 Mar 08
Hi, I just bought sea salt as it was recommended to me by a health care professional to use while gargling. Supposedly it will help with sore throats and other throat ailments. I'm wondering if that's true so if any of your readers know, please drop me a line. Thanks!
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
3 Mar 08
Gargling with salt water is always good for a sore throat. Mom always made us kids do it, and I passed it on to my kids.
Don't know if sea salt is any better for that than table salt, thought.