Weight Gain: Is it really a big deal?
By the_dutchess
@the_dutchess (2610)
Philippines
February 28, 2009 1:27pm CST
Not being exaggerated, but it's like every minute I see ads and discussions about issues on weight gain, dieting, weight loss programs and surgeries. I'm like, so what if a person gained weight? Is there really a big problem with that?
Honestly, I do think that this is one of the reasons why there's teenagers and young girls who suffers from anorexia, bulimia, and other eating disorders. It's the stigma that less fat, less weight is sexy; which is so wrong 'cause I do believe people should see that it's being healthy that is right and it's seeing the inner beauty that is really important. Be comfortable with our own size and weight, whatever it is.
7 people like this
40 responses
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
28 Feb 09
Absolutely!!! So much pressure is put on people these days and I hear kids as young as 4, in my dance classes saying, "I have to eat less, I am getting fat!" I kid you not!! I cannot believe it!
I was always very careful with my own daughter, and she was a little bit overweight, no matter what we did, but we never put her on a diet nor mentioned her weight. Now, as an adult, she is fine, on her own. She never did anything about it until she realized that she had to and I am proud of her.
Being in the dance business, eating disorders are rampant, and it is not JUST in dance but in cheering, sports, martial arts, etc., and many times I blame the parents and their coaches or teachers. I have heard some tell a student that they are fat and need to lose weight.
I have never told a student to lose weight, even if they should. I have told them that I find their stamina lacking and made suggestions on foods that will help them in that sense, as well as what to avoid (sugar, junk snacks, etc.).
I would have a nutritionist come, once per year, and it was an open meeting for all parents and teens and anyone they wanted to bring. It was a big help because I noticed many of my students become more cautious with eating badly and not trying to starve.
I told a student, once, who asked me if she was too fat for dance. She was perfect and her mother was concerned. Instead I told her that if she did not eat enough and properly, that she would never be a dancer as dancers must be as strong, have great stamina, etc., as top athletes. She said, "Oh, I never thought of it that way."
I NEVER, ever mentioned weight or made comments on a student's physical appearance and when they self-deprecate, I stop them in their tracks and tell them that I know what I am talking about and that they are great the way they are.
Parents are no help, even when they do not realize it. A mother, who is constantly complaining about her weight and looks, is giving the same message to the child, without realizing it. We must be careful about what we say about ourselves in front of kids and teens. They will follow suit. If you believe in yourself, they will learn to be that way, too.
1 person likes this
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
Hi nanajanet! I adore you for doing the right thing. Telling people to be healthy and if they're overweight, telling them in the right away and not hurting their feelings. It's just so sad that kids as young as 4 years old cares to their weight as much like a 30-year-old person. It's really important to maintain the right weight and not to be over or underweight 'cause like you said, for activity reasons like dancing and stuff and for us to avoid any illnesses. Hope that you'll continue to be a good parent and teacher
1 person likes this
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
1 Mar 09
Thank you, and thanks for the BR. My take on it is, unless a child is so obese that it is not healthy, and then I would approach the parents and not the child, as it is up to them, not the child, then they are fine and who cares if they are the "perfect" size. Who is to say what that is and is there even such a thing?
I never grew up concerned about my weight and only started thinking about it when I was in my mid-twenties and had gained weight from pregnancy. I was not as thin as many other dancers, yet, I was slender. I did not look in the mirror and see those skinny girls and think that I wanted to be like them. I wanted boobs and to look like a woman.
My parents never once made complaints about their size and weight and we never heard talk of it. Now, maybe that was that generation because we did not have all the idiotic images that you speak of being shoved down everyone's throats these days.
I really fear for the health of so many young people. Even if they do not have eating disorders, some start smoking to remain thin. I had a friend who continued to smoke through her pregnancy, and one who did not. They were pregnant at the same time.
Both still smoke the but one who did not stop did so because she did not want to gain a lot of weight during pregnancy. Her own vanity was more important than the health of her child. Even her mother was upset because she smoked during her first two pregnancies and they both had asthma. The other two were fine.
I have seen all the crap that people will put into their bodies and I have seen a student wolf down almost half a chocolate cake and then disappear into the bathroom at a baby shower and be in there for a while, coming out smelling like mouthwash and vomit.
None of this will really change until the media changes and I do not see that happening too soon. When they make comments in the papers that a star, who put on five pounds and almost stopped looking like a starved person, is getting fat and better go on a diet, when they stop hiring only beautiful people to play normal people, when they stop photo-shopping imperfections out of films and photos, then maybe, just MAYBE, it will start to change. Somehow I do not see this happening.
As you can see, I am VERY passionate and angry about this. All we can do is start with ourselves and if we help one person, then we did a lot.
Hugs for starting this discussion. Do not let it end on Mylot.
1 person likes this
@nanajanet (4436)
• United States
1 Mar 09
Many teens have low self-image to start with. That is why I feel we must be extremely sensitive on the subject and try to get their mind off of all of it. I know that I did look at girls with nice hair, and I hated mine, who were prettier, had nicer noses, better this or that, and be a bit envious, but I also did not give it too much thought other than a little here and there. No obsession for me, I had too much fun with my teens, otherwise. Thank God I had great parents.
@regal_aeros (2605)
• Singapore
2 Mar 09
i know what you mean. The media has blown everything just out of proportion.
But we must never forget, that there is a group of people that needs to lose those weight because of their health.
BUt in all other cases, i agree with you. Be comfortable with yourself. Respect yourself and people will respect you. Be darn with the media.
1 person likes this
@trinidadvelasco (11401)
• Philippines
3 Mar 09
it is true that if one is already comfortable with his/her weight, what is important is making sure that he no longer adds more weight. this is because, one is already fit and healthy in that weight. we do not have to necessarily come up with a figure which is just about those ones who are modelling in the ramps nor should we measure up to the standards of those actors and actreeses. after all, we are just normal individuals we'd better lead normal lives.
@savypat (20216)
• United States
28 Feb 09
I wish it were harmless health wise, but it isn't. It puts a tremendous load on the heart and other internal organs in the body. It radically shortens ones life and for our teens is very damaging to their futures. Of course there is a social cost also which i agree is very bad.
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
28 Feb 09
Hey savypat! Thanks for responding. Unfortunately yeah, that is the scary truth about this issue. The damaging future and the social things that would affect young ones. I do hope that more and more people would speak and stand up for this, being healthy and stuff. It doesn't even look good to be too skinny.
@xianshuixyz (91)
• China
1 Mar 09
Hey, the_duchess, i completely agree with you. I think health plays a more important role than sliming for one person, a bit overweight doesn't seems serious if it has not affected the health and it is really not a problem. But in the sight of the youthes espescially girls now, slim always seems a good word for describing one's stature, opposely, someone who is fat whould always encounter some embarrassing moment for his/her shape, which makes he or she join the group to lost weight and promotes the sales of losing weight products. A bit fat is not a problem in the thinking from the aspect of oneself, but most persons care about how they are in other persons' sight, so this problem sometimes seems a bit complicated to handle.
1 person likes this
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
Hey xianshuixyz! You're right. One's definition of being healthy is what they think they are on people's sight; they tend to be so conscious with their body image especially young ones that they think being too skinny is the right thing. I think media plays a big role also here.
@saran86jay (98)
• India
28 Feb 09
Little bit of weight gain is not so big deal, you can be healthy with little workout, there is nothing to worry about that. You could gain good physical health with that much of little extra weight, you could become sexy, smart. No matter how huge figure you have if you are comfortable with that then its fine, only the thing is you have to maintain and nothing all.
1 person likes this
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
28 Feb 09
Yup, being sexy is being comfortable of who you are and not what others are trying to impose. It's giving importance to our body and mind to stay healthy.
@golddrizzle71 (113)
• United States
28 Feb 09
I don't see what the problem is if you gain a little bit of weight. However to other girls, that's a problem. For example, my friend, Natalie is a size 5 and claiming that she is fat. She isn't being close to fat all. Very skinny and pretty. I'm very happy with my weight, no matter what size I am.
1 person likes this
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
Size 5 is not fat all. Yeah, I really do agree, it depends on one's "definition of fat"
@roniroxas (10559)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
this is another all depends discussion. some people are over acting that when they gain 1 kilo they will say that they are fat and they need to lose weight, and some are really vain that they even have a body like their favorite stars.... those are some of the resons why losing weight and surgery has became very popular. as you know i am a mom of four children, but in the right disipline and balance diet i gained back the body i had before getting pregnant. it also needed disipline. some are to lazy to stretch their body but wanted to have a curvy one. in other cases such as people who are really born voluptuous... even they eat a little they are still big so it becomes an issue of surgery and losing weight. some people gets into their depression mode and food made them happy then later on realize that they are already fat. so it is always case to case.... but i guess it is exagerated already by those who are really thin and wanted to get more thin and lazy people who does not like to exercise but wants to have a curvy body. just my view.
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
I agree with you, cindi4. It's not just the weight factor that affects our health; there are plenty more and what is right is eating healthy and choosing the right foods that will help our body fight against diseases. Glad to know that your cousin made it. Thanks for the response and thanks too, carrine, I think it's just right to maintain an average weight, it's a matter of checking our BMI (Body Mass Index).
@cindi4 (11)
• United States
28 Feb 09
As someone who had been dieting for most of their life I would like to offer a little insight. When I focused on the weight and the scale I didn't do my health any favors. See Sawing between gaining and losing, even if if was only 5 to 10 pounds but a strain on my health. It took years for me to learn that all you need to do is focus on eating moderately, exercising moderately, and don't worry about your size.
Size does not reflect how healthy you are. My cousin just had a heart attack at 46. He's tall and thin and has always been active. He has never been overweight a day in his life. He also loved french fries and was a constant worrier. Thankfully he made it, this time.
Just focus on being healthy and forget the scale.
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
1 Mar 09
I think a little bit of extra weight is okay, but not a lot. Too much extra weight can lead to health problems. Personally, I know I am carrying a little extra, too much in my own opinion, and it is a huge deal to me. I know that no one else in my family cares that I am bigger than my ideal weight, but it is a personal issue for me and I am trying to lose the weight and then some.
1 person likes this
@moneymommy (3418)
• United States
28 Feb 09
I dont think there's a problem with a little extra weight. I think if you really get over weight you may want to worry about losing some pounds. But a little wouldn't be to bad for ya.
1 person likes this
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
28 Feb 09
Yeah, I don't really think there's a problem with that, too. It's just sad that other people think that gaining weight is such a big issue.
@nansheeca (215)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
being a woman in the heavy side, i guess its our personal preference of wether we would allow ourselves to lose or gain weight. me, i do eat a lot but i also make it a point to stop bingeing when i have to. i dont put much emphasis on judging a person by his/her weight. i mean, if they are happy about how they look, what matters is they are happy with thier life. and i am happy too, with how i look now. its not the body that counts but the heart.
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
Yeah, as for me, I don't really care what people around me looks like, it's a matter of accepting who we are and the self-esteem and confidence on ourselves. A little extra weight doesn't mean you're unhealthy. There are many cases that slim people suffers from cardiovascular diseases rather than an overweight one. This is just a matter of taking our body inside and choosing the right food to eat. Thanks for your response.
@cortypants (604)
• United States
1 Mar 09
Personally, I don't care what anyone else weighs, makes no difference to me, other than the fact that I want everyone to be healthy so they are around me longer! I try to keep my own weight down to a healthy weight, just so that I stay healthy and don't jiggle too much!
1 person likes this
@heehaw78 (566)
• Malaysia
28 Feb 09
What a great topic you brought up today, well from my opinion , weight gain do matters for most of us, if you are a bachelor that is a big trouble for most women might think you are already married, for women weight gain do matters too.
Another reason why people hates weight gain is because , you will need to spend extra money to buy new clothing. I had began to put up weight and i am not comfortable with it.
@thungster (156)
• United States
28 Feb 09
I agree. Gaining a little weight isn't really that big of a problem. It's definitely better than developing an eating disorder or possible health side effects from weight loss programs. As you said, there is a stigma against "overweight" people and many companies take advantage of that by producing those "lose weight quick products."
1 person likes this
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
28 Feb 09
Yup, and there are even products that are not even medically tested to be safe and they bring it in to the market, geez, that's terrible.
@magda191919 (391)
• Romania
31 Mar 09
No, don't be 'comfortable with our own size and weight,whatever it is', but try to balance your body.
Unfortunately those diets will not help, all comes from the inside. You can loose weight eating less or ... killing your fears.
Trying to convince people about miracle diets instead of fighting to make them free of fear and stronger, is not a honorable thing to do.
Yes, we must feel comfortable with ourselves, feel good in our body and understand that many weight problems come from the inside, so we can be the first to find out what is really going on and what is our problem behind the problem.
@missybear (11391)
• United States
28 Feb 09
I wish I could think like you, I'm always on some kind of diet or trying to loose a few pounds.
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
Hi missybear! There's nothing really wrong about losing weight but if you're obsessed, that really too bad. You should comfortable with your weight and be confident about it.
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
1 Mar 09
My friend's sister in law is quite thin and I can see she it totally obsessed with her weight and focuses on food at all times. She suffers from depression which may well be related.
When I was around 16 (back in the dark ages!) I began to lose weight and almost became anorexic, my monthly cycle stopped and I looked terrible. Fortunately my mother found a good doctor who talked me off the path I was on, I was not quite anorexic but it wouldn't have taken long for me to become quite sick.
It's hard to imagine now as I hardly ever worry about my weight nowadays. I do remember being obsessed and stressing about gaining a single ounce. It's a very sad way to live.
My friend's sister in law is displaying all the same traits and is heading toward a serious eating disorder.
It's such a shame that so many women are affected by dieting and body image issues. I have a seven year old daughter and I purposely never talk my weight because I am terrified of her developing an eating disorder and low self esteem due to poor body image.
@the_dutchess (2610)
• Philippines
1 Mar 09
Hey paula! Thanks for responding. I've been through "dark ages" too when I was in my teens but I'm not obsessed. I just think that I'm fat when I'm really now so I tend to diet. I see that it's really important to have guidance of a parent or a people much older to walk us through the right path and also someone's confidence and self-esteem.
I feel sorry for your sister in law; I think you should have advise her if you think that it's really going to some eating disorder.
@blue65packer (11826)
• United States
13 Apr 09
It is a big deal if you put on 80 pounds on in one year and since then 30 more pounds! That happen to me! Alot of it was do to depression! Anyway as long as my health isn't a issue I'll be ok! Not mentally! I'm almost 47 and still have trouble loving myself! It sucks and hope I can over come this in my life time!
@aldztrust (38)
• Philippines
13 Apr 09
If you gain extra pounds in a year, that would be good but if you gained it in couple pf days, you're in trouble. Obesity and weight gain are interrelated and you can get sick by just being obese.
@jheLaichie (4438)
• Philippines
20 Apr 09
well for me thats somewhat kindah issue., because of our family blood line of being diabetic... so being fat is a very big no no...