"Would you give money to a beggar boy?"

@Shavkat (139933)
Philippines
May 28, 2017 3:58am CST
A young boy aged 10 got into a jeepney that I am riding in, he has this piece of paper and laid on my right thigh. The handwritten message says, "Ate, Kuya pahingi ng pera pagkain ko lang po. Salamat po." (Sister or brother: Can I have some money for me to eat? Thank you). I gave him some coins. But I feel pity on him. "Are you going to give something to him? Image Credit: Shavkat
16 people like this
15 responses
@responsiveme (22926)
• India
28 May 17
I usually give food , I keep biscuits or buy something instead of money
4 people like this
• India
28 May 17
@nomus24g I know . This boy was looking cheerful and was enthusiastic about the food which was also fresh and hot
1 person likes this
• India
28 May 17
@nomus24g they are fake ones too...That's another story.... Last week a fellow passenger exchanged some small talk and then he told us that the enuch in question is a father of 3
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
@responsiveme I know what you mean. But it is not possible to give some food. The jeepney is on the go. If I have some foody, I will give it to him instead of money.
1 person likes this
• Pamplona, Spain
28 May 17
Yes I would but I would not make a habit of it either. They use children here also. its really hard to know what to do about this kind of thing.
2 people like this
• Pamplona, Spain
29 May 17
@Shavkat They should be protected always no matter what and yet they are not.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
29 May 17
@lovingangelsinstead21 I am aware that children were being abused in begging on the street. I wasn't used to seeing them. In my city, these children cannot able to do this.
1 person likes this
@artner (60)
29 May 17
I can speak first hand of the poverty in the Philippines. Manila is a city with extreme opposites, obscene wealth and abject poverty co-existing side by side. The government cannot tackle this alone and that's where so many of the churches and smaller community based projects play such an important role. This is one of my passions and we are looking at various mechanisms to allow these smaller unregistered projects access to funding from abroad. Spend the money in the right places and we reduce the need for children to beg on the streets. Raising the profile of the smaller community run self help programs is critical to helping the poor drag themselves up by their own bootlaces.
• Philippines
28 May 17
The poverty is real, no doubt about it. But there are poor that are also being used by Syndicates. I feel sorry for them because Parents simply didn't care specially if they didn't have plan or money to raise kids. There are times that I give something to them.
2 people like this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
I think our politicians forgot what's really the problem in the Philippines. They are so busy scrutinizing each other.
@atoz1to10 (6780)
• Australia
28 May 17
Of course I will give him some money... But with his age, isn't he supposed to be at school? I was told that some adults abused the children by making them beg for money...
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
It is summer vacation, my friend. I do think it is possible that some adults are abusive and let the children beg. All I know, they've been doing this because of being marginalized in the society.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
31 May 17
@atoz1to10 If only the government do something.
1 person likes this
@atoz1to10 (6780)
• Australia
28 May 17
@Shavkat some children seem to have everything and some children do need a lot of thing... If only ...
1 person likes this
@Teekaaa (11580)
• India
28 May 17
We usually give something to eat....
2 people like this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
I do think it is ideal to give food.
1 person likes this
@Teekaaa (11580)
• India
28 May 17
@rjain1055 (595)
31 May 17
i think if you give food rather than money then it is useful for him
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
31 May 17
I agree. But I am a passenger on a jeepney and not possible to give or buy some food.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
31 May 17
@rjain1055 I don't bring food while on travel especially in jeepneys.
1 person likes this
31 May 17
@Shavkat you said you are passenger, so you have your own food. So why not you give a small part of it!!!
1 person likes this
@popciclecold (38723)
• United States
28 May 17
I would give, because you really can't be sure.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
I agree. It is better to extend our help even in small ways.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 May 17
Yes if I have it, I will give it. I often do even if they do not ask.
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
I also give something especially the old ones. My country is still hoping for all the promises of politicians being vited by the people.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
31 May 17
@TiarasOceanView I agree. They are sinners.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 May 17
@Shavkat Aw I know the dang politicians.. You are good to help them Shavkat.
1 person likes this
@ridingbet (66854)
• Philippines
29 May 17
it depends. if i see the beggar strong and healthy, i won't. he might use the money for 'cara y crus', which is so common here.
@Kandae11 (55036)
28 May 17
Sometimes their parents send them to do it. With some it is a business, but I won't know the true story therefore I'll give.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
I agree. I know some stories about it. It could be a syndicate's business. I hope it ia not.
@Bodyandbrain (13797)
• Gurgaon, India
29 May 17
I always try to help with food or money but these incidents increase pain in my heart.
@JediYoda (1646)
• Samoa
28 May 17
Maybe the same thing as what you did.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
I think it is better to give than think what if he really needs to survive.
29 May 17
I would give what I have at that time, either money or eatable. But not to stop with that i would enquire about his condition and provide any information on his education or place to stay....
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
30 May 17
In the capital, there are so many children like this. The government is too busy dealing with so many projects. At some instances, they were not successful.
@jnesperos (269)
• Davao, Philippines
28 May 17
I pity those beggars in the streets and in the market especially the differently abled ones, if only I have much money I could just let them stay in my house and give them food,
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
28 May 17
I hope our president will know what to do with them. He can provide livelihood programs.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (139933)
• Philippines
31 May 17
@jnesperos I respect your opinion about him. But I don't like him from the very start.
• Davao, Philippines
28 May 17
@Sharyvkat I think he will, he's great,he even declared martial law in mindanao, how much more livelihood program?
1 person likes this
@prashu228 (37524)
• India
28 May 17
No, we can't trust them, if they can work and earn for themselves, we should not give them money