Is it alright for a man to cry???
By mariedenae
@mariedenae (335)
United States
February 24, 2009 12:38pm CST
I get so many people saying " Men aren't supposed to cry" or telling their sons that "Boy's don't cry" or telling that they are a sissy or soft for shedding a few tears. My husband cries when he has the emotion to cry and I don't see anything wrong with it. I do think it's a little weird if a man cries more than I do, and I cry a lot! lol But I don't think it's odd for a man to cry.
I will be honest, I don't like it when my 3 year old son cries a lot, being he is a boy and he actually cries more than my daughter. But I know that right now, this is just his age and the things that toddlers do. If he keeps crying when he is around 7 or 8 then I might let him know it's okay to cry sometimes, but that big boys should not cry as much.
So what do you guys think? Is it alright for men to cry?
4 people like this
26 responses
@carrine (2743)
• Philippines
24 Feb 09
there is a saying: "boys dont cry but men do".. i mean why not? crying is not a minus point of being a man, a tough one. and we have to admit that men are so high pride, they all want to be the best, the strong..
if a person dont want to cry, they will become mean person.. why? because all the burdens, failures, disappointments in life, frustrations, all of those are inside his heart and mind, once its there, it will keep on reminding him the things that had happens to him. so they're having a hard time to moved on, they kept on blaming other people who made them frustrate and so on.. i have a cousin who is like that, he has this kind of attitude,, look at him now? he has no job, i mean the wife is the bread winner of the family, and hes the yaya of their kids.. LOL knowing that hes very intelligent man.
well life is a matter of choice. maybe he chooses that kind of life he has right now.. good luck to them :)
1 person likes this
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
26 Feb 09
Yah, in those situations, it's the best thing to do :) hopefully they will change :)
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I agree... by men not allowing themselves to let it go and express themselves in crying, they do become frustrated and from what I have seen, more aggressive. I hope that your cousin gets better at expressing himself, it would be great for his wife and his kids to know that he can be a good man AND be able to cry :)
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
Yes! I agree, it IS an attractive trait in a man. For one it lets me know that he is secure enough in himself to allow the tears to fall, AND that he is secure in me and comfortable with crying in front of me. It actually makes my heart melt when my husband has tears in his eyes with pride over our kids or something special he has done for me. :)
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
You've got that right. It took my husband a little while to show me his soft side but when he did I was really grateful and felt honored
@katsmeow1213 (28716)
• United States
24 Feb 09
I've never told my boys not to cry, not in that sense anyways. I do say the usual "Stop that crying or I'll give you something to cry about" sort of thing, and I'm also very stern on telling them not to cry over a punishment, they did the crime, so they have to accept the punishment without crying or whining. But I've never told them they're sissy's for crying, or that boys can't cry.
My husband doesn't cry often, but he has been known to cry. I think he's only cried a few times since I've known him, and it was awkward to see him cry, I wasn't sure what I thought about it.
I think it's okay for men to cry, just not very often.
1 person likes this
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
Thanks Kats!
I too, have told my son not to cry for things he knew he shouldn't have done, and I agree, it's okay just as long as it's not THAT often. Like I said, if a guy cries more than I do then it's a little strange... I guess I feel jealous, lol, because I am the one supposed to be comforted and all emotional all the time, but I am always comforting you... somethings off here! lol But as long as it's occasional, I don't mind it at all, gives me an extra excuse to love on my guy :)
@gicolet (1702)
• United States
24 Feb 09
Yes it's alright for men to cry. To cry is human. Like you i also think that it's weird if a man cries more than i do. My ex b.f. was like that and he was 3 yrs my junior. It was a turn off. I wanted a man not a baby. But occasionally when my husband cries over a real emotional situation it actually turns me on. LOL I mean I kind of like it when my husband shows emotion. Men are thought of to be stronger than women but when a man cries it only shows that there is a serious emotion there that I very much would like to take care of by making him feel better.
1 person likes this
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
Yes! Doesn't it make you feel good knowing you can be there for him too like he is there for you when you are crying? I love it (not that he's in pain) but that he trusts me to lift him up :)
@strawberrychocodahi (4818)
• Philippines
24 Feb 09
Men are said to be made of steel, not easily cry. But for me, it is okey for them to cry as long as they don't sob and been crying for 15 minutes or so because i will definitely mind now. I don't like to see men starting from teen to yuppies to be crying like a baby.
I mean it's ok to see a tear rolling down their eyes. All they need is a pat in the shoulder and a good advice and then stop crying. But to cry for more than 15 minutes like crazy or like a kid, oh boy, i don't think so, it's a turn off for me.
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
LOL You said it, crying for too long it starts to get a little uncomfortable. Even when my husband has cried, it's never been longer than a minute or two. :)
@lorraine27 (271)
•
24 Feb 09
sure it is there human also are they not. i never think it wrong for a man to cry and why would anyone. they have feeling, they get hurt, they feel the lost of someone close to them and they get there hearts broken. it shows that they have feelings, it just that they dont show it in the form of crying as must as us girls do.
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
Yes, I agree Lorraine, it's normal and okay for them to cry. But you know how some people are, not allowing men to cry at all. I don't think it's fair to not let them have release. Crying is normal :)
@celticeagle (165954)
• Boise, Idaho
25 Feb 09
Well, men were given tear ducts weren't they? Now why do you suppose they were? Not for milk squirting! Men who don't cry I would seriously wonder about. They have emotions they care. And who wants a man who doesn't care?
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
26 Feb 09
You are right celtic lol, "milk squirting" lol. Yes, I know that, and seems a lot of us on here know that, but there are some who seem to think though they have them they aren't supposed to use them :) But, personally, I am glad my husband uses his :0)
@deejean06 (1952)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I think it's ok for men to cry. Maybe much of the rage in this world would be gone if men did cry a bit more often. Maybe the rage is pent up emotion which needs an outlet. I have only seen my husband cry once, and seen my father cry once. Because men have this image that they don't cry it's absolutely heartbreaking when they do.
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
26 Feb 09
Thank you Dee, and thank you for sharing your memories as well :)
@deejean06 (1952)
• United States
26 Feb 09
Thanks so much for sharing - they were two wonderful memories of your family.
@dinkydo (14)
•
24 Feb 09
Yes it is part of a person's make up to cry when they are sad or even happy. It releases chemicals which would otherwise build up in the body and cause problems. It is a tremendous relief after you have had a good cry, you feel so much better. It causes health problems if you hold your tears back - tears were put there to act as a release mechanism to our bodies to control stress levels.
1 person likes this
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
24 Feb 09
It's funny you should say that.
I have often times told my husband that "I just need to cry". He would look at me strange, and I Would tell him that I just feel so overwhelmed and pent up that I need to have a good cry and get it all out. And you know, afterward I feel so much better.
There is a song that says "Last night, me and my woman, we cried together" and when I have those times that I just need to cry and I am hurting or feeling filled with anxiety, nothing makes me feel better than when my husband cries with me!
Tears are a release for the soul! I will tell some of my lady friends that the next time they say "A man's not supposed to cry"
Thanks for that answer!!!
@cvrajan (354)
• India
25 Feb 09
Every man has some amount of femininity in him. Every woman has some amount of masculinity in her. The proportion varies from person to person. Where a man is more manly with very limited femininity element in him will not cry. On the other hand, a man with more femininity in him is likely to cry. Personally, I don't like men crying.
Great religious masters, who overflow with love for God are seen crying frequently. Chaitanya Deva, Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, his very manly and proud disciple Vivekananda and numerous male Hindu Saints used to cry when they get overwhelmed with Bhakti -- love of God. I think Jesus Christ too cried.
They are at a higher spiritual level; their cry is not connected with mundane attachment with the worldly affairs and hence are adorable.
@GloriaSimpson (10)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I think men have the same emotions as women, but have been led to believe that they are weak for crying. For ages, men have been taught to be the strong one, the fixer, the glue that holds things together when the going gets rough.
Men, women, children, everyone, should cry. It releases anger,and sadness, as well as happiness. It better to cry a puddle then to release these emotions in an agressive way.
When my only daughter got married, my husband cried like a baby when he had to let her go. How could I feel awkward when I felt the same way.
Smiling...
G
@butterfly6305 (47)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I think it's perfectly okay for men to cry. I think that there is a huge stigma about it, and I don't believe it's right for our society to tell them they can't. My brother cried up until he was around 13-14 years old. But he has very sensitive feelings, and I could just tell when it was going to start happening, and try to get him out of the room. I didn't like to watch him be made fun of, just because he got his feelings hurt. But he did grow out of it, and now he is a daddy-to-be, and extremely faithful to the woman he is with. He became my best friend, and is an incredible man to have around. He seems to understand where women come from in their emotions, and has a wonderful shoulder to cry on.
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
25 Feb 09
Butterfly, thanks for commenting, and welcome to mylot! I am a little selfishly flatterer (lol) that you chose my topic as your first, thanks :)
Your brother sounds like a great, if not better man for being able to express those feelings that others teach men to shun. It's great that he had a sister like you to keep him from being made fun because that could have caused him to tuck those emotions and he probably wouldn't have been the man he is today. So Kudos to you!
Isn't it odd how society can deem what's good or bad, and what's healthy or unhealthy about people and everyone just follow suit? It's crazy. I don't mind a man crying, nor do I mind my sons crying (they are just 3 and 1) and I won't mind when they get older. I think I'd only get a little bothered if they cried ALL the time or at the drop of a hat. But other than that, it makes them stronger men :)
@evsoriano (166)
• Philippines
25 Feb 09
yes, its alright for a man to cry. everyone of us have emotions/feelings, when we are sad or deepress, we usually cry. i dont believe that "men aren't supposed to cry". i for my self, i do cry especially when im lost someone that loved
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
25 Feb 09
Thanks for responding, and welcome to myLot :)
I give you kudos for letting us know that you do cry. Real men cry and are not ashamed of it! :) I am glad you are one of those!
@dropofrain (1167)
• India
25 Feb 09
Though men are not supposed to cry but with the change in times men can cry. I think even they have the right to carry out their emotional outburst. I am totally against the saying that men can't cry.
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I like your name :)
And I agree, men should be given the same emotional leeway as women. They should be allowed to get the hurt feelings or whatever the emotion out. :)
@gracie04 (4549)
• Philippines
25 Feb 09
I see nothing wrong with men crying.. in fact, it's a lovable trait.. because there are only few men admit that they are deeply hurt..and yes, they are human being too.. they have the right to cry whenever they feel like letting out their emotions.. i've seen my brother cried and it happened when he got married two years ago..
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
25 Feb 09
That's exactly right. :)
My husband has cried for VERY specific reasons, our wedding, the birth of our 3 kids, and times when the emotions were just too much to handle. Men crying is a beautiful thing, because it shows they have not lost touch with humanity.
@mermaidivy (15395)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I think man don't cry for nothing like they won't cry when he is mad with women but women cry when they get emotional. I think men will cry for some certain things like if they lost somebody really close like parents or wives etc. I won't say they "cannot" cry and I won't say they are weak if they cry for those certain things.
@Pleiades (846)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I asked this question several months ago to a man I was getting to know better. The answer he gave me was one that I would have expected from a man like him, "It's not very soldierly to cry...not in public". Sure, he's in that macho world where emotions are carefully gaurded. But, I think if he was in another team, such as one that sees heavy combat he'd feel differently. Tears are an outwardly expression of our inner feelings. Actually, I feel stupid that crying can come so much easier to females. The night before he returned from his leave, I was in his arms, crying. He didn't shed a single tear or get choked up with regret or emotions. That doesn't mean he didn't feel it inside.
Now, my exhusband wasn't afraid to let the tears flow from his eyes. It was fine, but once he day he was mocking my oldest son and so when it was the ex's turn to cry, we (as the rest of the family) had no compassion for him.
It's natural for a person to cry, after all animals do it.
*Pleiades
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
25 Feb 09
Wow, not very "soldierly"? Most of the men in my family were soldiers and even they would cry when they were going on leave again. Wow.
That's pretty harsh of your ex to mock your son, when he allows HIMself to cry! That's just ridiculous! I don't blame you for not being empathetic to him; he wasn't that way for your child.
Thanks for responding :)
@liferokz1 (45)
• India
25 Feb 09
Crying is something tat makes u come out of bad feelings.It is bad saying tat a man should not cry.The who never cry is nopt a complete human.Girls r equal to boys by all means.Crying is common to all.its very good to health sometimes.
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
25 Feb 09
Yes, you are so right. The sooner we all realize that guys are just like girls and should be able to express their feelings the better. That's not to say that I want them ALL the time crying, but just when they need to :)
Thanks for responding, and welcome to myLot :)
@candy811123 (334)
• China
25 Feb 09
A man who is a famous singing star in Hongkong has sung a song named "man to cry is not fault".And so many men in KTV like to choose this song. Maybe this song has express their thinking. In today society, men have to endure many kinds of stresses,such as living stress,working stress and so on. They need method to relax themselves. Someone choose to cry. We should understand them, I think.
@mariedenae (335)
• United States
25 Feb 09
I think so too. Besides if a man didn't cry at least once I would think something was wrong with them. It is amazing to know that the same stipulations about men crying carries over into other countries! It's so amazing to me! We shouldn't have these rules against men, they are but human and have emotions too :)