medical profession
tests for nothing
tests make more questions
tests make more tests
wrong direction
Ever feel like medical care is going in the wrong direction for you?
By writersedge
@writersedge (22563)
United States
July 5, 2008 7:54am CST
I had a test to see what the spot was on my kidneys, took the test and basically after a whole bunch of medical talk, the test says I have an unknown spot on my kidneys. That was a lot of money for nothing.
Then I had a skin problem. Three different doctors in three months said it was ring worm (a fungus, not a worm), so then they do a biopsy because they think it might be something that looks like it (so like one diagnosis or the other you would think). The test comes back, definitely not ring worm, but could be THREE other things, so now I have to go get tests to rule out them.
So what good are these tests? I feel like I'm getting tested for nothing. I also feel like I'm going in the wrong direction. Am I the only one?
2 people like this
7 responses
@peavey (16936)
• United States
5 Jul 08
Nope, you're not the only one. I went to a doctor who had her nurse take my blood pressure while I was perched upon the examining table, with my arm hanging down. Of course, it was high.
Doctors don't know how to diagnose diseases any more, all they know how to do is order and read the results from tests. There was a time when doctors actuallylooked at you and touched your back and tummy and whatever, to see what was wrong. Now they just talk to you and order tests. No wonder no one knows what's going on.
I have kidney disease and no one has ever even told me what I should eat or not eat or how to take care of it. All that I know about it is what I've managed to find on my own. Why do I pay a doctor?
The last time they took blood tests, the nurse called and said everything looked "about the same," and to come back in 6 months. I didn't bother.
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
6 Jul 08
I hear you. I've had Drs. just talk to me and not look at anything before. These guys all looked and all thought it was one thing and now I'm up to three things.
Tests should tell you what's wrong, not lead to more tests. They biopsied my skin, why couldn't they tell from that for crying out loud?
Don't get me started on blood pressure and urologists. According to them, I can't take any meds for my arthritis besides tylenol and that stuff does nothing for me. So what am I supposed to do, suffer? One freaked out that I was taking aleve. Don't ever take that again! Well I have to be able to sleep. 24 hours of suffering in the winter time isn't my idea of a life. It's not like I pop 8 of them a day for months on end, just a couple on sub-zero nights.
You're right, you have to diagnose and cure yourself. I sleep in a sleeping bag with a ground pad under me and a blanket on top. Found that in arthritis magazine from a Grandma whose Grandkids wanted to camp so she had them camp in her living room. First sleep she'd gotten in months. Everyone had a sleeping bag. So she bought one and has been in one ever since.
I'm sorry that they're no help to you, kidney disease can be very dangerous, I hope you're doing better Peavey.
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
6 Jul 08
Peavy, it took three years for me to get the right blood pressure meds. Some of what was wrong with you sounded like what happened to me. I was dizzy almost all the time on one of them. If I stood up fast or tried to do anything quickly, I almost knocked myself out. Then they switched me to another kind of meds that made me sleep all the time. Now I take HBP meds two times a day (they broke up the dosage) so I'm not worse off witht he BP meds.
I had to diagnose myself with occular rosacea because my doctors couldn't figure it out, so I know what you're saying.
Thanks for asking to be my friend, I just added you. Take care and I really hope you feel well soon.
@lingli_78 (12822)
• Australia
6 Jul 08
i never actually experience this before... it will be annoying if i have to spend my money for nothing and the medical test does not do anything to help me at all... i will be very angry with the doctors and definitely demand an explanation from them... they can't expect us to keep on doing various tests and then come out with no conclusion after we waste our time and money doing the tests... it is really very irresponsible and unacceptable... i hope you will get the explanation that you are entitled to about your medical conditions from your doctor... take care and have a nice day...
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
6 Jul 08
Yes, it is annoying and one does have to wonder what they are sending me to tests for if test after test tells me nothing. I hope I get some answers soon, too. Thank you very much and take care.
@kareng (61756)
• United States
6 Jul 08
Nope, one of my daughters saw a urologist for over a year for a pain in her side. After numerous ultrasounds, x-rays and scans she was sent to a gastrologist. He sent her for colonoscopy. That came back normal so she was sent back to her family doctor with no diagnosis whatsoever. A year had lapsed and she still has the pain in her side which nobody seems to be able to diagnose. She also went to a physical therapists which was probably the most help of all with relieving the pain. Go figure.
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
7 Jul 08
True, in a way, but if you keep reinjuring something, it can go on forever, besides my guess is as good as anyone else's and I don't have a degree. I hope your daughter feels better soon and that the physical therapist helps her get back to normal.
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
7 Jul 08
Sounds like she knocked something out of wack or strained/sprained something, that stuff doesn't show up on tests.
1 person likes this
@Grandmaof2 (7579)
• Canada
5 Jul 08
Good Lord NO you're not the only one. Here where I am (Canada) I could spend a few hours telling you of stuff that has gone wrong here and how you spend money running to the city for test after test. I think a doctor should be paid well after he has found the problem and ONLY after he has found the problem. The remedy shouldn't be too much of a trick, it's being able to find out what the heck is wrong. I've had doctors ask me what it was I had. Do they think I'd go see them for a visit if I knew what was wrong.
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
6 Jul 08
lol, you remind me of my departed Father, "The Doctor asked me what was wrong with me, I told him if I knew I wouldn't have to come to see you!"
It seems the older I get, the more the run around. Like at 50 I've got all the time and money in the world to go for test after test, you know?
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
6 Jul 08
muscles4me, I was dizzy and almost passing out because of blood pressure medication for awhile. They switched my meds and then I slept all the time. Finally, they one doctor split my dosage in half and I take it morning and night so I don't have as much going into me at one time as I was and that cut my side effects so I could live. Took three years of feeling miserable for them to get it right. I told them the cure was worse than the disease and I was going to stop taking it, that's when they sent me to a specialist and he divided the meds.
Hope something I wrote above helps and that you aren't dizzy/passing out any more. Take care
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
7 Jul 08
A waiting list for 6 weeks to see a Doctor? We have that for specialists too up here.
@palonghorn (5479)
• United States
5 Jul 08
All of those tests are mainly so the doctors can cover their a$$. At least they are testing in an attempt to treat you. I have been having an issue with a doctor basically not doing anything! I injured my wrist mid-April, I finally got off work and to the ER 9 hours later, they took xrays......and said 'it doesn't appear to be broken, but we're gonna cast it as if it were (removable cast)' Doesn't appear to be?? either it is or it isn't. Two weeks later, the doctor still hadn't seen those xrays, but ordered an MRI, the report said, 'normal'. After 8 weeks of occupational therapy, three times a week, no improvement. The 'doctor' sent me to an orthopedic specialist, he did his own xrays, and I took the xrays that were taken when it happened and the MRI with me. He looked at his xrays, compared them to the other reports, and said 'they couldn't see that when they took those xrays' and for the MRI 'no, thats not normal'! I have a chipped bone in my wrist and 2 bones that are seperated further than should be! So he has orderd another MRI where they shoot dye in it, to confirm what he already knows (his words) and then we can 'fix' it and treat it! Which more than likely means I'm looking at surgery. So finally, I am headed in the right direction, after 2 months! So hang in there, hopefully the test will show something.
Remember, 50% of doctors graduated in the bottom half of their class. What do you call the one that graduated at the very bottom of his class..........answer: Doctor!
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
6 Jul 08
The last Dr. sounds like a keeper, at least he can read an x-ray! Good luck and I hope they can fix it to the point where you're doing well again.
Reminds me of a friend of mine, they told her that her back was normal, but she was loosing the feeling in the bottom half of her body. They kept giving her anti-depressants. Then a Dr. that graduated in the top of his class moved here, asked her if they were all blind! Her spinal column had calcified to the nerves and was going to keep going until she was paralized from the waist down! He operated and now she can finally do things again. In the meantime, she gained 100lbs and hasn't been able to loose it and at one point she was in so much pain her husband had to talk her out of killing herself, but her tests were supposedly normal.
Another test to confirm the other test? That's like the time my Dr. told me I had pneumonia and wanted to send me for a test to confirm it. So I asked him if that was really necessary since I was sick as a dog and could infect half the hospital while coughing and gagging my head off. He told me it wasn't so I got my medicine and went home to bed, where I belonged.
I hope everything goes well for you soon. Thanks and take care.
@runahead (82)
• China
5 Jul 08
I'm so sorry that you had a kin problem. But I have to say it is very difficult sometimes for the doctor to make a difinite diagnosis. I am also a doctor in the dermatology department so I know the difficulty. There are so many diseases which are easily confused with each other,especially for skin disease(There are more that one thousand different skin disease and it is difficult to give a diagnosis just by eyes). When that happens, it is necessary to have some tests to exclude some diseases. Each test has its importance.Doctors would exclude the diseases he or she considered one by one on the basis of the test results. So none of the tests are useless.Trust your doctor and I think it will be helpful for you and for him.
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
6 Jul 08
I just find it weird that I started out with one diagnosis, then two and now I'm up to three possibles after a test that was supposed to help clear up between two. But now I'm at three plus I have to have more tests. It seems like I'm going in the wrong direction here.
@carolbee (16230)
• United States
5 Jul 08
I've been through alot of this inconvenience also and it's terribly bothersome. Doctor's try not to alarm the patient but what they don't realize is sending the patient for test after test is very upsetting. This doesn't help matters.
I had, notice I said had, a very good medical doctor. He forgot to mention I had a spot on one lung. When I found out he totally forgot to tell me, I was no longer a patient. Turns out I ingested a mold spore and means virtually nothing. I have a great eye doctor. He noticed something behind one eye. He did tons of tests and sent me to a specialist. It was a freckle behind my eye and meant nothing. No further testing needed.
Hope you get a clean bill of health. The stress all these tests create is enough to give anyone a heart attack.