Reading with your child...please help!
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
Singapore
August 8, 2008 5:03pm CST
My daughter is 19 months old. I try to read to her everyday. But she just wants to turn the pages quickly and be done with it. Then she'll pick up another book and do the same. What can I do to get her to stay at one page while I tell her the story, before moving on?
5 people like this
24 responses
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
8 Aug 08
Hi there SydneyHazelton
It is great that she picks up and looks at a book no matter how quickly she does it. I would say leave her be to look at the books how she wishes to. Maybe that is how she interprets how she sees you or other people reading. She will in time understand what books are all about. My eldest would never sit still to listen to me read at that age let alone pick a book up.
@revellanotvanella (4033)
• United States
9 Aug 08
My daughter is turning two the end of August and she still does that unless her sister is right there listening but the only way she will keep to the page is if I point out the different images on the page and relate it to something she knows, like if its a duck I will say, 'hey its Ming-Ming' (from Nick Jr. Wonder Pets) or if there is a mail box, hey its 'Mailbox, from Blue Clue!' and correlate it into a story for her, my other daughter is 3 1/2 and now she likes to be read to and many books she likes me to read, lol
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
One of the reasons why I ask is I wanted to know if there are any kids her age out there like my daughter. Thanks for telling me about your experience. She used to keep still when I tell her stories. But now she just wants to bounce on the bed or roll around before falling asleep. You are right about how she's interpreting how adults read. My mum and dad reads the papers aloud when I was young. They have been telling me that when I was about a year plus, I would pick up the newspaper and blabber baby talk as I flip the pages. Haha! I don't read loudly like them, so maybe that's why my daughter is flipping the pages and then putting it down.
1 person likes this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
9 Aug 08
To be honest it just sounds like she is more interested in doing something else right now, like jumping around as you say. I have 3 boys and quite often sit there reading a story to them at bedtime while they are doing something else but I always continue to the end of the book and they know exactly what I have read to them. They are listening to me even though they are also playing.
Wow, I have just realised that my children, although they are all male, are multi tasking, this has got to be a first hahaha
2 people like this
@tonythetard (59)
• United States
8 Aug 08
I used to sit her down and read a book out loud and show her the pictures after i was through reading the page (like they do in school) at first she wouldn't sit through an entire book, but i made it fun by adding special effects like growls or i'd act as if it was the funniest thing i've ever seen just to make her think that *I* was truly interested in what i was reading... eventually she got to where she would sit on my lap and let me read to her from there... from time to time though, she would still flip the pages, but now she's 4 and she seems to like to savor each book, asking questions about the pictures (as we do to her) and heh, now she asks me what *I* think will happen next and she'll tell me what *SHE* thinks will happen next... ah, it was so worth it.
2 people like this
@alori61 (344)
• United States
9 Aug 08
Aw who cares if you sound funny? You are building memories with your little girl that is what is important. My older daughters are 19, 20, and 21 and they still talk about how we sat down and read the baby sitters little sisters books (all of them) when they were 3, 4, and 5. We still have the books they fight over who gets them for thier kids when they have them. Build your memories with your little girl and ignore that you may look funny that's the times she'll remember and you both will cherish in the years to come. Believe me they grow up very very fast enjoy now
2 people like this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
That's wonderful. I have tried adding special effects and she seems more interested. But how many sound efffects can you add without sounding funny?
1 person likes this
@Sillychick (3275)
• United States
9 Aug 08
That's pretty common, and not to worry, it's ok. Get her some books with just a few words on each page, on topics she enjoys, and board books that she can look at by herself without destroying them. You don't have to read the words on the page. Just point to the pictures, talk to her about them, ask questions. Try to get her involved. If she still just wants to flip through quickly, don't push too much- that may turn her off to books entirely, at least for a while. Just continue to sit with her and try, and let her do it her way. Eventually she will become more interested and spend more time with each book.
2 people like this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
We have a couple of board books at home and she likes the lift the flap books, though she's not very dainty. Must remind her not to tear it up. I must her more of those. I will let her flip pages if that's how she likes it. Maybe she has photographic memory for all I know LOL!
1 person likes this
@alori61 (344)
• United States
9 Aug 08
At that age if your going to read the book the pages should have no more then two or three words on them and lots of pretty pictures to look at. If your wanting her to begin early reading then get books with just a couple words that go with the pictures. Thier attention span isn't that long, but you can instill a love of books and reading even at that age. As she gets older and her attention span increases you can start reading her books with more words on the page.
2 people like this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
Thanks for the great advice. I must go and look for more books with just a few words on them and move on from there, with more words as she grows older.
@wanderer086 (759)
•
9 Aug 08
She is a bit young to be listening to stories yet. let her look at the pictures and point to things and tell her what they are, how many there are and the different colours. This will start her off in her learning but take it slowly. She will learn at her own pace and eventually things will start to come together for her. Do not take any notice if someone says their child is more advanced than yours. Children do different things at different times. Just enjoy having her. She will soon be grown up and you will wonder where the time went.
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
You're right. Every child learns at their own pace. I must not be pressured to get my daughter to do things she's not ready for. And I must not compare my daughter with other kids. Thank you for your advice.
1 person likes this
@lipsticknladdles (814)
• Philippines
9 Aug 08
I think it is normal for children on this age range to behave that way. Just a quick scan on the page is good enough, as long as she sits with you and flips on the pages. Its ok to let her do what she wants so as to make the reading time (even if its just 'flipping the pages' time) a pleasurable experience. The fact that she stays focus on the activity is already a sign of a developing attention span.
Also, flipping pages is a good activity. It develops fine motor skills.
Before you know it, she will develop the interest to the stories =)
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
I guess "flipping the pages" time is also bonding time with her. And I must make the effort to make it a pleasurable experience like you mentioned.
1 person likes this
@academic2 (7000)
• Uganda
10 Aug 08
Dont push her, forgoodness sake, she is not yet even 2 years! You are making the poor little thing bite off more than she can chew-just by turning over pages, i feel that is a big achievement for a 19 month old!
1 person likes this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
10 Aug 08
I'm not pushing it. I know that she is still young. I'm still letting her turn pages.
@rogue13xmen13 (14402)
• United States
9 Aug 08
It is rather hard to read to children at that age. I have that same problem with my nephew. I am lucky if I can fit one story in with him. He will not sit still for a story. I usually just put on a film for him, and be done with it.
@rogue13xmen13 (14402)
• United States
10 Aug 08
When he turns 3, he might actually be more behaved and he will pay attention to what I am reading to him.
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
I know that it's hard. But I do hope you will continue trying...
1 person likes this
@kareng (61316)
• United States
9 Aug 08
Your daughter is showing an interest in books so I wouldn't worry too much. You have to remember that children have a short attention span. Make sure the text in the books are simple when you read to her. You should choose stories that will be quick to read.
You may want to try tactics like letting her turn the page. Make a game out of it by telling her you have to read first, and when she hears the ding sound that means turn the page and her turn to do it! Use a bell or just make a ding-ding sound or some other silly sound.
Another option is to let her have a turn to read to you. I realize she can't read, but let her tell you the story she sees from the pictures. This is a great way for children to learn and keeps them interested in books.
Good luck and have fun reading to your child!
1 person likes this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
I think the bell might work. Will try it out. Thank you for the suggestion! I never thought of that.
1 person likes this
@kate635 (126)
• Philippines
9 Aug 08
It's normal for their age. The best thing to do is give her some old colorful magazines so it's just okay if she tears it. During their age they also like to touch everything as they are still discovering the feel of everything around them. While she is enjoying in her page scanning, sit beside her and do your own reading also. It doesn't matter if it is orally or just through your mind. The important thing is that you are instilling in the mind of the child that reading is important. Children tends to imitate what their parents do. You will just discover that even if you are not doing it, they will pretend to read even if they do not know what is written on the page. I suggest you also play some classical music on the background because this relaxes the child. You may also read to her aloud while she is sleeping, she can hear it and the story will be absorb. Always tell her also that you love and care for her and will be there always. I did this to may kid, and one day when he was able to speak already, he did just the same thing to me and I was really touched.
1 person likes this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
The power of the subconscious mind... I have yet to explore this territory. I think I will try this method. Thank you for making my discussion thread so interesting!
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
8 Aug 08
My daughter is 18 months old and for the most part she is the same way. Once in awhile she will let me read to her, but not too often. I was told that even making the effort is beneficial. Try just sitting with her on your lap and let her flip through the book. Point out what the different pictures are to her and try to act excited about it. At this age it is the pictures that are exciting to them and not so much the story. Pretty soon she will want you to read the words too.
2 people like this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
It's a relief to know that my daughter is pretty normal. I will continue to make the effort to read to her every day. Maybe I should get her more picture books.
1 person likes this
@savypat (20216)
• United States
9 Aug 08
Watch out, don't make this unpleasent for her, go to your library or book store and let her choose at least one of the books you get. 19mos can have a very short attention span, Make it a bed time treat, but don't force anything she'll come around. My folks use to read out loud at the dinner table, of course we kids were not to interested so we ate our dinner and then we excused. But after awhile they started reading books that were interesting to us, just a chapter a night and pretty soon we were begging for the reading. Just like soap operas. We also learned to read so we didn't have to wait for the grownups. To this day 60 years later we are all avoid readers. LOL
1 person likes this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
Yes. I must make is a fun experience for her. We do go to the library and bookstores sometimes. But she just wants to run through the aisles. Haha! I don't understand her fascination with aisles, I think she will love mazes..
I think reading aloud might help her get more interested in reading. Thanks for your advice.
@devylan (695)
• United States
13 Aug 08
Yes, she is at the age when she is trying to be more and more independent. My twenty-month-old son just recently started climbing out of his car seat, and then out of the car, completely by himself (after I unbuckle the straps for him of course). One suggestion I have for you is to try to read to your daughter at times when she is occupied with something else maybe. For instance, I sometimes read to my son while he's taking his bath. He may be preoccupied with splashing in the water and playing with his tub-time toys, but he is still getting the benefit of hearing me talk, and I still show him the pages and point to the words, just in case he decides to look up at certain points in the story. Or, you could try giving her a picture book to pretend read while you read her the other book.
1 person likes this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
13 Aug 08
If your son learn to climb out of the car, my daughter decided that the view from the top of the table is better. She climbed the living room table on her own today . I have to keep watch on her all the time. Anyway, I think your idea is a great one - She does not have to look at the book I am reading to her, she can hold onto her own book while I read to her. I have gotten so many different advice from the myLot community, it's been wonderful having this discussion. Thanks for your advice!
1 person likes this
@fcangel9 (51)
• United States
9 Aug 08
at 19 months their attention span isnt that great, try the books that have the built in projectors that show scenes of the books on the walls. those keep my son's interests better than anything else. Keep your head up, at least she is showing some kind of interest in them, some kids bypass books altogether.
1 person likes this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
Built-in projectors? I have never seen those. Could you direct me a website which showcases those kind of books? Many thanks!
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
9 Aug 08
It is nice that you started reading to your daughter early... but most of the time... it is useless... because kids that age prefer to just look at the pictures... i tried reading to my two year old daughter... but she won't even listen to me... she would rather play with the book... or pretend that she is reading it herself...
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
My daughter plays with her books too. I think your daughter pretending to read it herself is good. My girl does that too.
@irishidid (8687)
• United States
9 Aug 08
I would get her picture books that have maybe one word per page. Make sure they are kid proof.
Everyone says to read to your kids, but there are some they do not tolerate it no matter how much the parent wishes they would. I have one that reads regularly, one that reads if he's really interested in the book and one who avoids reading unless she has to. I read to all of them when they were small.
1 person likes this
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
I'm trying to get hold of more picture books for her. Thanks for the advice and also telling me your personal experience with your kids.
@phoenix25 (1541)
• United States
9 Aug 08
I had the same problem with my son when he was young. He is now 4 and has just recently gotten to the point where he will actually let me read to him. My family would say, "Why don't you read to him," and I would tell them that he would just flip the pages too fast for me to read. She is young and doesn't understand. At this young age, you could just talk about the pictures. You could point out animals or colors on the pages. This will still teach your child some things and your child will still get the benefit of spending time with you and hearing you talk to her.
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
Yup! I must talk to her more about each picture she sees. You're right when you say that she'll benefit from hearing me talk. Hopefully she'll pick up the vocabulary.
@elaine5004 (84)
• United States
9 Aug 08
Might try getting her involved with the story, asking her about colors, shapes,characters or have her tell you her version. If she has heard the book often enough, the version she remembers may be more entertaining than you think. It's not always the activity she will remember, but the one on one time you spend with her. I know looking back on my childhood, the things I remember the most was the quality time I had with someone I loved and felt loved by. I spent a lot of time with my grandmother when I was real little and she would take time for tea parties, drawing pictures or dancing around the room singing to me some funny little rhyme she would make up as she went along. Wouldn't trade those memories for anything. I stayed with her the first 6 years of my life and every chance I had after that.
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
Thank you for telling me your experience. I know that it's not just about reading to them or flipping pages, but it's teh quality time spent with my daughter that is most important. I do sing and dance with her a lot. I want her to have fond memories of her childhood with me.
@reckon21 (3479)
• Philippines
9 Aug 08
Let the baby follow her wishes. If she just want to read
by looking at the colors and shapes, let her be. It's too
early for her to learn. Let her tender mind roam the world
of wonders. Don't hurry her, she is still developing her
awareness of the physical world around her. Just relax and
take is easy.
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
You've hit the key word her - RELAX! Sometimes I'm just so worried about how my daughter is growing and developing that I forget to relax and let her be at this age.
@chenmeiyi (972)
• China
9 Aug 08
i think ur daughter is just too little to learn,she is just almost half and one year
old.for her,she doesn't know the conception of books and it is the pictures that
attracts her. she is inpatient to turn to another page to fresh her sense of vision.
maybe when she grows to three or four years old,u can teach her something and read
together with her.it is so enjoyable to read with kid and witness their process
of growing.now u can turn on ur player and let her listen some short stories to
cultivate her sense of listening.maybe she will be interested in that.i also love
girls very much and i want to have two lovely daughters in the future.
take care,hope ur lovely daughter will grow up healthily and happily.
@SydneyHazelton (4586)
• Singapore
9 Aug 08
Thanks for your great suggestion! I used to let her listen to stories on a CD. But it got scratched and the CD could not be used anymore. I will try get some more of those.