Should my cousin refuse or not?

@akangirl (2436)
India
January 26, 2009 4:18pm CST
My cousin recently came to me with this problem.She works as a sales executive of ESPRIT in one of the biggest mall of here.Now she has a boyfriend who is quite rich but works in Tommy Hilfiger.He is doing it for friends and experience and later he will join his dad business.Now the problem is he wants her to leave her job as he says you stay on foot whole day, i don't like you too work so hard for money.Please leave the job i will pay you every month Rs. 13,000 and he is very sweet ,he never let her spend any money.She have collection of expensive dresses, perfumes given by him . Now she asks whether she should leave the job go back to studying which she left in the middle with help of her boyfriend or just refuse him? My suggestion was that she should accept and leave the job which have affected her health a lot and complete her graduation.She is lucky if her boyfriend wants to take care of her. What do you suggest?
2 people like this
21 responses
• Canada
27 Jan 09
I have to post again. Money is never an issue in regards to school that is what student loans are for. She should do what ever student does and take out a loan to go to school and get her education. She doesn't start paying back the loan till she's done school and after she's done she'll be able to find a suitable job for herself. You take out a big enough loan to support you for food etc. But I don't buy the entire 'Well I didn't have the money so I couldn't continue my education. " that's a cop out in my eyes. Many students take out loans its not an unheard of thing. If she really wants to advance in this world and in this economy she'll do it on her own. If she wants the easy way out she'll quit her job and have the sugar daddy pay for everything. However what happens when they break up she's left with paying for whatever schooling she has to pay for. You can't see the future and neither can I but I'd rather have my behind covered then have no safety net below to catch me if I fall.
1 person likes this
@akangirl (2436)
• India
27 Jan 09
Its not easy to get loan here in India. Loan is given if the family is good enough to repay back, have own house, solid income.Its nothing less than harassment to get loan.Education is not easy as in your country dear.Here most parents think why waste money on educating girl,just till 10th is enough to get a job then they are married away sometimes to a guy who we she don't even get to see. You are blessed that you are not born here. I remember when i went with my mom to bank for study loan . Bank manager after making us visit him thrice refused and his last advice to my mom was " why are wasting money on your girl education, what will they do of education later on they will have to get married and do household chores instead teach her to do household work". So i made a promise to myself no matter what i will work and educate my younger sister.Left school and started working at the age of sixteen. I have missed so much but i won't let anything like this happen to my younger sister.
• Canada
27 Jan 09
i am lucky however there's a thing called freedom of choice if you're not allowed to have that where your at the best thing for your sister is to get out of your country and come to one where she is able to actually build a life not only for herself but for her future children. That would be the best thing for her. She can come here or go to the states on a student visa. If you want what's best for her, it's best that she no longer live in your country if opportunities aren't available there. Is it easy, nothings ever easy but if it's something you want it's always worth the fight. Again what happens when she gets dropped by her man. You haven't answered that. Which makes it all the more reason why she should stay with her job and not rely on this man when he could easily leave her and screw her over. If he loves her he would have married her already.
1 person likes this
• Canada
27 Jan 09
I've known students who don't so much as have a penny to their name. This is where Financial Aid comes in and where the student loans as well. It is do able but she should do it on her own so she can have a sense of independence and accomplishment that she was able to do it ALL by herself. Again Money isn't everything especially when it isn't yours to spend. What happens when his money isn't there to save her?
1 person likes this
@anjel016 (329)
• Philippines
27 Jan 09
If I were your cousin, I'll grab this opportunity. You already said that her work already affected her health a lot. Working that much is useless if you'll end up getting sick. Her boyfriend already offered her a good life. In addition, being able to finish her studies will greatly help for her to have a beautiful life even if someday her boyfriend leaves her.
1 person likes this
@akangirl (2436)
• India
27 Jan 09
Yes that's what i suggested.They have been together for 3 years and that's long enough to trust.Now he is deeply troubled about her health and if he wants to pamper her.What's wrong in that? why always its thought that guy always help because they want something back from you. He
@anjel016 (329)
• Philippines
27 Jan 09
I understand what her boyfriend is trying to say. It's not like her boyfriend is making her to do such thing without any reason at all. Most probably her boyfriend just want to make her safe and avoid any harm. In addition, I think her boyfriend really loves her so much that he does not want his girlfriend to suffer. Three years is already a long time, your cousin should notice that. This issue is the same with my friend's parents. Her father, after their marriage, does not want her mother to work any longer. Her mother agreed with her husband. And now they are still living together - happy.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
27 Jan 09
if he is willing to do it then she should go back to school, she is very lucky to have someone like that in her life.
1 person likes this
@akangirl (2436)
• India
27 Jan 09
He wants her to quit because because the work is very tiring. She goes to store at 11 am and comes back at 10 pm , so she hardly have time to study so she left her studies. Yeah she is very lucky to have him not all guys want to help without forcing any conditions.She is quite lucky
@underdogtoo (9579)
• Philippines
27 Jan 09
I am not one who knows how to give sage advice but this I do know, when one is dependent of another, it can create a lot more problems than it can solve. If the boyfriend decides to find another girlfriend your cousin will be left high and dry. Still, she can go back to school with the help of the boyfriend and become independent later on. Cheers!!
1 person likes this
@akangirl (2436)
• India
27 Jan 09
Yeah you are right that's why i am suggesting her to grab the opportunity before he changes his mind.Even if he leaves her then atleast she would be graduate and find good job rather than working like slaves in stores.
@celticeagle (168256)
• Boise, Idaho
26 Jan 09
I think she should be independent. She has a good job. If the man has total say what does she have? She is at his beck and call. For a while this could be fun-even exciting. But, after that what? She gets bored and he is ademate that she not get another job, she gets indignant and he throws her out or worse. What then? I think she should stay with her job and be independent and her own person, not totally dependant on him. No,No,No! No matter how sweet he is now.
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (168256)
• Boise, Idaho
27 Jan 09
Maybe so but atleast she has a job. In this society a man who wants to take care of a woman alots of times will turn out to be controlling. So, if she quits her job then I wish her well.
@akangirl (2436)
• India
27 Jan 09
Working as sales girl is not considered a good job in our society. Only less educated people do it. She haven't passed her high school even.
• Canada
26 Jan 09
She should refuse for one reason manily. Every women should be able to support themselves. Once we put all our eggs into one basket that basket often falls and once it does the eggs have no where to go but down with the ship so to speak. If she has no back up plans and essentially gives away the good job she has now then she's setting herself up for possible disaster. I think that if he loves her and cares for her he would never make her have to make this decision. First and most important thing is that she supports her self and continues to do so till the day she is married. Nothing is for certain not even marriage. But at least after your married and something arises you can get the money back that you lost .. this situation spells problems for me. I think she should refuse and should persue her own career which could end up with her making more money than she is. If she doesn't then lord knows what kind of catching up she'll have to do after her and he are over with.
1 person likes this
• Canada
26 Jan 09
On top of that.. Money ISN"T everything especially when it ISN"T yours to begin with.
1 person likes this
@akangirl (2436)
• India
27 Jan 09
Yeah you are right by your point of view but i strongly think that he is trusted guy and also he is not forcing her to live with him or get married to him.They are very good friends too. And also there is career scope if are not even a graduate and who wants to stay working stores. Getting work in these stores are easy as so many new mall are opening so she can go back whenever she want. But serious she hates her sales job
@amitksing (1323)
• India
27 Jan 09
I think your cousin should give a sweet NO to the offer by her boy friend. The guy has shown his care for her by everything he has done for her so far. He is also very worried for her and doesn't want her to work very hard for small amount of money (as per his standards). I think she needs to work to keep herself on her own feet and not just be dependent on her partner. There are other benefits also, by working, she can keep herself busy as against doing nothing. It also comes to self esteem, if the guy is doing so much for him, she should value it and not be a burden on him. But if she is having health problems and/or she left her studies in middle, I think she can accept his offer. After all, health is above everything else, and studies need to be completed (very necessary)!
1 person likes this
@ladysakurax (1161)
• Canada
27 Jan 09
I think you just gave her the best suggestion. Not alot of people have the chance to have monney and study. She should put the pride aside and accept the offer. He does this because he wants her to have a better lifestyle than working in a clothe store. I don`t see why she doesn`t want to accept. Instead of wasting huge amounts of monney on expensive cars or other stupidity, he is helping someone for a good cause. I just think it would be a waste to not accept while so many poor people want to go to school and don`t have the help needed. Your cousin has a chance and she should accept it.
1 person likes this
@benhilo (871)
• Tripoli, Libya
27 Jan 09
I think your advice is sound enough for her to follow.
1 person likes this
@murugezh (273)
• India
27 Jan 09
If your cousin's boyfriend really love her and care her to marry or for what? that is not clear here..but when I read about him I do understand there will mutual understanding. But have to know the deal correctly before making decisions, that is my kind request. Some time richer may have two way decisions. You have to be very careful before making decision. I'll say think twice inquire twice about the boy and his family then make decision please.
1 person likes this
@djemba (767)
• India
27 Jan 09
well i don't think its a good idea for her to quit her job just because her boyfriend is offering to support her because its always better to be independent and not pressurize the guy ...if the job is really affecting her health then she could give it a thought but otherwise if i were her i would refuse politely, careful enough not to hurt him but make him understand .....
@MythiliK (138)
• Switzerland
27 Jan 09
Hey gal, once when she starts accepting his money, then she may need to accept what ever he demands later. This is what my instinct tells. May be he is good and trust worthy, but human nature keeps changing. After few years he may think your cousin as a burden. All of a sudden if he keeps helping your cousin, is she ready to face it? Is her family capable of managing such situations? If so, then she can go ahead leaving her job and accept his money and proceed. If NOT, then THINK twice.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Jan 09
I dont understand the whole thing but if she is living with him why should she needs to work? if they are'nt living together why he's supporting her, don't know, if i were hers i'll stay on my job, because i can't be sure the relationship, you know relationship could be broken, u think she should stay the job...
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Jan 09
If he's rich then she should go for it. But only if he's good looking and has a nice personality cause if he's one of those stuck up snobs then def. dump him. And make sure he's going to take care of her and that he loves her no matter what.
1 person likes this
@Galena (9110)
26 Jan 09
well that's up to her, isn't it. if she likes to work, then she should keep her job, regardless. if she is happy to have someone partially financially responsible for her, she could take a job with less hours. but it's an old fashioned view to see that a man should support a woman financially regardless.
1 person likes this
@gracie04 (4549)
• Philippines
27 Jan 09
I guess your cousin shouldn't quit her job.. if her boyfriend really wants to help her out then do it without any condition..
1 person likes this
@kedves (728)
27 Jan 09
There is a thin line between someone helping and supporting a loved one and someone owning a loved one .. I am very sceptical of his reasoning .. they are not married she has not got his kids .. why does he want to control her and own her ? sounds as if he wants to take away her independence and have her rely on him totally for everything.. even in marriage you need a little independence .. I would tell her no do not give up everything and have him own her ..
1 person likes this
@Jlyn22 (204)
• United States
27 Jan 09
I think if her boyfriend really wants to help her out he should without her having to quit her job. If she wants to get back in school then she could get fewer hours at work until shes done with school and can find a better job. Its so hard to find places to work now a days so I wouldnt just up and quit if I was her. Who knows what could happen they could end up breaking up and then what would she do?
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
27 Jan 09
I have to say I'm alittle confused. First, if he loves her, why doesn't he just marry her? Second, I don't see anything wrong with her working. I don't think her "health" is an issue either. I worked a job since I was 14 years old and still graduated from high school. I worked full time and paid my own way through college. I guess I don't understand why she can't work AND go to school? That just doesn't make sense to me. Your cousin is very lucky to have a boyfriend that wants to take care of her, but in all reality, why doesn't he take care of her as a wife instead. If they love each other and have already been together for 3 years. Why no just get married and then they can build their life together?
• Canada
27 Jan 09
I don't know... If she were going to leave the job and just be a housewife or let him take care of her, then I think that she should refuse. But since is planning to go back and complete her education if she leaves her job, I'm a little more ambivalent. The education can be really helpful for promotions and stuff. On the other hand, I don't think it's good to be wholly dependent on another person economically because it can screw up the dynamics of the relationship. It could also put her in a vulnerable position should he decide to leave her. Maybe she could compromise? Since her boyfriend has offered to help her out financially, maybe she could work fewer hours for the time being and go back to school part-time.
1 person likes this